6 Philosophical Ideas That Make Horizon Zero Dawn Even Better

There's even more to pick apart than you thought.

By Lukasz Muniowski /

There's no doubt that the plot of Horizon Zero Dawn is one of the deepest and thoughtful in recent video game history. Even without basic philosophical training you can identify notions of choice, destiny or religion, just to mention a few. The story is very engaging and interesting, but what is most important is that it doesn't disappoint.

Advertisement

This is achieved through asking the right questions and not coming up with forced - or, at times, any - answers.

Some of the answers may be reached, at least partially, through applying basic philosophical ideas. Simultaneously, these ideas can create even more confusion - they may leave even more questions unanswered, as they open up issues otherwise not taken into consideration - but it's important to consider this approach regardless, just to show how deep the game really is.

While these may seem trivial to some (the game does feature a lot of shooting giant robot dinosaurs in the face, after all), these philosophical ideas need to be stated and applied, if only to further the understanding of the narrative for those that didn't take them into consideration during their first playthrough.

It must be also noted that the list contains a lot of spoilers, so make sure you've completed the game first before continuing.

6. Democritus And Free Will

Democritus was a firm believer in determinism - how one event determines the outcome if others, even not purely connected with the primary occurrence. This theory is based on history and basic physics i.e. through the analysis of the past, we can (supposedly) predict the future.

Advertisement

While not always applicable in real life, determinism is what makes Aloy the savior of not only her tribe, but the whole planet Earth. GAIA recreates her programmer, Elisabeth Sobeck, and determines her future. She programs "future Sobeck" to find the Focus and gives her features that will allow her to re-enter the facility and destroy HADES. When Aloy learns this, she reacts with anger, shouting: "I'm an instrument!"

But as she comes to herself, she does what is supposed to be done. Even though HADES corrupted GAIA and Aloy needed to do a lot in order to learn her destiny, once learned, there was simply no escaping it.

5. The Turing Test

This one is the most obvious on the list. Alan Turing, the British mathematician, believed that a human equipped with a paper, a pencil and an eraser was pretty much a machine. According to him, this was also true the other way round: if a machine was able to make a human believe that it was a person, than the machine was human as well.

Advertisement

The Turing Test may be applied to GAIA as much as her whole creation. The former is fairly obvious, as GAIA becomes a conversation partner for Sobeck, ultimately befriends her, while in the meantime developing a conscience.

This conscience allows GAIA to masterfully recreate the ecosystem of the Earth, but, more importantly, "delete" it. when it's not up to her wishes.

The creation itself could also be subject to the Turing Test, as the nature is undoubtedly real, so are the people, but they were all created by a program - hence a machine. So are they human, or machine?

4. Marxism

This entry is not so much about Marxism per se, but rather about a society that was supposed to be the result of it.

Advertisement

Marxism (born from Karl Marx) argues that every society is built around two factors: class and production. The latter affects the former, as the workers, who produce the most, are at the bottom of the class hierarchy, whereas those that reap the profits are at the top. Marxism is obviously more complex, but we're dealing with basic notions here, so please read into it further at your leisure.

During the "A Moment's Peace" quest, Aloy meets the Banuk. They're a simple tribe, ridiculed by the Carja, because they are basically a classless society.

Unlike the Carja and the Nora, who shun b*stards and form bonds dependent on birth, the Banuk respect skill, and ignore if someone is rich or poor, male or female. The Banuk are even able to live peacefully with the machines. While that is possible thanks to an unidentified signal is of little importance - the Banuk are a society based on inclusion, which makes them the hopeful outcome of Marxist thought.

3. Nietzsche And The Death Of God

Just like determinism, this was also covered earlier.

Advertisement

German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche believed not so much in the death of God as a being that gave birth to the World, but God no longer serving as the moral compass, hence the source of knowledge of all the things right or wrong.

This posed Nietzsche to believe in the death of actual values of the Western World, which in turn should motivate people to look for new ones as now, without God, the possibilities were numerous.

Aloy learns about the death of God - the All-Mother - first hand, by seeing that she was a machine, just like those that aim to kill all humanity. When she leaves Eulethia, Aloy is worshiped by her tribespeople, even though they previously shunned her throughout her life.

She declares: "I'm not to be anointed, I do not belong to you," which is a clear breakup with religion, as well as the class system organized around it. She encourages others to form a better society, which is a very Nietzschean thing to do.

2. Plato's Cave

In Book VII of The Republic, Plato presents a group of prisoners chained in a cave, forced to watch shadows across a stone wall. They've been there since birth, with no knowledge of the outside world.

Advertisement

When something or someone passes by the entry of the cave, they see the shadows or hear sounds, which allow them to classify the things in their own way, in turns creating within the prisoners, the illusion of the outside world. It's only when they're able to leave the cave that they learn what the real world looks like.

While Plato compared that experience to that of a philosopher, it's applicable to Aloy as well. She has seen through the illusion of the Nora's religion - or any religion, at that - created by the unknowing people to both organize the primitive society and mask the lack of knowledge of the world.

Aloy's findings allow her to break her "chains", and in turn free the society as well.

1. Bruno Latour And The Politics Of Nature

This theory builds on the previous one, as the French philosopher argues for the end of the separation between culture and nature.

Advertisement

In Plato's view, the scientist/prophet/philosopher goes out to nature as if it's a different entity, and has to come back to the "human world" and introduce what he's found. Instead, Latour calls for the end of the separation between the object and the subject, calling for a complete inclusion.

In other words, he preaches togetherness.

This is once again personified by the Banuk tribe, which accepts all beings and tries to learn from them in order to coexist peacefully with their surroundings. This will also, hopefully, be the ending for the other tribes, as the Nora fight together with the Carja against a common enemy.

There is hope that this unity will last.

Advertisement