7 Characters That Must Be Cut From Super Smash Bros. Switch
Someone's gotta go.
Super Smash Bros. games are often judged on their roster of characters. With each new game comes an exciting slew of new additions and speculation as to which of Nintendo's all-stars (and, in some cases, not stars at all) will make the cut.
However, the fat must be trimmed. As the rosters have ballooned in size, oftentimes characters will get left on the cutting room floor. They're rarely fan-favourites - no one really cared about Young Link in Melee - but sometimes unexpected characters will be lost, like the Ice Climbers or Wolf O'Donnell.
Not only that, but with third party characters now being thrown into the mix, the roster for the previous game expanded enormously - that means someone isn't going to make it back.
With Super Smash Bros. announced for Switch, frantic speculation over the roster has begun anew - but while many people speculate on who they would like to join the fray, it's interesting to guess who might be leaving. There are a few obvious candidates for the chopping block, and some franchises just have too much representation. Smash Bros. is a cutthroat world, and some just have to go...
7. Cloud
It was a huge moment when it was revealed that Cloud Strife, of Final Fantasy and PlayStation fame, was going to be joining Smash 4's roster of DLC characters. Cloud being a playable character in Smash was the epitome of a far-fetched pipe dream and yet here he was, duking it out with Mario and friends.
Unfortunately, much like Solid Snake before him, Cloud just doesn't really fit with the aesthetic of Smash. He's iconic yes, but he's overly serious demeanor and slightly less cartoon style put him more in line with the Fire Emblem characters than anything else - and we don't need more of them, that's for sure. While fans would most certainly like Cloud to return, it seems unlikely.
However, it seemed unlikely he'd be joining in the first place, so really anything can happen. Realistically though, it feels like Smash 4 was Cloud's moment to shine. But there is solace to be found - if Cloud can make it into the series, then really anyone can. Except Goku, because that's just truly dumb.
6. Lucario
Lucario once filled an important role in the Smash Bros. roster. He represented not only the fourth generation of Pokemon games, but also the series that took the handheld games into the third dimension. He was the poster child for those games and deserved his place in the Smash roster. However, he also fulfilled another role - Mewtwo's replacement.
They have very similar movesets - both are floaty and have a focus on hand-to-hand combat, with energy blasts and chargeable energy balls at their disposal. However, fans clamoured for Mewtwo's return to Smash ever since he was cut from Brawl - and they got their wish. Mewtwo was Smash 4's first DLC character. So now that Mewtwo is back and Pokemon has moved on from the fourth generation (we now have Greninja), what role does Lucario fill?
Mewtwo is one of the most iconic Pokemon of all time. He absolutely deserves a place within the roster - which means Lucario does everything slightly worse and less cool than him, but with an added gimmick of needing to be dealt a lot of damage before being useful. It seems Mewtwo may now stay in the roster, meaning Lucario is no longer needed.
5. Corrin
Corrin was added into Smash 4 as one of the final pieces of DLC - and, in other words, acted as a glorified advert for the latest game in the series at the time, Fire Emblem: Fates.
Sure, Corrin has a unique move set, but the move set isn't the problem here - Corrin is the epitome of extraneous characters being added into over-represented franchises.
Corrin has practically no personality in the game - a game where making it into the roster should be reserved for the revered icons. Smash Bros. already has one essentially nameless avatar Fire Emblem character in the form of Robin - we don't need two. Robin, at least, has a unique playstyle, mixing magic with swordplay. Corrin is yet another Fire Emblem sword user.
Not only that, but Fire Emblem: Fates simply didn't make the same splash that Awakening did. Fire Emblem was already increasing in popularity, but Awakening, which featured Robin, sent the series' popularity into the stratosphere in the West.
Fates arrived with a bit more of a whimper, so it seems unlikely that Corrin will stick around.
4. Ryu
Here comes another controversial entry. Street Fighter's Ryu was implemented well into Smash 4 and, like Cloud, was also a pretty massive inclusion. However, also like Cloud, he just doesn't quite gel with the rest of the cast.
Perhaps it's the fact that he's already from a fighting series and therefore his moveset and playstyle innately clashes with that of Smash Bros. Or it's his near normal human-like appearance. Either way, Ryu simply doesn't fit the game's aesthetic. He does however have a pretty great stage and his Street Fighter moves were implemented well into the game.
There's another reason though why Ryu may not return. It stands to reason that Mega Man, the most requested third party character after Sonic to be added into the game, will return for Smash Switch. He was implemented well and his look really fits the Nintendo style. Having two Capcom representatives is beginning to get a little much for the third party inclusions - it would be better to limit it to one per company, so as to avoid the third parties swamping the roster.
3. Lucina
Look at the image! They look almost identical.
In all seriousness, Lucina is, in almost every way, just a clone of Marth. Introduced into the Smash Bros. roster at the height of Fire Emblem: Awakening's popularity, Lucina was someone fans were desperate to see. However, it was Robin who took the fully-fledged new character spot, while Lucina was relegated to being a clone of Smash Bros. stalwart Marth, albeit with a slightly different damage-dealing point on her sword.
While fans wanted Lucina, they also want a lower number of clone characters in general (particularly Ganondorf, who has needed his own move set since his introduction in Melee). However, this doesn't mean Lucina needs to be cut from the roster entirely. One thing Smash needs to work on is including more interesting skins for its many characters, rather than simple colour swaps. Lucina would make a perfect alternate skin for Marth.
In this sense, Lucina is an example of a clone character done correctly - she's a character people want to see in Smash, but there isn't enough to differentiate her from Marth. So, making her a skin is the perfect way to keep her in the roster.
2. Dr. Mario
There was understandable outcry when it was revealed, thanks to a series of huge leaks, that Dr. Mario would be making his long-awaited (hmm) return to Smash Bros. Last seen in Melee, the clone of Mario was a strange choice to make the final roster, especially when fans were clamouring for Melee favourites like Mewtwo and Roy.
Like Lucina before him on this list, Dr. Mario would better serve the game as a skin of Mario himself. He's unique enough to be a 'different character' and he represents a full game in itself, so to have Dr. Mario on the roster isn't a crime - but he should be a skin, hopefully one of an ever-improving roster of alternate character options.
It's likely that Dr. Mario was a last-minute addition to the game, a quick and easy-to-develop character who was added in to beef up the roster numbers. It stands to reason then that we might see more of these kinds of characters in the Smash Switch roster. In this way, the likes of Pichu may even make a surprise comeback!
1. Dark Pit
Despite making it onto this list, every character on here so far does hold some worth. Even the likes of Lucina and Dr. Mario, who are almost straight clones of existing characters, are different enough in their models to be separate characters.
Enter Dark Pit - the most pointless 'new addition' to the game yet.
Unlike most other clone characters, Dark Pit is quite literally a recolour of Pit. A fully separate character was made out of what usually constitutes a basic skin - a character colour change. Dark Pit is Pit but in edgier clothes, with an edgier attitude and a weird gun.
Again, like Dr. Mario, he could've been thrown in at a later stage to pad out the numbers, but there's just no need for him to take a slot on the roster.
Dark Pit is an interesting character however, perhaps the first real example of a clone character taken to the extreme, where their model isn't really different in the slightest. It's an example of an otherwise stunning roster going off the rails in the wrong direction.