7 Most Complicated Video Game Stories Absolutely Nobody Understands
Can you explain these games?
There are times when going the extra mile in video game storytelling heeds rich results. Other times not so much. And that’s when we’re left confused.
Stories in games are usually meant to serve and help the gameplay with an engaging narrative that gives the player and incentive to keep going. But something games often lose sight of is having their stories make sense to begin with. Whether it’s an abundance of exposition, too many subplots, or straight up contradictions to its own rules, some games just don’t take a moment to step back and actually review everything that’s happened so far.
However, this doesn’t mean that the game is bad. Even if it’s impossible to deny that understanding what’s happening in between the gameplay is a job all on its own. No, it’s when games go too far with their complex narratives that problems start to arise. Stories so complicated even the most diehard fans have a hard time comprehending what happens. So much so that part of their message gets lost along the way. And these games in specific are the games that stand out the most.
7. Fire Emblem: The Blazing Blade
Starting off, simply understanding the continuity of the Fire Emblem franchise is difficult enough. Of the thirteen games in the series, only Sacred Stones, Three Houses, and Fates serve as standalone titles. Every other entry is somehow connected to another with no consistency to be seen.
But Blazing Blade is special in this regard. This was the first game to come out of Japan and the prequel to the never localised Binding Blade. It’s also one of the most difficult to comprehend.
The story is told across static scenes with mountains of exposition heavy dialogue, making all sense of narrative drama non-existent and each event into something nearly impossible to process when all you have on screen are a few character sprites.
And this is without mentioning the story itself, which mainly consists of characters spending their time talking about murder plots and organisations that want to take over the world. And yet, we’re never shown anything. Everything is just verbally explained. Combine this with the amount of characters introduce and subplots opened, and you’ll quickly find yourself lost and confused most of the time - something that in turn makes the emotional moments stale and boring.
While Lyn, Eliwood, and Hector are still beloved characters from the Fire Emblem franchise, the same can’t be said about its convoluted narrative.
6. Dark Souls
Dark Souls is one of the most difficult games of recent times. But what you don’t know is that the only thing harder than the game is understanding the cryptic item descriptions.
The story of Dark Souls is mainly told through out of context dialogue and environments that somehow hint at what’s happening. But of course, none of it makes sense unless you have the Dark Souls wiki on hand at all times. Not to mention that paying attention to your surroundings while being bombarded with knights and snipers becomes a jarring experience after a while.
The narrative is interesting with elements of insanity and grief (something the game itself will make you feel often). But even so, you’ll have to watch a lot of YouTube videos in order to even get an idea as to what the full lore of Dark Souls is like in its entirety.
5. Xenoblade Chronicles
What starts off as a relatively simple to understand story about Shulk and his friends seeking to destroy the Mechon and bring peace to the Bionis quickly gets more and more confusing as it goes on.
Xenoblade Chronicles never runs out of plot twists and sudden conveniences that are always hard to believe. Major events that take place at the beginning end up retconned. Characters never find one consistent goal to follow. And above all, Shulk never stops screaming Fiora’s name. And these are all details you can’t ever lose sight of as the game is 100 hours long. Meaning that if you aren’t paying attention, you’re surely going to get lost fast.
Things get worse once you play its seemingly unrelated sequel. A game that takes the already established lore from the first game and drops a few bombshells to change everything you thought you knew about an already inconsistent story... Only to then throw you another left hook with its standalone DLC.
4. Metal Gear Solid
In the distant future of 2005, this little black ops unit named FOXHOUND stole a bunch of high-grade nuclear weapons. This organisation was run by a guy called Liquid Snake who’s actually a clone of an entirely different person called Big Boss. There’s also a character called Solid Snake who’s Liquid Snake’s unofficial brother. Solid Snake goes on to defeat Liquid Ocelot who is not the same person as Liquid Snake, but is at the same time? It’s confusing.
While a beloved classic made by legendary game designer Hideo Kojima, Metal Gear Solid is undeniably one of the most confusing games to ever be put on screen. With multiple clones, characters who end up not being what they say they are, sequels actually being prequels, and a massive lack of consistency. Especially from Metal Gear Solid 5 and onwards, when Hideo Kojima left the franchise after being fired by Konami.
And this is without mentioning all the spinoffs and bonus content in each game that expands on the lore even further.
The story of Solid Snake is close to our hearts, but the series desperately needs a coherent timeline explanation.
3. Final Fantasy VIII
Any of the Final Fantasy games could have a spot on this list. There’s Final Fantasy X with its non-existent main character; Final Fantasy VII with its constant political talk and story inconsistencies; and Final Fantasy IV with its dead characters that come back to life.
But Final Fantasy VIII specifically stands out. The story in the game from the very beginning becomes confusing and nearly impossible to follow, with a constant back and forth between the political unrest of the world and main character Squall’s personal life - something that makes the story hard to follow.
Things get more confusing once you beat disc one, which is when the rest of the game starts contradicting itself. Characters like Rinoa who previously showed no romantic interest in Squall is now suddenly in love with him; the baffling reveal that all the main characters actually knew each other way in the past when they were kids; and the war that takes place in the world at large coming out of nowhere.
All of this culminates in a finale with random visuals and trippy imagery which seems like something out of an experimental indie film. Only for everything to go back to normal afterwards with no explanation in a credit sequence that explains absolutely nothing.
While other games in the series are hard to follow, Final Fantasy VIII earns its spot on this list for not even trying to make sense.
2. Kingdom Hearts
Disney likes simple. Which is why all their movies follow straightforward storylines that any kid could watch. The only exception is Kingdom Hearts.
Unlike other entries in this list, the story of Kingdom Hearts couldn’t just be told with one game. No, instead, not only do you have to play each of the main games in the series, but also all the spin-offs in order to even have an idea of what’s happening. But chances are, you’ll still be confused.
The first game is relatively easy to follow, with Sora just trying to find his friends after they were separated by Ansem. However, by the time you reach Kingdom Hearts 2, you’ll be introduced to clones who don’t have feelings except for when it’s convenient for the story, an entire organisation created by the villain you killed in the last game who was actually an entirely different character, and memory wiping as the characters don’t remember the events of previous entries. And this is just the beginning, as Dream Drop Distance further expands on the lore by adding time travel, dreams within dreams, and previously defeated villains coming back from the dead.
1. Five Nights at Freddy's
Unlike other entries on this list, Five Nights at Freddy’s has been impossible to understand from the very first game. With a cryptic and eery story that includes child murder, haunted animatronics, and a lot of Atari minigames.
In order to fully understand everything in the narrative, you have to play all ten games in the franchise (which includes an AR and VR game), read a book trilogy (ranging from 300-500 pages each), and lastly read an ever growing number of book anthologies that supposedly expand on the story but end up making things more confusing.
Characters who were considered dead constantly come back to life for no explainable reason. Each entry continues to add more and more animatronics whose origins are unknown. And then there’s the timeline: a series of events that is never consistent. Even when you think you’ve reached a “definitive” timeline, a new game will come out that will make you throw everything you thought you knew out the window.
And with the series expanding further each year, it doesn’t seem likely that we’ll get a proper explanation for everything any time soon.