7 Most Disappointing Video Game Stories Ever

When you're ONLY recommending the gameplay.

By Scott Tailford /

Capcom

In a medium where hype is king - where game mechanics can give way to hundreds of hours of fun, or a challenging boss might eat up a weekend - nailing a good story can often do a ton of the legwork for you.

Advertisement

Securing a sequel means self-generated snowballs of interest in between instalments. Sometimes even the most phoned-in titles gameplay-wise at least continuing their overarching narratives, and can be re-appraised or revalued somewhere down the line.

That said, we rarely talk about games that got a number of their core components right, but dropped the ball narratively.

Advertisement

Simply by proxy of the medium we're dealing with, if gameplay and other interactive elements are spot on, we can largely overlook a story being notably disappointing.

Jarring plot twists, deflated tension from a big reveal falling flat. Which titles had everything going for them - and maybe nailed the majority of their production - but left you wanting more on the story front?

Advertisement

Oh, and let it be known that Mass Effect 3's new Legendary Edition - finally including all DLC as standard, removing the unnecessary multiplayer and fixing how Galactic Readiness works - actually makes that game work INSANELY well.

Bioware's divisive finale is off the "most disappointing" list for now, but as for the rest...

Advertisement

7. Halo 5: Guardians

Microsoft

With Halo Infinite largely doing away with the more sombre tone of Halo's 4 and 5 - likely because legendary original trilogy writer Joseph Staten is back on board - it's a marked regaining of focus from just how messy Halo 5 felt.

Advertisement

Reeling from the death of Cortana and with 343 thanking fans for believing in their vision for the IP, Halo 5 then rolled out an entire marketing campaign centred on Master Chief fighting with relative newcomer, Spartan Locke.

John-117 had recruited his childhood soldier friends to help while Locke amassed his own platoon of spartans - the two sides set to have some kind of showdown, with the real reason behind their rivalry to be revealed.

Advertisement

Cut to the game and not only was the Chief vs. Locke fight over in seconds, but the advertised scene of Locke and Chief pulling a gun on each other never happened. The real reason Chief was on the run came down to investigating signs that Cortana was still alive - something Locke empathised with almost immediately - and we ended with Cortana becoming the main villain for the next instalment.

Help us, Halo Infinite. You're our only hope.

Advertisement

6. No Man's Sky

Hello Games

Shoe-in for "most miles travelled" between launch version and where it is today, No Man's Sky is one of the most impressive bodies of work from a gaming studio in history, but as we all know, that first year was bumpy as hell.

Advertisement

Sidestepping the many bugs and reality of how mis-marketed the project was, one key reason behind exploring in the first place was to see what lay at the centre of the galaxy.

Creative Director Sean Murray teased what lay at the end of the line, saying "there is something you can do", and that it "causes an event that is seen by everybody". He said we'd want to "experience it with friends" and get them to "join us there" - almost like the digital equivalent of some ethereal nirvana state, set aside for only the bravest adventurers.

Advertisement

Get to the heart of the galaxy - something that takes tens of hours, if not hundreds, depending on your trajectory through billions of planets - and you're rewarded with... the camera zooming back out, past all the planets in the cosmos, as the whole game restarts.

Newer updates have codified this sequence and even the earliest versions of No Man's Sky were a meta-narrative comment on life being a simulation, i.e. playing the game itself, but neither are anywhere near the way Murray was describing this event.

Advertisement

5. Resident Evil Village

Capcom

Potentially a controversial pick depending on how much you were invested in this mysterious new version of Chris Redfield - someone whose first order of business in RE Village is to shoot Ethan's wife Mia and steal their child.

Advertisement

Yes, that's the setup of Resident Evil's eighth instalment, and besides the closing months when Lady Dimitrescu thirst was in full flow, the core question of what Chris was doing, was front and centre.

Well, the explanation is possibly the stupidest thing Capcom have ever written, and in a world of boulder-punches and duels to the death in a volcano, that's really saying something.

Advertisement

The reason Chris shot Mia... was because she was actually "Mother Miranda", long lost partner of Mr. Zombie Virus himself, Oswell E. Spencer. Chris simply chooses not to tell a clearly very disturbed Ethan what's going on, and makes off with infant child Rosemary, because she too is being sought after by various members of the upcoming village.

There was literally ZERO reason Chris couldn't have told Ethan what was going on, and as he repeatedly shows up, telling Ethan "not to get involved" with no explanation, of course the husband of a murdered wife and father of a kidnapped infant is going to follow you to the ends of the Earth.

Advertisement

All this and I'm leaving out another mouldy reveal that comes later on, because at least that tied into Resident Evil 7.

4. Death Stranding

Kojima Productions

A game whose premise is its entire narrative, Hideo Kojima's blank cheque-feeling game about human togetherness in a bleak post-apocalyptic hellscape is genuinely a very rewarding, methodic and unique game.

Advertisement

It's also clearly the mind of someone who had 20 different thematic ideas across the decades he was with a former company, and decided to throw them all in the mix.

Death Stranding's core plot drive surrounds chasing after main man Sam Porter Bridges' kidnapped sister, Amelie, but holy hell does it go off the rails around the midpoint. Everything from Sam being a time-travelling entity that knew Mads Mikkelsen's character to the baby on your front also being you as an infant is in here, but the big thing that feels supremely "...what" is Amelie not even existing.

Advertisement

Turns out she's actually an "Extinction Entity", to which there have been many others in Earth's own history. The entire game revolves around realising it's less about Sam finding his sister and recovering from an affliction that doesn't let him touch other people, and more about hugging the apocalypse itself, as a reminder that humanity is worth keeping around, because companionship is irreplaceable.

Said like that, this 50 hour noodle pile of a script has meaning, but Hideo Kojima is 100% his own worst enemy throughout.

Advertisement

3. Assassin's Creed III

Ubisoft

It might be a faint memory now, but Assassin's Creed III was the turning point. The point where original conceptual lead Patrice Desilets left Ubisoft, and the original plan for Assassin's Creed as a set of six games was thrown out the window.

Advertisement

Desmond voice actor Nolan North revealed in 2015 that this original plan would've seen Desmond turn into the ultimate time-travelling assassin by the end of all the games combined, having inherited and learned all the best techniques from the likes of Altair, Ezio, Connor and more.

Instead, as Desilets left, Ubisoft chose endless sequels over narrative satisfaction. Desmond suddenly had to touch a mythical underground orb that would save the planet and kill him, because of course it would.

Advertisement

He does, the world is apparently saved, and Nolan North was asked to read some audible "diary entries" in Black Flag, as the franchise would only get more bloated and less character focused over time.

2. The Last Of Us Part II

Naughty Dog

A divisive entry for sure, but one that I'm curious to put out there, just to see where people come down now that we're more than a year after a notably chaotic launch.

Advertisement

Because Last of Us 2 is bold. It's meticulously made, award-winning and a notably high bar for digital performance capture.

It also employs a completely different tone that its predecessor, and though it eventually lands on the same beat of "life is worth living! Find someone you love and make some memories!", the path there involves killing main character Joel, perhaps the most passionately defended or at least talked about character in the last 10 years.

Advertisement

To so wildly steer into breaking up the "Joel and Ellie" dynamic that made Last of Us so seismic is one hell of a creative decision. It put us in the shoes of his killer, Abby, a character whose father was the surgeon Joel killed at the close of the first game.

Last of Us 2's entire story is ultimately about understanding your enemy and why they do what they do, but I'm yet to meet a single person who - when going up against Ellie as Abby - didn't immediately discard the previous 10 hours walked in her shoes, just to let Ellie have her revenge anyway.

Advertisement

Great art should move you, and The Last of Us 2 is a powerful palm-first shove to the notion that any sequel should be what you expect. How it sits now though, is what's really fascinating to discuss.

1. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Konami

If we're factoring in how much a story had to gain and how much it had to lose, Metal Gear Solid V takes the cake.

Advertisement

Seeing Hideo Kojima return to the franchise that made him a household name, five years after 8 hours of cutscenes wrapped up every remaining plot thread in MGS 4, it was going to take an incredible hook to convince anyone to come back.

Well, after a bizarre chunk of time where Kojima pretended to be fake video game developer Joakim Mogren, creating "Phantom Pain" under the team, "Moby Dick Studios", it was revealed MGS 5 would be the "missing link" between both portions of the main timeline.

Advertisement

With MGS 3, Portable Ops and Peace Walker being set in the 80s, and MG1, 2, Metal Gear Solid 1, 2 and 4 being set in the late 90s, 2000s and beyond, the connective tissue was "Big Boss", the hero of the former titles who'd lost his mind in the latter.

What could've driven him to such madness? Why did he give up on America and his duty as a soldier?

Advertisement

Tune in to find out.

Obviously this game was dogged by a very public spat between Kojima and Konami, but the reality is: There was VERY little in here to address that core question.

Advertisement

More narrative ground was covered in Peace Walker when it came to Snake's fracturing mental state, and that was before Phantom Pain brought in flying wales, resurrected MGS 3's Volgin as a man made of fire, and revealed even this version of Snake was a clone, with the real Big Boss still doing his thing somewhere else.

How... succinct.

Advertisement