8 Best Video Game Sequels (That Weren't Actually Sequels)

What's in a name?

By Jules Gill /

Much like the dawning of a new day, the "video game sequel" is something that seems almost inevitable in this day and age.

Advertisement

Very few are the titles that operate as one-and-done experiences in the Triple-A market, mainly because publishers are eager (desperate even) to turn every single one of their games into tentpole franchises. After all the only thing better than making money, is making money with a lower risk of wasted development costs and design time.

Yet some developers see the concept of a sequel in a slightly different light, as thanks to either contractual issues, the inability to carry on their own ideas after leaving a company, or simply because the lead creator has a style so unique that it becomes their trademark, even video games that aren't directly linked can end up being seen as "spiritual successors"

These games might not hold the branding, setting or even gameplay elements of those that it's supposedly tied to, but at their core, their genetic code acts as an homage or even a direct copy of the original.

So, let's take a look at the spirits haunting the bones of titles that sometimes look nothing alike as these are the best Video Game Sequels (That Weren't Actually Sequels)

8. Final Fantasy Tactics - Ogre Battle

While many titles will look to the Final Fantasy series as a point of inspiration for their own adventures, as let's face it can you name any other franchise quite as prolific as Square Enix's monster of a franchise? The series isn't completely free from borrowing ideas from previous titles and reshaping them into new experiences.

Advertisement

Take for example, the utter delight that is the Final Fantasy Tactics offshoot of games, which are heralded by many to be one of the finest examples of the tactics game genre. Ultra polished, ridiculously addictive and with often brilliant narratives, the FF Tactics games really are a pleasure to play, and yet without the equally brilliant Ogre Battle and Tactics Ogre games, they'd likely not exist!

Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together shifted the gameplay of the prior Ogre Battle: The March Of The Black Queen into something that FF Tactics fans will instantly recognize, using an isometric viewpoint and a turn-based battle system.

Unfortunately, despite the outstanding quality of the Ogre Games, sales just weren't adding up for the series to have a lengthy tenure, but rather than have the franchise die, Square Enix decided to take the concept and connect it to the much more popular Final Fantasy IP.

Thus Ogre Battle was allowed to live on, albeit under the guise of another.

7. Asura's Wrath - God Hand

Despite its rather stinky policy on DLC aka charging people for the real end of the game, Asura's Wrath truly is a special slice of video game savagery.

Advertisement

From start to finish this game is an adrenaline rush like no other, showing gamers the world over that despite what your parents tell you, anger can solve all your problems.

Yet while the games visuals, character design, and of course approach to making QTE's actually fun might seem fresher than a crisp winter morning, a lot of players began to comment that Asura's Wrath certainly felt like a sequel to a much loved (unless you were IGN) cult classic.

I'm speaking of course about God Hand, one of the strangest action games ever to exist, a title in which you could kick enemies square in the nuts, battle a group of knock off power rangers, and also race chihuahuas for fun.

This comparison was something that Asura's Wrath producer Kazuhiro Tsuchiya was utterly delighted by, noting that God Hand's approach to cartoonish levels of violence and moments of pure silliness was exactly what he was channelling while making his game.

In his own words, he wanted to make a game that nobody had seen before, and noted that "I'm sure that was the same motivation behind the team that made God Hand as well."

6. Football Manager - Championship Manager

While I personally might not know the difference between a technical foul and the offside rule (I think that's covered by my car breakdown insurance right?) I do know one thing for certain:

Advertisement

People absolutely love the Football Manager games.

That said, things weren't so rosy in 2003 when the original Football Manager game came into existence through a dispute with Eidos. You see originally the game was called Championship Manager and had been doing wonders for the company and its creators ever since its original game dropped in 1993.

When the developers wanted to leave, Eidos denied them access to the game rights, and thus a new franchise was born, carrying over much of the features that made the original so popular.

Both Championship and Football manager would actually run side by side for a while, but when Square Enix bought absorbed the rights and turned things into a mobile-centric experience, there was a sharp decline in passion for Championship Manager, ultimately being canned in 2018.

5. Dark Souls - Demon's Souls

Dark Souls as a series, is one built around a core concept of never, ever giving up, even in the face of overwhelming odds, and while this mantra is normally doled out to the player in incredibly harsh terms, it's a message that Fromsoft learned the hard way when it came to the release of Deamon's Souls on the PS3.

Advertisement

When the game dropped in Japan, sales and critical reception were lukewarm to say the least, and even Sony President Shuhei Yoshida called the title "an unbelievably bad game", leading Sony to pass on publishing the game outside of Japan leaving that job up to Atlus. Thankfully the game became a smash hit in the West and prompted the genesis of the Souls series as we know it today.

However with it came to making a sequel, because of issues with Sony and Bandai Namco, Miyazaki and his team were unable to actually call Dark Souls a true follow up and so the game had to settle for being seen as a "spiritual successor". So there we have it, one of the greatest sequels to a game, that isn't actually a sequel.

4. Anarchy Reigns - Madworld

I think the only thing more shocking than the fact that Madworld, a game so covered in gore that even The Evil Dead said "that's a bit too rich for my blood", dropped for the rather kid-friendly Wii console, is the fact that Anarchy Reigns, a game that also stars Jack Cayman in the lead role was NOT considered a sequel.

Advertisement

Things do start to make a bit more sense when you look at the wider picture, however. For a start, the game was designed to be multiplatform and with Nintendo's deal-making sure Madworld was always going to stay a Wii exclusive, changes had to be made.

Looking at the two side by side also showcases how Anarchy Reigns looked to build on what Madworld had established. The colour palette increased from LOTS OF RED, and had a much greater cast of characters, letting the player take up the mad mantles of 16 different fighters.

This greater roster reflects Anarchy Reigns' shift from one vs many to multiplayer brawler, as Anarchy Reigns big gimmick at the time was taking Madworld and making it multiplayer, and trust me when you could get into a match online, things got utterly silly within moments.

It was actually a pretty smart move on behalf of the game's producer Atsushi Inaba who was also the driving force behind Madworld. Use the star of the former to introduce players to the latter, but then provide expanded gameplay to help cement that this was Madworld but bigger and bloodier.

3. Maximo: Ghosts To Glory - Ghosts N' Goblins

Oh Ghosts N' Goblins, just when I thought I was able to finally break free of the vice grip you have on my heart, you punched through my ribcage with the almighty return to form that was Ghosts N' Goblins Ressurection.

Advertisement

Seriously if you've not played this title, please I urge you to do so as it's 2D platforming bliss.

Just maybe don't do it if you have a weak heart or high blood pressure as you'll be a fizzing mess by the end of things.

Despite its rampant popularity, however, Capcom didn't seem that keen on pumping out sequels for Ghosts N' Goblins, going years and years between entries, and even growing so bored of keeping things 2D that they actually released a 3D spiritual sequel called Maximo: Ghosts To Glory on the PS2.

And it was utterly brilliant!

Seriously the art design, the difficulty, and the tone of the game were just utter chef kiss, as was the fact that despite not being officially related to Ghost's N' Goblins, Capcom wasn't afraid to reference Maximo's inspiration.

When Maximo gets damaged he'll pop out of his armor and show off his boxer shorts, and in the game's opening level they even play a revised version of Ghosts N' Goblin's classic theme. What a corker of a game, and the sequel is even better!

2. Resident Evil - Sweet Home

Despite many seeing the original Resident Evil as the grandfather of the survival horror genre, it turns out that Arklay Mansion might well have been built on the foundations of several other games.

Advertisement

Many noted that the tank-like controls were reminiscent of later Alone in the Dark titles, and the setting of a gothic mansion with Lovecraftian vibes sure did seem to be on the table when Resident Evil was being created.

However, the game in which Resident Evil is the spiritual successor to, according to Capcom at least, is a Famicom title known as Sweet Home. Both games were spearheaded by Shinji Mikami, and originally Resident Evil was designed to be a remake of Sweet Home which would now be able to make use of the Playstations processing power in order to bring elements of Sweet Home to life in ways prior hardware prevented.

Yet because Capcom ended up losing the rights to Sweet Home, the game needed to be rebranded, making the name change from Sweet and Home to Resident and Evil make so much more sense than the rather confusing title did when it dropped in Western markets back in the mid 90s.

1. The Witness - Myst & Riven

The Witness is such a beautiful bastard of a game.

Advertisement

A beautiful bastard that pats you on the back with one hand for solving a rather tricky puzzle, then pushes you off a cliff into the nether with the other while yelling "Have fun trying to figure this out, mate!"

The combination of massive open-world devoid of direction and puzzles so hard they could even beat up that kid at school's dad made for an experience quite unlike anything many gamers had experienced thus far.

However for golden oldies, this feeling would actually be reminiscent of the video game Myst, and more so its sequel Riven, as both game centre around exploration, puzzle-solving and rather mystical elements.

While The Witness would take an absolute deep dive into insanity with its multiple endings, some of which don't just break the fourth wall but utterly shatter it into pieces and grind the wall dust into your eyes, Riven and Myst were no stranger to the ...well strange.

In these games, you'd encounter time travel, magic, fathers and sons trapped in books all wanting to kill the other, all of which was stitched together with rich and rewarding puzzle-centric gameplay.

Honestly if you've finished The Witness and still have that itch, go back and play Myst and Riven.

You won't be disappointed.

Advertisement