8 Great Video Games Spoiled By Terrible Graphics

By Ashley Bailey /

I€™ve never really been one to lend much weight to the notion that graphics are equivocal to a game€™s worth: a game is a sum of all its parts, and a good storyline and/or gameplay can usually make up for bad graphics. Such an argument will always inevitably come up when discussing a medium that€™s inherently visually based; but it€™s difficult to accurately measure €œgood graphics€ when the bar is constantly moving, and a variety of different techniques are being employed. I mean, is Picasso€™s Les Demoiselles d'Avignon in the same league as da Vinci€™s The Last Supper? No. Does that make it any less enjoyable? Of course not. All the same, there are instances when subpar graphics can be detrimental to the enjoyment of a good game. This problem often emanates from technological limitations, or as a direct result of the developers€™ lack of skill/unfeasible gameplay ambitions. Occasionally, even if you are willing to look past the graphical aspects of a game, there can be games forever ruined by particularly rubbish graphics. When conducting this list I decided to not include any games older than twenty years, as it seemed unfair to do so. The choices are either games (new and old) below generational standard, or games that have aged so badly that any fun they may have once held, has long been sucked out of them. Oh, and I have to have at one time considered the game to be good, so they'll be no E.T or Super Man 64 here.

8. Shadow Man (PS1)

The saddest thing about Shadow Man€™s inclusion on this list is that I spent more hours of my childhood exploring the twisted realm of Deadside, than I did any other video game world. But let€™s be honest here: Shadow Man was a very ugly game, and in some instances €“ practically unplayable. When Shadow Man was released in 1999 it explored some heavy themes (evil voodoo, torture, serial murder, etc) and the way it explored these was particularly noteworthy. It threw the player head first into an unimaginable world of misery and pain, and forced the player to endure that misery in order to progress €“ literally, the only relatively €œsafe€ areas of the game, Liveside, render Shadow Man powerless. However, if you were unfortunate enough to own the Play Station version then your experience would have been utterly ruined by shoddy animation, bizarre graphical glitches, poor frame rate and textures that look like they had been done by a contractor off Rouge Traders. The core game had enough questionable design choices as it was: especially its bizarre problem of having fantastic 3D models and environments, but exceptionally dire detailing and textures. Put short, the port should have been locked away in a room down in the darkest depths of the asylum.

7. Dexter: The Game 2 (iOS)

Until recently I wasn€™t even aware there was a game based on Showtime€™s serial killer killer serial (phew). I had long found it surprising there hadn€™t been such a game; after all the concept of ritually delivering bladed justice those who deserve it - whilst keeping the fact you do this a secret - would lend itself perfectly to a Hitman style game. The finished product is not Hitman, but rather a perfectly serviceable adventure with puzzle solving elements. Then I discovered there was a more recently released sequel with additional open world elements. Great, I thought: they€™ve expanded the gameplay, and had three years to polish the graphics, what could possibly go wrong? Quite a lot it would seem. Gameplay wise it€™s rather similar to the first, only with streamlined story elements; or at least I suspect this to be the case, because I quickly stopped playing after succumbing to saw the flawed graphics. Somehow, the game looks worse than the first (which was around mid-life PS2 levels), and fails in almost every other graphical area. Dodgy animations, abnormal graphical glitches, poor textures and the absolute crime of making a beautiful city like Miami look visually austere and stagnant, are all reasons why I wanted to surgically segment Dexter 2. Monumentally disappointing.

6. Powerslave/Exhumed (PS1)

Build engine shooters styled after Doom were the modern military shooters of the mid-to-late nineties. It became increasingly common for such games to have RPG elements and a non-linear structure, and one of the better examples of this type of game is Exhumed. Exhumed was an Egyptian mythology take on the 90€™s, and featured a Metroidvanian style of upgrade and exploration system. It was actually pretty fun. But unfortunately Powerslave was still a build FPS, and thus extremely ugly. Consider the fact that it was released in 1996/7 and featured flat sprites, when during that period shooters that used proper 3D models (Quake and Goldeneye) were being released. To make matters worse, the art direction in Powerslave took a semi-realistic approach similar to Duke Nukem 3D so that all the enemies ending up blurry and pixelated: a problem common among such games, but at least Doom and Blood have retained a charmingly cartoony appeal. I tried playing Powerslave the other week, but just couldn€™t get past the terrible resolution. The other problem Powerslave suffered from was its horrible environments. Whilst it had some of the best 3D levels to grace a build engine game, the actual aesthetics are quite simply bland and repetitive; I understand that the setting is somewhat limiting, but it doesn't excuse the lazy, uninspired level design. The levels become increasingly detailed as you progress (alien structures, volcanoes etc) but you€™ll spend the majority of the game exploring uninteresting generic brown locales; like Indiana Jones on one of his less exciting adventures.

5. Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Xbox 360, PS3)

I€™m pretty sure this is going to be a controversial pick, but nevertheless onto the list it goes. When the game was released in 2006 the graphics were a huge leap up from Morrowind €“ I remember the water effects and some Oblivion locations being particularly breathtaking - but even back then I never actually felt the game as a whole was beautiful: the character models were absolutely hideous for a start. Everyone had suddenly gone from being perilously thin and under developed in Morrowind, to round faced, bug eyed and generally saggy. It€™s like Invasion of the Body Snatchers, only instead of replacing the NPCs with perfect replicas they were replaced by a much older version of themselves. The world itself was pretty unremarkable, and lacked the charm and character of the previous settings in the series. The draw distance had improved remarkably, but Cyrodiil still felt so small and simplistic compared to Vvenderfell. Everything about Cyrodiil was lifeless and homogenised, and in the six intermittent years it has only gotten worse. Oblivion certainly doesn€™t have the worst graphics I€™ve seen in a current generation game: but I€™m kind of put off from returning, knowing I can get a more enjoyable experience in Morrowind or Skyrim. I€™m also aware that high res mods are available for the PC version, but unfortunately my laptop is too inadequate for such endeavours. But if I did, I€™m pretty sure I€™d have more important mods to install first: like the Mr. Mochi mod and, inevitably, the nude mod.

4. Body Harvest (N64)

Oh how I remember this game fondly: it came out I was seven and was about using planes and tanks to do battle with giant bugs (and occasionally, robots). If it included the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Body Harvest would have been a suspiciously accurate representation of what was going on in the back of my maths textbook. Ostensibly an open world game, it€™s hardly surprising that BH was designed by the studio that would go on to become Rockstar. The problem with BH is while the gameplay is utterly solid €“rather obvious, considering the game is about raining vehicular death on creatures from beyond - the world itself is blander than a timeshare pitch by Alistair Darling. The whole explore the world at will concept, whilst fairly ambitious, is ultimately pointless. In the game€™s favour each level did actually feel sprawling, and the level design got progressively deeper as the story went on; the fact there are five of them (3 vanilla, 2 secret) helped cement DMA lofty ambitions. But there was no substance to the world, which was poorly textured and utterly void of life; and you could guarantee that if there was any architecture even remotely interesting it€™d make an appearance in the story. The game also had weird scaling issues: Adam would often be smaller than most standard vehicles, but ten times larger than any insignificant NPC. Still, name one other game that let you fight aliens and drive an ice cream van.

3. Deadly Premonition (Xbox 360, PS3)

Merge Twin Peaks with the eccentricity of Richard Garriot and you€™ll have a half way decent experience of what Deadly Premonition is. It€™s often rightfully described as one of the most polarising games ever, owning to its incredible ambition, technical shortcomings and absolutely bonkers design quirks. Ignition Entertainment wanted to create an evolving open world city where all the characters had their own schedules. If you€™ve never played it and want an easily digestible sound bite: Deadly Premonition is Shenmue with extra-dimensional monsters. It€™s like a senescent Lothario desperately clinging onto his youth by frequenting Club 18 -30 destinations, there are times when Deadly Premonition looks almost acceptable, but under a certain light one can see it for the decrepit, aging creation that it is. Aficionados of the game claim the idiosyncratic graphics add to the whole Twin Peaks fevered dream tone, but whilst I€™m willing to concede to the similar eclectic gameplay counterargument, I can€™t accept that the graphics are anything other than poor. It€™s practically on par with the PS2 at times, later era PS2 mind, but PS2 levels nonetheless: you don't defend a serial killer because he "only" offed homeless guys.

2. Afraid of Monsters (Half-Life 1 Mod - PC)

Afraid of Monsters (2005) is a mod for the original Half Life. It is primarily known for being designed by a 13 year old (Andreas Ronnberg), and for its alleged abilities as a rather entertaining laxative. The whole drug addict story line is rather thin, but takes the player to some rather twisted and surreal places; and pits you off against hordes of terrifying monsters. Well, in theory anyway. Horror is at its best when it€™s ugly. It€™s the reason why Silent Hill can still scare to this day. The only problem with Afraid of Monsters is that it is a combat heavy game. In the aforementioned Silent Hill combat usually boils down to either a desperate struggle, or tactical evasion: you rarely get the time to notice how goofy or dated the enemy models look. Afraid of Monsters€™ combat mechanics mostly play out like they did in Half Life. Since you usually have enough firepower to survive each encounter, the horror relies on the monsters€™ psychical appearance alone. And whilst their design is creepily inspired - and can provide the odd initial shock - the models themselves are so hilariously dated and clunky it negates the previously hard earned tension and atmosphere. Ultimately, Half Life is still an enjoyable game. As is Afraid of Monsters; it just unfortunately confirms horribly dated that classic actually is.

1. High Heat Major League Baseball 2003 (PS2)

Forget Fifa, Madden NFL and NHL - apart from the one that let you play as zombies - The High Heat Baseball games were my favourite sports sims. They were always had a plethora of game modes, statistics/attributes and demonstrated a simple to play, difficult to master ethos. The only area where the games continually failed was in the graphics department; something which cumulated in HHMLB 2003. Try and play the 2003 edition today, and chances are the first thing that€™ll strike (sorry) you is that the character models are abominations. And by abomination I don€™t mean anything as stylish and intricate as Mothra, I€™m talking Innsmouthian Fishmen. Take Sean Casey up there, his model looks like Max Payne after having a freezer bag melted onto his face. I€™m no Baseball expert, but I reckon if you are adorning an expression that€™s somewhere between an unashamed outburst of emotion and receiving a prostate exam from a Parkinson€™s suffering Freddy Kruger, then you are doing something wrong. Agree or disagree with this list? Let us know in the comments section below.