8 Horror Video Games That Broke The 4th Wall
Invading your fears, and your homes for good measure.
When looking at what makes horror video games so appealing, one might point to the fact that it's the closest experience we can get to the real thing. With horror films you're placed into a passive role, the events will happen no matter your reaction and that's that. With video games, however, you're in direct control of your avatar, which means if you mess up, that's them done for.
However, there's still that relative level of safety. After all, you're in control of the game and can pause the experience or even turn it off if things get too much. So of course that's when some games choose to go that one step further and obliterate any sense of the fourth wall in order to get a rise out of you.
These are eight such examples, of times when simply killing, maiming, or frightening the player character wasn't enough and that it was the player themselves who were on the chopping block. So brace yourselves as these games won't let you quit if the going gets tough, and trust me, they make sure it does.
8. Calendula
The concept of a game that refuses to be played seems, on paper at least, like the worst USP for any title on the market. After all, we choose video games as a form of entertainment so why would we want to be locked out of it?
Well, Calendula is no ordinary game, and from the moment that it refuses to let you play, citing issues with your own hardware, you know something is deeply wrong here. Calendula operates almost exclusively on fourth wall breaking moments and challenges the player to work out how to actually play this game all the while positing that there is an evil force behind all of this.
What makes all of this so unsettling is that when you do get glimpses of the "game" itself, you'll wish you hadn't as the images are disturbing, to say the least.
Still, because it teases out what is behind all the tricks and traps, you'll press on... although when you see what's in store at the end of Calendula, maybe you should just put the whole program in the trash.
What do you mean I can't?
7. Doki Doki Literature Club
I still get chills when I think about Doki Doki Literature Club, as never has a game been so unassuming at first glance before turning into pure nightmare fuel.
The pretence of a high school dating sim absolutely nosedives the moment that one of the main cast ends up killing themselves. At first you can't entirely believe it's happened, which makes the subsequent fourth wall shattering moment of another club member telling you to delete that character from the game like a one-two punch to the chest.
Playing through Doki Doki will drop all pretence of being "just a game" from that moment on, and while it might not sound horrifying, having one of the members confess their love to you the player, rather than you the character is so uncomfortable I had to switch it off for a while.
Even upon returning this wasn't the last of the meta horror, as you had to effectively root out the evil from within the game files itself, making you question where the boundaries of this horror title lay. If indeed there are any at all.
6. Dead Space 2
The Dead Space franchise is probably the last place you'll be expecting to find a fourth-wall breaking moment, as it's so invested in telling the horrifying tale of Isaac Clarke and keeping you hooked that it seems like it would come at the detriment of its narrative.
However, Dead Space 2 is a master of horror and uses a fourth wall break to truly unsettle the player. It's not a grandiose moment like some others on this list, but thanks to Stross, it's a chilling moment to say the least.
Stross has been driven mad by hallucinations of his dead family, and as the game progresses these get worse and worse. Becoming detached from his reality he begins to ramble about things beyond their existence, and in a single moment looks directly down the lens of the camera and tells the player to "stop looking at me".
It's a brief moment, but it's one that makes you aware of all the other times Stross's eyes flitted over to you while he spoke with Isaac, seemingly inferring that he knew you were there the entire time.
5. Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines
Now Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines is not a game that takes itself too seriously. It's hilariously over the top in places and is a constant mix of brooding sexy vampires who dole out dialogue so cheesy the fromagerie has been on the phone and a wonderful B-Movie delight.
In fact, there promises to be so much schlocky and campy fun that it threatens to spill out into the real world as well, for when the player arrives in Los Angeles only to be ambushed by some Sabbat vampires, one of the fanged scenery chewers turns to the camera and states,"Those of you in the first few rows, will get wet!"
It's such a cheesy interaction with the player that the ambushing group might well land a few hits on you as you're reeling from laughter. You can elicit more strange "aware that they're in a video game" moments if you choose to be a Malkavian, which are basically this games version of Deadpool aka so unhinged that they believe their reality to be false.
And to be fair to them, it is!
4. Silent Hill 3
For a franchise that bases a lot of its enemy designs on fears from within the human psyche, it actually makes perfect sense that Silent Hill would attempt to live rent-free in your brain for a bit with a solid fourth wall break or two, and across the franchise, it has indulged in this "delightful" treat a fair few times.
In Downpour, countless references are made to the player's choices in ways which completely mess with your head. For example when you reach the prison and experience another brain-bending flashback, the loading screen drops the pretence of offering the player tips and instead says ominously "was it worth it?"
And in Silent Hill 3 we get a brilliant meta nod to the series itself which comes when Heather, forced to examine a nasty looking toilet, turns to the player and says "who would do something so disgusting?". This little Easter egg can only be found if you still have a save of Silent Hill 2 on your memory card, and references when James performed an equally disgusting moment of amateur plumbing.
Gross.
3. SCP Containment Breach
A quick way to test if someone has had a trouser browning moment while playing SCP Containment Breach is by checking their eyes when you mention its name. If you can hear the sound of their body producing emergency moisture then ding ding, you have a winner, as blinking in this game is basically an invitation for a heart attack.
This is because not only will the "horrifying potato baby who will eat your soul" that is the poster child for this game rip you limb from limb should you blink and allow it to teleport close enough to you, but even if you try and take a short break to catch your breath or phone an ambulance, the game will mock you for it.
Not the character. The player. As if you decide to try and pause the game while being chased by one of the SCP the game will display a message reading "Stop Hiding" and sometimes, as a real boot to the pride, UNPAUSE the game for you.
Cheers mate. Just what I needed.
2. Pony Island
As with previous entry on this list, Calendula, the fourth wall breaks come so hard and fast with Pony Island that they are mere mounds of dust after a few minutes of gameplay. Positing you as the unlucky player of the 1992 game Pony Island, you must perform rudimentary back end programming in order to actually play the game.
However, as you progress through all of these option checks, resets, and... er... soul deposits you become aware that the title itself is demonically possessed and will not let you stop playing until you have completed it. As the game mentions itself, this experience is "challenging but fair" and will push you to think literally outside of the box in order to get around this satanic security.
Things veer directly into the creepy territory though when the game actively messages you on Steam (if you're playing it through this platform) with made-up accounts to warn you or give information. This suddenly moves from you playing a character to actually being addressed by the game itself. It's funny how this one extra level of interaction makes an otherwise pseudo horror comedy title genuinely terrifying.
1. Eternal Darkness
Of course Eternal Darkness was going to be on here. How could it not be when the "sanity effects" it showcases are possibly the most memorable thing about this stellar survival horror title?
It was a brave move from Silicon Knights to implement features into Eternal Darkness that would mess with the player as it stands a possibility of falling foul of the "gimmick" term, but the sheer number of ways that this game messes with the player is brilliant and downright terrifying.
Moments like statue heads following you down corridors, or the walls dripping with blood will set your pulse racing, but these are bloody subtle compared to when the game wrests control away from you, muting the tv and in the most extreme case, pretending to delete your saves. That, as a fourth wall break was too far for some.
It's enough to leave you so unnerved that you won't trust anything you're being presented with, which is exactly what the developers intended.