Right then everyone, Im going for it. Ill do my best to break down the various viewpoints around this rather hefty debate, as it seems 2013 has been the year when this discussion has boiled over into the overall gaming vernacular. Not only have we had Bioshock: Infinite do extremely well with its controversial prejudicial depictions of an Old-America-gone-wild, but also The Last of Us with its zombie-backdrop-black-mirror, questioning the player as to how inhumane they are forced to become to survive an apocalyptic nightmare with some sense of humanity intact. Im not about to pick apart the biggest most easily-accessible titles under the guise of high art, much the same as a discussion around films artistic label would not immediately be applied to Michael Bays Transformers series. That being said as the debate around video games as art rages on, I do think they are an ever-increasingly important medium that is often at the forefront of media consumption. Just look at the incredible success of Grand Theft Auto V (29 million units so far) for confirmation as to how something that was once regarded as a literally-underground pastime has crossed over into being fully embraced by the mainstream.
8. Aesthetic Beauty
So before we get into the weightier stuff, lets get the most common artistic reference point out the way. For the most part when a lot of people consider something to be art, or to have an artistic quality, they refer purely to aesthetics. Whilst that does lend some credence as to whether something has been produced with a degree of talent, it can miss the point of how a creation should be viewed. There are so many abstract pieces of physical art in the real world that get roundly trounced by mainstream critics or the general publics viewpoint, based on the assumption that any piece of art should 'wow' you or present an immediate visual showcase of talent and colour. Thats not the case depending on what the creator may be trying to say, as with the heart of an artistic message there are other ways to convey the gamut of human emotion in physical form other than conforming to an idea of what a piece should be. A game as mechanically-minimalistic as Journey is just as worthwhile as the bleak palette of The Last of Us, or the bright exuberant fantasy world of Bioshock: Infinite is just as worthy of exploration as the real-world offices of The Stanley Parable, if we are to take the very idea of intended expression as a worthwhile artistic endeavor.
7. Passive vs. Active Audiences
Now into one of the many things that separates gaming as a medium from that of films or books; the active participation of an audience to unlock the rest of the game by way of playing through it. Comedian Dara OBriain once remarked that gaming is the only medium that will restrict content to those that dont possess the adequate skills to view it. With a passive medium such as film or the written word, the content is fully formed and will unfold in front of you should you pay attention, requiring no input to facilitate a full experience. This is something that feeds into the authorship debate around gaming, being that many ask how a piece of content that requires user input to take it, can be classified as art.
6. Intrinsic and Extrinsic Reward Systems
Instilment of drive and the will to carry on is one of gamings most identifiable tropes, especially in the face of the previous point where a developer needs to engage a player enough to actually uncover the majority of their content. With games costing increasingly more and more to create, big developers are taking less risks with their content not being seen as worthwhile, therefore we see the likes of EAs Unlock All optional paid DLC, or Ubisofts UPlay reward schemes allowing access to components that make their games easier to get through. Whilst few games feature extrinsic reward systems i.e. there are no incentives outside of completing the game for either yourself or others, instead they center on intrinsic reward schemes such as the joy you get from playing. Small Klei Entertainment-developed indie-title Dont Starve places you in the shoes of Wilson, a scientist marooned on a desert island. With almost no exposition youre just left to your own devices, with the realisation that night will be coming soon and you need to find some shelter. The game was something of an experiment in intrinsic reward value, as there are no extrinsic rewards for getting anywhere in the game, instead the only pleasure you can garner from playing is to see how far you can get on the in-game calendar. With a plethora of creatures all baying for your blood, its an effort to get through the first few nights, until (for some players) they settled into a routine of hunter-gathering to conquer the next few weeks. If art in its highest sense is designed to make us think and ponder our own existence by way of projecting aspects of our personality into different visual systems, then games like Dont Starve provide immeasurable evidence that games stand for something more than the assumed its just for kids/teens mentality often levied our way.
5. Auteurship
Alongside the increased size of development studios and the emergence of video games as a medium some younger teams have grown up with, games have developed a sense of auteurship, whereby we are able to identify a game based on a particular screenwriter or development studio. Rockstar games such as Grand Theft Auto, Red Dead Redemption or even Bully are easily identified as their own, as are Naughty Dog games with their trademark level of polish and animation. Thats not to mention the swathe of memorable figures such as Peter Molyneux, Jonathon Blow, David Cage and Ken Levine etc. that have emerged over the past few years, lending even more weight to the fact that individuals with great creative visions can exist in gaming just as in music, film or books.
4. Character Studies
A staple of some modern games is the ability to dissect character motivations and actions, thereby providing another link to other vested media forms where such discussions usually take place. One of the most controversial topics this very minute is that around the actions of GTA Vs Trevor; is he an unredeemable psychopath, or a horrifically misguided soul searching for companionship? Is what happens in the last few minutes of The Last of Us justifiable considering that game's context and character progression? These are fascinating discussions that must rely on some of the most fleshed out titles to do justice, as although you could question Sonics fascination with glowing rings back in the 90s, games have come so much further than just bleeps and bloops these days, to actually instil genuine emotional reaction within the player is evidence of their evolution.
3. Filmic Comparisons
It does serve to point out that many games are taking influence purely from films, as for the most part some of the people making them were brought up on the classics of yesteryear. Uncharted is a love-letter to Indiana Jones, Mass Effect a tribute to all things Star Trek, and Grand Theft Auto V a ribbon-tipped arrow straight to the heart of Michael Manns Heat, amongst a cavalcade of titles all paying tribute in varying degrees of subtlety to the tropes of Western Cinema. If we forget the strides that gaming has made through interaction, player agency and authorship of a creative experience, and just take them as a collective work put together to tell a story similar to other narrative frameworks, whats stopping games from qualifying as a piece of expression in that way alone?
2. Authorship
The answer to that question is authorship, and the biggest distancing factor from video games being immediately placed with their fellow new-age contemporaries. I already mentioned the fact that games will lock away content to inexperienced players, but even if you are a struggling player, the game is relying on you to navigate through its levels in a certain way. However although the detractors of the Games as Art debate would seek to say that no experience whereby authorship is taken away from the creator can be art, the counter-point would be that all elements that are open to interaction are coded by the designers in the first place. When playing Grand Theft Auto V, there may be occasional glitches or bugbears within the game that take away from the overall experience, but anything the player can do is forever governed by the coding of the game. As obvious as this is, at no point in any game can you alter things to make them better fit your idea of how a game should play, and that is the true sense of authorship prevalent in video games; the designers. Those who would say that the experience is authored by the player would be correct, if said experience was not fully governed in the first place by the rulesets programmed into the game. Obviously Im not accounting for people who spend their time breaking down code for the sake of finding out how to make their character briefly take flight or how to pass through a building in one step. Even so, the assets they are interacting with were put there by the true authors of the experience, and must be dealt with through stringent reliance on how that game animates and controls before anything else can be changed.
1. Defining Art - Expression Through Intent
The biggest overall problem, as with any emerging mediums recognition by a larger populace, is with established norms and definitions being challenged and changed over time. If we take the answer to what is art? to be, in the broadest terms possible expression with intent, then we can apply it to any game from Call of Duty to The Stanley Parable, Grand Theft Auto to Flower, being that the notion behind all game-making is a creative process that takes structured thought and replicates it somewhat within the confines of an interactive experience. The likes of Beyond: Two Souls, The Walking Dead or even L.A. Noire all feature a heavy amount of cinematic sequences, yet something like Beyond seemed to give up a robust set of gameplay mechanics for the sake of an accessible narrative that allows anybody to complete the game in their own way. However this year we have also seen the phenomenal The Last of Us, a game that has very moving cinematic cutscenes, yet leant more towards letting you control the vast majority of them, convincingly marrying the two ideas of what a game should be, and ticking the right boxes of influence from the film world. Games are a very different medium to anything that has gone before, primarily due to the emergence of technology that provides gameworlds that are more than just simple goal-chases, exercises in hand-eye coordination or puzzle-completion. These systems have been implemented into newer titles that provide narrative rewards alongside the intrinsic joy of playing, cementing video games as a medium worth taking part in. So what did you guys think? Is the title of this article enough to make you groan-out another 'Not again!'? Or are you pretty content with where video games are in the overall societal spectrum? Let us know in the comments!