8 Ridiculous Video Game Plotholes We Love Anyway

These games just wouldn't be the same without these totally daft plot holes.

By Jack Pooley /

Plot holes are an inevitability in any piece of media and certainly video games, which with their typically more expansive runtimes than, say, movies, invite the probability of some serious lapses in narrative logic.

Advertisement

Plot holes can be majorly distracting when they're big enough to drive a truck through, but at the same time, there's something to be said for favouring feeling over logic where media consumption is concerned.

And then there are those plot holes which, while utterly absurd, bring a charm and personality to the table that makes them tough to hate. Hell, you might even like or straight-up love them.

That's absolutely the case with these totally bonkers, wildly WTF plot video game plot holes, each of which have been widely dissected by the fandom, and yet whose presence many fans will defend to their dying breath.

From head-scratching disparities between story and gameplay to plot twists that just make no damn sense at all, these holes could've been utterly game-ruining if circumstances were slightly different, but here they're simply a quirky part of each game's DNA. 

Without these gaping plot holes, these games just wouldn't be the same...

8. Codec Calls Make NO SENSE - Metal Gear Solid

One of the most distinctive elements of the Metal Gear Solid franchise is the codec - a discrete radio communications device which each game's protagonist wears in their ear to communicate with their support team.

Advertisement

In the original Metal Gear Solid, the concealed nature of the codec obviously prevents enemy soldiers from overhearing Colonel Campbell and others talking to Snake, but Snake is still shown speaking at a totally regular volume. What gives?

It's comical to think about Snake crouching down and speaking at great length for minutes at a time all while Genome Soldiers are waltzing around mere feet away, apparently blissfully unaware.

In a game centered around stealth of all things, it's especially ludicrous, and yet, in its own way a rather charming quirk of the series - something most fans are prepared to accept because the codec dialogues are just so damn cool.

Hideo Kojima did however come up with a convoluted workaround for Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty, where the codec now handles communications via nanomachines, ensuring that characters can "speak" while appearing silent to the outside observer. Wild.

7. What Happened To The Destroyed Moon? - Sonic

In Sonic Adventure 2, Dr. Eggman uses his ultra-powerful Eclipse Cannon to rip a huge chunk out of the moon, yet as totally insane an accomplishment as this is, it's bafflingly ignored by every other game in the series since, where the moon just looks totally fine once again.

Advertisement

It's completely absurd, and yet it became much tougher to take genuine issue with this once Sonic Adventure 2 director Takashi Iizuka pulled an explanation out of the deepest recesses of his ass.

When put on the spot in an interview with Game Informer, Iizuka hilariously declared that the moon looks fine post-Sonic Adventure 2 because it has rotated around to show its "good side," with the destroyed side remaining out of view in the dark.

Iizuka also added that the moon in the Sonic games doesn't have the same physical properties as the one in our own reality, so the damage dealt to it wouldn't have an impact on, say, the tides on Earth.

What the hell, sure.

6. Everything About Doors - Resident Evil

Since the Resident Evil series' inception, one of its key characteristics has been a bevy of locked doors which players can only unlock by finding keys which are typically gated behind a host of convoluted puzzles, because why the hell wouldn't they be?

Advertisement

For anyone playing Resident Evil for the first time, it's impossible not to look at these locked doors and wonder why our heavily armed protagonists aren't able to cut the middle man out and just shoot or blow each problematic door to shreds.

This is especially egregious in areas of the games where the doors look like they're made of flimsy wood. As a wise man once said, it don't make no damn sense.

But Resident Evil just wouldn't be Resident Evil without these hilariously overbaked, at time maddeningly obtuse puzzles. 

Just like having to use ink ribbons to save your progress and magically healing near-fatal wounds with a first aid spray, it's fundamentally illogical, but nevertheless an iconic, even much-loved staple of the franchise.

5. How Can Mirror Face Change His Face? - Yakuza: Like a Dragon

Impressively one-upping Yakuza 4's infamous rubber bullet fiasco as the dumbest, most credibility-straining thing in the Yakuza franchise - and that's really saying something - we have the Mirror Face nonsense from Yakuza: Like a Dragon.

Advertisement

Mirror Face is an assassin introduced later in the game who possesses the mysterious ability to shapeshift and perfectly assume the identity of anyone he so wishes, right down to their voice and muscle mass.

Now to be clear, this franchise has always had an innate silliness about it, though there's also been a consistency to that absurdity, and the more out-there stuff is usually confined to substories which are of dubious canonicity.

Yet introducing a guy in the main story who can inexplicably assume the full form of anyone he wants, through techniques unknown, was seen as a bridge too wild by many fans.

But personality also goes a long way. Yes, Mirror Face is deeply stupid, but unless you're taking the Yakuza series' story dead-seriously at face value - which, let's be honest, you really shouldn't be - it's easy to cackle with glee at how little sense this twist makes.

4. The Inconsistency of Phoenix Downs - Final Fantasy

While it's often parroted that Phoenix Downs in the Final Fantasy franchise can be used to bring dead party members back to life, that's of course not quite true - they're actually used to revive KO'd party members.

Advertisement

Yet there's a fundamental inconsistency to the effectiveness of Phoenix Downs, given that one apparently couldn't be used to save Aerith after being mortally impaled by Sephiroth in Final Fantasy VII, even though we've seen them used to heal characters from far more insane injuries in the heat of battle.

Now to be totally fair, we're definitely tiptoeing into ludonarrative dissonance territory here, where there's a sheer disconnect between a game's story and gameplay.

Phoenix Downs are basically only ever as effective as Square Enix wants them to be at any given moment. It's silly, but there's also a charm to it - a Very Gamey Thing that many players not only accept, but find somewhat amusing.

3. Nobody Identifies Makarov At The Airport - Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2's "No Russian" is the most controversial mission in the series' history, as the player goes undercover with terrorist Vladimir Makarov while his team commits a mass shooting at a Russian airport.

Advertisement

At the end of the mission, however, Makarov reveals that he knew you were undercover the entire time, killing your character and leaving their corpse to be discovered by the authorities, in turn implicating the U.S. in the attack.

What's truly bizarre, however, is that despite this, Makarov - again, a super high-profile mega-terrorist - doesn't wear a mask during the assault, and yet inexplicably isn't quickly identified through the airport's surveillance systems.

After all, the post-mission cutscene even shows the airport's cameras being used to zoom in on a bullet used in the attack and identify that it came from Brazil, so why the hell wouldn't Makarov have been ID'd in a mere matter of seconds, ensuring his plan instantly went up in smoke?

The real answer, of course, is that any Call of Duty campaign is best enjoyed as a big, dumb, loud Michael Bay movie that's allergic to anything beyond surface-level logic - and that's just fine.

2. How Did B.J. Blaskowitz Stay In Shape? - Wolfenstein: The New Order

At the start of Wolfenstein: The New Order, ass-kicking protagonist B.J. Blaskowitz is seriously injured and held in a Polish asylum where he remains in a catatonic state for a whopping 14 years.

Advertisement

Yet when B.J. finally snaps out of it - as one does - and the player takes control of him, there's virtually no adjustment period whatsoever. 

Blaskowitz is immediately back to his hell-raising self - his muscles haven't atrophied at all and he's looking every bit as swole as ever despite spending the better part of 15 years confined to a wheelchair.

This obviously doesn't vibe with basic science, but also, it's a Wolfenstein game - adhering to rigid scientific principles went out the window a long time ago.

But the fun answer - which also happens to be the best and correct answer - is that B.J.'s physical wellbeing was sustained solely by his white-hot hatred for the Nazi scum. 

His body simply wouldn't allow him to degenerate physically because it knew, at a cellular level, that he had so much more Nazi-murdering left to do.

1. Scott Shelby's Inner Thoughts - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain was widely criticised on launch for its manipulative, even dishonest approach to its big plot twist, that the Origami Killer is actually one of the game's central characters, private detective Scott Shelby.

Advertisement

The big issue is that, considering we're privy to the thoughts of each playable character during the game, it makes no damn sense at all that we're able to control Scott and investigate the Origami Killer's crimes as though we're not the killer ourselves.

And then there's the infamous scene at the antique shop, where the Origami Killer strikes while we're controlling Shelby. How does this work? The truth is, it doesn't.

But it was much easier to be angry about this in 2010. 15 years removed from Heavy Rain's release, where its reputation has morphed from a gritty cinematic thriller into a campy slice of choose-your-own-adventure kitsch, it's far easier to roll with the silliness of its twist, especially on repeat playthroughs.

It's an entertaining game packed to the gills with odd creative quirks - David Cage-isms, you might say - and this is just another one of them. It's stupid, but it just wouldn't be Heavy Rain without a contrived, Telenovela-worthy clunker of a final twist.

Advertisement