8 Terrible Decisions Made In Horror Video Games
DON'T. SPLIT. UP.
Whether it’s the shambling of a corpse freshly risen from the grave, or a demonic spawn of Satan throwing prams and nannies about like they were made of paper, horror as a genre is something that is deeply rooted, loved, and analysed by our society.
It’s that unknown fear of what lies beyond our understanding of death, and a pervasive unease that comes from modern life that manifests in tales of monsters and madness. It’s also something that’s been heavily embraced by video games as players seek to uncover mysteries and avoid being munched on by all sorts of nastiness.
Yet, as is true with horror films, if you’re going to make it to the end, you’re going to have to be smart. No running upstairs when Jasons on the ground floor, no bringing a toaster to the water levels in Amnesia and don’t even think about eating that feast in Resident Evil 7.
It’s a shame that the entries on this list do the exact opposite, and are perfect examples of what NOT to do when sh*t hits the fan.
8. Any Horror Game - Splitting Up
Horror movies and splitting up go together like peanut butter and a knife to the gut, because abandoning your friends at the drop of a hat to go “check out a noise” is a terrible, terrible idea. You know why they give police officers partners? It’s not so they can hold the coffee while you interrogate a perp, it’s because they have your back - and so any time you see a character in a video game asking to do a solo run, you have to question their logic.
So many video games have pulled this trick as it’s a great way of putting players on edge - fear comes through isolation, after all - but in terms of gameplay, it can make for some pretty terrible decisions. Who can forget Barry abandoning us at the drop of a hat, or the gang from Until Dawn popping to the shops to leave you on your lonesome? Even in a game like Obscure where you go off in pairs, you’re STILL splitting off from the safety of the main group.
So the next time someone says “let’s split up and search for clues”, remind them as best you can that this isn’t a Saturday morning cartoon, and stick to each other like you’re playing Left 4 Dead, because the group that stays together, slays forever.
7. Looking For Notes - Slender
Now, this isn’t necesscarily a dumb decision by personal player choice here, since Slender: The Eight Pages all but forces you into this mess by dropping you right in the middle of the supernatural s**t. You appear in the woods, armed with nothing but a flashlight, and have to go scratting around for notes hidden in various locations whilst big bad Slenderman hunts you in the background.
And to make this whole thing worse, the notes are nothing more than some lame scribbles and a couple of janky drawings of the long limbed rascal himself - so why on earth are you hanging around to pick them all up?
Being stalked by a supernatural creature in the middle of the night that’s intent on sending you mental is more than enough reason to hop the little fence that’s holding him in and get the hell out of there. You can literally draw your own, better versions of these scrawled pages in the comfort of your own home and not get a front row seat of slender-vision whilst you’re at it - so why on earth your character doesn’t just cheese it is a particularly strange mystery. Daddy slender isn’t worth hanging around for, guys.
6. Actually Going To Willamette - Dead Rising
Frank West: what a guy, am I right? Not only has he covered wars, but he’s a wise cracking photo hound who’ll stop at nothing to get to the bottom of what’s going on in Willamette and Fortune City. Yet... that’s not to say he’s the smartest man alive by any stretch of the imagination.
By this I mean that despite seeing very literal and HD focused evidence of a zombie outbreak on his flight into Willamette, he STILL decides to go on with his mission of gathering a scoop. Frank mate, you’ve GOT your scoop right there, you saw a gas station explode, a man get eaten alive and another get pushed off a roof, you don’t need to know any more GET OUT OF THERE.
However, on he plods and manages to enter the Mall in which he spends the next 3 days and beyond fighting for his life. Plus he puts a tonne of trust in his pilot to come back which is a ropey escape plan at best, and the way he reacts to the helicopter going down showcases he’s not even CONSIDERED an alternative route of exit. Frank, I love you, but that’s just dumb.
5. William Birkin Injecting Himself - Resident Evil
There have been many, MANY strange decisions made within the Resident Evil Franchise. From Claire and Leon splitting up and ignoring the bolt cutters right next to them in the RE2 Remake, to ANYONE who trusts Wesker (because I mean, LOOK at him), all the way to Chris punching the ever-loving crap out of that boulder.
However, there’s one TERRIBLE decision that takes place in Resident Evil 2 which really can’t be overlooked, and it comes at the hands - or claws - of Dr William Birkin. Birkin was a scientist who worked on the G-Virus, a concoction that was meant to provide the host with regenerative abilities and the usual super soldier guff that mad scientists love, but when he decided to go rogue against the Umbrella corporation and sell this juice to Uncle Sam, they sent a team to gun him down in his lab.
Here’s where the dumb decision comes into play. After being shot and having his supply of the virus stolen, Birkin injects himself with an uncontrolled dose of the G and turns into a monstrosity. He KNEW that such a dose mutated everything it came into contact with, and he also would have know from his experiments that the hosts lose control. Yet he did it anyway, not only dooming himself, but thanks to smashing all the vials of the G and T virus when he caught up to his would be murderers, also infected Racoon city through its sewers. Absolute idiot.
4. Going Back For Another Night At Work - Five Nights At Freddys
I think we’ve all worked for companies where going in for the day to day is an absolute chore, where there’s literally only the paycheque keeping you from storming out of the place on an hourly basis.
And yet you put up with it because of utilities, food and rent bills to pay, and it absolutely sucks. Right now ask yourself, would you be as prepared to put up with all that crap AND deal with horrifying mechanical mascots who are trying to crush you to death and are possibly haunted by the ghost of a dead kid? Nah me neither, so why oh why do you continue to put yourself through this night after night in Five Nights At Freddies?
Worse still is that while you’ve got countless cameras to manage as well as the horrible mascots, you’re also working with a strange antiquated system that uses power to CLOSE a door. Getting your head around that alone would be a nightmare, and then to have to live through one each evening is more than any pay slip is worth.
It’s not like the boss can say “What do you mean you don’t want to work for minimum wage at a company where suits try to murder you? Who are you, the King of Spain?”
3. Entering The Asylum UNARMED - Outlast
Now, this one is pretty self explanatory. As a private investigator, sticking your nose into unpleasant situations on the daily, as well as being faced with the classically spooky set up of a psychiatric institution that’s operating under abnormal circumstances, as well as then arriving to see that the place is half ruined and there’s no security or officials in sight - you’d at the very least take a big stick with you to smack any ill intentioned folk you’re likely to stumble across along the way.
But no. Not Miles Upshur, the big idiot. He thinks he’s fine walking into an asylum full of experimental horrors without even a pea shooter in his pocket. He very easily could have decided to arm himself before going in, but feels that the power of a video camera and hyperventilation is all he needs to fend off the clinically insane.
Riddle me this: how the hell are you going to defend yourself with paper file, Miles? How?! The answer, as you all know, is not at all, as this dumbass gets himself into all sorts of situations that could really easily be solved with a both a pistol and a flashlight. Some private investigator you are.
2. Fontaine Ignores Evidence In Front Of His Eyes And Takes All The ADAM - Bioshock
Rapture is a hell of a place isn’t it? Full of the smartest minds of the time, unbridled by petty morality and unpunished for exploring areas of experimentation that really should be left alone. Their revolutionary breakthrough in the discovery of the sea slug containing ADAM is what led to their brilliant rise and horrific fall, but it seems like few lessons were learned along the way.
Throughout the game, which has many moments of pure terror, you’ll see people who have become twisted by their dependance on ADAM, their very features swollen and mutated with tumor like growths. They are splicers, and they are addicts, locked into this cycle until they die.
Fontaine, on the other hand, is another matter. He is a con man, a smart man; in fact, up until the end of the game he’s never even used ADAM before. Instead, he’d been orchestrating events for years behind the scenes and is only now making his play for Rapture though his ultimate plan. You.
Congratulations Fontaine! You gotta son, in the form of Jack, who kindly does his bidding and ends the reign of Andrew Ryan. However here’s where he lost the plot as Fontaine injects himself with a huge amount of ADAM to become a god. Which is all well and good for all the rush of power you get, but Fontaine had seen what it did to people, he’d seen the downfall of all these great minds and therefore he has to know that looking like a giant metal statue probably isn’t good for the body in the long run.
Still he goes ahead with the plan, and up until you kill him is technically in charge of Rapture. A leaking city, full of drug addicts, which is losing power, oxygen and purpose. Doesn’t seem like a great deal does it?
1. Returning To The Lodge - Until Dawn
Until Dawn has plenty of moments that are pretty obviously terrible decisions to be making in any situation. First of all, don’t prank your friends by getting them naked and having a whole group of people laugh at them whilst you pop out with a video camera. Second, don’t then run out into the middle of the woods on a cold, stormy night to get away from your d*ckhead party pals, because no s**t you’re going to fall off the edge of a cliff and never be seen again.
Finally, don’t then arrange a group trip BACK to where two friends disappeared off a cliff after you shamed them for a big party, as if that isn’t going to end horribly. Come on guys, I know we’re in a horror set up here, but this really is taking the biscuit.
The rest of the events that unfold throughout the time at the lodge are all caused through eight idiots deciding that getting radgey on a mountain is the most appropriate way to mourn. It’s obvious that there’s something up here when the brother of two missing sisters is the one to bring them all together - so that they all take so easily to the bait is an intensely rookie error. Well done guys, you played yourselves.