8 Terrible Video Games With AWESOME Stories
Come for the story, leave for the gameplay.
Despite what many forebearers of the video game industry would have you believe, narrative and stories are a huge reason why video games have exploded in popularity over the last few decades.
With titles weaving lengthy and immersive narratives it's never been easier to escape reality and dive headfirst into a world of adventure and fantasy.
A well-constructed narrative gives players an emotional anchor to latch on to, and if it's good enough will pull them through from start to finish and quite possibly leave them speaking about the events they witnessed for years to come.
In fact, sometimes a story can be that damn good that it actually carries mediocre gameplay over the finishing line, with players more engaged with the plot than the actual mechanical day-to-day they had to endure.
Such are the examples of this list, of video games that had all the right ideas, but maybe didn't translate that into exciting gameplay well enough to have it stand on its own.
It's a testament to the writing quality of these titles, but also a bit of a shame that some of these games were dragged down by their gameplay, burying great stories in the process.
--
Article adapted from our "Tues Your Own Adventure" series - available here!
8. Death Stranding
Now the joke could easily be made that no one actually understands the story of Death Stranding enough for it to be listed as being "awesome", but when you look at the threads of this strand genre game that do make sense, then you really are witness to something pretty special.
Sure, the messages of connecting with your fellow man, treating each other with respect and pulling together as a society are about as subtle as a brick to the face, but at their core these are actually pretty bloody essential mantras that we should all imbue within ourselves!
Even when the game is getting abstract you can never say it's boring, however you can say this exactly when it comes to its gameplay.
Or at least, that's what the internet with have you believe.
It does seem that the moment that people take control of Sam was the moment the fanbase divided sharply. Some loved the laboriously slow and methodical walking mechanics and delivery mission-centric gameplay, others hated being Post-Apocalypse Postman Pat, and derided the meat of the game as being the worst bit about the experience.
Whatever your take there's no denying that the narrative of Death Stranding was different, and in this day an age that actually counts for more than you'd think.
7. We Happy Few
I wanted to love We Happy Few so very, very much.
In the run-up to the game's launch, the world was awash with trailers promising an uncanny take on 1960's Britain, of a small town that uses a wonder drug called Joy to make them forget the horrors of what the locals did after The Battle Of Britain in order to get The Germans to leave their little island alone.
Side note. It wasn't rainbow rhythms.
The aesthetics, the attitude and overall creepiness of the setting lent well to a kind of "Bioshock in Blighty" vibe, which resonated with many. It's just a shame that the gameplay itself didn't come close to scratching this very curious itch.
Instead, we got - for the most part - a survival title with all the trappings of an Early Access game aka ropey AI, recycled assets over and over, and a single gameplay loop stretched out to agonizing lengths in order to pad out the runtime.
This truly was a world devoid of Joy, and yet the story was utterly engrossing, enough so that some players saw it through to the end regardless of the grind it put you through. Coming out the other side and learning of the true events that took place in Wellington Wells was rewarding, but the gameplay getting there was most definitely not.
6. Brink
So, Brink is a FPS parkour-shooter title that takes place on a man-made island called The Ark. The original design for this monolithic structure was to be a self-contained city that was self-sufficient when it came to resources and power.
Yet, somewhere in our human timeline, global warming causes the waters to flood most of the world leaving only pockets of survivors. Rumors begin swirling that The Ark is still active and so many seek out its safety and supplies.
This results in thousands of people inhabiting a structure not made for this many and soon The Ark becomes a tinder box full waiting to ignite from raging class tensions and extreme division in wealth.
That sounds pretty bloody great right? A class war over dwindling resources with parkour elements thrown in? Sign me up!
Well, it's a shame that this information is NEVER CONVEYED IN THE GAMEPLAY AT ALL.
Seriously, the game feels like two different titles stitched together, as all the tension, nuance, and intrigue of the setting is utterly blasted away by the mediocre AI and ridiculous repetition of the core matches.
The single-player mode, if you can call it that, is just the same series of multiplayer maps cycled through again and again with AI teammates. And while there are snippets of info you can glean from the levels about the events going on behind the scenes, the fact that your teammates cannot AND WILL NOT perform essential tasks means that you'll have to sit on objectives and squint hard to see the details.
A great story let down by its mediocre approach to gameplay.
5. Deadly Premonition
So let's set the record straight from the off:
I absolutely adore Deadly Premonition. From its completely off-kilter narrative to its laughably bad voice acting, this is a game that stands proud amidst its peers despite its many strange decisions.
However, it's also a title that, from a gameplay perspective at least, is utterly terrible.
Take for example the shooting mechanics, which you will use a lot in the game, the fact that the auto-aim pulls you to shoot at the enemies arse is immediately jarring, as are the stock sound effects for the guns and the fact that everything feels as if you're firing wet paper pellets at enemies instead of bullets.
Then how about the driving sections? In which you have to obey the speed limit and can actively run out of petrol and be stranded in the wilderness. There's realism and then there's being an utter arse, and Deadly Premonition moons you from the second you open the disc case.
However, I know that this is all part of its charm, that its strange resistance to be fun is what makes it so alluring, and while I might grind my teeth into dust getting from point A to point B, I'm doing so because the story is actually bloody brilliant.
The tale of a red-coated killer who only stalks their prey in the rain, and the fact that the town seems so unwilling to help you solve the murder, all add to this growing sense of paranoia.
It's a game that makes you feel like you've arrived in the deep end of the pool only to learn you can't swim, and while its gameplay will try and hold your head under, its story proves to be the lifesaver this game needed.
4. Getting Over It With Bennett Foddy
Simply uttering the name "Bennett Foddy" might be enough to send a few people into relapse, but I assure you, you're in a safe place here, as we all went through the torture that was "riding the snake".
Now if you're to ask me what I truly think of Getting Over It With Bennet Foddy, my brain is going to tell my mouth to say the word "masterpiece" as on paper this game truly is something special. An incredibly tough and frustrating set of controls meeting horrendously cruel level design, this is a title that aims to keep you at arms length at all times.
Or so it seems.
For as you ascend, clawing and scratching your way up the mountains of random objects and finall into space itself, you start to see what this game truly is about.
It's about perseverance, it's about determination, it's about proving to yourself that you can bloody well do this. It's a narrative you create the more you suffer through it. And that is a truly frank and disarming conversation to have with yourself.
3. XIII - Remake
Now I know that many of you might have seen the title of this entry and began hammering your keyboard with the passion of a thousand suns to tell me how wrong I am and that XII is a sublime piece of cel-shaded shooting perfection.
And you'd be right. It's a fantastic game!
However, there is just one glaring problem with the title that absolutely earns its place on this list, which comes in the form of the XIII REMAKE that dropped in November of 2020, a video game so bad that the 2003 version is far superior in every single way.
What this remake did was take a video game with a razor sharp storyline about an amnesiac assassin fighting for survival against those who think he's killed the president and just smeared it with every single brand of dog feces they could, turning it into an utter stink fest of missing sound effects, terrible animation, horrendous enemy A.I and gameplay that somehow feels even further back along the evolutionary chain than the original game.
The fact that this title maintains the brilliant story but effectively drowns gameplay in a used toilet makes for an utter horror show. It also no doubt sullies any chances of newcomers picking up this version of the game and demanding that a sequel be released to finish off that almighty cliffhanger.
It's a game so bad we wish we could be hit with a dose of amnesia to forget this raging skip fire.
2. Ride To Hell: Retribution
I can almost hear the entire internet raise an eyebrow with this entry, but please, hear me out.
I know that Ride To Hell: Retribution is a terrible game, in fact, it might well be one of the worst games I've ever had the displeasure to play. It's a broken mess of shoddy fighting and driving sections and genuinely feels like the budget for this game was whatever was scrounged out from the back of the couch as only this lack of care and finance could explain the lack of polish present at every turn.
However, deep under its well-baked and filthy crust, is actually a story that could, and I want to stress could have actually been pretty decent.
Think about it, a war veteran returns home to a country that's grown strange to him, his family is being pulled apart, and all he wants to do is reconcile with his younger brother.
Though awkward at first, the vet and his brother begin to bond over their love of bikes and soon the pair seem to be building a once-burned bridge. However, in an unwarranted scuffle with a rival biker gang, the vet sees his brother get his throat cut and thus sets him on a path of vengeance.
Now that actually sounds pretty decent right? Well, that's because it actually could have been! It's just a shame that the only decent slice of narrative in this game was dealt with in the first ten minutes before the dross of the main game actually started to kick the piss out of your patience!
1. The Order: 1886
Ok so let's do a little test. I want you to put your hand up in the air and then lower it the moment that you think the following concept is boring.
You're part of a secretive order of monster hunters, the game is set in Victorian England, in which you use high tech steam-punk weapons and tesla cannons to blast apart werewolf and man alike, and you're also about a thousand years old thanks to a mysterious liquid that you drink which makes you nigh on immortal. Oh and also some of the events of this parallel universe cover Jack the Bloody Ripper.
Ok so let's just check the hands here. Pretty much a full house still. To be honest, I'm not that surprised, mainly because this story sounds equally bonkers and brilliant, however, I'm going to have to ask you now to turn that raised hand into a fist and begin shaking it because all of this is now squeezed into four hours of the most uninspired gameplay you'll ever witness.
Everything, from the gunplay to the lychan battles feels like it was copy-pasted from the last generation of consoles and did little to show off what the PS4 could do other than aesthetically. The story elements of this game needed more time to be fleshed out, but unfortunately this ended up resembling a right mutt.