8 Video Game Deaths That Just Didn't Work
Oh, how little we cared about thee.
Death is a pretty common, and often very effective storytelling trope. Whether it's used as a motivating factor for the protagonist or as a means to deliver some nice and chunky exposition, death, it seems, is just the start of many a hero's adventures.
That being said, not every demise is deemed worthy as a lot of films, TV shows and of course video games often misjudge how to send characters off into the great beyond, instead coming across as lazy, boring and sometimes even morbidly hilarious.
You won't find the likes of Aunt May calling it a day or Lee from The Walking Dead saying goodbye on this list because these deaths were just silly through and through. Hell, some of them were instantly reversed which makes it even worse!
So let's bury these supposedly emotional endings six feet deep lest they try and rise again in the pits of our stomach.
8. Trish - Devil May Cry
With all of the demon ass-kicking that goes on in the Devil May Cry games, it's sometimes easy to forget that at their heart it's a tale of sibling rivalry and a whole lot of daddy Issues. However, you don't need to brave these hardships alone as you soon encounter series fan favorite, Trish.
Trish is an absolute badass. She cracks wise and uses them thighs to kick the everloving piss out of demons throughout your adventure, and it seems that even cool poser boy Dante might actually have found someone as early 2000s X-treme as him. The growing tension between the two is used as a motivator for the final fight with Dante's deadbeat dad Mundus, as it's revealed that Trish has been working with this claymation looking big bad, yet chooses to jump in the way of one of his attacks to protect Dante.
This shocking death allows Dante to unleash the beast and send his father out for cigarettes permanently. Now at this point, this is all well and good, and Trish's untimely end feels pretty emotional and we can close out the tale in a bittersweet manner, right?
Well...that's kinda undone by this one following line: "I should have been the one to fill your dark soul with LIIIIIGHT"
Ooof. That... that really takes some of the heat out of that moment, doesn't it? You're meant to be sad here, not giggling at Drew Coombs' voice breaking.
7. Marcus' Dad - Gears Of War 3
With such a surprising amount of loose ends to tie up, Gears of War 3 had so much on its plate that it was constantly in danger of overflowing. At the start of the third act of the franchise we had: Dom dealing with his wife's death, Marcus looking for his father who might still be alive, The Locust Queen appearing to pull strings behind the scenes, an entirely new mutation strain occurring within the Locust, and of course, the ever-present world-ending threat of global war.
It's a lot to take in, right? And yet it was up to Gears Of War 3 to try and close things out the best it could. And you know what? When it came to Dom's death, they absolutely nailed it. This was a moment that felt earned, that it was a truly emotional sacrifice for his friends. Marcus's dad's death on the other hand?
Well to be honest, I forgot it happened.
Playing second fiddle to Dom's death, Adam Fenix's demise felt like little more than plot necessity rather than an emotional payoff, and the character was resurrected and then killed off again in a matter of hours, leaving players almost confused as to what the point of it was.
6. Kaidan - Mass Effect
So here's the thing. I love video games that offer choices, and if an experience has me sweating bullets and hovering over the reset button in case the route I've taken has gone rotten, then all the better in my eyes. Yet this means inversely that I have a special deep-seated hatred for video games that offer choices that are utterly dumb and without meaningful consequences.
Enter Kaidan from Mass Effect, easily the worst party member that joins Shepard on their quest to save the known universe. He's so generic, annoying, clingy, and judgemental that I would take the soulless husks that comprise Mass Effect: Andromeda's party members over him any day.
Thus when it comes to the supposedly emotional climax of the original game in which one of your group needs to stay behind and sacrifice themselves, I, along with countless other players, couldn't stop hammering the "KILL KAIDAN" button.
It absolutely sucks that so many of us were ready to jettison a party member so quickly, but when your character development boils down to "ooooh I wouldn't do that if I were you" then absolutely get in the bin and out of my game.
5. Maya And Lilith - Borderlands 3
Borderlands 3 was such a mixed bag, wasn't it? On the one hand, you had the tight-as-government-school-funding first-person shooting that felt utterly engaging, the wonderfully realized and over the top environments, and more looty than you could ever shove in your booty. On the flipside was... well... in all honesty most of the story, which tried (and failed) to one-up Handsome Jack with two annoying and utterly ineffective villains, a ton of guff designed to pad out the story, and of course, some pretty cheap deaths.
In Borderlands 2 we actually may have shed a tear over the sudden demise of Roland, but here? With Lilith and Maya, two mainstay fan favorites? Well, things just ended up feeling very flat indeed. Maybe it was the lackluster ways in which they were killed, with cutscenes showing a baffling lack of badass from these two Sirens, or maybe it was because both were only offed to try and push less likable characters to the forefront.
I know the series operates on a kind of rotating cast basis, but here? This was like trading a Mars bar on the school playground for a kick in the knees and having your history workbook pissed on.
4. Any Death In Kingdom Hearts
It might seem a little strange to make such a sweeping statement, but seriously Death does not matter AT ALL in the Kingdom Hearts franchise. Sure you vanquish a few villains here and there, but when it comes to party members and allies, "tis but a flesh wound" and all that.
Look at the opening game in which all your pals on "Generic Holiday Island" are killed off only to be brought back at the end, or when Sora kills himself but gets brought back mere moments later, or the best of the best when Maleficent is brought back to life THROUGH OTHER CHARACTERS REMEMBERING SHE EXISTED.
In fact, things got so bad that when series creator Tetsuya Nomura was quizzed on who is actually dead amongst the cast that he said that he's not even sure that the concept of death even exists in the franchise!
What this has led to is a numbing of the fanbase entirely, wherein each supposed death of a beloved character is met with an apathetic shrug that they'll be back by the end of the title. A rather callous approach which means none of the send-offs we witness are actually ever emotional.
3. Bill - Left4Dead
There are a fair few games which let players act out the events of their narratives, only to be told at a later date that only certain outcomes were canon. For example, the Dead Rising series doesn't actually see Frank West die until the absolute stinker of the fourth game, or Resident Evil, which allowed you to kill off Jill or Chris if you didn't manage to save them, but then went on to show both alive and... well, not exactly well considering all the horrors they see, but you get the idea.
Left4Dead was also guilty of this, and unfortunately it meant that the canon death of Bill actually lacked a lot of impact. The franchise isn't exactly known for character development but that didn't stop us from falling in love with both the cast of the original and the sequel. In the Passing DLC, we're told that Bill sacrificed himself to save the group and at that point in time it truly did feel like a bit of a gut punch. Bill was grizzled, quick witted and an even quicker shot so it was a shame to lose him.
However, when The Sacrifice DLC came out and let us play through this event, we found out that Bill didn't actually need to die at all as any player could stay behind and embrace their heroic fate. What this meant was that players hoping to see a scripted event with some actual pathos ended up just sacrificing whoever felt like it, thus removing a lot of the emotional payoff.
2. Mikey - Ride To Hell: Retribution
So let me tell you a story.
A man returns from the Vietnam war. The country he knew has changed in his absence and not, it seems, for the better. His younger brother is distant and the man doesn't know how to communicate with him on an emotional level. Their only connection it seems, is music. The pair begin to reconnect through music and their shared love of motorcycles. However, one fateful day his brother is attacked by a rival biker gang and after a standoff, is killed when his throat is slit.
The man vows revenge.
Now on paper that actually sounds like the setup to an, admittedly pretty generic, but altogether fun story of revenge right? Well take all of that, slap so much cheese on it that it resembles a fromagerie, get the worst voice actors in the world to have a crack and then animate it with rigging that looks like it's been dragged off the ocean floor and graphics that look uglier than an exploded kitten in a microwave.
Congratulations: you've got Ride To Hell: Retribution, and no I didn't care that your brother Mikey dies BECAUSE THIS GAME IS LIKE LICKING LUCIFER'S ARMPITS.
1. Slippy Toad - Star Fox (SNES)
One of the really interesting things about the first Star Fox game is that your party members could, and if you were like me and too caught up in the banging soundtrack, WOULD die if you didn't rescue them whenever they ran into trouble.
In the follow up games they would retreat back to base to lick their wounds, but here? Once they go down, that's it, which actually made for some pretty tense moments... well that is unless it was Slippy Toad's death.
Now in all fairness, in this original form Slippy isn't actually that annoying, in fact he's downright reserved compared to his frustrating future self, but playing this game with the foresight of where he will end up makes it so incredibly hard to commit to pulling the trigger and saving him time and time again.
I won't lie to you: watching his ship go down in flames brought a smile to my face the likes of which I've never felt before. Good times.