8 Video Game Franchises That Ruined Their Identity

The Boys, Nicki Minaj, and Snoop Dogg are just the start of Call of Duty's problems.

By Josh Brown /

It's tough to keep a video game franchise creative. The more years that pass, and the more gaming trends change, the bigger the chances things get of becoming stale.

Advertisement

The usual response to this is a franchise reinvention, a new creative direction that shakes things up and gets people interested again. It's tough to pull off, but when it's done right, you can take a series to the next level or, if times are desperate, save one from the brink of destruction.

The great thing about video games is that they are malleable. Rather than doing the same thing over and over, they're able to shift gears and subvert expectations - just think of the constant, amazing reinventions the Resident Evil series has undergone, or the recent shift in direction for God of War.

This change is something to be celebrated in the video game space, and franchises shouldn't feel constrained by their own tropes and conventions.

That said, sometimes a recalibration of a beloved series is done for all the wrong reasons, where their unique identity is swapped out for something far more generic, far safer, and far more boring than what made them beloved to begin with.

8. Assassin's Creed

The original Assassin's Creed games felt like a breath of fresh air for the gaming industry, tightly focused on social stealth, parkour and an interesting Assassin vs Templar story with a sci-fi twist.

Advertisement

However, after years of annualised release that became increasingly buggy and stale, fresh ideas were needed. Rather than figure out how to take the core components of the series and provide a new spin on them though, Ubisoft looked to other games for inspiration.

From Assassin's Creed: Origins onwards, the franchise turned into a bloated action-RPG that included every sandbox trope under the sun. Incorporating elements from The Witcher 3 in particular, modern Assassin's Creed is trying to be the "everygame", with a loot system that wouldn't feel out of place in Destiny, combat based around abilities and cooldowns, and a massive open world that's no longer built around parkour.

That't not to say the games haven't been enjoyable of course, but when there's barely a focus on the Assassins and their stories in a game called Assassin's Creed, why give it this title at all?

Though the upcoming Assassin's Creed: Mirage is largely dropping this new approach and going back to basics, this will be short-lived as Ubisoft have already announced plans for a live-service future for the franchise.

7. Battlefield

As will be the case with so many franchises on this list, the Battlefield series would be fine if the developers were just allowed to make a Battlefield game. Unfortunately, EA isn't content with "just" selling 15 million copies of each new game to its dedicated playerbase, but clearly envisions Battlefield as a larger money maker, something that appeals to both fans of the franchise but also fans of other shooters.

Advertisement

As a result, the last few instalments have made concessions to more casual audiences. Removing or diluting classic mechanics and features - especially those centred around teamplay - we've seen the likes of Battlefield 2042 introduce hero shooter-style 'Operators' in place of the regular class system, half-baked attempts at battle royale and extraction game modes, flatter, less detailed maps, and far less environmental destruction.

Fans don't come to this series for an Overwatch clone, or a Call of Duty clone, but to, well, play Battlefield. EA doesn't seem to understand that though - in order for it to bring in billions, the company wants Battlefield to appeal to every shooter fan not understanding that, as the cliche goes, that'll only result in it appealing to nobody.

6. Watch Dogs

We're coming up on the tenth anniversary of Watch Dogs, and a decade on the franchise's squandered potential still stings.

Advertisement

The first game, famously, had its issues. The overly-serious revenge story starring Aiden Pearce - an incredibly generic video game protagonist - was a major dud, but the gritty Chicago open world it established had a lot to love. The hacking mechanics remained somewhat grounded, facilitating interesting storylines and gameplay possibilities that shook up the otherwise familiar open world structure.

In an attempt to sort out the tonal issues with the story, the second game focused on a new cast of characters and a more vibrant and personality-filled San Francisco setting. While the characters were strong here, they brought their own tonal problems. The freedom players had to gun down anyone they wanted during gameplay clashed with their depiction as anything but murderous psychopaths in the cutscenes.

Perhaps attempting to avoid this mistake again, Watch Dogs: Legion moved the action to cyberpunk London and had no main character, instead allowing players to jump into the shoes of any randomly generated NPC. Unsurprisingly this felt like the most incoherent game of the lot, with no creative throughline and stereotypical hacker visuals.

With three games, Watch Dogs tried to hit three identities. The first being a moody, superhero origin story. The second a funnier, character-driven crime caper. The third being classic cyberpunk.

If it had chosen one and ran with it, it might not be languishing in obscurity today.

5. Call Of Duty

What is Call of Duty in 2023? While it used to run annually with three developers each getting three years to make new entries into their own sub-franchises, now it's an all-hands-on-deck affair with every developer across Activision contributing to one release each year just to get it over the line.

Advertisement

Not only has that led to a strange release schedule, where Modern Warfare 2 is immediately followed a year later by Modern Warfare 3, but that many warring creative voices have naturally led to the series feeling disparate and lacking cohesion.

Take the beloved Zombies mode. Once a Treyarch speciality, the mode has since become a standard COD staple, with new versions of it being included in a bunch of sub-franchises, whether it makes sense or not. Gone is the overarching story and natural mechanical progression of its original inclusion in Treyarch games, and in its place is just "a Zombies mode" thrown in any new release lacking in content.

And then there's Warzone. What started off as a PUBG-killer has slowly morphed into Fortnite. While COD games have had wacky crossovers and out-there skins for years, the volume of this pop-culture crossover in what's otherwise a grounded Battle Royale experience has gotten outrageous.

Fans are just getting over the inclusion of The Boys skins and superpowers when they're about to be hit with the next season, which boasts skins for Snoop Dogg and Nicki Minaj.

Where these used to be fun one-off events, they're now the norm.

4. Halo

Halo's unique brand of arena combat, stunning sci-fi art direction and - of course - epic overarching story made it the kind of series that people buy a console to play.

Advertisement

Since original developers Bungie left the franchise following prequel Halo: Reach, though, things have not gone well. New devs 343 Industries debuted Halo 4 as a franchise reinvention, and initially, things seemed fine. While it was clear the sequel was missing some of the Bungie magic, it was still an impressive continuation of a story thought to be complete.

With Halo 5, though, the wheels started to come off. Haunted by a misleading marketing campaign that sold a completely different story to what was actually in the game, the series' identity crisis began in earnest, incorporating live-service elements into the multiplayer, chopping fan-favourite features and altering mechanics to better fit with other successful shooters of the time.

Sequel Halo: Infinite, after a last minute delay anyway, looked like it was trying to return to the spirit of the original Halo. Evoking that title's art style and initially trying to do right by fans, Infinite had a solid start, but felt surprisingly empty over time. Once again, the community-driven elements that made the series so beloved to begin with - couch co-op, Forge mode etc. - were absent, proving that the developers lacked the understanding of what allowed Halo to stand out to begin with.

3. Batman: Arkham

The Arkham Trilogy (and Origins) remains a hugely recommendable series of of games, but even in Arkham: Knight (an instalment I think is underrated), you can see the developers moving away from Asylum's defining identity.

Advertisement

While that first game had its fair share of gadgets and gizmos, it presented itself mostly as a classic, Gothic Batman tale in its visual presentation. By the time Knight came around though, that original aesthetic had given way to something more mainstream, less weird, and more indebted to sci-fi tropes.

That's evident not only in Gotham as a whole but Batman's suit, which functioned more like Iron Man's than The Dark Knight's. Of course, the shift in direction was summed up by the focus on the Batmobile, which meant a huge chunk of the gameplay was spent shooting down drones and other tech-focused enemies. A far cry from the mutated monsters and Gothic villains of Arkham's first title.

But it's with the upcoming Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League that the Arkhamverse has truly lost any originality. Not only is the visual design more generic, but the gameplay has shifted to a multiplayer loot-shooter closer to The Avengers than what made the developers famous.

And that might still make for a great game, but it's a shame it's come at the expense of what got people interested in this series to begin with.

2. Wolfenstein

It's pretty easy to pinpoint where it all went wrong for the Wolfenstein reboot. The first attempt at modernising the veteran series was Wolfenstein: The New Order, a surprising hit that eschewed first-person shooting conventions of the time by delivering a decidedly more old-school experience. That ironic freshness combined with its fascinating alternate-history setting of a 1960s where the Nazis won the war made for a perfect reinvention.

Advertisement

And despite some tonal wobbles, Wolfenstein 2 carried that on perfectly, delivering more robust shooting whilst going all-in on the first title's wackier elements. The series seemed to be in a good place, and then came Wolfenstein: Youngblood.

Technically a spin-off, Youngblood was such a misguided project that it managed to sour fans on the franchise as a whole. Though it had an intriguing premise, taking place 20 years after the events of the previous game and putting players in the shoes of hero BJ Blazkowicz's two daughters, changes to the core gameplay saw it flop.

Unlike the narrative-driven single-player games that preceded it, Youngblood was a grindy, co-op timesink with bullet-sponge enemies, uninspired missions and barebones story. As many critics at the time pointed out, it felt like it was trying to have Destiny 2's lunch as a "looter shooter without loot" - an approach which was a far cry from what people enjoyed about the first two games.

It was a huge misstep, and sadly it's been six years since the last main instalment.

1. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon

Ghost Recon made a name for itself as a tactical, near-future military shooter. While the series would swap between first-person and third-person combat, the focus was on getting through environments - usually as a squad - giving orders and using state-of-the-art weaponry to take out your targets.

Advertisement

Especially when it first launched, its focus on not-quite-sci-fi, not-quite-modern-day settings and stories made it stand out from other shooters, and even though it would push further into future technology with each game, this cohesion of presentation and game design remained at the heart of the experience.

... And then it became just another Ubisoft open world game.

With the release of the pretty good Ghost Recon: Wildlands, the franchise traded in regular levels for a huge sandbox. Taking inspiration from GTA and other open world titles, Wildlands still put you in charge of a squad, but suddenly you were able to commandeer vehicles, hunt down side missions and clear out enemy bandit camps.

And while that was still enjoyable to a degree, it was a formula barely different to the one found in Far Cry, Watch Dogs, and a whole bunch of other open world games.

Ubisoft tried to push this further in failed sequel Breakpoint, before then trying to reinvent Ghost Recon as a battle-royale style multiplayer shooter, an announcement that was so hated the project was cancelled before release.

Maybe the answer to the publisher's issues, then, is to just make a Ghost Recon game? Call me crazy...

Advertisement