8 Video Game Plot Points The Developers Abandoned
Did David Cage forget his own script?
A video game story sounds like a total nightmare to craft. Not only do writers have to compensate for the fact that a game can last for tens of hours - alongside the need to incorporate side quests just as big as the main narrative - but the changing nature of production can mean levels and missions are altered or ripped out at the last minute.
All of this falls back on the one element that should be set in stone: The story.
It's the kind of environment that led to a whole rewrite of Destiny's story when the studio was half a year out from release, so it's no surprise that even the best video game stories don't always tie everything up in the neatest of ways. Especially when developers are tasked with telling a cohesive narrative over an entire series, plot threads are likely to be introduced that never come into play in the major way fans expected them to, or whole characters are just dropped because they're no longer relevant to a story's new direction.
That doesn't make these games bad - and it sometimes doesn't even make the story weaker - but it can still be baffling to look back at some releases and identify major plot points that went absolutely nowhere.
8. Everything In Manhattan - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty
The ending of Metal Gear Solid 2 isn't really supposed to be taken at face value. After all, the final levels have you running naked around a surreal hanger being chased by ninjas, before you confront an A.I. who tells you to turn off the game, which you respond to by massacring hundreds of goons alongside Solid Snake, who proudly claims that his bandana gives him "infinite ammo".
There is one plot tidbit that seems pretty straight forward though: when Liquid Ocelot takes off with a Metal Gear in pursuit of the Patriots, Snake swears to track him down and continue the fight, a cliffhanger for a sequel that wouldn't happen for another seven years. Sadly, even when that game shipped, the events of what happened immediately after MGS 2 are never really addressed.
We know Snake and Raiden tracked down Olga's daughter, but we don't know what happened with Liquid.
Even worse, the surreal feeling of the ending is never explained, and it's unclear how Raiden's fiancé Rose ended up in the middle of Manhattan with him, or how much she really knew about his mission, or where Snake disappeared to.
Why?
Because there was never supposed to be a sequel, and Hideo Kojima's decision to discard these abstract elements in MGS 4 makes everything abundantly clear.
7. The Significance Of The Sires - Gears Of War 2
While Gears of War hasn't always had the best storytelling chops, its rich mythology has provided a detailed sci-fi world for players to pick apart. There's a real history to the Locust/Human war that was slowly fleshed out across the first three titles (as well as the spin-off books and comics), but one lingering thread has never been addressed: what the hell happened to those mutated 'Sires' from Gears 2.
In that sequel's final stages you fight your way through an old, abandoned research lab where you're treated to an action scene against these new enemies. They're humanoid, but look neither human, locust or lambent, and the suggestion is that these creatures were essentially the progenitors of the locust swarm.
They were once humans mutated by "Imulsion", experimented on by scientists along with their children. These monsters were seen by the scientists as humanity's bridge to the next stage of evolution, and through their attempts to play God, could have spawned the locust drones that raged war against humans years later.
The reason their origin is so wishy washy though, is that after Gears 2 they were dropped entirely, and while they were originally going to be explored much more in the third game, they failed to show up in that release and Gears 4.
6. The Cliffhanger Ending - Call Of Duty: Ghosts
Though they're easily written off as brainless trash, even the very worst Call of Duty games have enjoyed compelling enough stories. In fact, it was probably one of the only redeeming factors of Ghosts, one of the least-beloved entries in Activision's entire series. Taking place in an almost apocalyptic setting after the Middle-East is wiped out by nuclear weapons, the player controls Logan Walker as he joins the Ghosts, an elite, legendary spec-ops unit
Their goal is to take down terrorist and all around bad dude Gabriel Rourke, who used to lead the Ghosts team, but was captured by the enemy and subjected to intense torture and pumped with hallucinogenics.
However, after a final fight where you seemingly take down Rourke and save the day, he ambushes you and drags you off into the jungle, where he promises to put you through the same torture and brainwash you to join the other side and fight the same people you almost just died protecting.
The game ends on this tantalising cliffhanger, ready for a sequel to pick up. However, while Call of Duty games are rarely made without a franchise in mind, Infinity Ward's titles have been particularly unlucky. Since Modern Warfare, the studio has failed to get another sub-series off the ground, and after the disappointing Ghosts they were moved onto creating the futuristic Infinite Warfare, and now they're back rebooting Modern Warfare.
Consequently, we're probably never going to know what happened to Logan once the credits rolled.
5. Galactus' Invasion - Marvel: Ultimate Alliance
Nobody is expecting comic-book games - especially ones released by Activision in the mid-2000s - to have a great plot that spans a bunch of releases, but it still sucks when a cliffhanger is teased and then completely disregarded in a sequel.
This is exactly what happened with Marvel: Ultimate Alliance, as the original title's adventure to stop Doctor Doom ended on the impending invasion of Galactus (who you actually fought earlier in the game), en route to eat Earth. It would have provided a ridiculous starting point for a sequel but, alas, the second game went down a decidedly less cosmic route, choosing instead to adapt the Civil War storyline.
While that could have been a cool concept, and divided up the roster in an interesting way, it wasn't particularly well executed (nor was the rest of the sequel), and left everyone to dream about what the original plan for the second game could have been. Players just had to assume the Marvel heroes kicked his Galactus' ass offscreen.
4. Dark Energy (And The Human Reaper) - Mass Effect 2
Wherever you fall on the resolution of the Mass Effect series, it's been readily documented that there was a pretty major shift in the writing between the second and third game.
One of the two lead writers, Drew Karpyshyn, left the franchise, leaving Mac Walters to tie up all the loose ends. This resulted in the writer throwing away a bunch of plot points that were teased in the first two releases and were supposed to take precedent in the third.
The biggest of these was the idea of 'dark energy' being the motivation for the Reapers' extinction event. Originally, biotics being able to wield dark energy was what triggered the Reapers returning, as messing with that part of the natural order could have changed the fabric of time and space itself. This was dropped entirely in the third game, with it being the emergence of A.I., and the war between species and their robotic creations, that was the reason the Reapers reset the galaxy.
That's not the only thing that was dropped though, but the human Reaper, the final boss from ME 2, was similarly swept under the rug. The implication was that the Reaper ships took the form of a harvested species with each new cycle, but when ME3 came around, they all adopted the classic squid style.
Probably for the best, that one.
3. Ethan's Incriminating Behaviour - Heavy Rain
Though it's still full of David Cage-isms and goes down some completely preposterous routes, Heavy Rain is probably Quantic Dream's most accessible and tightly-woven games. The story, all about the search for the 'Origami killer' as told through the perspectives of a bunch of different characters, is genuinely gripping, as players are tasked to unravel just who the criminal is.
Of course, Cage and his team didn't want to make it too obvious, and sprinkled in a bunch of red herrings to throw players off the scent. The biggest one surrounded Ethan, a father whose son Shaun has been kidnapped by the killer, and whose tragic backstory heavily hints at the kind of psychological break that could send him down a murderous path.
Arousing even more suspicion, the game also depicts Ethan having blackouts around the time the Origami killer strikes, even showing him waking up holding an origami figure.
The thing is, even when the real killer is discovered, Ethan's strange behaviour is never explained. Deleted scenes shed more light on the issue, but the final game never bothers to explain why Ethan was so shady.
2. Subject 16's Warning - Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
Assassin's Creed's convoluted mythology makes Metal Gear Solid's look like as simple as a child's picture book, because while the latter's story is long, complicated and winding, Kojima at least attempted to wrap up a bunch of lingering plot threads and holes with MGS 4 the best he could.
Assassin's Creed's story got so unwieldily that most of it was brushed aside after the third game, including Subject 16's warning that finding Eve (as in, Adam and Eve) would be essential in humanity's survival.
Subject 16 was another descendant of AC hero Ezio, showing up first in Brotherhood's secret 'Truth' videos with orders for Desmond to track down Eve for a... mysterious reason.
When he showed up again in Revelations, the story was entirely about finding the Apple of Eden, and Eve's significance was no longer mentioned.
With Subject 16 sacrificing himself at the end of that game, the importance of finding the religious icon died along with him.
1. Quincy Sharp's Spirit Of Arkham - Arkham Asylum
While it often gets overlooked, one tragic casualty of the Arkham series as it grew was losing the gothic supernatural influences that made the original so distinct. Though it was still rooted in real-world technology, there was an undeniable fantastical aura about it, primarily in the sub-plot regarding the 'Spirit of Arkham'.
By finding a bunch of hidden artefacts you can uncover the story of Amadeus Arkham, and how he built the psychiatric facility and how his view of the patients grew over time. It's essentially set up as a haunting tale for whoever is brave enough to find all of the entries, and it ends on a stunning twist.
It's revealed that Quincy Sharp, the warden of the Asylum in the present day, houses the spirit of Arkham inside him. Or at least, that's what he thinks, and this sinister alter ego encourages him to kill the insane patients, believing that death is the only cure for them.
There is still some doubt, as Sharp was diagnosed as having a personality disorder and this serial killer side could have been a manifestation of that, but the resolution of this thread suggests supernatural things are afoot.
Sadly, this was never really followed up on, and Sharp plays more of a background role in future titles as the tone shifted to be more focused on gadgets and technology than the gothic supernatural implications of this sub-story.