8 Video Games That Are Way More Intelligent Than You Think
Yup, GTA V had even MORE going on under the hood...
Most of all, the 'purpose' of a video games is entertainment, and it is the idea of 'entertainment value' that ultimately shifts units.
Still, once in a while, a creator wants to go deeper, well beyond regular gameplay to add a special layer to their narrative or game overall. A layer that may be invisible for the casual gamer, but will appeal to a chosen few who share a similar level of academic insight. These people will then gladly go on the internet, write about such things and make the rest of us think, "Ohhhh, so that's what they were aiming at... why didn't I get that?"
Because we were too concerned with the gameplay, of course.
These elements, whether they be references, nods or pure quotations, make the whole experience of playing just that little bit better. You're now a member of an exclusive club of people who know "what's really going on."
It can make you feel appreciated, alongside hopefully making your favourite games that little bit more special. All that time spent on collecting knowledge has finally paid off, and that's nice, right? And gaming is nice.
Hopefully, you'll find something nice, new and informative on this list as well.
8. Watch Dogs 2 - Neoliberalism
This one has been covered in detail recently, so it's only fitting to start with Ubisoft's latest release about a group of hipster-hackers - reminiscent of Anonymous and WikiLeaks - aiming to abolish the tools of governmental control.
The hackers oppose what may be generally characterized as neoliberalism and some of its key components, such as: social insignificance - the data produced by individuals is more important than the individuals themselves; consumerism - the aforementioned data is used to more successfully market products to citizens, whose consumption makes the functioning of the system possible; diversity - Horatio is one of only three African-Americans working at Nudle and other workers want him to feel accepted, so they give him backhanded complements, like saying he is so "well-spoken".
But the game itself falls victim to the neoliberal agenda because of its reliance on apps and social media. Apps are used to present the player with his potential-self, something he can become, which is always so promising to neoliberals. The constant quest for an expanding number of followers is also based on promise, but a promise of fulfilling others' expectations.
Lastly, by reading negative comments and using them as an impulse to act, graphics artist Sitara exhibits overt-concern with keeping her "brand" - DedSec - compatible with other hacker groups.
7. Grand Theft Auto V - Cruel Optimism
With a lot of philosophical and sociological takes on the franchise, I'd strongly recommend The Meaning and Culture of Grand Theft Auto, edited by Nate Garrelts, however one school of thought that hasn't been applied enough to the series is 'Cruel Optimism'.
Created by Lauren Berlant, the term describes goals that are supposed to make us happy, but fail to deliver on that promise.
For example, in the case of Michael, it's the life that he wanted to "escape to", leaving his past behind by symbolically changing his name. Michael turns his back on Brad and Trevor, and decides to move to Los Santos, where he can sit in his mansion and do nothing. It's only when he meets Franklin and comes back to committing crimes that life becomes fun again.
Franklin aims to leave "the hood" behind, but he's never at home with his new group of affiliates, as they always change the manner in which they address him to sound more stereotypically 'African-American'. Even though Franklin is involved in insider trading, and has a house in the more exclusive part of town, he cannot shake the "homie" label.
Trevor is a predator and his sole goal is survival. Hence if he's supposed to do something in order to survive - save his life, crush the competition, make money, etc. - he's willing to do the most violent act possible. But when a mission doesn't involve this goal - when he has to find a celebrity "artefact" for an elderly couple or take two drunk lovers to a motel - he gladly commits to the task.
It may be therefore assumed that his aim is "the good life," but he has to do so much nasty stuff to reach it, that he eventually becomes miserable. With some transgressions involved, obviously, this is still Trevor we're talking about.
6. Batman: Arkham Asylum - Social Norms
Michel Foucault's Discipline and Punish is essential an understanding what is at play in Arkham Asylum, as Foucault's thought has been already applied to the 1989 graphic novel on which the game is based.
In an article on the topic, Sarah K. Donovan and Nicholas P. Richardson claim that the asylum separates the sane from the insane not only physically, but more notably by the opposition of inside/outside. What I mean by that, is the location of an individual - if he/she is confined or not - determines their sanity.
For example, the Joker wants to be in the asylum because of his rejection of norms - he wants to be deemed insane, free from all social obligations. Batman on the other hand, wants to stop the rebellion from spreading outside the walls and leave the Asylum as soon as possible. This opposition is also essential in Batman's construction of himself, as he has modelled himself to reject - and eliminate - those capable of transgressing.
Batman's world is that of clear cut divisions and oppositions. Catwoman is the only questionable character that he allows to function outside of Arkham. Other criminals, despite complicated backstories, as well as clinical insanity, are punished for allowing themselves to break the rules.
5. Mafia III - Racism
This one is fairly obvious and has been the topic of many articles. With an African-American protagonist and the game taking place in 1968 in the American South, racism was too promising an issue not to tackle.
Lincoln Clay encounters it on a daily basis, either when entering a store, talking to the police or listening to the radio. The player will fall victim to profiling and suspicion, despite not doing anything criminal. Well, at least at that particular moment.
The open-world structure of the game is only open to some extent, as the character's freedom is limited as well. With that Mafia III succeeds in putting the player in the shoes of an oppressed individual.
Some gamers described the game as "catharic", as it allows them to punish racist characters with actual violence. The gamer is able to resist white supremacy, physically destroy it with its own hands, which must be somewhat rewarding for those experiencing it in real life.
4. Far Cry 3 - Violence And Reality
While lead writer Jeffrey Yohalem counts Hobbes, Rousseau, Adam Smith and Nietsche among his key influences in constructing the island, let's focus on a different aspect of the game, which is reality. The game's graphics are very realistic, the plot is rather overdrawn, so why is Far Cry 3 different from any other shooter?
Because its intention is to make the gamer uneasy, for example by forcing them to torture their adversaries or kill the ones close to them. The gamer may want to put the controller away, but the interest in what comes next, as well as the habit of following linear plots in games is too strong.
The protagonist, Jason, is at first shocked by the violence, but quite easily gets comfortable with killing others. Far Cry 3 is a critique of regular narratives in games, even as recent as Watch Dogs 2, where the protagonist is a playful hacker, yet he's able to kill hundreds of people without batting an eye. He then happily goes back to being the decent character that he is.
Far Cry 3's main question is: "since there are no real life consequence, is it therefore OK to kill?"
If the protagonist so easily conforms to the violence around him, why do we even want to play as him?
3. Bioshock - Objectivism
This title is well known for its deep thought and allusions to Ayn Rand's philosophy of objectivism. With the "Who is Atlas?" posters referencing Rand's over a thousand page long novel Atlas Shrugged, and the main antagonist being in fact named Andrew Ryan, the connection is all too obvious.
Ryan, just like Rand, rejects religion and government - "No gods. No kings. Only man" - instead basing his faith in the power of an individual.
Opposing socialism, Rand clearly believed in self-hood, self-service and self-care. Basically, man should be allowed to do what he or she clearly intends. Its the man that shapes the society, not the other way round. The underwater Rapture rejects socialism and communism, in favour of free market.
Bioshock Infinite is also famously packed with meaning and even though both games deserve a spot on this list, the first instance of the franchise is featured here basically because it was, well, first.
2. Uncharted: Drake's Deception - Psychoanalysis
The games in the Uncharted universe are among the most cinematic, entertaining, and beautifully animated for next-gen consoles. The hero, claiming that he's a distant relative of Sir Francis Drake - a real-life English sea captain - embarks on fantastic adventures and explorations, at the end reaching the typical trifecta of: women, fortune and fame.
Alfie Bown observes that all three are side-goals, as Drake's main obsession is with history, and the desire to explore the past has been actually implemented by Nathan's unconscious. In Drake's Deception, we learn that Nathan is not who we thought he was - instead of being Drake's ancestor, he is actually an orphan, who constructed the narrative to instil meaning in his life.
There are two victims of the titular deception: the gamer and Drake himself. Bown's Freudian analysis informs us that there's more to the game than money, marriage, orientalism and heroism.
All of these desires are not true, as "desire is always inherently political" which means it is shaped by the system of power just as much as it is able to shape the system of power as well.
1. Call Of Duty: Advanced Warfare - Masculinity
The year is 2054. Jack Mitchell loses his arm and his best friend in battle. During said friend's funeral, he is approached by Jonathan Irons (Kevin Spacey), who is the owner of a PMC (Private Military Company) called Atlas Corporation. He allows Mitchell to become a soldier again by giving him a prosthetic arm and access to the newest military technology.
When Mitchell's hand jams during training, he is informed by his commander that his best weapon is his brain. As the exosuit also has a tendency to jam, the game responds to the Cartesian notion of the brain being separate from the body, but also highlights man's troubled relationship with technology.
During the final showdown with Irons, the villain is left hanging from Mitchell's prosthetic hand. By cutting of his arm, the hero affirms the separation from technology which also dominates previous editions of the game. Instead of accepting transhumanism, Mitchell seems to have learned that to remain masculine he doesn't need his arm, because knowing that he's a man is enough to be one.
Mitchell is reminiscent of the gamer, whose prosthetic - the game controller - allows him to act as a man in the game, as opposed to actually being one in real life.
--
Were there any other hidden meanings or academic insights you noticed in your favourite games? Let us know in the comments!