8 Video Games That Could Have Just Been An Email

These video games didn't even touch the sides.

By Jack Pooley /

There probably isn't a person among us who hasn't played at least one video game and thought, "Well, that was definitely a game."

Advertisement

For one of many reasons, a game might leave you feeling utter indifference, the experience failing to move you in any way or stoke any sort of strong feelings.

It was a game that existed, and you probably stopped thinking about it the moment you closed it off.

While not all games can be immortal, generational bangers, sometimes you might play a game and consider it such a fleeting, ephemeral piece of work that, well, it basically could've been an e-mail.

And that's absolutely true of these games, each of which are either woefully undercooked entries in beloved franchises, or hyped-up original games that came and went in the mere blink of an eye.

Time hasn't been kind to these titles which, in the grand scheme of things, mostly feel like pointless excursions which wasted the time of both the developers and players alike.

Though each of these games were hotly anticipated pre-release, they fell out of the cultural conversation in record time because there was so little meat on them bones...

8. Devil May Cry 2

Impressively even more polarising than 2013's Devil May Cry reboot, Devil May Cry 2 is one of the most bafflingly undercooked sequels of all time - a bewilderingly naff rush-job which Capcom sloughed out less than 18 months after the acclaimed original.

Advertisement

Devil May Cry 2 put basically every foot wrong - the combat was intensely casualised to the point of tedium, Dante's edgy personality was cleaved away in favour of generic stoicism, and the repetitive level design was an absolute snoozer throughout.

Combine all this with a brief five-hour play-time and how blatantly the storytelling was nothing but filler, and it's little surprise that even ride-or-die DmC fans often recommend newcomers to skip this one and jump straight into the brilliant third game instead.

Devil May Cry 2 did the one thing just about nobody expected - it made the character action franchise boring, damn-near derailing its momentum before it even firmly established itself as a core Capcom staple.

7. Super Meat Boy Forever

It's fair to say that by 2020 fans of the all-timer platformer Super Meat Boy were beyond jonesing for a sequel, but man, what a letdown it ended up being.

Advertisement

The chief complaint about Super Meat Boy Forever is that Team Meat made it an auto-runner, meaning that players no longer had control of Meat Boy's movements beyond jumping. 

Further polarising was the decision to have levels be procedurally generated depending on the player's skill level, ensuring that this sequel lacked the tightness and exactitude of its predecessor.

Ultimately Super Meat Boy Forever came and went in a flash, because while it's actually a rather good example of an auto-runner, it's consequently a terrible Super Meat Boy game, and hardly what anyone who loved the original wanted for a sequel.

Team Meat originally designed the game as a mobile-only spin-off before pivoting it into a direct sequel, and boy does it show. 

The fact that very few people talk about the game today, except to dunk on it of course, says it all.

6. Resident Evil 3 Remake

After the enormous success of Capcom's Resident Evil 2 remake, fans naturally expected the same level of care and attention for the remake of Resident Evil 3: Nemesis.

Advertisement

But while the new take on Resident Evil 3 offered up solid visuals and superficial rollercoaster-ride thrills, it was also clearly rushed out by Capcom for a quick buck. 

For one, large sections of the original game are missing entirely, the branching choices are gone, boss encounters and puzzles have been "streamlined," and Nemesis himself has a far more subdued presence overall.

The result is a rather half-baked "remake" that can be easily beaten in around five hours and doesn't get close to capturing the intense atmosphere of the original.

Resident Evil 2's remake was a perfect example of how to reinterpret a classic for a new generation while not being 100% faithful, but the new Resident Evil 3 just felt like Capcom couldn't really be bothered to do it full justice.

5. Star Fox Zero

Considering that Star Fox Zero was the first mainline Star Fox game in a full decade, fans quite understandably expected it to take full advantage of the Wii U's hardware.

Advertisement

What they didn't expect was for Nintendo to stubbornly shoehorn motion controls into the game, as became a massive sticking point with critics and players alike on launch.

Being forced to use motion controls which were additionally uncomfortable and unintuitive meant that the game felt like a chore to play from minute one.

Beyond that the story was a dull retread of earlier Star Fox games, ensuring that this felt like a spectacularly unenthusiastic, half-hearted attempt to bring the IP back to the mainstream.

The vocal complaints about the controls alone were seemingly enough to sink Star Fox Zero commercially, as it ultimately ended up selling less than half a million copies, albeit also a result of the Wii U's stagnant sales.

The basic act of playing this game is such an awkward pain in the ass that opening an email is genuinely preferable.

4. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III

The Call of Duty franchise has pretty consistently delivered the meat-and-potatoes goods, but 2023's Modern Warfare III was a tepid stew missing so much of the good stuff.

Advertisement

It's little secret that the game was originally developed by Sledgehammer Games as a DLC for Modern Warfare II, before Activision changed it into a full-fat retail release mid-production.

This likely explains both why Modern Warfare III released with a cobbled-together excuse for a campaign and the multiplayer suite launched with no brand new maps at all - just remastered ones from 2009's Modern Warfare 2.

Though the multiplayer at least delivered a basically fun time, it was painfully, embarrassingly clear that this product was never intended to plug a gap in the franchise's annual pipeline. 

Activision made it happen because they knew it will sell anyway, even if the negativity surrounding the release is what likely prompted it to sell less than Modern Warfare II.

All in all it's a rare Call of Duty game that even some loyal fans decided to skip, because it showed so little basic respect for them and their wallets.

3. The Order: 1886

Now to be completely fair to Ready at Dawn's alt-history steampunk action-adventure game The Order: 1886, it would've made for a really, really pretty e-mail.

Advertisement

The marketing for the game focused on its undeniably jaw-dropping visual presentation, with Sony hyping it up as their next big AAA IP, the potential of which spoke for itself.

But the rug was firmly pulled out once the game launched and critics and players alike expressed their thunderous indifference. 

This was a game that, despite its technical innovations, was otherwise a bog-standard third-person shooter with nothing even remotely mechanically interesting on offer.

Even worse than that, neither the characters nor the story made much of a dent, wholly unaided by a brutally short five-hour length, ensuring players were afforded little time to immerse themselves in the game's superficially rich world before it was all over.

Though some scattered enthusiasm for The Order remains, it evaporated from mainstream gaming culture in the blink of an eye, likely because it felt less like the start of a franchise than a thinly drawn proof-of-concept.

2. Shenmue III

Fans were overjoyed when Shenmue III was finally confirmed at E3 2015, but when the long-awaited sequel released in 2019 - almost a full 20 years after the second game - it was tough to mask the disappointment.

Advertisement

Sure, there were those die-hards simply happy to return to the series in any form, but if we're honest with ourselves, Shenmue III is one of the most audacious squanderings of a belated sequel in gaming history.

Rather than appreciate that Shenmue III's existence was basically miraculous and press on with progressing Ryo Hazuki's quest to avenge his murdered father, creator Yu Suzuki decided to make the threequel a glorified filler entry where almost nothing of consequence actually happened.

One could forgive, perhaps even embrace the stiff combat and clunky controls if Shenmue III had any story momentum whatsoever. 

However, villain Lan Di doesn't appear until the final minutes of the game, before he effortlessly beats Ryo in a brief boss fight and the two once again go their separate ways.

Shenmue III ends on another agonising cliffhanger that's made all the more infuriating by the distinct possibility that Shenmue IV won't ever happen, especially considering all the fan goodwill Suzuki burned with this utter nothingburger of a sequel.

1. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed had its rough edges but nevertheless remains one of the more entertaining and memorable Star Wars games, selling enough that a sequel was quickly put into production.

Advertisement

But Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II is a depressingly blatant cash-grab that largely just rehashes the original but makes most everything worse.

With a wafer-thin story, woefully repetitive level design, clunky combat, and a mere four-hour play-time, this thing absolutely dripped with cynicism from its every pore, feeling more like a half-baked DLC than a full-fat retail product.

Following the game's release it unsurprisingly emerged that production was a nightmare, with LucasArts insisting that it be completed in just two years - half the time the team spent making the original The Force Unleashed.

Due to this writer Haden Blackman had only three weeks to pen the game's script, which combined with leadership changes at LucasArts resulted in the project's scope and style being pulled in different directions throughout development.

Despite the first game being a massive commercial hit, this limp sequel failed to move the needle, effectively killing the franchise shortly before Disney bought Lucasfilm.

Advertisement