As digital distribution continues to replace brick and mortar stores, Valve's power only seems to grow with every passing year. With just over seventy-eight million active members using Steam, the company all but completely eclipses its competition despite good showings from the likes of GOG.com, Green Man Gaming and many others. You can also probably argue Origin should be counted, but any distribution platform which needs to hold new titles ransom to encourage members to join is clearly doing something very wrong. However, while Steam has well earned its popularity it's hardly without some failings, as it only takes a very brief examination to pick out several critical flaws within the platform. These range from the company's basic mindset when it comes to dealing with certain issues, to failing to truly promote latest releases. These aren't teething problems either, with many failures being systems initiated to help allow games on Steam or better player access, each is a critical flaw which will only become progressively more damaging as time goes by. Should Valve ignore them, they will only hamper its success and gradually allow for another service to gradually replace it. So here's a list of those flaws, nine critical failings which are slowly killing Steam over time.
9. Front Page
Easily the most obvious failing of Steam is the front page layout, which seems less devoted to promoting the most recent releases than it does big sellers. Along with a massive scrolling banner which flips between the most hyped new releases and AAAs, everything a user sees the moment they log in are games the Valve staff have personally picked out from the past several weeks. The actual new releases section is confined to an area beneath this, something which limits awareness for new titles and harms sales. Even accounting for the members of the community who take the time to check for new releases on a daily basis, the design severely limits that all important front page awareness which can mean the difference between a studio making profit and tanking in sales. Compared to the likes of GamersGate and GOG.com, Steam's front page is poorly structured out and counterproductive to promoting all of its releases equally. While both of those examples suffer from some of the same excesses as Steam, they are far more compactly designed and easier to navigate, allowing for new titles to have a far better chance of being noticed. Freeing up space by removing relatively useless add-ons such as Community Activity would allow for easier searching and more pertinent information - this could be anything from listing the year a game was originally released along with the developer, to even just giving a small indication which ones are a port from iOS.
8. Release Schedules
Valve CorporationOne particular failing of Steam right now is the order in which developers are allowed to release their games in, or rather the sheer lack of any structure for such a thing. It seems that most games are allowed placement whenever they are pushed forwards by a publisher or grouped together by Valve. While this might have made sense with a better sales page layout, it causes more than a few problems given Steam's layout and certain decisions by publishers. Just for starters this pushes down other new releases outside the initial view; as games are effectively listed one after another in a column, should a bigger publisher opt to release a vast number of titles onto Steam at once, they can very easily muscle out most of their competition, thereby ensuring that their titles will garner the most attention and secure more buyers. Just one offending example from recent months was by Activision, who opted to release the Amazing Spider-Man 2 onto Steam along with all of its DLC outfits at once. As it stands, this suggests that Valve has no desire to give each title a reasonable chance to draw attention to itself. This would be bad enough if these were only new games, but many publishers have taken to uploading ancient titles en-mass, especially if they have recently acquired older IPs. As a result, this is not only severely marginalising the potential revenue of indie developers but makes life harder for users to browse through genuinely new releases. With no apparent structure to these releases or an option to filter out older titles, Steam is drowning in decades-old games, shovelware, hastily assembled cash-grabs, and the sorts of titles which give the industry a bad name. For every overlooked gem like Skyborn, Meltdown or Ring Runner: Flight of the Sages, there are hundreds of cheap titles which would have been laughed off even the iOS App Store.
7. Greenlight
Already infamous for entirely the wrong reasons, the Greenlight process has long been singled out as a major shortcoming within Steam. The original plan for the process was to serve as a popularity contest, with the community voting on which game they would want to see eventually released onto the platform, and then to put support behind it. This is an idea which works on paper, but it only takes a brief moment to see how easily the system can be abused or even outright broken. For example, the R-rated title Bonetown (yes, it's exactly what you think it is) only achieved being Greenlit thanks to a joke made by a presenter on The Game Station Podcast, rather than genuine interest from gamers. What's more is that more than once the system outright contradicted itself or counteracted the very thing it was supposed to do, denying studios access after finding success. Easily the most infamous example to date is the fiasco surrounding Paranautical Activity which was initially barred from Steam for supposedly trying to bypass the system. How were they trying to bypass it, you ask? By successfully striking up a contract with an established publisher weeks after starting on Greenlight. Members of Valve itself later admitted that Greenlight was not working as they had hoped, and opted to pursue another approach. It was at this point Steam went from one extreme to the next, creating an even bigger problem for the community. See the previous point to realise the massive problems caused by Valve opening up the proverbial floodgates and letting effectively anyone through. While the Greenlight has seen some improvements in recent years, it's questionable whether or not it even remains neccessary following Valve's change in attitude. Rather than being reworked into a more effective system, it instead seems more like a holdover from a previous - now failed - approach, which Valve has yet to get around to removing.
6. User Tag System
An example of Valve's contradictory attitude of giving the community power only to take it away is the tags system. Implemented to allow the Steam community to create their own tags to help organise games and create new categories, forming new ways to search for similar titles on Steam and find certain lists of titles which might best interest users. The result was definitely a mixed bag, with all the abuse you would expect. Due to their hands off approach, Valve permitted multiple titles to carry unrelated and useless tags which ranged from old jokes such as "Half Life 3 confirmed" to unsavoury and offensive additions such as "Jews did 9/11" and similar choices. Despite this, among these were some surprisingly effective additions which significantly helped with browsing. "Walking Simulator" was attached to titles such as Dear Esther, which helped to signify the lack of serious interactivity in the game and the way it presented content to the player. The likes of "Procedural Death Labyrinth" was added to a specific sub-category of roguelikes, and even comedic tags such as "Nanomachines, son" listed fantastic cyberpunk titles. Furthermore, tags were utilised used as warnings, with mentions of "bad PC port" often showing up alerting the community to problematic releases and buggy content. While the system needed definite cleaning up, Valve's response to this was overkill. Deleting just about every tag imaginable, it only permitted certain extremely basic tags to remain, usually only linking into a title's genre. This crippled a potentially fantastic idea and as of yet there have been no major pushes to bring back certain tags, with only a few truly useful ones starting to emerge again. This mass purge only serves to harm Steam. It not only tells the community that Valve is unwilling to permit the marking of games with tags useful to them, but it will go out of its way to hide which titles are broken, are poorly ported to the PC or are buggy beyond belief. These are not actions which help engender faith or goodwill from users, and it serves as a black mark on Valve's otherwise good track record.
5. Developer Lies And Misrepresentation
While many of Valve's failings ultimately come down to how they present titles, they seem to equally stumble when it comes to making sure a game actually has the content being advertised advertising. Time and time again, players have been conned into buying broken releases which somehow managed to be released despite not only displaying false information about their content but sometimes completely fabricating gameplay. The most well known example of this was Infestation: Survivor Stories, formerly The War Z, which outright lied to customers in order to draw in an audience it could leach money from. Its page featured false screenshots of NPCs which did not exist, weapons which were not present, and many shots of vastly better graphics than the game could support. Worse still, the developers actually straight-up lied about its features atop of this; along with grossly exaggerating server populations and area sizes, the game also advertised an experience system which was never implemented into the game - you didn't even need to start playing to realise something was drastically wrong. Not content with just lying to customers and latching onto the success of DayZ, Hammerpoint Interactive opted to also pinch content from more successful studios. Artwork from The Walking Dead and various online images were photoshopped slightly in an effort to pass it off as their title screen, and the game featured the entire terms of service for League of Legends in place of its own, completely unedited - so anyone who bothered to read it would keep seeing "League of Legends" in place of "War Z". Bare in mind this took only a scant few minutes following its release for the community to pick out these falsehoods, yet Valve allowed it onto their distribution platform without a second thought. Even after the forums erupted into a veritable firestorm of bile and hatred, Valve onto temporarily removed the game and allowed it to return with a few minor edits weeks later. This wouldn't be the only incident of this either, with following games such as Earth: Year 2066 and Air Control proceeding to do the same thing, and similarly be released onto Steam without any opposition. The fact multiple games can get away with this is astounding beyond belief and is a sign of just how lax Valve's standards are. If Steam is to continue to be taken seriously it needs to take measures to prevent this occurring again by making sure future developers cannot con their community into buying polished turds of releases with the barest shred of truth on their front pages.
4. Early Access
Yet another idea which looked good on paper, Early Access has served as a double-edged sword. Allowing customers to buy into what was effectively a beta or sometimes even alpha of a title, Early Access saw popularity with growing games with booming communities despite their incomplete nature. The likes of DayZ, Rust and many others found success in Early Access and continue to build towards bigger things thanks to the additional income. The chief problem is that the system is easily open to abuse and, like so many other things, it lacks active oversight. There is no definitive push by Valve to ensure that games listed under it are being actively developed, or that they will not merely be abandoned a few months down the line. The closest there is to any set of standards or a warning that a project might never see fulfillment is a blue bar, which states that a game "may or may not change significantly over the course of development" along with a word from the developers themselves. There is no effort made to ensure that players are informed of future updates, that any kind of development schedule is followed, or even a general outline of what is finished. Many games have found success with such transparency, such as Failbetter Game's Sunless Sea, which lists what elements are closest to completion and publicly displays a development road-map. All this is even ignoring some of the worst uses of the system, with developers using the system to escape criticism of obviously broken games. Notably BlackSoul: Extended Edition was initially uploaded to Steam as a full release, only for Valve to quietly move it to Early Access when criticisms were levelled about its finished quality. While the actual idea of Early Access has merit and does feature good titles, the system desperately needs staff to crack down on the quality of titles. The system needs set standards, careful monitoring of all games listed and workers that will ensure they will see continued development as time goes by. Without it, Early Access will merely become yet another element of Steam to be exploited and fill up the platform with low quality, partially complete games.
3. Developer Censorship
One of the efforts to free up work on Valve's part was the way its multitude of forums work, as rather than being moderated and individually monitored by a third party, each is directly controlled by the developer personally. It only takes a brief look into gaming history to see how this power turns into censorship; Piranha Games Inc. (the aforementioned Hammerpoint Interactive), Wild Games Studio and countless others have proven just how readily certain companies are willing to censor and delete negative opinions wherever possible - and this is rife among certain releases on Steam. These include the likes of FUN Creators, developers of the infamously bad Guise of the Wolf. They used their power to delete statements and ban members under the excuse of making "useless paintbrush posts" - usually when some customers had opted to complain about the unfinished graphics, poor AI and the problematic stealth system. A more extreme example can be found in the form of Earth: Year 2066, which featured the developer Killing Day Studios (AKA Muxwell) censoring, editing and destroying any comment which he felt affronted him. Usually the ones which pointed out certain questionable design choices, such as the fact the screen on the game's menu had been taken from Google Images and used without crediting the artists. After declaring that all critics were "spammers, trolls and provokers" the developer went on to nuke the entire forum and renamed the game's community forum "The Troll Tavern." Neither of these examples involved Steam stepping in to stop this at any point, at least until very widespread and public protest forced them to remove Earth: Year 2066 from the store. While it would be an almost impossible task to devote a group of Valve employees to patrol each and every forum for the thousands of games on Steam, the sheer lack of oversight is inexcusable. With this hands off approach by the Valve, developers are free to censor any threads or comments they view as potentially harming their sales. With no obvious moderation, there is no threat of retribution to prevent this sort of thing happening before it truly starts. The forums as a whole need some kind of oversight, with a small staff devoted to investigating the worst cases or performing random sweeps throughout certain forums to check on their state. To put it simply: Valve needs some kind of Sword of Damocles-style repercussion to keep the worst of these developers in line.
2. Quality Control
Of all of Valve's failings, their sheer lack of quality control or ability to keep check on games uploaded to the platform is what harms the system the most. It would be one thing for bad games to be released on Steam, but quite frequently bug-ridden, badly programmed titles which hardly even count as finished can be found up for sale. Forget Ride To Hell: Retribution, these include the sorts of titles which look as if they have yet to reach alpha testing, or worse prove to be outright unplayable at the best of times. It seems that with the right publisher backing up a game or the right pitch, any title is permitted onto Steam without objections, no matter their state or whether they were actually playable. Daylight was allowed onto the platform despite severe graphical issues which made prevented countless buyers from even starting the game. Deus Ex: The Fall was so badly ported to the PC that fighting was a near impossibility thanks to a bug which zoomed into the screen every time the player fired a weapon. Revelations 2012 is another stellar example; a game with less strategic depth than Pac-Man that was little more than a Half-Life 2 mod, yet was given the okay for full price purchase nonetheless. Then we have the really bad ones such as Killjoy Games' Air Control. Little more than a poorly put together Flappy Bird clone with the graphical quality of a child's crayon scribble. This is a game which explains to the player how to overcome game crashes, graphical glitches and the like in the tutorial - because the programmers could not be bothered to personally correct them. While some of these games were fixed in later patches, the fact they were sold despite retaining such massive programming errors and shoddy quality speaks volumes about how little Valve will curate its own stock. Well, that and Steam's report system. Updated back in March of this year, clicking on the report button brings up a variety of catagories such as Hate Speech, Fraud, Legal Violation, Harmful (Viruses and Malware), and Child Exploitation. While any extensive reporting system is naturally appreciated, it's very hard not to raise an eyebrow at just how specific many of these categories are. Or, more to the point, why Valve itself is requiring users to single out and report these elements rather than staff discover these problems before allowing them on the service. As more and more games find their way onto Steam, the more titles broken to the point of being unplayable will show up on the store page. With each one, Valve loses more credibility as a publisher and the community are given more reasons to start looking elsewhere for a more reliable platform. It may even take years for this to have serious effect, but gradually players will lose their patience with the company.
1. Reactionary Behaviour
Above all else, above even their inability to ensure the quality of the games they release, the biggest failing which is gradually killing Steam is Valve's work ethic. Infamous for their slow development and with "Valve time" practically being an industry joke, the company maintains the attitude of only taking things seriously when it wants to. While this might have brought them success as a developer, as a publisher this merely causes more and more problems over time. Just going from this list alone there are a multitude of examples in which the corporation has waited for some accident or disaster to happen before reacting, rather than initiating procedures beforehand to ensure it never took place. Even after they do occur precautionary measures are a rarity, and Valve are frequently slow to respond, often overreacting. Multiple figures within the company openly admitted they disliked how Greenlight had turned out; yet not only did that take them several years to turn around, but it resulted in the company only making things worse. This attitude only harms them further thanks to their contradictory actions of desiring to have the community do the bulk of certain work for them, but then promptly stamping down once an idea involving them evolves beyond what they anticipated it to be. Even when a major error is found on their systems, they seem to opt for a move which will result in less longterm paperwork and will be a fast solution, even if it will serve as a spark for drama. The most clear cut example of this occurred merely a few days prior to this article when Tomáš Duda - an employee of SCS Software - attempted to get Valve's attention when he uncovered an easily exploitable programming error. Eventually resorting to using a prank code which turned the screen into a Harlem Shake parody, Valve took over a month to respond to something which could be used to steal money from customers. It then promptly banned Duda for getting their attention in his rather unique manner. While the banning might have been reversed less than a week later, the fact it took such a prank to get Valve's attention displays the massive failings in their work ethic and practice. Even just a modicum of proactivity on the part of the corporation in preventing further issues would go miles in ensuring Steam's future dominance and high quality service. Did we miss some major problem Valve has yet to clear up on Steam? Please leave your own suggestions and thoughts in the comments below!