9 Incredible Features WASTED On Disappointing Video Games

Believe it or not, Anthem isn't ALL bad.

By Josh Brown /

EA

A disappointing game is often worse than an outright bad one. When something's terrible, either riddled with bugs and glitches or delivering a gameplay loop that fundamentally just doesn't work, it's easy to rip it to pieces and then move on. The cycle is always the same; the game comes out, the internet tears it a new one for two weeks, and then players move on to the next big release and don't give it a second thought.

Advertisement

Disappointing games aren't quite so lucky however. Just look at Anthem from earlier this year; not a day goes by where the game isn't blowing up headlines in the press or dominating forums, and it's not because it's outright bad, but because there's just enough good in there that makes it such a frustrating experience, because it should be better.

This is compounded even more when a disappointing release actually boasts some new, unique ideas or features. Whether the games are built entirely around these systems and mechanics or just included them as afterthoughts - with the devs not quite understanding that they had something special on their hands - they're good enough to have players pining about what they could have been, had they been included anywhere else.

Advertisement

9. Planet Terraforming - Mass Effect: Andromeda

Bioware

Mass Effect: Andromeda was a total mess of a game, but you can't say that it didn't have grand ambitions. Originally, the title was supposed to be this sprawling space epic, making players feel like real adventurers as they travelled from planet to planet while uncovering the secrets of the Andromeda universe.

Advertisement

Sadly, those plans had to be scaled down, as inner turmoil in the development team led to missed deadlines and a lack of direction overall. The focus on discovering uncharted lands and colonising them did make it into the final release, but it was a much more watered down version.

The idea that these new planets were completely alien and hostile to humans remained however, and in just about every case you needed to make the world hospitable and safe for humans by changing the environment through alien technology.

Advertisement

Terraforming these planets provided a handful a great gameplay and story opportunities for the Andromeda team, but the system had clearly been scaled down at some point, when it should have supported the entire game.

8. Augmented Reality Pokemon Hunting - Pokemon GO

Niantic

Pokemon GO was a bonafide phenomenon. Launching to immediate popularity in the summer of 2016, the millions of people who picked up this free mobile game will no doubt remember having a blast with it, venturing outdoors to catch new creatures, attack gyms, and bump into a bunch of people out doing the exact same thing.

Advertisement

It was a stroke of brilliance from Niantic. The game itself was incredibly accessible as well, requiring essentially only a flick of the finger, while focusing on Gen 1 Pokemon lit up the nostalgia receptors of anyone who had ever been interested in the universe at some point. For those first few weeks, collecting and evolving your collected Pokemon was ridiculously addictive, but sadly the developers didn't quite have the content to sustain the interest.

That's because the "game" of Pokemon GO was entirely in collecting the monsters in the augmented reality, rather than doing anything with them. That still made for a good time, but there was always the feeling that it could have been so much more, and while more features were eventually added, they were sorely missing from that first wave of interest.

Advertisement

7. A Non-Linear Story - Beyond: Two Souls

Quantic Dream

Even the best video game stories play out relatively straightforwardly. Sure, there might be an unreliable narrator here, or a twist there, but the structure of video games as a medium and the control they give players means they can't get too wacky with their storytelling, in the AAA space at least.

Advertisement

Beyond: Two Souls, on the other hand, attempted to prove that developers could push the boundaries of how gaming stories are told, offering a tale that wasn't told in chronological order. It's the kind of thing that could only happen in a game from studios like Quantic Dream or Telltale, whose authored, controlled stories give the writers more freedom.

Beyond embraced the idea as well, hinging everything around these jumps through time in order to obfuscate specific plot points and deliver powerful revelations. Unfortunately, while this element was inspired, Beyond didn't quite have the narrative prowess to capitalise on it. The jumps around in time made the plot difficult to follow, while the writing in general wasn't quite refined enough to deliver the resonant story many were expecting.

Advertisement

Because of this, a remixed edition of the game was released, which put the narrative in chronological order. While this allowed players to comprehend the story, it broke the pacing, and revealed just how much the game was built around its non-linear conceit.

6. Living The Story Of A Director's Film Pitch - Far Cry 5: Dead Living Zombies

Ubisoft

Speaking of messing around with how video game stories are presented, Far Cry 5's DLC Dead Living Zombies attempted to do something similar. Essentially, it cast players as the hero of a film that's in the process of being pitched to a bunch of studios and producers. The director doing the pitching is Guy Marvel, someone who's desperate to get his zombie movie off the ground, and keeps altering it based on the feedback he receives.

Advertisement

Each level makes up these alterations, as the environment and set-pieces shift in real time depending on the notes he's being given and what the producers are responding to. It's such a cool idea, not only because it draws attention to the artificial ridiculousness of the DLC, but because it opened up so much potential for the devs to go wild with altering the play space and subverting expectations.

Sadly, the team didn't go far enough with the idea, and Dead Living Zombies is a surprisingly bland affair even with this idea at the heart of it. It's not quite the same, but Call of Juarez: Gunslinger pulled off a similar feature way better years prior as well, so check that out instead.

Advertisement

5. Open World Free-Running - Mirrors Edge: Catalyst

EA

In a classic case of "be careful what you wish for", Mirror's Edge: Catalyst was on fan wish lists for years before it came out, but then when EA actually went ahead and greenlit a sequel, nobody cared. In part that was because the sequel itself wasn't a total home-run, with the main problem being the jump from a linear free-running game to one set in an open world.

Advertisement

On paper, that should have been awesome; no longer would you be funnelled down these carefully constructed areas that limited your movement options, but instead thrown into a huge sandbox where you could craft your own routes alongside the authored ones the developers created. In practice though, the gameplay was nowhere near as satisfying as it should have been, and the new structure actually negatively impacted the flow of the story.

Like the original, it was a great concept surrounded by a disappointing game, and it's a shame DICE will probably never get a third attempt to get it right.

Advertisement

4. Massive Zombie Hordes - Days Gone

Sony

Now, I want to preface this entry by saying that Days Gone isn't a bad game by any means, and doesn't deserve to be ripped apart as much as it has been, but the game is still disappointing and flawed in a lot of ways, from its presentation and story to its combat and exploration.

Advertisement

For the most part though, its USP, that being the huge zombie hordes that populate the post-apocalyptic world of Oregon, is enough to keep the gameplay interesting and dynamic. Encountering one of these masses of decaying flesh and gnashing teeth is always terrifying, and trying to navigate this seemingly unstoppable force of nature is thrilling. It's a visual spectacle as well, as the horde clambers over the environment and themselves to get to you.

Technical shortcomings do lessen the enjoyment of these enemies however, as having so many zombies on screen at once means each one has pretty basic animations, and the A.I. freaks out (no pun intended) quite often. It's as good a job as the devs could have probably done considering the memory limitations of current consoles, but it does feel like this element will be realised properly in the inevitable Days Gone 2.

Advertisement

3. Permadeath - ZombiU

Nintendo

ZombiU (retitled simply "Zombi" once its WiiU exclusivity deal was up) was an underrated gem for Nintendo's fledgling console. It wasn't perfect by any means (hence how it's ended up on this list), but its core survival loop provided a surprisingly compelling horror experience on a machine that was otherwise populated by classic, kid-friendly fare.

Advertisement

Really putting the emphasis on the "survival" part of survival-horror, the game implemented a permadeath system which would strip you of all your items should you end up zombie chow while out exploring. It wasn't punishing enough to strip you of your story progress, but dying would see you coming back as a fresh-faced character with only the bare necessities.

If you wanted your gear back, you'd have to find your previous self, now a zombie, and take them out. Even better, if you were playing online, the corpses of other players and their gear would also appear, subtly making their experiences part of your own. It made for some great risk/reward gameplay, but the combat itself was nowhere near enjoyable enough to make it totally worthwhile.

Advertisement

2. Players Hacking Into Your Session - Watch Dogs

Ubisoft

While Watch Dogs is remembered for not living up to the hype when it came to its graphics and gameplay, what shouldn't be forgotten is just how much its multiplayer suite was bigged up in the run up to release. Not only did the original game have an extensive competitive multiplayer mode that Ubisoft pushed hard, but there was also the ability for a player's solo campaign to get "hacked" by an invading real-life person.

Advertisement

This kicked off a dynamic game of cat and mouse, as the invader attempted to blend into the environment while the hacking metre increased, and you had to scramble to figure out where they were and put them down. It was undeniably cool the first couple of times it happened, but the system wasn't the most robust, and the lack of reward for engaging with this mode meant it was barely used.

Even when it returned in Watch Dogs 2, Ubisoft had barely improved it, and multiplayer as a whole took a back seat. It's a shame, as games like Dark Souls have proven how online integration into single-player can result in amazing, memorable multiplayer moments, but Watch Dogs never seemed all that interest in pursuing this area properly.

Advertisement

1. Flight In Combat & Exploration - Anthem

BioWare

It might be interesting to know that Anthem's signature movement system - that being the ability to fly around the entire map - was actually something that was almost cut from the game. Bioware apparently toyed with not including the system at all, worried they couldn't get it to feel right and that it would negatively impact exploration.

Advertisement

They did eventually include the feature however, and it became one of the very best things about the live-service shooter. Taking to the skies felt weighty, but had an elegance to it and sense of speed that felt just right, with it being so much fun to fly around the world and see the sights. Unfortunately, while the devs absolutely nailed this ability (and, admittedly, combat as well), the game surrounding it didn't capitalise on such a solid mechanic.

You don't need me to tell you all the reasons why Anthem was disappointing, as while the core gameplay itself was enjoyable enough, the missions, customisation and story left a whole lot to be desired.

Advertisement

Bioware fulfilled players' dreams of being an Iron Man-like hero, but it's a shame that excitement only lasts about 20 minutes.