9 Video Games That Didn't Know How To End

The gaming equivalent of running out of road and falling off a cliff.

By Scott Tailford /

Remedy

Why are there so few video game endings we actually remember and talk about positively?

Advertisement

In an age where the majority of triple-A video games are designed to be played for literal years at a time - facilitating DLC and microtransactions, before a sequel resets everything all over again - the very purpose of an ending is forever changing.

Do you tie off all your potential story threads, running the risk of a satisfied consumer base not coming back? Maybe go with a cliffhanger, as whilst you might not have secured funding for a sequel, a surge of fan interaction could make that a reality somewhere down the line.

Advertisement

There's also the fact that developing a video game is incredibly hard. Budgets run out, key staff members leave or can have any number of emergency commitments.

Any large-scale title has a team-size reaching closer to 100 individuals, and the likes of Assassin's Creed or Red Dead Redemption 2 have that number doubled, tripled or more so.

Advertisement

All of this folds back into a game's design, and the challenge of executing on an initial vision becomes substantially more hard.

--

Advertisement

-- Spoilers within --

9. Rage 2

Bethesda

From something that was loaded with story potential to a game that felt like it just gave up. Rage 2 easily has supremely polished combat at its core, but the decision to spread that across a barren open world was met with derision and questioning.

Advertisement

Why, when you could've turned out a lightning quick corridor-based shooter with occasional arena elements, did you try and chase arbitrary "triple-A design goals", like making the acquisition of the best weapons optional, as we drove a boring vehicle from A to B and back again?

Say you did buy into this design though, the ending of Rage 2 is insulting at best, and downright unfinished at worst.

Advertisement

Coming after you've been through a ton of busywork, stepping into the role of a Ranger after a set of armour is left behind, you eventually find yourself in the compound of General Cross, battling him to the death, but succumbing to a lethal virus at the same time.

It's one massive set-piece followed by an out-of-nowhere twist, and just as you're trying to parse out what you're supposed to be feeling and if this will lead to anything... the game slooowly fades to black, reemerging with a credits roll.

Advertisement

Afterwards you're immediately saved by Dr. Kvasir, undoing the "peril" of the pre-credits twist, and put back to work doing the same side content as an endgame.

Because video games.

Advertisement

8. Wolfenstein 2

Bethesda

I bloody love Wolfenstein II. The shooting, teardown of BJ Blazkowicz as an emptied shotgun of a man - the liquid butter shooting that sees you tear a massive S-shape through alternate history where the Nazis won World War II.

Advertisement

It's all supremely sublime... except the ending.

Possibly down to this being a middle instalment, or something involving the game's budget running out, production schedules falling apart etc. The reality is, Wolfenstein 2 - after setting up the notion that BJ and co. are mounting an offensive against Hitler's forces and the systematic infection of America - finally pin down the location of Frau Engel.

Advertisement

Keep in mind, Engel has survived being killed from the first game, abused her sibling, beheaded people in front of you and all-round been the main bad guy in the new canon. She's a real piece of sh*t, and whatever was coming her way, you bet it would be satisfying.

...or done in a cutscene.

Advertisement

As Engel is performing a chat show interview, you literally walk up to her, slice off one of her arms as the game pilots BJ instead, then watch the game awkwardly judder into a cutscene that shows an axe being buried in her head.

Before you can comprehend that "Yes, this really is how they're closing an otherwise stellar video game", a handful of scenes show our heroes addressing the nation, as the rebellion is finally kicking into high gear. Then we cut to a truly horrific version of Twisted Sister's "We're Not Gonna Take It", the credits roll, and so do your eyeballs.

Advertisement

7. Anthem

Bioware

Even as I type this, Bioware are likely going to roll back one of their previously announced "commitments" for the future of Anthem's story.

Advertisement

Because back at launch, we were regaled with this idea of the game being told in various "acts", that would unfold across the year. The actual campaign you played through was monumentally threadbare thanks to a hellish development process, but even that ended on a cliffhanger that a legendary member of the Urgoth race had been recovered.

In standard Bioware form, the Urgoth are the progenitor race holding all the cards. They'd presumedly cast some light on the "voice of creation" that is the Anthem itself, and the game rolls credits with an autopsy about to go underway.

Advertisement

Whilst this was toothless as hell in the first place - a way to say to any community "Hey, we'll think of something later, we promise!", it's only become clearer that EA and Bioware never planned a full year's worth of story acts to drop in quick succession.

The game's roadmap has since been discarded and the story all but abandoned.

Advertisement

Developers post community updates stating that Anthem is still "important" to them, meanwhile the game itself is dropped onto the lowest tier of EA Play, just so it can regain some revenue before petering out altogether.

A catastrophic misfire.

Advertisement

6. Gears 4 & 5

The Coalition

Hey, The Coalition? You can end your games on something other than a cliffhanger.

Advertisement

Gears of War is easily one of the most well-known and iconic franchises in gaming history. It has legions of fans - some of them with COG tattoos - it's not like they're not going to soak up every last morsel of a given story.

Sadly though, while Gears 5 contains the most polished gameplay of the series to date, like Gears 4, it has a marked lack of confidence throughout.

Advertisement

Sure, there are peaks like when Kait finds out the history of her bloodline and relation to Queen Myrrha at the close of Act 2... but that's about it.

Act 3 quickly deviates into a complete tonal shift as we embark on a barren open-world section, only for the closing Act 4 to be a standard "Save the city!" setup, and like Gears 4 again, the game ends on a cliffhanger that there's more to come.

Advertisement

Where Gears 4 had the reveal of Kait realising an heirloom passed down from her grandmother was the Locust symbol, Gears 5 has the crew look at Kait as they remark on needing to track down Kait's mother, who has become the new Locust Queen.

Both games end on Kait holding that same amulet, and both ultimately feel like wheel-spinning - especially after what Act 2 looked to set in motion.

Advertisement

5. Control

Remedy

Easily one of the best games of 2019, Control has a third-person combat system somewhere between freeform shooting and physics-based experimentation.

Advertisement

You're free to fire off single shot rounds and shotgun blasts, but you can also pick up everything from potted plants to tables, forklift trucks to chunks of concrete, all using the power of telekinesis.

All of this is so time-tested to perfection, and yet... the ending is godawful.

Advertisement

See, the whole game was about Jesse trying to track down her brother, who we find was taken away from her when the pair were extremely young, and after they came into contact with a supernatural entity, Polaris.

Within the space of half an hour, Jesse finds out this entity actually lives in a spherical chamber guarded by supremely hard enemies, discovers no, actually that's a lie and it was in her the whole time, gets thrown into a demon-controlled flashback where she can't progress without doing menial tasks over and over, then falls into an all-red dimension where her brother needs saving again.

Advertisement

She gets to the end of this gauntlet, touches and saves her brother, then he falls into a coma and we hit credits.

It's all handled as sporadically and jarringly as that sounds, and as you're allowed to keep playing, the game mentions there are still things to do around the facility; hinting at a "true ending". But what happens if you do all this?

Advertisement

Not a damn thing.

Remedy have confirmed DLC is coming, but I very much doubt that will fix such a shockingly naff change of pace.

Advertisement

4. Mad Max

Avalanche

As games continue to get bigger and more expansive on scope, you have to wonder what an "ending" even is, when we're spending so long in open-worlds and "platforms for content" anyway.

Advertisement

Mad Max certainly didn't know, as although you can argue the character is forever on the precipice of complete insanity; dogged by visions of his dead family or never knowing who to trust, the game - after 50+ hours of exploration, combat, crafting and customisation - undoes almost everything for an ending that ultimately felt pointless.

Doing the opposite of something like The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - where all your progress feeds into an armour set, selection of items and skills you take into the final battle, Mad Max's gameplay centres on building the "Magnum Opus" - a deluxe death-car full of weapons and upgrades - only to take it away in a cutscene.

Advertisement

Not only does the car you've built across the whole game get blown up, but your only ally in this land - the peppy enough Chumbucket - gets impaled on the front of it, as Max chooses to ram the villain's truck in the moment, rather than wait it out.

Of course, being an open-world game, there's still a post-credits endgame, only now you're in a far less impressive, run-of-the-mill car, rather than the one you'd invested in beforehand.

Advertisement

It was all.so.weird.

3. Borderlands

2K

The ending of Borderlands is one of the most disappointing and empty in all of gaming.

Advertisement

The whole game being centred on chasing after a particular Vault - a source of riches, treasures and essentially Something Worthwhile, instead what popped out was... a giant monster called the Destroyer.

No plot or narrative reason for it to exist. Nothing especially standout about what comes from defeating it either. Just a big, oily bullet sponge monster boss you could actually cheese by standing just out its reach and shooting from a safe zone.

Advertisement

In short, it was terrible, and Gearbox would later address the decision with mission designer Paul Helquist trying desperately to find a silver lining, saying that although the reaction was "stronger than they hoped", at least it "didn't paint them into any corners."

Now you know why Borderlands 2's story and characters were such a massive step up.

Advertisement

2. Final Fantasy 12

Square Enix

Onto something that didn't come up short through any conscious effort that didn't land, but a game that barely survived development at all.

Advertisement

First beginning production back in 2001 as a followup to Final Fantasy X (11 was always more of an online experiment), director Yasumi Matsuno reportedly had a ton of problems adjusting to the scale of production and level of expectation associated with a numbered Final Fantasy.

Final Fantasy 12 was also going to debut another all-new battle system - one that was more "hands off" and MMO in nature, with you setting combat "states" or animations to play out ahead of time, then micro-managing how battles played out as an overseer.

Advertisement

This divides fans to this day, but ultimately, everything combined to see Matsuno leave the project, as release windows and implementation goals were missed.

By the time 12 hit release in 2006, Final Fantasy 13 was then announced only months later, having been in development for years at that point. The overlap wasn't healthy for development on what now felt like a case of "Just get it out the door", and 12's final act almost fell apart completely.

Advertisement

With no lead creative vision and Square Enix breathing down their necks, FF 12 pivots very suddenly into a short dungeon, quick deaths, a wannabe "epic" battle against The Undying, and an all-round feeling of running out of time.

1. No Man's Sky (Launch Version)

Hello Games

Few games have had such seismic turnarounds as No Man's Sky.

Advertisement

While personally I always loved what Hello Games were able to achieve - an exploration-heavy sci-fi extravaganza where the isolation of charting the cosmos was key - holy christ did they drop the ball on an ending.

Set up as part of the game's marketing, Sean Murray repeatedly noted that there would be something "special" at the centre of the galaxy, and when gameplay then required hundreds of hours of planet-hopping and survival to get there, it better be worth it.

Advertisement

What happened though?

Well, you click on the final central star and... nothing.

Advertisement

Slowly your viewpoint zooms outwards, far back past every other planet you visited or could've visited, until the whole game has reset itself, and all your time and progress was for nothing.

Thankfully, Hello Games have overhauled No Man's Sky's story, hammering home all the notions of purpose and humanity's need to see what's on the horizon, but that original version? Eeesh.

Advertisement