9 Video Games That Played With Your Emotions

Those pixels that got you right in the feelers.

By Joel Harvey /

Whether it's your unholy despair when reading Fifty Shades of Grey or ecstatic joy when seeing a new Adam Sandler film, emotional responses are key to understanding any form of art. It's these reactions that uniquely define your experience and memories thereafter, with video games being no exception.

Advertisement

Some may mock the idea of a game evoking an emotional reaction in the same way as other art forms - and that was a fair argument back in the early days of gaming, as such complex feelings were not quite Pong's forte. But storytelling has evolved in gaming since then, and these days various titles wield the power to knock you emotionally sideways in a way that's entirely different to other creative mediums.

Unlike films, books or music, playing an active role a structured storyline can feel like you're the person moving the plot along.

This gives you a unique front row seat in any emotional drama that then gets played out, as every plot twist, revelatory rug-pull, backstab or final confrontation is yours to take in first-hand.

9. Firewatch

There aren't many video games that are prepared to tackle such tough topics as mental illness, but Firewatch isn't like many video games.

Advertisement

You play as fire lookout warden (Henry), and must unravel a physical mystery that's unfolding in the woods, as well as coming to terms with the emotional mystery playing out inside Henry's own head. You see, Henry is a man wracked by personal guilt and tragedy, as he struggles to deal with the diagnosis of his wife's early-onset dementia.

Firewatch's willingness to explore Henry's fragile emotional state is the game's triumph, as it turns the first-person perspective into an entry point for the player into his mind.

Smart writing and excellent voice acting from the two leads - all played out on walkie talkie, as Henry bonds with fellow fire warden, Delilah - makes Firewatch a powerful emotional experience.

8. Cannon Fodder

Deceptively simple, your aim in 1993's Cannon Fodder was to guide your soldiers through various scenarios, killing enemies as you go.

Advertisement

With fun gameplay and a tagline of "War's never been so much fun", you'd be forgiven for thinking Cannon Fodder was an overly comic portrayal of war.

Far from it.

The genius part of Cannon Fodder was the anti-war message that lay beneath all the sprites. Each of your men had a name, and if any of them died during a mission, a roll call of those that were lost in service appears on-screen.

If that didn't make you feel bad enough, a new gravestone would appear after their death on the green hill landscape of the pre-mission menu screen. Each gravestone blots out the green further, and this is juxtaposed with an endless queue of new recruits; all waiting to take the recently departed soldier's place on the battlefield.

These days, video game war is played out in hyper-realistic graphics and multiplayer death matches. But no war game has ever managed to be as subversive, and as poignant, about the horrors of war than Cannon Fodder.

7. The Banner Saga

The Banner Saga is a turn-based tactical RPG, that puts you in charge of a band of warriors and civilians. In it, you have to make a series of Oregon Trail type decisions for the group that you lead.

Advertisement

Do you help that shifty looking fellow you meet on the road, or steal his food and run off? Every choice is important as food levels, morale, and lives, are at stake.

Your decisions in The Banner Saga form the emotional crux of the whole game. Every choice might be made based on your own morality, or lack thereof, but you can never foresee some of the unexpected outcomes that come after you've made them.

You see, The Banner Saga has a sadistic Game of Thrones style willingness to kill off characters without even batting an eyelid. Within seconds of making a certain decision, you might be casually informed that your choice has resulted in the death of one of your favourite team members. And it's this matter-of-fact approach to fatalities of main characters, that makes The Banner Saga such an unforgiving, emotional brute of a game.

6. Papers, Please

Papers, Please uniquely puts you in the role of a passport immigration officer, working at a border of a fictional war-torn European Bloc state called Arstotzka. Residents are desperate to cross the border out of Arstotzka, but only certain people who meet the state government criteria are allowed through.

Advertisement

You must enforce these rules in order to get paid for your work. Fail, and your family starves to death.

Because yes, Papers, Please really is that dark.

Lucas Pope

The game then plays out like a Tetris puzzler, as you have to quickly evaluate the case of each citizen at the border and decide if they're allowed to cross. But these aren't geometric shapes, they're people, and their individual stories become more apparent as you progress through the game. You come to realise that the game unfairly rewards bureaucracy and paperwork over the lives of these people, and that's a heart-breaking revelation.

Papers, Please is not far away from being a Milgram experiment. It's a game where your empathy gets beaten down by an authoritarian figure, and their unflinching insistence to complete endless tasks for them.

5. Undertale

On the surface, Undertale seems to be a game that's no more than a cheeky, RPG in-joke. But beneath the surface, you'll find a beating heart there, one that fills you with emotional determination.

Advertisement

You play as an unnamed child, who falls beneath the Earth into an underground world filled with monsters. With distinctly 8-bit aesthetics and sounds, you're lured into thinking Undertale is just standard RPG fare. These thoughts are dispelled though when you start "fighting" the monsters.

The battle mechanics of Undertale are not made immediately obvious. You have an option to attack the monsters you face, but you also have options to strike up conversations with them too. Experienced RPG players will likely go sword in hand and take the offensive, because that's what years of playing these games have taught them. There's another way though, and for every monster there's a unique pattern to beat them with non-violent outcomes.

The monsters in Undertale are not faceless foes, they're characters with feelings, and you can complete the game without killing any of them.

Undertale is ultimately a tale of compassion, and rewards your blood-free kindness in the game with a happy, pacifist ending. Aww.

4. The Last Of Us

The Last of Us is a horror game, but the fear in it isn't just borne from the Lovecraftian mutant humans hunting you down - it's also the fear of losing someone close to you.

Advertisement

Naughty Dog's game focuses on the central dynamic between its two main characters, Joel and Ellie. Poor old Joel has the emotional baggage of losing his daughter years before, and sees Ellie almost as a surrogate for her. But his desire to protect Ellie at all costs is extremely problematic for the rest of the world.

With Ellie potentially being a cure for the mutant disease, she's willing to sacrifice her own life in order for an antidote to be created. Joel knowingly destroys that chance of a cure but worse than that, he bold-faced lies to Ellie about it.

The whole mess is affecting for the player because The Last of Us isn't a Telltale game, and you can't change Joel's decisions. You have to play on as he makes his choices, despite your reservations.

The Last of Us never lets Joel off the hook though, and with the upcoming sequel, you know that things can only get worse for his and Ellie's now fractured relationship.

3. Final Fantasy VII

There are 3 stages brought on by Final Fantasy games:

Advertisement

1. Denial - refusal to believe that any of these fantasies are "final", as they're now up to part 15.

2. Bargaining - you can have all my gil, just let me reach the next destination without facing another random battle with a Flan.

3. Despair - Aeris isn't coming back, is she?

Final Fantasy VII was the blockbuster baby of the Final Fantasy series. With an enticing movie-like trailer, it was clear this entry was intent on creating a cinematic, more dramatic, experience for the player. And nothing is more dramatic than the death of a main character.

Aeris was set up as the potential love interest for Cloud, your impossibly-haired playable hero. But she was no more than a sacrificial lamb halfway through, as you stared in adolescent shock when Sephiroth cuts her down in cold blood.

Permanent deaths in video games, especially in the FF series, were not rare. But few delivered such an emotional impact on the player as the tragic passing of Aeris did.

2. The Last Guardian

Trico, the fictional creature from The Last Guardian, is the ultimate video game pet. A cross between a giant dog, a giant wombat, and a bird (seriously, do not try this cross-breeding at home), he's an absurdly gorgeous creation. Team Ico have previous form in designing such intricate beasts, but with Trico they've surpassed themselves.

Advertisement

Your adventures with Trico are about guiding him through dangerous situations and environmental puzzles. And while the gameplay isn't always on point - frustrating camera angles and controls are the biggest bug-bears - the relationship between a boy and his beast successfully elevates the game into something quite special.

Like a real pet, you can't help to form an emotional attachment to Trico. You'd have to have the heart of one of the stone soldiers in the game not to. And in the end, when you're forced to send him away from your village to protect his life, it's positively heart-wrenching.

Much like the loss of any childhood pet, you can't help to blub like a baby as the end credits roll.

1. Football Manager

The standard criticism often leveled at Football Manager is that it's nothing more than playing an Excel spreadsheet. But can an Excel spreadsheet keep you up at night, worrying about its formulas? And can it make you pretend you're being interviewed by the host of Spreadsheet of the Day? If it did, maybe you should start re-examining your life.

Advertisement

Football Manager is more than a spreadsheet. It's a management simulation on the surface, but dig deeper, and it's a long-form football RPG. Dig even deeper, and it could even be a potential life simulator. It all depends on how deep the player wants to go with it, and many FM players will go miles underground and end up meeting mole-people.

Such player immersion into FM even has real-world emotional benefits. Take the story of Johnny Sharples, whose obsession with a fictional footballer from his FM game called Ivica Strok, ultimately helped him come to terms with the suicide of his brother.

Strok has even gone on to become a real ambassador for CALM, using FM to help men talk more openly about depression and mental health issues.

Now tell me, can any Excel spreadsheet manage emotions like that?

Advertisement