Well it's arrived, another Assassin's Creed - and yet again it's a bubble-burster of expectation versus reality as Ubisoft continue to spout the same canned rhetoric about this being "An entirely new Assassin's Creed" or how "It'll really change the way you play" all over again. There's even a moment where a member of the creative team is showing new main-man Jacob riding in a carriage, only to remarking that you can use these as portable haystack-style hiding spots - or to run people over - to which he states "The possibilities are endless". Well no, actually, they're not. You can ride on the carriage, hide in it or kill dudes. Done. It's hardly some revolutionary gameplay mechanic set to 'change how you approach any given mission' is it? Especially when said mission shown off in the first gameplay reveal is more of the same 'clear out this group of guards'-type fodder.Honestly, the fact that Ubisoft refuse to acknowledge they're ruining such a once-fantastic franchise is maddening - despite everything available proving their self-appointed yearly release schedule is crippling the end product. Now with Syndicate we have another game that looks to be an exact replicate of what's gone beforehand, with the development team touting things like a 'new combat system' even though we can see it plays exactly the same. This year remains the one where Ubisoft really need to prove to the fans they have something special to show off in the coming months, as if this is their opening gambit, it's worrying at best.
8. Repetitive And Badly Animated Melee Attacks
Yay, hand-to-hand fighting is back - but even within the 10 minute demo interspersed with two or three fist-fights, the same animations played out multiple times. It feels like the one where Jacob 'rakes' his opponents face (perhaps a badly-animated eye-gouge?) is already wearing thin, and that's not to mention the general lack of polish that appears when you're in combat. Come the point where Frye recruits a random assassin for help, the latter's seen firing a gun into the abyss as it fails to connect with Jacob's opponent, all the while the player is trying desperately to land some punches as their opponent flails around hilariously. Thanks to Ubisoft pushing to get this one out the door in such a short time, it's continually resulting in the most integral parts of the games not being laboured over enough to polish over the cracks. At least this time it looks as though sound effects are landing on time with their respective hits, but in terms of making anything look weighty or feel impactful because of it, this is by far just more of the same.
7. Yet.More.Chase Missions.
One of the things that immediately personified Assassin's Creed all those years ago - as well as prompting many to look forward to trying one themselves - were the high-octane chase missions, first demonstrated by Altair leaping deftly from atop a roof and slamming down on his quarry after a heated pursuit. For the last few games though - and especially AC III's godawful endgame chase - they've become necessary inclusions for the sake of the series' identity, being absolutely mind-numbing to play through. The gameplay literally amounts to holding forward on the stick and occasionally tapping a jump button to surmount something in your way - with the pre-assigned auto-animations doing the rest. Even if Ubisoft found a way to make these chases more fun, it'd be missing the point - regular purchasers of the series have had enough of this bog-standard game mode, and the fact it was shown again for Syndicate is only a sad indication of what's to come.
6. Shoddy Collision Detection
Speaking of the chase missions, they forever highlight something that's dogged the franchise since the beginning; terrible collision detection between character models and items in the world. In particular just looking at the new footage and the chase sequence within, there are multiple times where the carriage collides with rendered items - from other carriages to people and horses - all with the barest of impact, as the physics model governing what's happening on screen just isn't built to accommodate the gameplay. One of the largest and longest-running complaints about the series has always been the way characters 'rub up' against other things before awkwardly forcing past them like debris caught in a stream and breaking loose, and it's a real shame that this nothing has changed here whatsoever.
5. The City Looks Like A Re-Skin
Bet you didn't think Victorian England could look so similar to Revolution-era France, but here we are. For the most part the shop fronts and colour palette is different enough not to label this as too offensively copied and pasted, but at this stage in Ubisoft's overlapping development cycle, their world-building technique has to be reusing certain assets - something made more obvious when Jacob takes to the rooftops. In the previous teaser and leaked screens it looked as though we were going to get a heavily stylised black and gold aesthetic, thereby setting aside this iteration as something identifiable purely on a visual level. Instead, as soon as Frye gets above the hustle and bustle of the streets, it looks almost exactly the same as Unity, Black Flag's shanty towns or III's city areas.
4. General Animation Is Still Terrible
Fight animations are one thing, but even the traversal, general use of weapons and stealth attacks here look incredibly weak. There's a hilarious moment where Jacob sneaks up on someone (having dropped like a lead weight next to one of his partners), only to barely touch his neck and watch the person awkwardly tumble to the floor. There's still no weight or purpose to your manoeuvres, and the more Ubisoft's art team work their behinds off on what's got to be one of the most jaw-dropping and realistic graphics engines in the business - the more it highlights how archaic their animation is by comparison.
3. A Female 'Protagonist' - Where's Evie?
Well this is strange, as on May 11th a fresh rumour from Kotaku pertained to having a second playable character in sister of main character Jacob; Evie, appearing for around quarter of the campaign. Since then the official reveal had her nowhere to be seen outside a couple of cutscene appearances, with Ubisoft barely commenting on her involvement. Now, it's possible this could be something unveiled further down the line (most likely at E3), but as the general idea of brother and sister tackling the oppressive cultural context of Victorian England together is a brilliant one, Ubisoft really should've opened with it - especially if Evie's sections are anything to write home about. If we're going off rumours and the occasional writeup that delves into specificity, the Fryes do appear throughout the story together, with their own respective skill tree and missions - but for what little the developers do describe, Evie is resigned to a more advisory role than anything too hands-on. Plus, all these same rumours that 'confirm' her involvement mention she's only around for 25% of the campaign anyway. It's Jacob you'll be spending the most time with. It's very possible that her cutscenes (and playable sections) were some of the last things added to the game after the world had been built, and her inclusion (that's so far almost voiceless) only exists as a direct response to last year's controversy where an Ubi rep mentioned programming a female character would be too much work. Let's be honest, although the information available is touting her as a separate character, she'll 99% surely play and animate exactly the same as Jacob, making her nothing more than a skin-swap in-game.
2. 'Pre-Order Culture' Is Back In Abundance
Did you close the trailer after the action stopped, thereby missing the always-insulting "Pre-order now to get a bonus mission!" garbage? It includes Charles Darwin and Charles Dickens - confirming the first appearance of real-world figures from the time period, but asking you go off blind faith with your cash, plumping it down before barely a sniff of gameplay has been revealed. Not only that, but alongside the already-inflated $60 asking price, is a variety of additional pre-order bundles ranging from $90 to over $120 and beyond. What do you get for forking over such an abundance of cash? The extremely vague "Major expansion plus digital content & exclusives" apparently - although that's about as clear as a smoggy 1800's English skyline in itself. Ubisoft are making no bones about bleeding the series dry while they can, and when the first trailer touts such pricey offerings to get the 'full' experience, it's just insulting to the fans that supported the series for so long in the first place.
1. More Ridiculously Unbelievable 'Stealth'
https://youtu.be/hKR42Ci000k?t=208 3:28 on the above video: "I'll just take this guy out quietly..." "GAH!" *Continues to crouch-walk and stab people* Such is a regular day as an AC protagonist, and a particular instance of immersion-breaking gameplay in the reveal demo, as the commentator notes the need to silently dispatch a watching sentry only for him to scream out... and the other nearby A.I. patrol be none-the-wiser. Even the pedestrian who appears and remarks on the corpse notes "Well that doesn't look entirely honest" in some weird way that's assumedly supposed to be funny, but following this footage that statement could be applied to Syndicate itself. Fans will know these setups to be standard fare from the other games, but seven main sequels in it's simply unacceptable to continue trying to label this a 'stealth' game where the mechanics at play are completely broken. It's especially egregious when you can tell the most essential parts of the experience are being glossed over to crank another instalment out, barely refining the necessary elements that would make this a truly great game and simply demanding cash in return. How have you found the reveal of AC: Syndicate to be so far? Let us know in the comments!