Batman: Arkham Insurgency - 11 Things It Must Learn From Asylum

Will anything ever top that 2009 original?

By Scott Tailford /

Warner Bros.

Has it been long enough for Warner Bros. to come back with another Arkham game?

Advertisement

They certainly seem to think so, as a giant Reddit leak from a disgruntled employee revealed the working title for the next instalment as 'Arkham Insurgency'; apparently being another prequel tale focused on a Blackgate and Arkham breakout, where Joker is once again pulling the strings. It's reportedly open-world, though combat will feature a ton of interactions between Batman and Robin, the story showing how the pair became such a formidable fighting force.

Looking over the past four games, you'd be hard-pressed to say Rocksteady or Warner Bros. Montreal have ever created a sequel that topped the former's immaculate first instalment. Arkham Asylum blew the doors clean off the idea that superhero games could never be truly great, rolling together a legendary voice cast, innovative combat mechanics and some of the best graphics seen on the last generation of hardware.

Advertisement

Going forward, Rocksteady would pivot into an open-world structure, even adding the much-maligned Batmobile in Arkham Knight, though the question remains: Can any Arkham game post-Asylum - and post-Rocksteady - ever achieve the monumental heights of the original?

I say it can, if the developers know what to do...

Advertisement

11. No Story/Essential DLC

Rocksteady

One of the best things about the first Arkham by a mile, was that Rocksteady were yet to be forced into segmenting huge chunks of their game off into DLC by Warner Bros. The Arkham brand was an unknown, and as such, the only DLC we did get was multiplayer maps, the point being that they were completely, fundamentally optional to the enjoyment of the story.

Advertisement

Come Arkham City, it was controversy city; the substantial Catwoman chunk of the story being locked behind a paywall, as were a ton of additional costumes. That ideology was inflated even more for Arkham Origins and Knight, were suddenly every additional character was its own DLC pack or pre-order bonus. Costumes, Batmobile skins, Riddler Raceways - the only way to get the entire experience was to fork out twice or thrice the initial asking price, unless you waited and hoover them up at a discount.

Going forward - and this is highly unlikely being WB have tasted blood and liked it - we could do with a focused Batman experience that delivers all necessary and most enjoyable parts of its game in one package, only resorting to DLC for truly optional extras.

Advertisement

It'll never happen, but y'know, the DLC and microtransaction bubble has to burst eventually... right?

10. Combat Areas That Ramp Up In Complexity

Rocksteady

Mostly down to the fact we were being introduced to this combat system for the first time, Arkham Asylum goes from basic one-on-four starter rooms, to a Titan duel, gun-toting enemies, snipers and later, baton and knife-wielders.

Advertisement

The latter force you to unlearn how you've used the counter button previously, holding it until a specific point rather than jabbing it in-time with a screen prompt, yet this approach to combat wasn't carried forward. Once you'd mastered combat in Asylum, you were sorted for City, Origins and Knight. Yes, we got additional moves that could be factored in like Arkham Knight's environmental attacks, but nothing that fundamentally shook up how we fought.

Moreover, Arkham Asylum had this ramp-up in enemy numbers and tactics across its entire game-time, really letting you feel like you were getting deeper into the Asylum and Joker's goon-ranks, alongside learning how to fight like the Batman we'd watched and read about for years.

Advertisement

Give us a progression to what is easily one of the best third-person action combat systems of all time, not just an excuse to play the same way for the whole game.

9. Only Use The 'All In One Night' Setup If It Makes Sense

Rocksteady

A strange contrivance that even as you watched the relatively small amount of events take place in Arkham Asylum, felt like a bit of a reach. In the following open-world sequels it became downright farcical just how much Bruce could get done in one night, especially considering the amount of Most Wanted criminals you could round up as well as the main mission thread.

Advertisement

For Insurgency, we need a story that realistically takes place across however many days feel necessary. It's very rare that a Batman arc in the comics happens within 12 hours - say 8 til' 8 at a push - so why not discard this 'all in one night' framework? At the very least, write a concise, believable tale that makes contextual sense being packed into a single, frantic evening.

My assumption is Rocksteady liked the idea of Batman cleaning up the streets or minimising the damage while Gotham sleeps, but that just literally doesn't hold up when the games themselves can be 30, 40+ hours long.

Advertisement

8. An Effective Villain & Menacing Tone

Rocksteady

Before he was being crowbarred into unmasking reveals and sporadic memory fragments, Joker was actually an incredibly terrifying presence.

Advertisement

Mostly thanks to the audience and Batman forever being on the back foot as to his 'plan', the entire opening of Arkham Asylum is one for the ages. Firstly, the tone absolutely nails the dank, decrepit portrayal of Arkham as a building from Grant Morrison's A Serious House on Serious Earth, before mixing it with the characterful charm of the Animated Series, thanks to Mark Hamill and Kevin Conroy returning as Joker and Batman, respectively.

It's this combination of elements that allowed Arkham Asylum to present Joker as a truly terrifying character forever holding all the cards, yet one who's a joy to watch, purely because it reminds you of all those animated portrayals. All the villains we got after this were never given the same treatment, and it shows evermore in retrospect.

Advertisement

Arkham City forgot its entire marketing budget was setting up a Hugo Strange showdown after that first sequence, Origins admittedly delves deeper into Joker's mindset but it's more through one level than the whole feel of the game, and Arkham Knight's titular antagonist was a morose over-complainer. Even Scarecrow's most amount of screen time came at the end, where he's taken out in the final cutscene.

Nothing has come close to replicating the mood of entering Arkham Asylum and 'hanging out' with Joker as he's being escorted to his cell. Replaying it only hammers that home more.

Advertisement

7. Batman Being Outmatched (But Slowly Turning The Tide)

Rocksteady

Speaking of Joker, the key to writing him in a way that lives up to his regal nickname - he is a Clown PRINCE, after all - is to nail his unpredictability.

Advertisement

See, the reason both he and Batman work as oppositional constructs in an entertaining framework, is the audience should never be able to keep up with the whims of either. In Arkham Asylum, we don't know Joker's full plan and neither does Bats, but consequently, Joker doesn't know Batman has a hidden Batcave on Arkham Island, nor does Batman get remotely flustered dealing with the many things thrown his way.

Why? Because he's the World's Greatest Detective, and the player isn't.

Advertisement

It's these contrasting elements that lets the audience go along for the ride, allows Joker to be 'playful' and brutally violent, yet always keeps the audience on the right side of both characters.

In turn, we adore embodying Batman, methodically taking down the character of Joker in all his glory, not just ticking a final villain off a list, as was the case with Hugo Strange, Arkham Knight or Scarecrow.

Advertisement

6. Environmental Variation

Rocksteady

Think back on your memories of Arkham City, Origins and Knight - it's a lot of greys and browns, right? Perhaps the airship from Arkham Knight shook things up and injected some high-tech modernity?

Advertisement

The problem with taking a franchise open-world, is the player is then going to spend the majority of their time in said open world, minimising the directed 'levels' or sequences and letting them get lost in a sea of interconnected streets. I'm not saying that the latter Arkham games didn't have any variety - Mr. Freeze's chamber in City and Knight's Chinatown stand out, for example - but Arkham Asylum took us on a more guided trip through a far more varied series of levels.

Chances are you still remember entering Poison Ivy's overgrown wing of the Asylum, for example, or the menacing Killer Croc sewer tunnels. Again, this sense of variation is in direct opposition to letting the player free-roam around identikit environments, but look to the likes of Horizon Zero Dawn or The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. Those games' maps are very clearly segmented, giving a completely different vibe per quadrant as you go, but for the latter in particular, it all rolls together to form one gigantic 'level' in itself.

Advertisement

5. Use A Batmobile That's Actually A Batmobile

Rocksteady

The Batmobile is not a tank, okay, Rocksteady? We know you already understand this, because the first glimpses we got were those sick sequences in Arkham Asylum where Bats first beats up the thugs attacking his ride, then skewers Bane with the thing, sending them both into the brink.

Advertisement

Narratively, this then led to Bruce watching Christopher Nolan's biopic of himself and deciding to make a Bat-tank, only to keep calling it the Batmobile. Rocksteady would allow for the AA version to be playable again on some specific Raceways that appeared as Arkham Knight DLC, but aside from these two scenes in Arkham Asylum, that was all we got for the 'real' Batmobile.

It goes without saying that a sleeker Batmobile is the more iconic, and now we're even more years away from the Nolanverse as back in 2015 when Arkham Knight released, let's have Bruce make a version of the car that lines up with the character's more established iconography.

Advertisement

Even Telltale's Batman got it spot on.

4. Boss Placement & Variety

Rocksteady

Weirdly, despite them being a much talked-about feature in Asylum and things like the Mr. Freeze/Deathstroke fights in City and Origins being spectacular, Arkham Knight did away with boss fights for the majority, save for some truly terrible tank-based interactions in a sewer pipe.

Advertisement

Back to Asylum, and we had everything from figuring out how to take down a screen-sized Poison Ivy to dodging Bane's charges, stealthily avoiding Killer Croc, Scarecrow's nightmare, and well, Titan Joker... but at least they all came with what Arkham Knight completely missed - Variety.

And not just variations in their mechanics, but the pace at which you encounter them feels planned and perfected. Many new areas are ramp-ups of that individual's character, spread out and interacted with, before the final face-off tops off the section and you move on accordingly.

Advertisement

Contrasted against the sequels, what would be those levels were scattered around the map, interacted with and forgotten about, or - worse yet - ticked off a list like the Most Wanted missions, barely lasting more than a few minutes.

Batman's Rogues Gallery as a set of villains are some of the absolute finest in the history of comics, so make sure they're a constant part of the experience, forever reminding Bruce of his own various character traits.

Advertisement

3. Minimise Side Missions, Focus On Storytelling & Pacing

Rocksteady

Just because your game is advertised as - or eventually goes - 'open world', doesn't mean it has to do so within the first 10 minutes, or even for the majority of its time. As we're seeing with the genre slowly become the norm, developers like Platinum Games open something like NieR: Automata with a phenomenal, scripted sequence, then a hub-world series of conversations, then you're allowed to roam free and explore.

Advertisement

Persona 5 is another title that contains a number of linear gameplay sections, only to open up more and more as the game goes on. The Arkham sequels certainly attempted to pepper their open worlds with a number of defined 'levels', but there was no sense of escalation, overarching storytelling or deliberate pacing. You 'got round to them' whenever you liked.

What little open-ended areas Arkham Asylum did have - the whole game was free-roaming, after all - showed us that less is more. These connective parts in between the wings of the asylum itself were the perfect breathing room after any more directed segment. For Arkham Insurgency, it'd be fantastic to see WB design a campaign that goes from directed levels and storytelling, perhaps into larger areas and back again, before towards the back third of the entire game, then we unlock the full map.

Advertisement

It's high-time developers considered the pros and cons of "going open-world", and a franchise as narratively strong as Arkham really needs to up-end how we think about the genre.

2. ... But Have Reasonable Amount Of Riddler Trophies

Rocksteady

I'm going to put it out there that Arkham Asylum had the perfect amount of collectibles. So did Crackdown, as weirdly, both games had 240 components to hoover up across their runtime.

Advertisement

In Asylum's case, this revolved around everything from patient interview tapes to the Riddler Trophies themselves; the latter being strewn everywhere, requiring either a simple button press to collect, or a re-positioning of the camera to line up a shape between two objects.

In City, Origins and Knight, both Rocksteady and WB Montreal seemed to respond to the positive reception of these trophies by yelling, "OH, YOU WANT MORE?!", resulting in 250 separate trophies to find, and 315 riddles to solve, amongst other things.

Advertisement

Point being: Riddler trophies were far more palatable when the map and world size was smaller. We were far more likely to come across them, to spy a part of the 'question mark' symbol and wonder where the other half was - all round, they were enjoyable to seek out, and it felt somewhat natural to do so.

For Insurgency, WB Montreal need a straight-up less taxing number of collectibles to track down. Including almost 1000 separate checkbox requirements is intended to make people feel like they're getting their 'money's worth', but ultimately, a fraction of the populace actually bothered to see them through.

Advertisement

1. An Authentic, Heroic Batman

Rocksteady

I've already mentioned the duality of Bats' portrayal in an earlier point - the way we're marvelling at his forethought and abilities whilst simultaneously getting to control him - but there's another aspect to Arkham Asylum's Bat in contrast to the others: He felt far more authentic to the one on the page.

Advertisement

Calm, collected and always morally righteous, in Arkham City we see him randomly talk down to Robin and actively decide to chase after Talia al Ghul rather than save Gotham, and for Arkham Knight, he spends the majority of the game feeling sorry for himself, looking glum and staring at the floor.

Taken as one massive arc this almost works, but it's one thing to write a Batman story where he gets completely physically and mentally dominated (Court of Owls, for example), but another entirely to disregard his character, which must fundamentally be on the positive side of morality and good nature. Or at least, the audience can see he's trying to be so.

Advertisement

Playing as Batman in Arkham Asylum truly felt heroic, his stature being action figure-esque, his grey costume reminiscent of the old-school, and Kevin Conroy's voice performance assuring us everything will be okay, if we just go along for the ride.

I feel all of this was lost in the sequels, though being Insurgency is reportedly a prequel in itself, there's a chance we can return to a more forthright and well-meaning Bruce, rather than one who's the superheroic embodiment of being "Sick of this sh*t".

Advertisement