Batman: Arkham Insurgency - 9 Things It Must Learn From City
Remember when Batman games actually had great boss battles?
Perhaps because it's always sandwiched between the revered Arkham Asylum and the divisive Arkham Knight, Arkham City is often overlooked when discussions about Rocksteady's Batman franchise pop up.
It's a shame that the sequel doesn't receive the same recognition as the iconic first title, because even though it branched off into an entirely different direction, it still stayed true to the roots of what made the original game so special.
Landing somewhere between the contained design of the original Asylum and the expansive, free-form open world focus of the latest release, City was an experimental title in a lot of ways, and the upcoming Arkham Insurgency could learn a lot from both its successes and failures.
Because after Knight's misstep and without the franchise's main developer at the helm, WB needs to come out swinging with a refined Batman sequel if it wants to win back estranged players.
It'll take some self reflection on WB's part, but looking back at what the previous games did well and understanding where the cracks in the franchise began to show will be essential in making Arkham Insurgency the hero the fledgling franchise deserves, as well as the one it needs right now.
9. Don't Sideline Other Villains For The Joker
A mistake that all Arkham games have made so far, sidelining or undermining villains that are supposed to be major threats by constantly returning to the Joker only limits the creative freedom that comes with telling Batman stories.
Because although City told one of the best Joker stories in the Caped Crusader's history, it also attempted to centre the main thread on others like Hugo Strange and Two Face - the latter ending up being particularly shortchanged as a result.
If City had always been sold as a pure Joker story then it would have been fine, but up until its release the game was positioning itself as a Batman title that was going to dig deep into the superhero's rogues gallery, making it all the more disappointing when the main threat turned out to be the Clown Prince of Crime the whole time.
8. Keep The Combat Simple
Although it started off refreshingly simple, by the time Arkham Knight rolled around the franchise's combat system had bloated into a needlessly complex set of mechanics that all threatened to fall apart under the weight of each other.
But it didn't have to spiral as out of control as it did, as City's core brawling added just enough new to keep it feeling fresh and deep without overloading the player with options they'd never use.
Each new ability the game added served a purpose, and every one felt essential in making players the best crime fighters they could possibly be.
Moving forward, the developers of Arkham Insurgency need to go back to the roots of the combat system and remember what made it so revolutionary in the first place: its simplicity.
7. Don't Tease Other Superheroes And Not Make Them Playable
One of the most memorable parts of Arkham City was Tim Drake's cameo appearance. Because until Robin turned up in the sequel players had no idea that the character even existed in this version of Batman's universe, and his one scene suddenly opened up Rocksteady's world beyond the narrow view of just one superhero.
Unfortunately, the wonder of that initial reveal was quickly dashed when it turned out that his inclusion was mainly a way to promote him as a playable DLC character in the title's challenge rooms.
Even worse, other heroes like Nightwing were also released as playable characters outside of the main story, leaving fans wondering why they weren't included in the main campaign.
They were still fun to use, but in the future if the developers are going to take the time to create these unique superheroes then they should also make them a part of the title's story, rather than restricting them to extraneous modes.
6. Focus On One Major Antagonist
Similar to the franchise's problem of always returning to the Joker when it needed a main villain, Arkham City also suffered from packing too many different antagonists into its main story.
Instead of focusing on either Hugo Strange or the Joker, the game attempted to make them both equally important, while at the same time making players pursue other members of The Dark Knight's rogues gallery in missions that rarely contributed to the overarching narrative.
It's not a problem to have multiple different villains for Batman to fight, but when they're all pursuing their own motivations and goals it makes for a story that lacks a central focus. City attempted to merge these divergent plot points together into a satisfying whole, but it wasn't an effective synergy.
If Arkham Insurgency is going to once again be packed with villains then it needs to create a connective through line between their stories that keeps the main antagonist in focus for the whole game, otherwise it's going to fail at creating a credible threat for Batman to battle.
5. Don't Find An Excuse For The City To Be Deserted
Despite being a superhero, Batman was rarely ever seen actually saving people in the Arkham trilogy. Because of the way the games were structured, with civilians always being conveniently evacuated, it meant that players never had to worry about hapless bystanders getting in the way of their crime fighting.
But it was the second title's excuse to lock Bats in with a city full of thugs that felt the most contrived. Sectioning off a part of Gotham to become an expanded Akrham Asylum, it didn't quite make sense in the world of the game for all of the people living there to be relocated or missing.
Going forward, there's no doubt that the developers will once again be putting Gotham City in danger, but this time they should let the players see what happens when civilians get caught in the middle of superhero showdowns.
Batman needs to feel like an actual superhero rather someone who just gets off on breaking the ribs of criminals, and having him interact with innocent bystanders could be a way of achieving that.
4. Truly Brilliant Boss Battles
The Arkham series has always had a shaky relationship with boss battles, but City was by far the best they've ever been.
More imaginative than the lame tank fights in Knight and less repetitive than fighting constant hulking menaces in Aslyum, the second game in the series gave players the chance to face off against iconic villains from the superhero's rogues gallery in excellent themed boss battles.
Constantly switching up the flow of gameplay depending on who you were fighting, the Mr. Freeze stealth section has gone down as one of the most memorable parts of the entire franchise, while other imaginative sections like the Ra's al Ghul showdown were similarly effective.
With the other games it often felt as though the developers threw boss encounters into the mix simply because they thought they were obliged to, but City sticks out as the entry where the studio was clearly trying to focus on making the boss battles as good as they could be.
Whatever Insurgency turns out to be then, it should either return to the style of the second game's set-piece fights or just throw them away entirely.
3. Playable Villains Can Be An Amazing Way To Tell A Story
Although Knight was the first game to truly go all-in on creating multiple playable characters, City's implementation of a playable Catwoman did something much more interesting: let you see the game's story through the eyes of a villain.
Okay, so Catwoman isn't a straight-up baddie on the same level as the Joker or Two Face, but her morally ambiguous personality brought a freshness to the narrative and gave players a break from Batman's holier-than-thou quest for justice.
Batman is an interesting character, but his unwavering dedication to doing the right thing means that he's quite predictable. Playing as Catwoman in City on the other hand was always interesting, as even though you knew she would probably help Batman out in the end, you weren't ever sure what she'd do along the way.
Going into Insurgency the developers should take this idea even further and allow players to take control of the actual villains during certain sections, giving them the ability to add a bit more depth to the plot and explore the motivations of otherwise one-note bad guys.
2. Return To Distinctly-Themed Levels
If there was one element where Arkham City improved on the level design of Asylum, it was in the way it themed specific areas of the map around certain villains. Rather than having you fight through the same few blocks of Gotham, each area came with a distinguished theme that made the world feel vibrant, alive, and distinctly Batman.
Whether it was the Joker's funhouse or the horrific dreamscapes conjured up by Ra's al Ghul, there was always something different and interesting to see in City that most other open world games wouldn't even think about including.
Unfortunately, Knight moved away from this style of world design somewhat, perhaps coming as a cost of its expanded map. Insurgency would do well to go back to the specifically detailed areas that City executed so well though, and if that means scaling down the sandbox a little bit, then so be it.
1. Bring Back Paul Dini
Although Arkham Knight had a pretty decent story once you got over the terribly written mystery surrounding its title character, it was still a huge step back from the quality of the storytelling found in the previous releases.
Of course, a huge reason as to why the story of Rocksteady's final Batman game paled in comparison to both City and Asylum was that the developers decided to not bring back famed writer Paul Dini for it.
In charge of both the first two titles as well as countless other Batman stories, there's very few writers who know the Caped Crusader as well as Dini, and that deep knowledge and understanding of the character's world is present in every fibre of his writing.
Paul Dini's work on Arkham City gave the world not only one of the best video game Batman storylines ever, but one of the best Batman storylines period. And if WB wants to keep the narratives of its franchise interesting moving forward, then convincing the writer to return could be the best way to go about it.