Batman: Arkham Knight - 10 Things It Must Learn From Origins

Warner Bros. Montreal's take had far more going for it than you might think.

By Ewan Paterson /

Whilst the world eagerly awaits the release of Rocksteady's conclusion to their immaculate Arkham-Saga, there is much it can learn from the oft-criticised Arkham Origins. Despite its few shortcomings, developer Warner Bros. Montréal made a valiant effort in taking on a franchise many thought only belonged to Rocksteady, and crafted a game that actually outshone its predecessors in many key areas - not least of which in its amazing story and detective based gameplay sections. Like it or not, Rocksteady aren't perfect. Despite their two well received Batman releases there are still aspects of gameplay and story that the London-based devs have yet to perfect, and on top of a markedly poor marketing campaign for Arkham Knight worries of its potential flaws are only being amplified. This isn't to say that the only emotion to be met with the threequel's release is anxiety, as it's very clear Rocksteady have gone to great lengths to truly make it their Magnum Opus, but flaws should never be overlooked - especially when they're extremely easy to rectify and build upon. Despite building a reputation of being a flawless release, Arkham City did make a number of errors that prevent it from outshining the claustrophobic and semi-linear Arkham Asylum. Whilst there are certainly lessons Rocksteady can learn from their 2009 superhero début, taking a long look at what Origins did right (and wrong) is really what the developer needs. WB Montréal's prequel, though not perfect, is still a stellar title and a worthy addition to the compendium of Batman video-games released thus far - neglecting it would be a grave mistake to make.

Advertisement

10. Character-Driven Tales Work

If there's anything Rocksteady really need to improve upon, it's the way they tell a story. The few snippets we've seen of Knight's story haven't been particularly impressive, and whilst it's understandable that RS wish to remain tight-lipped when it comes to key plot details, dialogue so far has inspired anything but confidence. The script in Arkham Origins was penned by veteran writers Corey May, Dooma Wendshuch and Ryan Galletta, and it was undeniably the best the Arkham franchise has seen yet. Dialogue felt smooth, the narrative was coherent, and emotion ebbed from every line delivery. More importantly however, it really captured the early days of Bruce Wayne's vigilantism perfectly. In contrast, Arkham Knight's dialogue has gifted us with such gems as "Be careful," and "Do you really think Scarecrow's crazy enough to detonate a chemical weapon in Gotham?" On top of a plethora of already shakey lines being released accompanying screenshots, the recent 'Officer Down' demo only cemented the existence of such stinkers being present - Paul Dini's absence is certainly noticeable. Obviously it's too late to call for a script change, but Rocksteady really have a lot to do to make their narrative feel much more 'Long Halloween' than 'Dark Knight Strikes Again'. It'd be a pretty spectacular feat to ruin the threads left open by City's ending.

9. Batman Is Still A Detective

Never fully explored in the Rocksteady releases, it took WB Montréal to really explore Batman as he is - The World's Greatest Detective. Though not a truly magnificent addition to the Arkham-formula, the prequel's use of crime scene investigation techniques really helped cement the feeling as though the player was taking on the role of the Caped Crusader. In both Asylum and City, Detective Mode merely served as a 'follow the trail' mechanic in a non-combative role, and when used in stealth situations it easily became a crutch for players to lean on. Quite horrifically, some players even went through the entirety of Asylum with it always on - completely demeaning the vibrancy of Arkham Island's environment. WB Montréal didn't amend this problem either, but it's certainly something Rocksteady should be looking to fix. What we've seen from Knight so far has been largely combat focussed, and whilst it's fair to say many gamers are chomping at the bit to get behind the wheel of the Batmobile there is a massive danger that Rocksteady overlook the other areas in which Batman is truly made. The Dark Knight's detective aspect was already marginalised in the previous two Rocksteady entries, so it would be a massive shame to see the advances made by Montréal dismissed in the finale to the Arkham trilogy.

8. Fast Travel Is A Good Idea

With the advent of a larger area to explore, WB Montréal saw fit to introduce a fast travel measure to make sure gamers didn't get too bored with constant backtracking. As Arkham Knight's open world is meant to be five times the size of Arkham City's, fast travel is probably a good idea. Though zipping through the streets in the Batmobile will undoubtedly be fun, sometimes it's a good idea to cut out the travel time and get stuck into the middle of the action right away. No doubt people will want to marvel at the beauty of Rocksteady's latest iteration of Gotham, but a fast travel feature should really be essential on the current generation of platforms.

7. Don't Overdo Pre-Order DLC

Whilst ever present in the Arkham prequel, pre-order DLC was nowhere near as prevalent as it has been in City and Knight. Bordering on the grotesque, the amount of pre-order content accompanying Knight's release is just plain wrong. Graphic Novels, Steelbooks, Challenge Maps, Character Skins, Playable Characters, and even Batmobile Skins are being brought forward ahead of Knight's June release. Origins' pre-order content looks minute in comparison, with a far smaller amount of skins and maps forming a part of the release than in Knight. This sort of thing may be in the hands of the publishers and not the developers, but enough is enough - take the amount of pre-order bonuses down a notch.

6. Have A Good Voice Cast

If there was anything fans were worried about prior to Origins' release, it was the change in voice actors. To focus on Batman's earlier days, WB Montréal decided to recast the roles of Batman and Joker, gifting us with the now much revered performances of Roger Craig Smith and Troy Baker respectively. All other cast members put in admirable performances as some of Batman's most iconic characters, and even Robert Costanzo reprised his role of Harvey Bullock from Batman: The Animated Series - a much loved character from a show universally adored by legions of bat-fans across the globe. Without jumping to conclusions about the acting ability of Knight's cast, there are some notable flaws in the line delivery that has been released so far. Though utterly legendary, some of Kevin Conroy's lines in the recent gameplay demo were less than exemplary, with some just coming off as being overly stiff and wooden. Unable to avoid stepping on the toes of many a Breaking Bad fan, Rocksteady's decision to recast Gordon has been a poor one, with the weary commissioner now sounding completely disinterested from the events taking place in the city. Combined with some awkward writing, Knight's cast could either make or break its ability to convey a truly epic Batman tale - something Origins did with great ease.

5. Don't Ignore The Supporting Cast

A key element of WB Montréal's prequel was the emphasis on how Batman forged the relationships that came to define him as a character. Indeed, Bruce Wayne's supporting cast defines him just as much as his pointy-eared cowl does. Origins portrayed a strong emotional arc between Bruce and his loyal butler, Alfred, and even showed the transition of Batman's tumultuous relationship with the GCPD to one much more amiable in nature. The game's plot didn't necessarily cover all the bases, but it established the origins of Arkham brilliantly. In both of Rocksteady's games so far we have seen Batman's supporting cast in a very limited aspect, with Oracle and Jim Gordon bearing the brunt of attention in Asylum and City. Alfred's companionship was sadly cut short in City, and the Commissioner was almost non-existent in the game's storyline as well. Robin had a brief cameo, but he wasn't really given anything to do until the Harley Quinn's Revenge DLC - it is therefore essential that Rocksteady aim to do justice to Batman's supporting cast this time around. Batman would be nothing without his allies - they form a part of his rich and colourful history, and whilst the more solitary of tales have worked to writers' strengths in the past, a supporting cast really is a must-have for a game as expansive as Arkham Knight.

4. Don't Make Cuts Noticeable

A clear problem with Origins' rushed release - cuts are never pleasant to notice. A number of elements within Origins were unfortunately axed before it hit shelves in October 2013. The running train from the E3 demo is nowhere to be seen in the main game, and it's fairly clear that Montréal intended for Lady Shiva's side mission to be much larger in scope than it ended up being. City had some pretty obvious narrative cuts as well, with Batman's relationship with Talia never being as fully explored as it was intended to be. The lack of development between the two meant that the pivotal moment in which Batman actually had to choose between saving the city or saving her felt completely unnatural - deviating from Batman's personality rather strangely. Point is, it felt jarring to notice these omissions. Rocksteady are already known for their polish, but every developer is in danger of overstretching themselves in one way or another. Breaking immersion in such a way would be disastrous for Knight.

3. Boss Battles

Despite a stellar confrontation with Mr Freeze in Arkham City, boss battles in Rocksteady's two Arkham entries struggled to match the overall quality the series was known for. Origins on the other hand, gave a varied set of boss encounters that were both enjoyable and challenging. Though Mr Freeze's boss battle shows that Rocksteady are moving in the right direction, the fact that WB Montréal were able to create a good variety of bosses in their first Batman title shows that it's not a difficult goal to achieve. Arkham Knight can't rely on glorified 'Titan' thugs to pad out the good boss encounters there are, and a focus on 'Batmobile bosses' would be anything but beneficial to the Arkham formula. Rocksteady still have to master these key fights - taking a look at Origins would help make that learning experience much easier.

2. Don't Make So Many Riddler Trophies

When are collectables not fun to collect? When there are too many of them. Edward Nygma was at his best in Arkham City when he was challenging the wits of the player through a variety of means. Riddles and torturous hostage situations were an obvious highlight of the sequel, but there were a lot of flaws in striving for 100% completion. Some of the Riddler challenges in the game just weren't fun at all (lining up the question mark? Really?), and there were far too many trophies to search for. To make matters worse not only did Batman have to deal with these glowing monstrosities, but Catwoman also - meaning players had to backtrack into areas not traversed by Selina in the main storyline. Origins suffered as a result of there being a lack of Riddles to solve, but the 'datapacks' that Nygma emplored the Detective to find weren't nearly as intimidating in scale as City's trophies were. Collectibles are always welcomed, but there is a point where they become just a tad too much to bear.

1. Incorporate The Wider DC Universe

One of the most expansive and beloved universes in all of pop-culture, allusions to the wider DC Universe have been present in all Arkham games so far, but it was Origins that really put it front and centre in a storyline. Deathstroke - more famed for being a Teen Titans villain than a Batman one - was one of the eight assassins sent to kill Batman on Christmas Eve, and there were even multiple references to Oliver Queen's company Queen Industries. City made distinct references to Keystone and Metropolis too, but didn't build the universe in the way in which Origins did. With there being much speculation surrounding what Rocksteady will do after they depart the Arkham series, chances are fans are going to dissect each and every last hint towards the wider DCU in Knight in the hope that it provides a clue as to what their next project will be. A perfect way of giving fans a definitive answer would be to incorporate the DCU directly into Knight's story, very much akin to Origins' approach. Those Lexcorp signs have to indicate a certain someone's presence... Do you think Origins can offer a learning experience for Knight? Or do you think Rocksteady have it in the bag already? Sound off below!