Batman: Arkham Origins 2 - 10 Big Things It Can Fix From Knight

Warner Bros. Montréal have the skills, but what can they do to redeem the franchise?

By Ewan Paterson /

Well, the dust has finally settled. Rocksteady have now marked their departure from the Arkham series they made their name on with a game that, though great in many respects, failed to conclude the saga in a manner many had hoped for. Indeed, it's now safely nestled along with 2013's Arkham Origins as being among the most divisive releases in the franchise (though I've already reiterated many times why I think WBM's prequel doesn't deserve to be there). Hot on the heels of Knight's release, Warner Bros. Games Montréal posted a listing on their site for positions available to tackle an open world title on the current-gen, and even more recently than that a new video posted by the developers seemed to open up the possibility of a second game being in existence - showing that the company is expanding quite rapidly. The most likely choices for these two games will come as no surprise to fans who have been keeping up with every piece of Arkham info following Knight's conclusion, but considering the supposed 'leaked' Superman screens and the way the original Arkham Origins ended, it's almost a given that these two projects will be centred around the two most prolific denizens of DC. For those who can't get enough Batman (myself, guilty as charged), the prospect of a WBGM return to the character is an extremely exciting one - not least of which for those who found themselves reminiscing over the franchise's early days when they clocked their first disappointing playthrough of AK. There's already so much the developer can do to take the series to a whole new level, but it will mean nothing if they can't correct the mistakes their predecessors made in their final outing.

10. The Batmobile

What better way to start the list than to dive straight into Knight's most detested feature? Of course, we all knew straight from the start that the Batmobile wasn't going to be anything near as what it was cracked up to be by Rocksteady, but that sure didn't stop us from hoping we'd be proven wrong. Though it's true that some were more than pleased with its inclusion in the franchise, most players were left irritated by the way it unbalanced the Arkham formula - an upset amplified evermore by the game's insistence that the player use it at every turn. There is a way to include the Batmobile in a manner that will please the majority however - a way which is far less intrusive on the game's experience than Knight's was. The main thing here would be to make the vehicle entirely optional for those who wish to use it, and also to get rid of that garish 'Battle Mode' ripped straight from High Moon's Cybertron games. If fan reaction is anything to go by it's pretty obvious fans don't want to 'be the Batmobile' - it's a tool, not a crutch. Give players the opportunity to truly invest in Batman's ride the way they want to and they will - just look at Asylum's Batmobile for inspiration though, as it was by far the coolest one in the series.

9. The Storyline

As a character driven tale Arkham Origins easily exceeds its Rocksteady counterparts. It was emotive, lacked the more convoluted and contrived elements of the other titles, and gifted us with some truly magnificent performances in the form of Troy Baker and Roger Craig Smith to name just a few. The developer's decision to set their gaze towards the Caped Crusader's formative years as Gotham's protector allowed the team to really develop not just Bruce's character, but that of his villains and allies as well. The game ended with a visit to Slade Wilson's cell on Blackgate by none other than Amanda Waller, and set up a sequel that will no doubt feature the Suicide Squad as DC looks to push the team further in all sorts of mediums. The problem with Knight's plot was that it lacked focus and direction. Whilst offering a fantastic reassessment of Jason Todd's character, the story failed to deliver impactful moments and was hindered by a poor script that delivered dull lines on an almost recurring basis - even managing to miss the point of Batman's character completely in its closing moments. These are easy things for WBGM to rectify, as Origins managed to convey the anger of Bruce's early years as the Bat really well. An Origins sequel could posses all the trappings of a wonderful Batman tale. Everything from Dick Grayson to Harvey Dent and more are open to the writers to explore - it's just lucky they have such a great universe to do it all in.

8. Those Awful Lines

Music numbers and certain cutscenes aside, Arkham Knight suffered massively from clichéd dialogue and poor line delivery. This had already become apparent in the numerous trailers and screenshots unveiled prior to Knight's big release in June, but the sheer scale of some of these flat notes really didn't display itself fully until players had booted up the game's story. There's one character in particular who bears the brunt of much of these jumbled sentences, and it's especially unfortunate that it was Jonathan Banks' tenure as Jim Gordon - a performance that could've been made so much better had the writing improved. At times Gordon feels as though he'd be more at home in some 80s cop drama trying to inspire John McClane as he climbs Nakatomi Tower, proclaiming with biblical admiration as he reiterates just how useless the GCPD is and how we have God to thank for Batman's presence on the streets. It's just tacky, especially for what's meant to be Rocksteady's swan song to all things Batman. Here's hoping Origins' sequel will lead to more heart in mouth moments like when Bane attacks the Bat Cave close to its closing act.

7. Side-Missions

To be fair on Rocksteady here, this wasn't something WBGM managed to do justice in AO either. What is frustrating however is the decline in quality fans were given for Knight's side missions, as previous plot threads from Arkham City were sent to die in glorified quick time events and AR Challenges. An Origins sequel should really endeavour to do something new and inventive with its side missions, or simply do away with them altogether if they can't give them ample development. There's plenty to choose from in the way of stories, with a continuation of the Lady Shiva League of Assassins thread perhaps being best poised for due attention in the next game. Maybe even a proper murder mystery and conspiracy plot could be introduced with the Mob trying to reassert control over a city they don't recognise anymore? You certainly don't have to look far to find inspiration for characters and stories that could be introduced, but the key thing here is to make them a worthwhile investment.

6. Joker Fatigue

Arkham Asylum was a fantastic battle of wits between The Dark Knight and his green-haired adversary, but at what point did Joker's presence become eye-roll worthy? Whilst a fitting end to the two's relationship, Arkham City was largely built up on the threat of Hugo Strange knowing who Batman's identity was - the antagonist then went on to form a measly part of the story, only reminding players of his presence with timely audio announcements regarding the mysterious Protocol 10. Half of the game is spent in the company of Joker, and though Origins more than suffered this too, both games benefited from his presence. Arkham Knight however? Maybe not as much. Don't get me wrong, Knight actually had some truly great moments between the pair, with the psychological climax at the end really forming a part of what I'd consider to be a 'perfect' Batman moment, but his overbearing presence was just too much, and really helped to detract much of the emotional worth many of Knight's key plot points aimed to deliver. The Joker is a fascinating character when deployed effectively, but his presence has become so fatiguous that any significant role in a future Arkham story can only be detrimental to its quality.

5. Focus On The True Dynamic Duo

By far one of the biggest highlights of Arkham Knight's narrative were the small segments in which Bruce and his former ward Dick Grayson teamed up to take down Penguin. The writing and voice acting on display were top notch and easily stood out when compared to the game's other Most Wanted missions - it's definitely something WBGM would have to be mad not to explore, as witnessing the past tension between the characters fester through sequels would really enrich the series. It's something that could be done well in the Arkhamverse's light, and would do much to prove to all the nay-sayers and detractors of the Robins that they do fit in rather well with Batman's self proclaimed war on crime. To go one step further, taking inspiration from the well received 'Dark Victory' story arc would easily make Grayson's Origins a treat to see in an Arkham game. After Knight so badly mistreated Bruce's allies, focussing on the likes of Barbara and Dick would be the perfect thing to really enshrine their worth in the lore.

4. Lazy Boss Fights

After showing how challenging and inventive boss fights could be with Mr Freeze in Arkham City, Rocksteady just went and pulled a complete U-Turn and thought "hmmm, how can we best re-skin this?" It was especially poor considering WBGM threw down the gauntlet fairly spectacularly with their numerous bosses in Origins, but what we saw in Knight were basically glorified drone battles and predator encounters - not particularly great all things considered. Any Origins sequel really has the potential to make boss encounters really challenging and dramatic again, with a wide bevy of villains to choose from really adding variety to the story's proceedings. Of course not every boss can be a perfect encounter, but practically anything different would be an improvement over what we were offered in Arkham Knight.

3. Show The Importance Of Bruce Wayne

This was personally something I felt that Knight botched completely, and that was the relationship between Bruce Wayne and the cowl he hinds behind. Knight would have you believe that the character of Bruce is the true mask, and that Batman is who he really is. This is a gross misreading of the character, especially as Knight aims to glorify the moment in which Bruce fully succumbs to his role as vigilante protector, lacking even the decency to tell his most loyal allies what his true intentions were. This isn't to say that the psychological relationship between Bruce and Batman isn't mutually exclusive (as one most certainly forms more of the character than the other), but to disregard the more human elements of the character in favour of the more mythic ones is an error that dehumanises what should be a very relatable character. At his core Bruce may be a vengeful person, but he's also one that possesses great empathy and compassion. Omitting that from the Arkham series wouldn't be a good idea at all.

2. Introduce Another Hub In Wayne Manor

Arkham Origins took the first step in this regard, bringing fans a fully explorable Bat Cave complete with training room, computer, forensics lab and suit changer. It was a great little feature that helped break the pace of the story and let players interact with Alfred, whose snarky quips were always a fun thing to witness. The next logical step would then be Wayne Manor, right? Well, this shouldn't be such an unfeasible request, with the series having already delivered two Wayne Manor environments in the form of challenge maps in Arkham City and a small roamable area in A Cold, Cold Heart. Instead of having the game take place over the course of one night again, allowing players to return to Wayne Manor would be a fantastic way to speed up time, discover Easter Eggs and even interact with other characters too. It definitely deserves the next gen treatment, and would be the perfect successor to Knight's GCPD building.

1. Make Things Semi-Linear Again

This last point may be a little controversial, but it's something that would put the potential sequel well on its way to becoming comparable with Rocksteady's earlier works. What was the one thing lacking in Arkham Knight's locales? Interiors. Throughout the game's entire course the only expansive interior locations are Panessa Studios, the Arkham Knight's headquarters and Stagg's airships - pretty much the rest of the game takes place in the city's streets and rooftops. This doesn't do much good in the way of atmosphere, something Arkham Asylum certainly possessed in great abundance. The location was jam packed with Easter eggs, environmental detail and claustrophobic tension, something the other titles have really struggled to emulate since. Without confining the sequel to merely one location, putting players down a more streamlined path is definitely called for. Origins' sequel would really benefit from having dynamic interiors that are as colourful as they are memorable, and that means the open world would have to suffer just a little bit, but let's face it - who's really that enthused about exploring a city evacuated again? They're running out of acceptable excuses at this point. C'mon WBGM, give The Carpenter and Broker some business. Really go wild with hideouts, traps and the sort - it'll only benefit the series in the long run. Are you at all excited at the idea of a WBGM sequel to Origins? Or would you rather they steer way clear from Batman? Be sure to let us know in the comments!