Batman: Arkham - Ranking EVERY Villain Worst To Best
The ultimate rundown of Rocksteady's rogues gallery.
Superhero games are historically quite quite hit-and-miss.
For every Spider-Man 2 there's a Superman 64; for every Megaman, a Mighty No. 9. But in the grand scheme of things, it would not be unfair to say that Rocksteady's critically acclaimed Batman: Arkham series, despite the odd low point, is the absolute zenith of superhero gaming experiences.
2009's Batman: Arkham Asylum took the world by storm, lauded for its haunting atmosphere, innovative approaches to both combat and stealth gameplay, and, in no small part, some of the best depictions of Batman's classic villains outside of the comics.
This trend continued in the series' following three instalments, with many of the voice cast reprising their roles from the beloved Batman: The Animated Series. It wouldn't be a stretch to say that, had the portrayals of Gotham's rogues fallen completely flat, the games would never have enjoyed the success and notoriety that they did.
Over four sprawling open world games, the Dark Knight has seen more than his fair share of adversaries. From Asylum to City to Origins to Knight, dozens have tried to take down the Bat, and each and every one of them was halted by the righteous blow of the hammers of justice.
Strap yourselves in, then, for here are all of Batman's significant Arkham series villains ranked from worst to best.
40. Electrocutioner
Those who've played the oft-neglected prequel in the quadrilogy, Arkham Origins, will know exactly why this glorified nightclub bouncer places where he does on this list.
One of eight assassins who answer the call of Black Mask's $50,000,000 bounty on Batman, Lester Buchinsky, a simple-minded brute set apart from the common thug only by his electrically charged gloves, takes on the caped crusader aboard Penguin's ship, The Final Offer.
And it goes exactly how you'd expect - he goes down in one spiky-gauntleted punch.
While it's funny to see the stage set for a boss fight only for it to be over in the blink of an eye, you have to wonder what Electrocutioner was thinking even bothering to show up that night. The other villains have no time for him either - so little so that the Joker ends up kicking him out of a window to his death.
On the plus side, Batman then salvages the shock gloves off his corpse, so everyone's happy.
39. Catwoman
Now, I'm not contesting the fact that Catwoman is an excellent character within the Arkham universe. But as far as being an actual villain goes, she's certainly less of a threat to Batman as she is simply a recurring annoyance.
Selina Kyle makes her debut in Arkham City, putting her cat burglar skills to use immediately as a playable character. Her feud with Two-Face accounts for most of her story arc, although she does cross paths with Batman at one or two convenient points in the game.
Arkham Knight, meanwhile, has Catwoman confined to a single building for the whole game, kidnapped by the Riddler and forced to take part in his lethal puzzles. She rarely has the chance to indulge her jewel thieving habits here, despite being playable once again.
In this series, at least, her most villainous acts seem to be taken against other villains. Can she really be blamed for destroying Riddler's robot factory and robbing him blind after what he put her through?
38. Alberto Falcone
The son of crime lord Carmine Falcone and part of the Falcone Crime Family, Alberto seems to fancy himself the head of the organisation when his father retires. Only problem is: he's kind of a psycho.
Though he denies it, sessions with Doctors Hugo Strange and Harleen Quinzel imply him to have dissociative identity disorder, and his 'Holiday Killer' persona that makes an appearance in 'The Long Halloween' (set after Origins) is later referenced in Batman: Arkham Knight.
Alberto only has one scene in Arkham Origins, kidnapped by Penguin in an attempt to compromise Carmine's business. After Batman shows up and is pulled straight into a heated battle with Deathstroke, the unstable Falcone boy is never seen or heard from again.
37. Solomon Grundy
He was born on a Monday, christened on Tuesday, married on Wednesday...and killed on whatever day you happened to be playing the game.
Cursed with an eternal seven-day cycle of birth, death and burial, Cyrus Gold is over a hundred years old, and kept as a kind of pet in the basement of the Penguin's nightclub, The Iceberg Lounge. Batman, poisoned by the Joker, seeks Penguin out in search of a cure, and in doing so is lured right into Solomon Grundy's lair.
As boss fights in the Arkham series go, this is arguably one of the better ones. His fiery chains can pick off an unprepared player in just a few swings, and Batman's quickfire gadget mechanics, new for Arkham City, really prove their worth here.
But aside from that, there's really not much else to him. His only smidgeon of cognisance is in reciting the 'Solomon Grundy' rhyme over and over again. Batman can even get away with killing him and keep his one rule intact, as the hulking zombie eventually just comes back to life.
36. Starro
A truly unsettling entry, and likely one that many players - myself included - didn't know about until a walkthrough showed them where to go.
Starro is the easter egg to end all easter eggs in the Arkham Knight prequel DLC, A Matter of Family. As Batgirl, the player is free to explore an already-creepy-enough abandoned theme park in the middle of the ocean. There are several strange posters around the place, promoting a freak show that features a mindless man with a one-eyed starfish stuck to his face.
Then you enter an incredibly hard-to-see grate to find the one behind this strange being. Starro himself, the mind-controlling alien and the first to take on the Justice League, is housed in a darkened room, pressed up against a cylindrical glass tank and watching closely.
He doesn't do anything...except stare. And stare. And stare. You have to wonder how they even got him in the tank in the first place.
35. Anarky
Batman sure didn't get many of the good villains in his early days. Dangerous though they may have been, even planting bombs around Gotham City isn't a guarantee of a memorable tenure under the Dark Knight's radar.
As his name suggests, Anarky, aka Lonnie Machin, tries to make a name for himself as the voice of the people in Arkham Origins. Anti-government, anti-establishment and seemingly anti-everything else, he rallies followers from Gotham's poorest areas for protests, graffitiing and general non-conformist debauchery. You just know his bedroom's full of Nirvana posters.
But he doesn't stop there, no. Anarky is totally prepared to resort to terrorism in order to make himself heard. And that's when he gets Batman's attention.
Machin lures Batman to the Solomon Wayne courthouse, where, predictably, his ego takes quite a literal beatdown. He's then revealed to just be a teenager, which somehow makes us take him even less seriously. It's doubtful his lackeys would've stuck around if they knew their leader was nothing more than a pent-up kid in an unflattering jacket.
34. Talia Al Ghul
Like Catwoman, Talia al Ghul isn't exactly a villain in the traditional sense. She does seem to genuinely care about Batman - but at the same time, she knows his secret identity, and as the daughter of the demon, she could sure do some damage with that knowledge if she wanted to.
She appears in Batman: Arkham City, in the League of Assassins' secret base of Wonder City. Overseeing Batman's trials along with her father, Ra's, Talia expresses disappointment when her former lover refuses to become the new Demon's Head.
Later, she fools the Joker into thinking she can offer him immortality, activating a tracker so Batman can follow them to the Monarch Theatre. When Joker is revealed to be an imposter, however, Talia is suddenly shot by the real Joker from a balcony, dying quickly in Batman's arms.
Arkham Knight shows her sword on display in the GCPD evidence room, demonstrating her legacy in the eyes of the law. But Bruce, as his guilt clearly shows, could never remember Talia al Ghul as a true force of evil.
33. Hammer And Sickle
The Abramovici brothers, known as Hammer and Sickle for their respective weapons of choice, were once conjoined twins, but were separated at the arm by the Joker and brought to Gotham to work as his henchmen.
Batman first encounters Mr. Hammer at the Joker's hideout, the abandoned Sionis Steel Mill. He appears as little more than an abnormally large one-armed minion, but when his brother, Sickle, later shows up as one of Penguin's goons, you get the sense that there's more to them than it seem.
Not much more, mind you, but still, it really adds to Joker's cruelty seeing what they have become under his ownership. What's more, a hidden late-game scene shows the two brothers sitting stump-to-stump and expressing their mutual desire to be rejoined. Quite a bittersweet little end to their otherwise one-dimensional story.
32. Nyssa Raatko
With Talia dead and Ra's on his last legs - for real this time - it's not surprising that the other daughter of the Demon would show up to try and sort things out.
The return of Ra's al Ghul in Arkham Knight's Season of Infamy expansion sees Nyssa leading a rival faction against those loyal to him, trying to prevent him from accessing the Lazarus Pit and regaining his strength. She offers Batman a choice: to side with her and prevent Ra's from rising again, or to help Ra's and face the consequences.
If you choose to accept Nyssa's offer, Batman destroys the Lazarus Pit, and convinces Nyssa to let her father die naturally, despite her wish to kill him herself. But if you give Ra's the Lazarus, he swiftly kills his daughter and disappears in a cloud of smoke.
Though highly dangerous and volatile, Nyssa is not really evil. Allowing Ra's to die results in her promising to disband the League, after which she and her followers leave Gotham, never to return.
31. Deacon Blackfire
The people of Gotham seem to be rather an impressionable sort, at least within the criminal underworld. And with flocks of aimless people looking for an answer comes an opportunist with the cunning and charisma to indoctrinate them all into his evil cause.
Joseph Blackfire is one such person, using religious ideology to brainwash Gotham City's homeless and underprivileged into crazed, homicidal zealots. His cult capture the investigative reporter, Jack Ryder, and Deacon Blackfire prepares to sacrifice him on an altar before Batman shows up to take care of his horde of followers.
Even when locked up in a GCPD holding cell, Blackfire continues to proselytise like a mad preacher, claiming to be over a hundred years old and knowing the secret to immortality. So convincing are his words that you even start to believe them yourself - but then, with mentions of his name all the way back to the 1920s, could he actually be telling the truth?