Battlefield V Review: 7 Ups & 4 Downs
EA's latest shooter isn't the disaster you've been led to believe it is.
After a tumultuous year mired in controversy, backlash and community discontent, Battlefield V has finally scraped onto shelves. However, all of the discussions and questions surrounding the game pre-launch have obfuscated the most important one: is it actually any good?
Though it's been reductively dubbed as "Battlefield 1.5" by some fans, DICE have made some pretty monumental changes to the classic multiplayer formula, opting for more "immersive" gameplay and a new attrition system. This is all alongside doubling down on their single-player War Stories as well, in an era where most big-budget shooters are dropping campaigns altogether.
The game had big boots to fill, and an uphill battle to fight, but these alterations and additions - along with the expansive Grand Operations mode - have made for one of the most ambitious releases the developers have ever produced. And with a roadmap planned into next year that's going to add a whole host of new content, it seems as though EA believes in the sequel's longevity.
While it all sounds great on paper, not everything works, and the final result has made for one of the most fascinating - and undoubtedly the most divisive - entries in the franchise yet.
Ups
7. Attrition Changes The Game Completely
As mentioned, the biggest change Battlefield V makes to the core experience is the idea of attrition. Unlike in previous games, players now spawn with a limited amount of ammo (two-to-three mags max, usually) and health that doesn't automatically regenerate.
Combined with an increased time-to-kill, which makes the lack of ammunition tolerable, the sequel is deadlier than ever, requiring more thoughtful approaches to combat than simply rushing objectives and firing blindly at enemies.
Though this system was a little rocky in the beta, it's fortunately fully-formed in the final release, and one of V's biggest strengths. It makes firefights more demanding, but it's also increased the skill ceiling. The simple act of knowing when to shoot or when to let that enemy in the distance scamper off adds an extra element of tactical thinking that's always been present in Battlefield, but which has been brought to the forefront here.
Aside from making each match more intense, though, it also puts the importance back on individual classes. The lack of regenerating health makes a medic's bandage spam welcome, while support a support class's ammo pouch can mean the difference between life or death.
6. Animation-Based Gameplay Is More Demanding, But Way More Immersive
One of the biggest aims of DICE going into the sequel was to try and make gameplay as immersive as possible, taking away or altering a lot of the "gamey" crutches players relied on in the previous title. This meant that 3D spotting was virtually thrown out entirely, with players no longer being able to rely on the little red marker above enemies and force them instead to track them with their own eyes.
Likewise, the devs have also put the focus on animation-based gameplay that keeps you in the moment. While that means you have more freedom over your movement and the chance of being knocked off your feet by an incoming explosion, it also means that reviving people is now contextualised, and you have to enter an animation to bring people back from the brink.
This could have been a needlessly complex change from the simple stab-your-friend-to-bring-them-back-in-a-second approach from Battlefield 1, and it is certainly more obtuse and prone to get you shot, but it is a change that makes the game better overall.
Sure, it's not as quick as it used to be, but physically having to grab players writhing on the ground, look them in the eye while you heal them as bullets whizz past your head is exhilarating. As strange as it is to say, it makes you feel connected with the random people you're playing with, and enables a real sense of camaraderie between your team.
There'll no doubt be people who prefer the arcadey elements from previous instalments, but the new system is undeniably more immersive.
5. Maps Have Welcomed Verticality And Variety
Although there's sadly only eight of them at launch, most of the multiplayer maps are thankfully up to the Battlefield standard. Whilst the previous instalment seemingly made a few questionable moves towards flatter map design with few interiors and little in the way of verticality, V thankfully hasn't furthered that approach.
The very best of the bunch like Twisted Steel, whose central elevated bridge makes for intense back and forths, as each team wages a war of attrition across multiple levels of elevation, have the same balance of play that the series' very best levels boast. Moving from interiors to exteriors, long engagements to short, all the while needing to check above and below you, makes for matches that always play out differently, even if destruction sadly takes a larger backseat than ever before.
As a whole, it's not the series' greatest collection of levels - as the bottlenecks of Aerodrome or the repetition of bombed-out buildings in the urban areas can feel a little uninspired at times - but when you do get thrown into one of those great maps, they facilitate some of the most creative and jaw-dropping firefights franchise veterans will have ever played through.
4. No Random Loot Means Customisation Is More Personal
In order to claw back some goodwill after dropping the ball completely with the loot boxes and microtransactions of Star Wars: Battlefront 2, with Battlefield V EA have taken out random drops entirely, instead gating customisation behind Company Coin, a new form of currency that can be earned by completing challenges, assignments and levelling up.
While still not a perfect system, the fact that you aren't grinding to earn currency to spin a gambling machine and hoping you get something you want is admittedly a step in the right direction. There's still a wealth of personalisation to Battlefield V, whether its the camouflage painted on weapons, new outfits for your character or new looks for vehicles, but now you can actually straight up unlock whatever you want with the in-game points.
Sure, you still have to grind a little to make sure you have enough currency (some of the face paints in particular are weirdly expensive considering they're just a coloured smudge), but being able to use the fruit of your hard work to tinker with your soldier has brought back a layer of personalisation that so many multiplayer shooters these days unfathomably lock off.
3. It Looks (And Sounds) Amazing
At this point, it should be a given that a new Battlefield game is going to look and sound amazing. DICE have done incredible things with the Frostbite engine, and once again delivered a version of WW2 that's hauntingly beautiful.
However, there have been a few changes from the previous game which keep things fresh. This time around there's far more colour, as apposed to the blood, metal and mud style of DICE's WW1. Likewise, there's far more variation in the terrain, with dense, bombed-out cities giving way to snowy mountaintops, colourful fields and dreary broken bridges.
Dynamic weather has also returned from Battlefield 1, which adds another unpredictable element to each match. Those mountaintops, for instance, might become shrouded in a snowstorm that makes spotting enemies difficult, promoting a more methodical style of play. Little flourishes like this keep engagements visually interesting, while the way your gun will become covered in mud as you crawl through dirt to the next objective continues to immerse you in these conflicts.
2. Class Changes Make Teamwork Even More Important
DICE have altered each class radically going into Battlefield V, leaving pretty much only the most broad conventions of each one intact. The medic still provides health and the assault still offers defence against vehicles, for instance, but the devs have made under-the-hood alterations that ultimately make teamwork even more imperative, and even more seamless.
The medic, for instance, now has a revive syringe by default, with that gadget slot replaced with a smoke grenade launcher. Consequently, their relatively weaker weapons are supported by this larger arsenal, allowing them to distract enemies by concealing friendlies in smoke while dishing out revives and the all-important bandages.
The attrition system also makes the support class more relevant, as a constant stream of ammo can mean the difference between walking into an objective armed only with a pistol, or a fully-stocked assault rifle and a pouch full of grenades.
However it's perhaps the recon class that's received the biggest boost, though. While the weapons and gadgets are mostly unchanged from the previous game, the fact that spotting is limited across the board makes their spotting scope, and that enemies are tagged after being shot with a sniper or suppressed, means they provide vital situational awareness for your team that no other class can.
Between these changes and the attrition system in general, teamwork is not only more important, but players are actually encouraged to help each other out without it feeling like a burden.
1. War Stories Play Better Than Ever
Though much of this list (and the focus of Battlefield V in general, may I add) has been on the multiplayer, War Stories have also returned from Battlefield 1, and they're pretty damn good. Though there's only three this time around, the stories of each feel more fleshed out and robust, with the same calibre of super-serious storytelling that defined the previous WW1 tales.
Thankfully, however, DICE have improved the gameplay portion of these single-player campaigns this time around. Previous incarnations were split up into pretty basic combat encounters that, without the overarching narrative, would have descended into tedium. Each level was always crafted around a single gameplay drive, which occasionally made the action feel a little jarring and disorientating, like it had been chopped up and pieced together from other content.
This time around, however, each level and gameplay section is thankfully more coherent and varied. No longer a string of set-pieces linked by a threadbare story, the narratives play out like a proper campaign. They're not perfect, and your mileage will vary in just how much you get out of their war-is-hell focus, but they are an improvement over those found in Battlefield 1.
Downs
4. It's Buggy As Hell
Though it's not quite Battlefield 4, DICE's latest game is one buggy mess, at least at launch. Though I've not discovered anything game-breaking so far, there are plenty of little annoyances that completely tank the experience.
Sometimes, for instance, when you first begin a match the game can bug out and decide that neither the starting area or your squad-mates are valid spawn points, leaving you lingering in the map overview until you quit out and find another match. Other times one "day" in Grand Operations will refuse to end, leaving you in limbo for hours blinding racking up kills and deaths until everyone leaves. This might be the same match of Grand Operations that disables your controller vibration for... some reason, leaving you to play the entire match without any rumble feedback.
These are all on top little visual hiccups, like characters spawning in with no arms, or as low-poly models that have faces like Snake from MGS1. It's the kinda thing that will obviously be improved in time, but after the delay, it's kinda frustrating to still have them drag the experience down.
It also adds to the general feeling that...
3. It's Incomplete
While Battlefield V isn't exactly lacking in content - after all its six-hour story and multiplayer modes can keep you occupied for weeks - it's undeniable that it feels like an incomplete game. In part this is because a lot of the features announced months ago (like the battle royale mode) are set to be rolled out over the next few months, while certain aspects of the sequel are proudly marketed as "coming soon" on the dashboard every single time you boot the title up.
As a result, it feels a little like you're getting a lesser product at launch than if you wait and inevitably get it for cheaper further down the line. With a brand new War Story, battle royale, Tides of War, co-op and even the classic Rush mode not yet ready for the game's inclusion, it's hard to escape the feeling that there should be more, now.
Yeah, it's cool that EA are rolling out this support for free as the sequel expands, but a lot of it feels like content that should have been there at launch.
2. The U.I. Is Needlessly Messy
Although this might not sound like a big deal, it's kind of shocking just how much DICE continue to drop the ball when it comes to the user interfaces of each Battlefield game. With that said, their latest sequel might feature the most obtuse, most infuriating set of menus yet.
While the devs thankfully added in the ability to customise your classes in the main menu rather than mid-game (why they tried to insist on leaving this out is anyone's guess), actually altering these loadouts is unnecessarily time-consuming, forcing you to manually switch between Axis forces and Allies.
It's good that DICE included so many customisation options, but it's a shame they made messing with these options so finicky that you'll probably ignore them to get into the action that bit quicker.
This is all on top of them being sluggish as hell as well, with it sometimes taking longer to quit a match than to join one. It's frustrating to get so riled up over a bunch of menu screens, but them being so poorly implemented does impact your moment-to-moment enjoyment, and adds to the overall feeling that the game is undercooked.
1. War Stories Are Tonally Inconsistent
I mentioned earlier how relieving it was to see that DICE had upped their game when it came to the actual meat-and-bones gameplay of their singe-player campaigns, but it's the actual narratives each of the three War Stories tell that are the problem this time around. DICE's attempt to unearth unknown and unseen conflicts that aren't usually highlighted in WW2 media is indeed noble, but tonally they don't always come together.
The first starts things off on a particularly bad foot; it's all about cockney hard lads finding themselves in war, told through lush cutscenes and committed voice acting (bar a couple dodgy accents) admittedly, but the humour feels a little ugly, as do the transitions into super serious war-is-hell montages.
There are bursts of genuine emotion and inspired storytelling to be found - especially towards the end of that initial chapter and the majority of the second - but it's a very particular, very weighty-with-a-capital-w style of storytelling that you either get on board with, or revolt against.