With one eye open, dribble pouring from the side of my mouth, my head fighting to stay upright and sleep engulfing me like a cloud of depression; this was not me going home on the night bus at 4am after a heavy nights drinking, but rather the state I was in as I approached the trilling climax of Beyond: Two Souls. Having been a huge fan of Fahrenheit and Heavy Rain, I was looking forward to David Cages new movie/game offering. I was looking forward to it so much, I accidentally ordered the Special Edition from two different outlets. But what followed was something that can only be described as a crashing disappointment. There is so little in Beyond: Two Souls that can be described as a game, it is a wonder that its not been investigated under the Trade Descriptions Act. Pretentious, dull and a cluster of clichés, Beyond: Two Souls is like youre being forced to participate in movie you know is terrible but are contractually obliged to finish. Every time you think it might get better, it comes crashing down to Earth again and spends another two hours making you drag it through the mud that is the story, while wearing lead boots. Fans will argue that Beyond: Two Souls is innovative, its a new way to tell a story through the medium of video games and that the thrilling storyline more than makes up for the limited interaction. But they would be wrong. Like I said, I loved Heavy Rain and it was one of the best experiences I had on the PS3. However, if it is too much confidence, too much freedom or no self-control, something went wrong during the development of Beyond: Two Souls. A game that should have been the last must-have exclusive for the PlayStation 3, Beyond: Two Souls instead shows itself to be a terrible movie thats been repackaged as an interactive experience. Click Next to find out why the game was so terrible.
8. The Rubbish Story
Playing Beyond: Two Souls, it became apparent that a certain type of story works better in a QTE game than others. To keep you playing in the absence of gameplay, you need the player to be kept wondering about what is going to happen next. In Walking Dead, the pressure was always on from the zombies and the other people in your group. You wanted to see what happens next and you were invested enough in the story to want the main characters get to safety. In Heavy Rain, the crime drama kept you guessing because you didnt know whom the killer was. You were part of the process to uncover the mystery, which got resolved at the end. In both of these examples, you played the game to find out where the story was going because they were thrilling, there was a sense that the story could go anywhere and you had a goal to work towards. Beyond: Two Souls puts you in the shoes of Jodie and you play various events in her life that take place over 15 years. She has a spirit that she is attached to and it is a burden as much as it helps her in times of crisis. You see her struggle to be a normal child, get shunned by her friends in her teenage years, and become a test subject in a lab. And lets not forget the gap year trip to Somalia where she was a lethal CIA operative. But all these events are just things that happen, you play each sequence to its conclusion and then start the next one. There is no overwhelming story arc to give all these events enough of a context for you to care. Apart from finding out who Aiden is, there is not much else to keep you interested. You expect that there will be some sort of conclusion but the game doesnt give you any drive to make you want to find out. For a game like this, you need a mystery to uncover; helping a girl deal with living with a spirit is not that. It just wasnt very interesting.
7. Disjointed Storytelling
If the story was a problem in Beyond: Two Souls, the way it was told was a huge mistake my David Cage. Jodies 15 years are broken up into disjointed chapters. In once scene she might be a frightened little girl and in the next she is a terrorist fighting operative. You jump from the test lab to Jodie cooking dinner in her apartment to her being a child again. Unfortunately for David Cage, this artistic choice was a massive mistake. Early on in the game, because you have no idea why you should be feeling sorry for Jodie, it makes playing all those early scenes pointless. You are in control of a girl who has had no character development so you dont care. By the time things start making sense, it is too late because you have no invested feeling in Jodie. You cant relate to her and that is all down to her story not being in a chronological order. Had Jodies story been told in the order, it would have a huge difference. You would have been on a journey with her. But at one moment her foster parents are rejecting her and then she is homeless and then she is trying to get a boyfriend; these are just events that happen and there is no context to them. You cant relate one chapter in Jodies life to another.
6. Crap Script
Put simply, the script for Beyond: Two Souls is terrible. Much like the cliché characters, the script is full of awful dialogue that gives the actors very little to work with. Never trying, the script is a collection of bad dialogue and obvious events. No matter how hard Ellen Page or Willem Dafoe act their hearts out, the script gives them nothing to work with. When Dafoe is crying at losing his family or going all mad at the end, not only does he sound silly when he should be sounding distraught, but it was blatantly obvious that he was going to be the antagonist when we saw him in full James Bond villain mode in his base. The only thing missing was a white cat as he sat behind his desk. And then there is the NAVAJO, the level where the game takes a left turn and puts you in the middle of a really bad X-Files episode. Jodie ends upon a ranch, which is being attacked by a spirit. The Native Americans who live there have almost given up on dealing with it, but lucky for them that Jodie knocks on their door and asks for a place to stay for the night. What follows is spirits that cant find peace, a father who wont let go off his farm, a angry son with secrets and a granny who never speaks except for when there is a comedy climax to partake in. Boring, badly written and mostly pointless, this level sums up perfectly what is wrong with Beyond: Two Souls. It even contained a cringe moment where one of the sons finds his grandmother dead and then looks up into the sky and shouts her name SHIMASAAAAAAANNNNIIIIII. I literally burst out laughing.
5. Jodie
Ive never really understood the obsession with Ellen Page. Yes she is a talented actress but I always found her to be a little dull on screen. Seeing the words Starring Ellen Page dont normally have me rushing to the cinema. But she does a good job in Beyond: Two Souls, even though the Jodie character is one of the most boring protagonists ever written. Jodie is a damaged girl that has had a troubled life over which she has no control. She is like a Carrie lite, never been given the chance to be a normal girl and form normal relationships. There is a lot to play with there but sadly, the more Jodie grows up, the less you care. When she is a child, you cant help but want to look after her. Its not nice to see her be called a witch by other children or be too scared to go to sleep at night. Even if you are not a parent, you want to make sure she is ok. As she gets older and she suddenly performing stunts that involve fighting armed attackers on her own or jumping from moving vehicles, she moves away from being a character you want to look after but instead becomes someone performing stunts in a bad action film. Any affection for her goes because the leaps and progress in her life have been so badly told. You dont care about Jodie finding out about her real mother, or being homeless and eating fish from a can. You dont care because why should you? As a child, you had to look after her, but adult Jodie can look after herself. And as the control scheme gives you no illusion that you are controlling Jodie, you are merely watching this woman do stuff. That is why the ending is so anti-climatic, you are enabling the next cut scene in adult Jodies life without any control over where her path goes. But unlike a good film where you are invested in a characters well being, there is none of that for Jodie.
4. Wooden Supporting Cast
For a game that so badly wants to be a movie, you would think that a lot of the focus would go on creating characters that grabbed your attention and kept you playing. But in Beyond: Two Souls, we are presented with one of the best collection of cliché characters, seen this side of a Resident Evil game. If its William Defoes caring/mad scientist routine, or Jodies melodramatic foster parents, or the good looking love interest with an edge; they all drag Beyond: Two Souls to depths that are only seen in American daytime soaps. There is nothing interesting about any of them and they all project their individual story arcs as soon as they make an appearance in the game, because they are all characters we have seen a thousand times before. Jodies on/off boyfriend, Ryan is the worst. Either through the choices you make or more likely due to bad writing, it is hard to gauge how he is going to behave from one scene to the next. You know he will be involved in the climax somehow but his journey there is a mess. He is introduced as a total jerk who then becomes Jodies boyfriend. He then manipulates Jodie, they break up but then come together for the boss fight at the end. Like the preverbal puppet Ryan is, he does only what each scene requires him to. Because there is no actual character development, all Ryan can do is play sexy boyfriend 101 or angry boyfriend 101 or CIA man 101. Bad acting combined with a terrible script, even Willem Defoe cant save the scenes he is in. His delivery is almost as dead as the eyes on his avatar.
3. The Music
Imagine a giant sledgehammer repeatedly hitting you in the face while shouting out emotions that you should be feeling. HAPPY! SAD! LOVE! SCARED! That is the best way to describe the soundtrack for Beyond: Two Souls. Much like the script, it is track after track of cliché orchestral fluff that only diminishes how much of yourself you invest in a scene. If it is a sad moment, you hear sad music. If it is happy, the music is uplifting. If there is a dramatic event, the full orchestra starts playing its heart out. Heavy-handed is an understatement; it is almost like composer Lorne Balfe was told to write music that fits a particular mood but make it general as possible. They could have downloaded the music from a royalty free site and you wouldnt be able to tell the difference. You get fed up with the music overshadowing every scene or telegraphing what is going to happen before it happens. It becomes annoying because it is a symptom of everything that is wrong with modern soundtracks. Composers often resort to writing bland orchestral music, which you have heard a million times before. Bland orcestrals dont make a game epic, they drag it down to TV movie level.
2. Aiden
Aiden the ghost is probably the best thing in Beyond: Two Souls but that doesnt mean he is anything special. When prompted to do so, you take control of Aiden and fly around the room and through walls. If Jodie needs someones attention, Aiden will go and spill a conveniently placed cup of coffee over them. If Jodie comes across a locked door, Aiden will pass through it and unlock it. If Jodie is attacked, Aiden will strangle or possess the assailant to stop him. Taking control of Aiden is a welcome break from the mundane that is Jodie. At first, it is a lot of fun to knock over tables and smash glass but then you soon realise that you dont really have that much choice in what you do, the game is telling you what to do. Randomly, you will either be able to possess a bad guy or choke him to death. You will have certain objects you can interact with, depending on the scene. Just because you could throw a chair across the room in once scene, dont expect to be able to do it in the next. About a quarter of the way into the game, it soon dawns you that Aiden is as much of a cut scene enabler as you are. And most of the time, you play hunt the white dot so you can interact with it and start the next cut scene. The one interesting moment that Aiden has is quickly dropped and forgotten about. He becomes jealous that Jodie is forming a relationship with another man. He does his best to make their first date really awkward. But that is only explored in that scene and you soon return to the monotony that is pressing R1 when told to and pushing the controller stick towards doors. Totally wasted.
1. No Gameplay
Beyond: Two Souls really highlighted how important controls are in immersing you in the game world. By simplifying them to the point of patronising, David Cage put up an unfortunate barrier that stopped you from taking the role of Jodie and turned the player into a glorified cut scene activator. I have no problem with the QTE control scheme; it worked well in Fahrenheit and Heavy Rain. And Telltales Walking Dead showed that it was possible to tell an engaging story that fools the player into thinking that he or she has some semblance of control over how it plays out. But the problem with Beyond: Two Souls is that there is no real control scheme and almost no game play. You move Jodie slowly from one point to another and activate a cut scene. You help Jodie cook a meal by activating a series of cut scenes. Help Jodie in a fight by watching the cut scene carefully and activating the next cut scene. The gameplay in Beyond: Two Souls is a big hunt the white dot game. You look where the white dot is and then point the stick on the controller towards it. It takes controls for the casual gamer to a new and mind numbing level. You dont feel like you are in control of Jodie, the only thing you control is how the next cut scene starts. In Heavy Rain, the combat was intense. The fight scene where Madison Page is trapped in the house with the psycho doctor is still embedded in my mind. Even though it was a series of QTE, you felt like you was in control of Madison and the pressure was on to get her to safety. But compared to the combat in Beyond: Two Souls, all you do is push the stick in the direction Jodies arm or leg is travelling in; rinse and repeat. Simplified controls are ok but you still need some control for you to feel like you are part of the experience. Games like Walking Dead and Heavy Rain got the balance right but unfortunately, the control scheme is too simple and therefore the gameplay is virtually non-existence. Unless you count helping Jodie cook, tidy her room, pack her bag, have a shower but my life is full of chores like that, the last thing I want to do is do all that stuff in a game Ive paid £40 for. Beyond: Two Souls is like watching a bad film where you get to play all the stuff that is normally edited out for being too dull.