Bioshock Infinite Creative Director Ken Levine Sits Down Just With Us For Extended Conversation
Columbia is about showing off. It is a rooster for America. So it was designed to be seen, it was designed to be impressive. An icon. It didn't work out that way but it was very intentional. We knew right from the start that we didn't want to do the hidden city again. Or more importantly, the unknown city that no one knows about. That presented us with challenges. Having the secret hidden base is a lot easier. Having darkness is a lot easier. Having tight quarters is a lot easier. Everything was a lot easierBioshock and Bioshock Infinite both feature 'overlords' figureheads of wondrous cities that ended up going askew. These leaders both embody strong ideological views about how the world should be run and practice their beliefs in their city to prove it. Their beliefs are completely opposite but the outcome and basics of their structure are the same. Ken replies, "Yeah, If you go far enough left, you hit the right and vice versa."
It is interesting how opposite they are, but also how similar they are. If you look at Andrew Ryan and Comstock, the respective leaders of the cities, Ryan is an atheist, capitalist and...imperisist. Comstock is a spirtual, religious, nationalistic figure. They sounded as different as they possibly could be, but they are also similar in that they both have a system of beliefs that answers all questions and will solve all problems, and if you don't agree with that system of beliefs...well you are in trouble.As well as being set in different cities, the game timelines are seperated by 42 years. The original Bioshock was set in 1960 where as Infinite is set in 1912. It is obviously a very deliberate decision, I wonder how Ken finally landed on the time period. He retorts, "I got really interested in the time period because it was so transfermational."
I didn't know much about it at the time. I started looking into it and I started looking into the science and technology, I know the impact that the internet had on our culture, right? In that period you look at electricity, you look at telephones, airplanes, you look at cars, you look at radio, you look at movies. You go, oh my god each one of those is as substantial as the Internet. Then you look at the social changes that were happening. You look at the changes of women's rights and the very beginning of civil rights movements and workers rights. You have WWI about to kick off. I don't think there was ever a period so packed with transition to observe in history over such a broad thing. You know, WWII is very transitional, but that was a single event that caused that. So I was really fascinated by that. Then you start digging into the sciene at the time and you start digging into Einstein and what he meant about our understanding of our universe and what story opportunites that opened up. I just kept getting drawn in and drawn in and drawn in.No piece of media text exists in a historyical vacuum. There is generally a reason something has come out at the point it did. Films like Lincoln and Argo all say something about the world we live in now. "I think if you are telling a story about any time period, you are telling a story about today." Levine says. But the relevency of Bioshock Infinite also grew by happenstance.
You know, a lot of people have asked me along the way, "Oh, did you do this as a reflection of that?" And generally no. We're generally reflecting on things from the historical period. You know the whole Occupy Movement and the Tea Party, all of those movements came after we started working on it. It is not because we inspired them or we saw them coming. It is because they are version 990,997 of those movements. They happen over and over again. I mean you can go back to Bioshock 1 and who would have known that a few years after it, a politician called Ryan, who was an objectivist would try to become the Vice-President of the United States. If that had come first, then people would have said that you are making a Paul Ryan character. And again, I didn't know, I had never heard of Paul Ryan. It was just because, well after the financial melt down, we saw a lot of people kind of turn to that economic philosophy as a cure all in some people's headsClearly Bioshock is going to juggle a lot of plates and wear lots of hats, But how did all these ideas come together in practice? It is a question worth asking. With a project so big, all this can come together slolwy or very fast. How did the team at Irrational Games come together to tell this story and where did it all start?
The first day was...we wanted to make a Bioshock game but not set in Rapture. We sort of really left ourselves open to figuring out what that was. So on the first time, we said, Well lets do a different time period. We knew that was important because that will mean a million different things because so much of Bioshock is about the culture and the history and the politics and the science and so we thought of the turn of the century and a lot of the images from the turn of the century, especially in science fiction, you saw a lot of cities in the sky at that time. All these fantastical images and I thought, that is really cool, that is so optimistic, that is so different from Rapture. So, we decided those two things on the first day and that was the most successful day we ever had on deciding things. I don't think there was another day were we made major decisions that everyone agreed on and completely stuck. So we started with those two things. Honestly...it may have been a year until Booker and Elizabeth made their appearance after that.
Your New Found Friendship With An AI Named Elizabeth In the game you will play as Booker Dewitt, a disgraced Pinkerton agent challenged with infiltrating the city of Columbia and 'rescue' a young girl called Elizabeth. However, as such things are, it isn't quite that simple. Elizabeth poses the power to tear holes between dimensions and time and is at the center of a raging civil war. In the game, Elizabeth will accompany you through the majority of your time on Columbia. Levine is obviously very excited about people interacting with his character.
To me, Elizabeth is the real experiment. She is an AI. Most AIs are gun turrets right? She is an AI that is really designed to...put it this way, I was talking to Guillermo Del Toro once. He said, an interesting character is one that you can imagine in repose. Not in combat, not attacking. It is relatively easy to make AIs who are in combat. How do you make a character you are just hanging out in a room with believable? We spent so much time and energy making sure the Elizabeth feels engaged and feels believable, even when you are just in the room with her. Let alone the cool stuff and the combat. If you are out of ammo, she will toss you a gun and do all these really helpful things for you but just hanging in a room, just being interested in what is around her. Being engaged in the space, just starting conversations with you, but also going through a narrative progression and changing and being changed by the world around her. In any other media, you can't build a relationship with another character the way you can in games. I think the closest thing would be an improv with somebody. That is the closest connection.I have noticed, especially recently, several fascinating case studies of companionship in games. From games with great single player companions like Clementine in The Walking Dead to more interpretive multiplayer companionships like Journey, experimentation in how we interact with a companions in our games is ripe. Levine seems fairly confident that his game will bring something new and better to the table.
Journey is sort of an abstract version of companionship. There are a lot of questions they don't ask. Clementine is an excellent companion but she only exsists in designer crafted moments according to a script. She doesn't really have a life outside of that. Where as Elizabeth both exsists in crafted moments in the script but she also exists in a dynamic sense inside and outside of combat, just in walking in the world. You will be in an arcade and she will start playing with them and acting with them, you walk into a ladies bathroom and she'll like comment,"what are you doing here?" So we have all this stuff that is built into and happens between the lines of the scripted moments. You have all these if/and statements and all these sort of reactive statements. So I think Elizabeth really is, there is a continum of like, Alex from Half Life, Chip from Enslaved, that I thought was really strong, and I think Elizabeth is . Then you have, like you said characters in Journey. I think Clementine is a little different. Very well, very well written. Extremely well written but thats all... she is essentially a written character. Really not that much different than how you would write a character in a movie or animated series. So Elizabeth has to exist in both of those spaces and that was the real challenge for her.When the word companionship comes up, it's bigger, more corporate brother 'connectivity' is never far behind. In fact, the word is coming up all over the game industry. The Playstation 4 have even gone as far as to base their whole console on it. I ask Ken if he thinks Bioshock fits into the connectivity equation and if as an industry we are jumping to the idea too wholly. "I am a primarily a single player gamer myself" he assures me.
I mean, if this is a co op game, and it is not...there is no Elizabeth as a co-op partner. Then she is just a collection of powers that is running around with you. It is that character connection that matters here. So we never thought of her being a co-op partner here. The amount of roleplaying that would be necessary here would be pretty extraordinary. And yet, we want you too feel like partners. We want you to feel like,"Wow, It is a co-op game where the partner I have is this really great actress who is really invested in this part." Now, of course it isn't always going to feel like that, but I think that's cool. Because generally you either had co-op or a really solo experience. This is somewhere...I wouldn't say in between, but a third way.With all these interesting narrative innovations, Levine could have been forgiven for feeling less inclined to focus on the core shooting of the game. But he is an entertainer first. While trying to tell a serious story imbued with political overtones, he wants to deliever the gleefulness of gun-totting and vigor wielding.
The people I admire the most are the people who have their cake and eat it too. The people who make a great entertaining film that stays with you for years, you know? I don't think you have to choose. I believe in entertainment, but I also believe in... well, look at Animal Farm, a great little short book about a bunch of pigs that take over a farm. An say that you knew nothing about the Russian Revolution, that is what you would think it was. That isn't even the Russian Revolution, but human nature and political thought, it is still a great little story. I think you can do both.So, there is clearly something for everybody here. Maybe standing around in an arcade to see what an AI is going to do and say just isn't the way you get your kicks. Perhaps you care less for the story and more for running though everything and shooting at the other AIs. Well, if you are a run and gun player, fear not, Elizabeth shant get in the way of your power fantasy.
I think it is that we really let the player take the lead. You never have to feel obligated to Elizabeth. In the sense that, right at the begining we did a lot of testing and you have some people say, "I feel like I really have to wait for her." We knew that was a problem. So we wanted her to really drive the player's experience. Her AI is generally watching you all the time. I don't mean her, she isn't concious of it. The game is constantly wathcing you to make sure that if you tend to hang out in an area, she will sort of branch out and start doing interesting things. Or if you tend to zip through things, she'll zip through things. It is our responsibillity to sort of show you what cool stuff she can do. We find that, y'know, people tend to like to say, "Well cool, what is she going to do here?" That has been a real interesting challenge because there hasn't been a real precident for that, where people may or may not do a bunch of cool stuff in that space.But if you are indeed about all that exploration, Don't worry, the franchise hasn't lost anything.
It is very Bioshock. We have always had all these little nooks and crannies that you can choose to explore or not and you get rewarded, I mean if you are into that, if you are into the detail, there is 'so' much in this game that you will, 'soo' much detail you will be able to discover.Bioshock Infinite ties to the original in the series are not immediately obvious. They take place int he same universe but at largely different time spans and on completely different cities. So how do they tie these two together? The answer is through gameplay. Bioshock was known for its first person shooting but also the use of plasmids. What I always liked about the plasmids was that they weren't just fun to play with but also how they enhanced the themes of the story. Bioshock Infinite deploys a similar concept in vigors.
The thematic connection is really talking about where the Vigours come from in this world, that is a story in a way. I think probably the theme of plasmids was more important to the first game, because it was about people becoming super people, you know, supermen and what happens if that gets pushed too far. That was a very sort of visceral representation of that. Where are with this game, we are really getting with Elizabeth and her ability to open portals to other dimensions and other version of our realities and the differences between that. Those are the themes of this game and are closely tied to that are the vigours of this game. There are reasons why they are there but it is more about providing the Bioshock gameplay experience. Some things are thematically tied, most things are thematically tied. Some things are a little more systemic.While on the idea of game mechanics, I really wanted to get Ken's opinion on the First Person Shooter. It is a concept that I have always found a little confusing. Coming from a film literate background, my understand of genre is often based on content such as Horror or Romance, where as game genre defines itself by gameplay. But Ken puts me straight and tells me the strengths of the FPS.
Right, right, right. For me, the FP is more important than the S. To me, that is a genre because you are in the shoes of..well I guess it is not technically genre. But, the fact that you and Booker are sharing a skin, it is very interesting to me. Because there is no way we can hope for you to build a relationship with another character unless you are first person, I don't think. Because there is observing a relationship and being in a relationship. I think there are lots of times where you observe a relationship. If you look at the Big Daddy and Little Sister relationship, it was a very powerful and emotional relationship, but it is an observed relationship. People look at me strange when I say this, but Elizabeth is the inheritor. People say, oh is the Songbird the new Big Daddy? Is the Handy Man the big daddy? I think Elizabeth really is. What made the Big Daddy powerful was that you empathised with him, you felt for him because of that relationship he had . Creating emotion with the AI was really the goal of that. That was the goal with Elizabeth as well. a connection and emotion and empathy. And so, I think that is way more important than any combat experience with the Big Daddy. So I think that is why the first person matters to me. You having this relationship with Elizabeth and for a few moments, even for a few moments, make you forget that she is just a collection of motion captures and character models and dialogue, because I knew sometimes, and I wrote the material and directed the actor.
Advertisement
I have no patience for people who try and make games that I make, because only I make games that are "worthy". Seriously, I want to punch those people. I love great games, I love thoughtful games, I love stupid games in the same ways I like movies. I will love There Will Be Blood and I will love Idiocracy. I'll love great movies and I will love stupid movies. I love Harold and Kumar and I love Miller's Crossing, you know? I think that snobery is the enemy of art. Snobs always turn against every new form of art. Comic books, rock and roll music, Jazz, impressionist painting, it is always the snobs who are saying no. And it is always that snobs that hinder the progress of all art. I don't have any patience for that. And look, I make a certain kind of game, I have made some silly games. You know Freedom Force was fairly silly but it is a love letter to a certain kind of thing. And I make games that some people perceive as more serious or less serious and frankly that is my prerogative. And I mean, it is every artists perogative to make what he wants. Especially for another artist to poo poo that really bothers me.His comments strike a cord with me. Snobbery is something that is often associated with critics. It is an important thing to remember when we are evaluating the worth of a piece of art. Now, I am a big supporter of new technologies like 3D and high-frame rates and often try and find worth in films I really don't like, but the sentiment is true, snobbery can only hold back a medium. However, what I also feel is holding back the medium is the suppression of Auteurism. By doing this. the medium is devoid of creative faces to rally around like a film director or novelist. But also on a more important point, it makes game creators interchangeable in publishers eyes. But Ken Levine is one of the mediums most revered creatives. So I ask him, Why do you think there is a lack of auteurs in the medium? "Well, I think This is a dangerous situation if the mediums artistic future is to be secured. Ken thinks "There are a bunch of reasons" for that.
One is, generally, film is done by groups of different people who come together for a short period of time, where as games tend to be companies. So... when you have Spielberg and he is working with literally dozens of different combinations of people like a different cinematographer, it is sort of easier to identify him as the common element. When you talk about Autuership, I think what you are really saying is, some one at the end of the day has to sort of make the taste decision. Not that they create everything, but that they have to sort of go, "Does this fit in the game or not?" At Irrational, that is me. I have a creating role, I am the writer, I am the lead writer and I have to develop my own stuff to and I have to decide, does this fit this game? There have been many, many, many, many times when the answer has been no. I am a writer who has no problem deleting that file. There are some scenes, I was at the Dolce Museum in Munich the other day, looking at smelting, where you seperate metals. I wrote this whole scene for Booker and Elizabeth where they had to do this quest that involves smelting. Booker knew about it because he was a strikebreaker for the Pinkertons, so he worked with all the scabs at the factories and he learned about it. And I researched it, and I really enjoyed it and it was precedual fun and they had a great banter. Then I realised that there was no way this was going to work in the game and I cut it out. I spent days on this and I really educated myself, but it didn't work so it had to go. It is the same for everybody elses work at the company. I think that what ever you want to call that person, there is a person whose taste is the final say. That doesn't mean that they make everything by any stretch of the imagination but they have to say does this fit, or does this not? I think some of it is, like say for a film director, for instance, can be on the Tonight Show or whatever, where as a game maker is not. TV is a very very powerful way to get someone's face out there. I remember after anytime I do something on TV, I get recognised for the next few weeks at a much higher frequency than I normally do because it has a much greater effect on people. I think that is part of what it is. Because the people making decisions about what goes on in talk shows and stuff, they don't get games. Even though the guys who have made Call of Duty are responsible for however many billion dollars of business, are making games that 15 million people or so more play etc, they won't get on these shows over a guy who has written a book that will sell 15,000 copies because the people booking these shows don't quite get games yet. I think that will change over time and you will see games creators having a higher profile. Specifically, and I know it sounds silly, because they will be on television more.It is a more practical answer than what I was expecting but he is totally right. Getting game creators more loved and revered is likely to come down to how much time they get on TV as opposed to however many articles I write about them being 'artists'. But his answer brings up another interesting question. Has the medium been thrown into corperate franchising world before it had even found it's legs as an artistic medium? "Hm...Well, good question..." (I take a little pride from that one). Ken explains how Kickstarter could potentially help the industry get back to finding its roots and distance itself form publishers.
There has been a second wave of digital distribution with Kickstarter. This sort of new independent wave. In a film, you know it took a long time for film to develop in an alternate distribution model and also a funding model. Games have achieved both. And it is a very powerful thing because that is where innovation is going to thrive. The fact that you can kind of have this democratised patronage with Kickstarter or something like that. And who knows if Kickstarter is a permanent thing or if there is some other version and there is a way to have people buy shares in a company of repute. But the fact that gamers can say, I believe in this thing and I want to see it happen. I am going to put my money where my mouth is. And you know, you don't need to deal with a wheel within the giant machinery of a publisher. Now, it can't be something of that scale on Bioshock Infinite. It is on a scale that is intially not feasible. But the fact that you can go to a broad range of junior investors and one or a couple senior investors is an incredibly powerful thing. It will really allow a kind of development that just couldn't have existed a few years ago. I think that is really exciting.While on the point of the future, I decide to ask Ken one of the broadest questions to explore. I give the question some context by discussing the last year of gaming with fantastic experiences like Far Cry 3, Journey and the Walking Dead. What does it all say about where we are going and where does Bioshock fit into that? He laughs, "Wow, f**ked if I know." He then did something that not many interviewees generally do. He went quiet to consider his answer. "I am trying to think of a thoughtful answer here that I have some faith in." I tell him those are the kind that I like.
I think quality matters and quality is always going to matter. I think how people buy their games, how they are distributed, where they play them, how they play them, is really up for grabs. I think that crowd funding is a real game changer. I think there is going to be some giant screw up that is going to cause problems, but it is realy a game changer because you are really allowed to vote with your wallets. People feel participatory and that is really great. That is not just for a game, that is for anything. People want to support the things they like. And banks and funding instiutions really had a monopoly on that. I think that is incredibly powerful. I think that games are going to be taken more seriously over time because the people who decide what should be taken seriously, don't understand games because, frankly, they are too old. People my age are too old. I just happen to be one of the few people who played games when I was a kid. Most people didn't know games and they didn't grow up knowing games. Like I have talked to plenty of film directors who are like, Oh, I love Bioshock. I watch my kids play it. because there is a literacy issue. In the same way, when novels came out, people couldn't read, they don't know how to do this right? And it is complicated. That is not easy when you are 50 years old to pick up. But as people in that group sort of move on and turn into soil and green... you know? you see 2 year olds with an IPad. It is like second nature to them. So game is just going to be another form of media to them. And just a valid as every other form of media.It is a sentiment that was shared by Jenova Chen in my interview with him a few weeks ago. Older people are struggling to get into gaming. Levine is spot on to highlight a literacy issue, because it is just that. I can attest to it. I have tried to teach my own mum how to play Portal. It wasn't pretty. So while looking forward to the mediums future, I find it a shame that we must wait a generation for it to really get the prominence that it deserves. But in the more immediate future, Bioshock Infinite is going to be hitting shelves on the 26th of March. While I can not say that the game will live up to the hype or surpass it yet, I can say that it was put together, by a wonderful development team with a thoughtful, intelligent and artistically attune creator, who was a joy to interview. That I will sign off on. If you somehow have missed the hype for the game, here is a trailer of the game to get you excited for it.