Black Ops 2: Where It Succeeds And Fails

Love the series or not, it just seemingly won't die.

By Ryan Musker /

The Good

1. The Story and The Characters

Black Ops 2's single player story mode is written by The Dark Knight trilogy writer David S. Goyer so we can no doubt expect a step up in story from previous entries, even the first Black Ops game. The new setting could provide a new inspiration for the story. Also, Treyarch has employed a new facial animation system and it looks awesome. Check out the E3 gameplay to see an example of this. I love how Treyarch constantly finds more things to do, as opposed to Infinity Ward's..."innovation". And kudos for the protagonist a voice, it's a shame it's so ignored by all modern shooters. Also, a quick note, the pilot Mason is communicating with sounds like Jennifer Hale. Anyone agree?

Advertisement

2. The Setting

Sometimes, a simple setting change is enough to breathe fresh life into a series. Look at Crysis. The first game was set in a jungle, yet the second was in New York and the whole vibe of the game and the way it played changed. Resident Evil 5's Africa was different to RE4's Spanish-inspired nation, yet RE6 looks different again. It's the right move to do, and for fans who aren't completely sold, the campaign also has Cold War flashbacks to the days of Woods and Alex Mason.

3. The Unlocks

Something consistently great about the series is the variety of unlocks available for all aspects, especially in Black Ops. While some features, namely the face paint, were totally useless, they added a few things like clan tags and emblems on guns, new perks and the awesome ballistic knife. The thing that sets COD apart from other shooters is how the fast pace makes unlocking things rewarding. Yes, BF3's system was excellent. Every ten kills with a weapon unlocks a new attachment for that weapon, but once the tree was finished the weapon became instantly less rewarding. The constant flow of killstreaks unlocking mid match is a great reward for doing well, and plays on the strength of the game's longevity. Black Ops' varied camos and red dot sight design were so much fun and it added a lot changing each match to find the right one is engaging, and so rewarding to find the perfect one.

4. The Music

You've probably already heard about Trent Reznor doing the main theme for the game, but did you know the soundtrack is being composed by Jack Wall? If you have never heard of him, he did the soundtrack for Mass Effect and Mass Effect 2, Jade Empire and Splinter Cell: Pandora tomorrow. His music is iconic for fans of the games he composed for and he has won several awards for his work. Here's what he brought to Mass Effect 2: http://youtu.be/VTsD2FjmLsw Brilliant work, and if he can reach those heights again with Black Ops 2, fans can expect an outstanding score. So, that's the good points out of the way, now, let's deal with the reasons Treyarch's upcoming shooter won't be the world-beater some are suggesting... The Not So Good

1. The Sound

Call of Duty 4 and World at War, and to some extent, Modern Warfare 2 sounded pretty good. Modern Warfare 3's gunshots sounded like keys jiggling and Black Ops had very cartoony and fake weapon effects. Unfortunately, Black Ops 2 seems to be following suit. A game's effects need to fit the game - Mortal Kombat 2011 is great example of this: as an over the top fighting game, the punches are loud and full of bass and Kitana's fans whizzing sound pitch perfect. The explosions of COD games are weak. Yes, you're going to hate me for this, but Battlefield 3 set the bar last year for sound design. Fortunately, however, sound design is becoming better in gaming in general. Uncharted 3 sounded much more realistic and cinematic than Uncharted 2's effects (remember the 92FS-9mm, anyone?) The upcoming Medal of Honor: Warfighter sounds very aggressive, and the Assassin's Creed series sounds consistently great.

2. The Equipment

The X-ray scopes will add a new tactical element, but some things shown in yesterday's seem like a bit much. It looked like the jamming device stops enemies from shooting and the air supports looks very powerful. While I don't personally have a problem with this, I can see matches turning into a spam fest of explosions and X-ray and suppression jammers. This may not be the wisest move, and no doubt a lot of people will get frustrated with the game and quit. Why does Activision care? No one will buy the DLC.

3. The Gameplay

Yes, love it or hate, the core game is unchanged. One hit kill knives, aim assist and the general feel of the controls are identical. You'll still be running through levels mowing down goons without being able to see your feet or feel like a person in a world. This, for me, is the major killer, the reason I doubt the game. Treyarch have put solutions in place to make the game feel different from previous entries, yet still haven't changed the gameplay. This is a real bummer at COD gameplay is getting a little bit stale.

4. It's Call of Duty

There is no doubt this game will get marketing deals with energy drinks, slews of premium DLC, celebrity endorsements and extremely high purchase prices, at least in Australia. Regardless of how much you enjoy the game, the constant paid content and advertising gets a little overwhelming at times, especially when you know that after spending another 60 bucks on DLC you need to pay again for next years game, and then it's content. So there we have, a few ways Black Ops 2 could go right and wrong. As a Battlefield, Crysis and Warfighter fan, I will be keeping an eye on this as opposed to just jumping on the "COD sucks" bandwagon. Yes, I know I didn't mention the zombies mode, which looks to add plenty of features, but not much is known yet so it could either be amazing or have a fatal flaw. Much like the game itself. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 launches on November 13.