Cyberpunk 2077 - 8 Major Worries We Can't Shake

Something's not lining up.

By Scott Tailford /

CD Projekt RED

Try as I may, I can't shake a series of doubts with what should clearly be one of the most anticipated games of 2020, if not all time.

Advertisement

Because CD Projekt RED are one of my favourite developers. The Witcher 3 is one of my favourite games, and for the first few years of Cyberpunk 2077's rumoured existence, I was elated.

However, as more information has come out; the behind-closed-doors stage demos, extended gameplay and the overall feeling around the game right now, I think most people are looking forward to "the next thing from the Witcher 3 devs", rather than what's actually in Cyberpunk 2077 itself.

Advertisement

To break that down will take time and analysis - and I'll say right now, I hope I am DEAD WRONG about ever doubting the majesty of what is clearly a medium-pushing open world game with unprecedented scope - but I'd be lying if I said I was as excited for this, as the likes of The Last of Us 2.

Cyberpunk 2077 just isn't wowing as much as a game that's 4 months away likely should, and here's why.

Advertisement

8. No Third-Person

CD Projekt RED

I know, I know. It shouldn't matter, right? It really shouldn't matter, but if I'm honest, I never truly got over the revelation that Cyberpunk wasn't continuing one of the biggest strengths of The Witcher 3 - a freely rotating, cinematic third-person camera.

Advertisement

Instead, the post-announcement revelation that CB2077 will be first-person as much as possible has almost become a dealbreaker. Every time the game is showing well; its graphics looking gorgeous or its action looking engaging, I'm hit with the reminder that I'll barely be seeing any of it.

Yes, cars can be driven in third-person, but firefights and the more high-octane stuff is back to first-person. If something like Far Cry 4 is anything to go by, this stuff pales in comparison to the likes of Pursuit Force or Sleeping Dogs, where characters are leaping from roof to roof, tossing drivers to the pavement and burning off around the next corner.

Advertisement

All those mind's-eye gameplay clips many of us had, where our custom protagonist was slicing through enemies or firing futuristic machine guns while pirouetting through the sky or taking on foes from all sides? We'll just never see it.

7. Where Are The New Gameplay Mechanics?

CD Projekt RED

If you combine everything that's out there, we have access to a good couple hours of Cyberpunk 2077 footage.

Advertisement

However, I'll give you a cookie if you can point to one - just one - new game mechanic that hasn't been done before.

Sadly, it's very hard to get away from the fact that everything on offer looks like Deus Ex's occasional "mini-open world" environments, with the scale cranked up. Yes we'll be talking to NPCs, upgrading abilities and undertaking missions where we spear enemy guards with blade arms, but it makes me wonder if Cyberpunk 2077 is aiming to be the best version of an established formula, more than concocting its own.

Advertisement

And while that will still result in a bankable framework and identity that guarantees people know what they're buying into, it's a double-edged sword.

The gaming industry has become inundated with safety this generation. Safe genres, safe mechanics, safe gameplay loops - things that made more money than ever... but also drained it of the one thing a creative medium needs to stay relevant over time: Risk.

Advertisement

Let Cyberpunk 2077 set a new bar for the genre with fresh ideas, not just another product of refinement.

6. ANOTHER Four-Tier Loot System

CD Projekt RED

What already feels like an outdated bygone of this generation we'll be MORE than happy to leave behind?

Advertisement

Four tier loot systems.

Pioneered by Diablo 3 back in 2012, this generation it feels like every triple-A game dev just defaults to the same mix of grey, green, blue and purple gear.

Advertisement

Comprising everything from The Division to Borderlands, Assassin's Creed to Anthem and Fortnite, gameplay for Cyberpunk points to the exact same "four bucket system" being rolled out yet again.

This speaks to the aforementioned issue with CD Projekt RED relying on established frameworks rather than their own, but in gameplay terms, it means you'll be going through the same acquisition loop over and over again.

Advertisement

Loot systems inherently encourage a wasteful way to play. You're forever hoovering up and discarding 10x more gear than you keep, which discourages character builds and takes the visual focus of the game off specific items or rewards, and onto groups of tat to chew through.

5. The Dialogue Seems... Bad

CD Projekt RED

CD Projekt RED are clearly - clearly - incredibly good writers, narrative world-builders and storytellers in general. All three Witcher games excelled at putting you in the shoes of an emotion-stripped supernatural bounty hunter, and all the consequences that came alongside.

Advertisement

However, a lot of the dialogue shown so far looks like an attempt to continue the faux-"stylised" phrasing and notion of what "cool" is, from the Cyberpunk books.

The only problem? These books were written in the late 80s, being published in 1988 and 1990.

Advertisement

Like many movies that imagined the "dystopian" or corporately-mandated future of the 2000s and beyond, they are riddled with fairly cringeworthy, faux-rebellious phrases like "think dangerous, live dangerous!", referring to people of power as "suits", or talking about "leaving the meat behind, man" when it comes to living in the Netspace.

I'm not saying this stuff is outright bad, but it's notably outdated - indicative of a post-hippy time when sci-fi writers thought the future would splinter us into a 50/50 split of "the corporate elite" and the leather trenchcoat-wearing freedom fighters telling those squares like it is.

Advertisement

There's nothing worse than an entertainment property thinking it's cooler than it is, and if there's one thing that would detonate the foundations of everything being built, it's your parent's version of a cyberpunk script.

4. V's Character Agency Doesn't Make Sense

CD Projekt RED

For as much as many fans are imagining Cyberpunk 2077 as something of a "sci-fi Skyrim", the reality is that it has more in common with The Witcher - at least from what we've seen.

Advertisement

By that I mean you're not playing a blank slate, designed from the ground up to be moulded into any shape you please, personality-wise. Instead, whilst V can be customised in terms of weight, gender fluidity and clothing, they will have a personality that comes through regardless.

Again, just look at your dialogue responses. There's every possibility that embodying a character with a specific attitude comes down on the wrong side of immersion.

Advertisement

Point being: In The Witcher you were never anything other than Geralt. There was no elaborate customisation screen; no allusion to "make the character your own" outside of armour and hairstyles. You couldn't even switch weapon types - Geralt was a swordsman and nothing else.

V, on the other hand, has an agency in this world that walks between two extremes.

Advertisement

On one hand they've been shown auto-responding to NPCs, phrasing responses with a certain tone or talking in a way that establishes them as a figurehead in an assumed rebellion arc, but on the other, you can customise a ton of specific elements and "make V your own"... but in every way other than the main story.

Does this mean we're left with a Fallout 4 situation where the overarching sense of customisation and agency is actually a facade? Time will tell.

Advertisement

3. Pointless Visual Customisation

CD Projekt RED

Another spin-off from no third-person gameplay and the aforementioned character building stuff, is that all the aesthetic customisation you'll want to indulge in - from neon jacket decals to ramming technology straight into your eye-holes - is barely going to be seen.

Advertisement

Honestly, can you think of any RPG or game with a heavy amount of customisation, that then resigns you to first-person?

Yes, you can view your character in an inventory screen, but like designing your face in The Outer Worlds, it only highlights how pointless all this visual tinkering has been overall.

Advertisement

The shift to FP stands out as a bugbear based on CDPR's prior work, but combined with stealth mechanics, open-ended combat scenarios and - most importantly - detailed visual customisation and clothing, it could result in solid individual elements not sitting well together.

Why would we spend time designing a character; augmenting them, purchasing equipment and items, only to barely see any of it?

Advertisement

2. It's CD Projekt RED's First FPS

CD Projekt RED

One of the bigger worries surrounding any developer jumping into uncharted waters comes from the inevitability of the first instalment being a test case.

Advertisement

Like Ubisoft with Assassin's Creed and The Division, those first instalments succeeded in spite of their core mechanics; gameplay being serviceable enough, but it was the world-building, ancillary mechanics or notion of developer ambition that carried things through.

There's a reason developers stick to what they know, and whilst I commend CDPR for taking a MASSIVE risk in shifting genres so completely, we're going from fantasy hack n' slash action adventure, to sci-fi first-person hero-shooter.

Advertisement

I'm not saying CDPR can't get this right, but going off the gameplay that's out there and considering the competition in the FPS genre, it'll take a miracle for a first-time team to compete with the likes of Call of Duty, Titanfall or DOOM when it comes to the feel of shooting.

1. The Amount Of Patches & Overhauls The Witcher 3 Needed

CD Projekt RED

As if it needed spelling out yet again: I adore CD Projekt RED. I think they've deftly taken Bethesda's RPG crown, and The Witcher 3 is one of the most recommendable and essential RPGs of all time.

Advertisement

... But it didn't start out as that.

Whilst I could get on board with Geralt's movement and the inventory/UI systems as they were at launch, Wild Hunt was subject to a staggering amount of meaningful patches across its first few months. All-told there were 26 of them, ranging from fixing bugs, glitches and quest roadblocks to changing things like how Geralt controlled and completely overhauling the game's inventory and pause menus.

Advertisement

Many of these were sizeable changes, and while I applaud CDPR for responding so quickly and optimising their product based on immediate consumer feedback, it doesn't give much hope to the launch day version of Cyberpunk 2077.

If CDPR somewhat struggled to get The Witcher 3 into the state it is now - after two prior instalments, no less - does an all-new sci-fi game in a completely different genre stand a chance?

Advertisement