Death Stranding Review: 9 Ups & 3 Downs

2019's Game of the Year(?)

By Scott Tailford /

Kojima Productions

How to even put the phenomenon that is Death Stranding into words?

Advertisement

You've got the first game from legendary creative mind Hideo Kojima since departing Konami; someone who brought us Metal Gear Solid, Zone of the Enders and P.T. - all financed by PlayStation.

Centred on delivering items from A to B while fighting ghosts and being rammed full of A-list celebrities, it was a barmy idea from the get-go, introduced off the back of CG trailers where a photo-realistic Norman Reedus clutched a tiny foetus and cried in the rain.

Advertisement

Come launch, despite reviews, thousands of players are still asking the question of just what this game "is", and which titles it's comparable to.

To be honest, it's here where Sony have dropped the ball. Death Stranding is not some indescribable mess of pretentious ideas only wine-drinking chin-strokers and philosophical thinkers are going to "get". Instead, it's easily one of the best games of 2019, and a bold, risky attempt to breathe new life into an industry forever falling back on the same bankable formulas.

Advertisement

There's nothing even close to Death Stranding, and it might be the most important release of the generation because of that.

Not everything works, but the vast majority is outstanding.

Advertisement

--

Note: There are zero story spoilers within.

Advertisement

- UPS -

9. Building As A Community Feels INCREDIBLE

Kojima Productions

A major component of Death Stranding is connection. Set in a destroyed, post-apocalyptic world in need of being put back online so resources can be created and shared using supremely capable 3D printers, it's on you to spread word of the "Chiral Network".

Advertisement

Whilst this results in unlocking everything from weapons to vehicles, hiking gear and health packs, you're free to place power generators, watchtowers, safe houses, shelters etc. wherever you like. These are then shared between players, and even though you never see others in person, everyone benefits from an interconnected "web" of assets and interactions.

All items and vehicles can be left in "Shared Lockers" too, so you can willingly donate higher level gear, bikes and trucks to someone who might need them more than you.

Advertisement

Highways also form much bigger investments in terms of how many resources they require (again, shared amongst everyone), but the end result from beginning to end is staggering.

Seeing such a desolate, challenging landscape become overlaid in accessible roads, motorways, bridges etc. as the game progresses is a feeling like nothing else.

Advertisement

8. Redefining Open-World Progression Systems

Kojima Productions

How many open world games this generation have given us a set of abilities, or revealed the entirety of their scope in the opening hour, only to repeat until you get bored?

Advertisement

So many titles fall back on this numbing sensibility, and it gives the impression that you've seen the entire game in the opening stretch. Yes, the numbers go up, you access different tiers of loot, but you're not fundamentally playing in a different way.

Compare to Death Stranding, and literally every few hours, you're unlocking something that completely changes how you interact with the world, or how you consider the base function of getting items from place to place.

Advertisement

Ropes and ladders become bikes and trucks, then become floating platforms and ziplines. Stealthy strangulations become assault rifles and grenades. Basic running and climbing becomes learned routes where you and likeminded players have put down pathways to progress.

It's all tied together to give you an immaculate sense of progression through time and investment, and again, no other open world game is doling out so much over such a massive play time.

Advertisement

7. Some Incredibly Well-Researched Thoughts On Life & Death

Kojima Productions

There's a distinction to be made between the scriptwriting and phrasing itself, and just how much time, research and effort Hideo Kojima has put into the text of this game.

Advertisement

Because at the heart of Death Stranding - without going into spoilers - is a rumination on life, death and purpose.

Characters like Higgs have aesthetics reminiscent of Ancient Egyptian architecture. There are explanations into what's going on that revolve around Egyptian principles of the afterlife and mirror images of our living selves.

Advertisement

Even the fact that Sam can weaponise his fecal matter, urine and blood (I know) feels like Kojima acknowledging the ancient art of "Humorism", where early medicinal techniques centred on our collective excretions for diagnoses and cures.

Ultimately, Death Stranding shoots for a general message of togetherness, community and uniting as one in the face of things like online hatred and political divide, but there's a ton in here about what "living" even is in the first place.

Advertisement

6. The Open-World Is The Game (One Big Level)

Kojima Productions

After the N64 showed off Super Mario 64, the industry started showcasing the fun and engagement of exploring 3D spaces. Platformers did this the most, but we also something like Tomb Raider, where climbing and conquering a towering environment WAS the game.

Advertisement

Then Metal Gear Solid came along, and for the most part, the industry started chasing Hollywood spectacle, with cinematically-rendered cutscenes coming in abundance.

All the "what's it like to make 3D the focus" stuff went away, and largely still is, apart from something like Grow Home or Zelda: Breath of the Wild restoring the notion of exploration being worthwhile and encouraged.

Advertisement

Cut to Death Stranding, and 'getting from A to B' might be the overarching mission "type", but actually doing that requires a ton of skill and investment.

The way this version of America is rendered, you'll encounter bodies of water that need careful navigation, ladders, ropes and ziplines can open up pathways you might otherwise miss, and you'll forever using the shoulder buttons to balance Sam, depending on what you've picked up.

Advertisement

Think about it: How many open-world games treat their travel mechanics as boring busywork in between more designed content?

Death Stranding inverts everything, and gives you a level the size of an entire world.

Advertisement

5. Varied & Conceptually Awesome Characters

Kojima Productions

Kojima has never been short on memorable character designs, and while he might stumble pretty badly (MGS 4's Beauty & the Beast Unit or MGS 5's Quiet), at least they're anything but one-dimensional.

Advertisement

In Death Stranding's case, Kojima has taken on a strange naming convention, calling everyone the most obvious thing yet, depending on what they do.

However, by getting names out the way and treating the role of humanity in this desolate world as more cargo, it forces you to focus on everyone's human qualities even more. If nothing else, calling a character "Deadman" or "Die-Hardman" only makes you wonder what else is going on.

Advertisement

And in this regard, every single main character has a ton of original, innovative components making them up.

Without giving too much away, Fragile's body from top to bottom is a subversive comment on how Hideo has framed women in the past. Mama's title and relationship with her child is fascinating, Higgs embodies his name completely, and Heartman's setup could only exist in this strange reality of life and death combining.

Advertisement

You can tell Kojima had a blast conceptualising the world and its characters, and considering how legendary every last one of MGS' heroes and villains are, it's great to see he's done it again.

4. Snappy & Experimental Combat

Kojima Productions

MGS V: The Phantom Pain is easily one of the best third-person shooters of all time. A snappy, responsive, almost arcadey at times combo of gunfire, melee attacks and experimental item placement, it was a blast engaging in every single combat scenario.

Advertisement

For Death Stranding, Kojima Productions had lost the FOX Engine, and the studio's array of devs had to start over using the Decima Engine, on loan from Sony and Guerrilla Games.

Thankfully though, that sense of tactical, 'sandboxy' play is completely intact, and the blank canvas of potential only creates more insanely fun scenarios.

Advertisement

For example:

- You're free to smash people over the head with cargo for an instant knockout. Grab an enemy's suitcase and do so, then grab what they were holding and do the same to someone else. You can create a chain of melee knockouts in seconds, and they feel incredible.

Advertisement

- Coming over the lip of a hill and seeing a campsite down below can really give off some MGS V vibes. Thinning the ranks with stealth kills is one thing, but you can use a "Sticky Gun" to retrieve stolen packages from afar, slowly winding the chord back to yourself and making a getaway.

- Blood grenades can be used to stun opponents, as can smoke-emitting cargo for distractions. There is a TON of gear to unlock including more regular firearms and bola-firing rifles, but to give all that away would be spoilers.

Advertisement

Point being: This is more of that MGS V combat we knew and loved, and that couldn't be better.

3. A Phenomenally Original World

Kojima Productions

Like the characters and themes that are explored in cutscenes or in-game character "Interviews" you can read at your leisure, the overall world of Death Stranding has a ruleset and level of depth all its own.

Advertisement

Things like whenever it rains, the droplets that hit accelerate cellular degeneration, meaning skin ages or items pass through time faster through contact alone. The existence of small, alien-like "Cryptobiotes" that restore health and have something to do with the phenomena of a crater-filled world.

Ghosts, demons, babies that can see the dead - even the Death Stranding itself, which mostly exists as a mystery, has thrown the idea of life and death as we know it completely out of whack.

Advertisement

Kojima has clearly sat down and thought of an entirely original world, with terminologies and rules that make sense within themselves, and it's a joy to take in.

2. Open-World Horror

Kojima Productions

Alongside carrying towers of packages and engaging in combat with the pirate-style MULES, are regular encounters with "BTs", or "Beached Things".

Advertisement

While the explanation for these would be spoilers, in-game they show up inside the "Timefall" rainstorms that blanket portions of the landscape. Sam's shoulder-mounted "Odradek" scanner will start flashing increasingly fast, and it's up to you to avoid them as best as possible, knowing they're invisible and all around you.

The key thing is though, this ostensibly turns Death Stranding into the world's first open-world horror.

Advertisement

Yes, The Evil Within 2 had certain levels that were mini open-worlds, but nobody has attempted what Kojima Productions have achieved here.

The idea of being beset by demons at any point is one hell of a thing, and that's before you factor it into specific missions like venturing into a collapsed city, or racing to dispose an item before time runs out.

Advertisement

Becoming more comfortable with BTs is like your own Ghostbusters-esque story of understanding how to tell where they are and what hurts them most, but as a mechanic and concept, they enrich the world tenfold just by how they're programmed.

1. It's A New Genre

Kojima Productions

Before launch, Hideo Kojima was talking a lot about this being the first "Strand game" - that Death Stranding would in some form or another, be a whole new video game genre.

Advertisement

And although I've seen plenty of critics lambast this idea or label DS as "an open-world game with fetch quests", that's completely missing the point.

The aforementioned things I noted about a community of players forever contributing to one another changing the landscape in tow while sharing items, weapons and routes, combatting the enemies of this world and "getting America back online" as one? That's something that hasn't been done.

Advertisement

Yes, we've had messages left in Dark Souls, items shared in Animal Crossing or motes of light representing players in Fable 2, but nothing on the scale of this, and nothing with a narrative backbone ostensibly still routing this into a single player mould.

Death Stranding is everything those games were working towards, and something only possible on the current generation of consoles.

Advertisement

It fundamentally needs server interactions and thousands of players working together to function properly, and as of right now, the "Death Stranding experience" is pretty incredible.

- DOWNS -

3. The Script Is Largely Terrible

Kojima Productions

Remember how loosely written and strangely "off" a ton of MGS V's cutscenes and script felt?

Advertisement

That sensation is back in abundance.

Sadly, Hideo Kojima has only become more self-indulgent and whimsical as he's gotten older, and whilst I'm still a humungous fan of his work and approach to art, Death Stranding's script is notably weak.

Advertisement

Loaded with the one takeaway message of togetherness he had when designing the project from the beginning, it results in two types of characters:

Either you're forever stressing the importance of "coming together" at every opportunity, or you've misanthropically given up on everyone, and don't wish for anything to change.

Advertisement

Norman Reedus' Sam Bridges is clearly supposed to wander from the latter to the former, but his arc feels forced, rather than through any particular line read or change in acting over time. So many altercations between him and other characters repeat this core message in a VERY on the nose way, and even when we find out more about the world and its key figures, there's a dreamlike quality to their dialogue and actions that can be distancing, considering the well-researched themes and information given elsewhere.

Death Stranding - and by extension, Kojima - largely wants to eat his cake and philosophise about it too. He wants a poignantly-delivered message on how online spaces have forced us apart; a rumination on togetherness and the importance of fellow humans... but he also wants you to deliver pizzas in the apocalypse, have a baby blow heart-shaped bubbles, or take out a militia with grenades made of poop.

Advertisement

Sure, that is entirely what "A Hideo Kojima Game" is, and while the vast majority is stellar, so much of the script lacks the throughline care and attention of his games prior to MGS V.

2. Physics Will Bug Out A TON

Kojima Productions

Coming from the fact Kojima Productions haven't made an open-world game where traversal was ever anything more than driving a vehicle or hopping on top of a horse, introducing verticality as a major gameplay element has resulted in a handful of hiccups.

Advertisement

Though not anything close to consistent or game-breaking, you will notice just how much Sam awkwardly bounces off the environment at every turn. The squirrelly driving physics of the bike mean it'll sometimes stop dead on a pebble, or leap 20 feet in the air like a Skyrim glitch, damaging cargo on landing.

Descending from any high place is also a cinch, because whilst you do have ropes and ladders, the game's hitboxes are supremely generous, and you can largely just face "into" what you're climbing down, surviving by glitching down to the next suitable foothold, bit by bit.

Advertisement

Vehicles regularly get stuck on the smallest of outcrops or things that just shouldn't effect them, and across the board there's a sensation of characters and environments just not meshing as well as they could.

I reiterate: It's not a game-breaker at all, but you will notice it, and it will stick out.

Advertisement

1. There's A MAJOR Time Investment

Kojima Productions

You do not get an assault rifle in Death Stranding for 20 hours.

Advertisement

Maybe that's all you need to hear depending on where you come down on video games and your personal preferences, but that statement speaks to a wider mentality you need to adopt to enjoy and value the game:

Good things come to those who wait.

Advertisement

Personally, I can say I've loved the game from moment one, but the whole point of this journey to "reunite America" means we need defining beginning and end points.

Death Stranding starts out with humanity on the back foot. Kojima clearly designed the opening hours to represent this, and you'll be making a conscious effort to overcome tumultuous weather and an unforgiving environment. You should feel the struggle here, as it only emphasises how much achievement there is in every other aspect of the game, from community-built structures to story scenes.

Advertisement

And don't get me wrong: All of this IS surmountable, and is not a major challenge. I largely think the people who hand-waved the opening of this away are the same who "got sick of the rain" when climbing in Breath of the Wild**

Regardless, I'm putting this as a "Down" because the story Kojima is telling gets spread across 60+ hours.

Advertisement

Death Stranding is an epic, and it's shooting to put you in specific headspaces and mentalities, just as as much as any story swerves or plot twists.

Know that all of these emotions are intentional - even though gameplay is stellar throughout - and you'll have no problem "getting" the game at all.

Advertisement

--

**Seriously, get Revali's Gale for ginormous jumps, or climb in small increments so you don't slip.

Advertisement