DOOM Eternal Vs DOOM 2016: Which Is Better?
Are iD still the masters?
Back in 2008, the idea for a fourth Doom wasn’t terribly well-received. Mainly, because even though Doom 3 was critically acclaimed when it released in 2004, most would agree that it did not age well. It was overly dark, the action was slow and the scares became very predictable, so the idea of another instalment seemed redundant.
What new territory could Doom 4 possibly explore that others didn’t already exhaust?
Well, revealed in 2014, instead of continuing the story, the decision was made to give the franchise a soft reboot; going back to what made the classics great, but also mixing in the best of the new generation.
This eventually became what we now know as Doom.
Fast-paced and exciting, it successfully brought back the feel of gaming in
the ‘90s with new twist. So, when a sequel was announced, the
gaming community was excited to see what else iD Software could bring to the table.
From the reviews continuously praising everything, it would appear as though they met those expectations. However, did it surpass what Doom 2016 accomplished, or could this be like another Doom 3, where we’ll start picking up the flaws later on?
Let's compare the two head to head, in a series of categories, scoring a winner for each.
10. Visuals – Doom Eternal
When Doom released back in 2016, it was praised for being faithful update to the original classics.
The enemies looked like they jumped out of the 2D plane and flawlessly entered the third dimension. It also perfectly captured the setting of the gritty, hell-infested Mars Research Facility. It was truly a love letter to fans of the old-school shooter. You wouldn’t think that Eternal could do much to improve on the visuals, but they did.
Eternal hit pretty much the same mark with their graphics, beautifully adding the details where it was necessary and keeping true to the original demon designs.
However, Eternal decided to go one step above by giving the player's weapons more effects. When shooting the enemy, their bodies actually deteriorate with every shot - something that isn't usually seen in video games. There’s also more variety to the environments.
Much like Doom 3, Doom 2016 mostly took place on the Mars Research Facility, while sometimes taking a detour through Hell. Eternal wanted to branch out with some new ideas by going to Earth during a demonic invasion. The team wanted to really try and create a Doom universe by featuring larger, more varied locations.
This allowed the player to explore more city-based locations and even an Arctic-style level in the daytime, which was a nice change of pace from those formerly repetitive dark settings.
All told, Eternal's aesthetics are leaps and bounds above what went before.
9. Audio – Tie
When developing the soundtrack to Doom 2016, composer Mick Gordon had a very important objective in mind. He wanted to modernize the original soundtrack with the “utmost respect”, but didn’t want to include electric guitars, fearing that the game would be seen as a joke, like Bill and Ted.
Gordon wanted to convert the game’s “Argent energy” vibe to sine waves and white noise, creating a unique electronic sound in the process. After including some seven and eight-string guitars for a lower tone, the sound we now know as Doom was born.
So, obviously, Mick Gordon was brought on again to work on the soundtrack for Doom Eternal, but he wanted to do something a little different for his second round.
He made a callout for “metal screamers” to participate in the music recording sessions. These screamers included Tony Campos of Static-X, Sven de Caluwe of Aborted, James Dorton of Black Crown Initiate and even the recently deceased Nature Ganganbaigal of Tengger Cavalry.
Both soundtracks do their job of amping up the excitement of single-handedly taking on the forces of Hell, each banging note throbbing while you rip an Imp apart with your bare hands. It’s too difficult to choose who did it best when both did it so perfectly.
8. Easter Eggs & Secrets - Doom Eternal
You can't talk about a Doom game without talking about the many secrets in each level... unless you're talking about Doom 3. Doom 2016 brought this lovable trope back with force, hiding power-ups, collectible toys and even classic Doom levels in each stage of the game.
Unfortunately, while it was cool you could unlock a classic Doom level to play in the new engine, it help the fact that they didn't play very well.
Simply put, they weren't designed to fit the new three-dimensional Doom Slayer and enemies and it really showed. Sure, it was a valiant effort on the developers part but we can all agree that they didn't work. Eternal wanted to go more simple with their Easter eggs and secrets but simply nodding towards Doom Slayer's roots.
Throughout the game, you'll find subtle winks to Doom Slayer's own father, Commander Keen, who had his own game series back in the '90s. You can also collect records that can play various soundtracks in your Fortress of Doom, alongside building your toy collection.
However, the coolest thing you can collect is cheat codes that can affect your gameplay when revisiting old missions. This could include something simple like God Mode or Infinite Ammo, but you can also collect codes that turn blood into confetti and give you crowds that cheer when you nail each brutal kill.
Also, just see what happens when you collect ALL those cheat codes.
7. Pacing And Progression – Doom
While Doom 2016 was a great shooter, it's possible that the developers were afraid that players would criticize the repetitive gameplay. Shoot here, glory kill there, rinse and repeat.
So, they decided to add some platforming sections into the game and, for the most part, they were fine. It added some more definition to the 3D map and made finding secrets more challenging.
However, id Software took this as though they should add more platforming puzzles and exploration, which is fine in some parts, but tedious in others. More times than not, players find themselves looking off the edge of a ledge, trying to find out where the level is trying to take them next.
For the most part, these sections just slowed down the game to a crawl.
Sure the platforming was an improvement from 2016, with more swinging and climbing, but we're not here to play Mirror's Edge, we're here to play Doom. Even the developers knew that the platforming would be trial and error because falling in the abyss was no longer game over like the previous game.
Doom 2016 knew that, at the forefront, the action should be priority number one. Anything else should take a backseat.
6. Difficulty - Doom Eternal
To a lot of seasoned retro-shooter gamers, Doom 2016 was probably a little on the easy side. When you're given a large arsenal of weapons with an even larger ammo depot, the difficulty takes a small dive.
Doom Eternal wanted to fix this problem by giving the Doom Slayer as little ammo as possible and take away his bottomless pistol.
Right off the bat, you're given the shotgun that only hold 18 shells and a chainsaw. If you run out of ammo, use the chainsaw, if you run out of gas, then hope that there are some pickups laying around. Some are split on the higher difficulty, but it does improve the flow of combat. It keeps the action fast-paced and exciting while also forcing the player to strategize each move they make.
Most enemies also have a weak point you can exploit in order swing the odds of survival in your favor. Shooting a revenant's rocket pack or launching a grenade in a cacodemon's mouth with make them easier to dispose of.
You'll want to consider all of these options because one wrong move to be the difference between full health to dying on the spot.
5. Boss Battles - Doom Eternal
Anybody else get chills when the Cyberdemon broke through the doors, grabbed the Doom Slayer and threw him across the room?
Let's not diminish how great the boss battles were in Doom 2016, because they were a perfect combination of everything the player had experienced in the game so far. However, with the exception of the Hell Guards, the Cyberdemon and Spider Mastermind were mostly there for our nostalgia.
That's not a bad thing because the entirety of Doom 2016 was suppose to feel like the original 2D game come to the new gaming generation. This just meant that Eternal had more wiggle room for creativity in their boss battles.
The boss fights perfectly fit the game's new difficult tone because each of them required a different strategy. Without extra plasma rifle rounds, you'll be at the mercy of the Doom Hunters and if you don't perfect your aim, the Gladiator will easily get the better of you.
With Doom 2016's boss battles, you could get an idea on how to beat the enemy rather quick and secure a victory. In Eternal, you'll need all the skills at your disposal in hopes of beating them on your third try, at the very best.
4. Learning Curve - Doom
Okay, so while the new difficulty in Doom Eternal was a welcome change of pace, there was a rather steep learning curve.
The beginning of the game is business as usual, shooting and glory killing, but as the game progressed, your arsenal improves. For example, you're given a shoulder grenade launcher that cools
down after use and napalm fire, which sets enemies ablaze,
making them drop armor pieces.
But that's not all. You're also given a grenade mod that freezes enemies and a new melee weapon that requires "energy" pickups. Still, that's not all, like mentioned before, a lot of enemies have specific weak points you can exploit for the upper hand in a fight.
Remember all that? Well, try remember all that when you have over a dozen enemies throwing projectiles and clawing at you.
A lot of the time, you'll actually forget you have a grenade mod or napalm fire because you're too busy trying to remember which weapon mod will be more useful in the coming fight.
Doom 2016, while obviously not as in depth as Eternal, was much more forgiving to those who couldn't remember a tedious amount of tutorials.
3. Multiplayer – Doom Eternal
One of the biggest criticisms of 2016’s Doom was the less than impressive multiplayer.
It didn’t deliver what was initially promised and what we got were boring generic game modes (Freeze Tag, King of the Hill and Domination) with flawed progression systems. Soon labelled an abandonment of new ideas, the lobbies quickly turned into a ghost town.
Doom Eternal tried something very different: Competitive
cooperative multiplayer and... this is probably going to divide a lot of players.
Eternal’s Battlemode pits two players playing as demons against another who controls the Doom Slayer. Some might say this is a creative mix of cooperative gameplay and others might be a little underwhelmed that it just adds more players to an experience the campaign already gives.
Regardless, Battlemode can add to the quick-thinking, strategy feel of the combat because demon players can summon smaller enemies to the battlefield, block the Slayer’s ability to pick up loot or health, and even create traps.
However, much like normal gameplay, this multiplayer has a steep learning curve as well. When roaming the battle, you’ll be scrambling to remember how to set a trap or summon more allies that you might meet the end of a shotgun before you figure it out.
While not impossible, it does make it tough to get good.
Still, while it does take a while to get the hang of things, it's more entertaining than Doom 2016's multiplayer.
2. Story – Doom
Let’s be honest, story has never the been the most important part of a Doom game. Doom 2016 understood this because, the beginning of the game tries to unload some exposition, but the Doom Slayer responds by immediately smashing the console and ripping demons apart instead.
Granted there is a story going on but it’s never the focus. The focus is always on the carnage you can bring onto Hell’s armies.
Doom Eternal tried to put more emphasis on the story to create a more epic experience, but it came across as too serious and kind of confusing.
At first, it seemed simple, you go to Earth to single-handedly take on the armies yourself, and save what’s left of your home planet.
Well, not exactly.
The game gives some insight to the Doom Slayer, his past, and how everything connects to Earth's current situation. In order to fully understand what is going on, the game expects you to read the many collectible files and PDAs, which is something most will probably not do.
Not that a more involved story couldn’t be interesting, but Doom 2016 took a welcomed major shift in the franchise’s tone, going from horror vibe to a more silly, over-the-top action blockbuster vibe.
This recent instalment messes with that tone and it just feels like a weird move on iD's part.
1. Conclusion - Doom Eternal
Coming in with the winning score of 6 - 4, id Software and Bethesda's newest instalment proves that this franchise is nowhere near out of gas. But, don't let this make you look down on the previous Doom game or make you think twice about trying Eternal.
Doom 2016 managed to do the impossible: Take an idea from the '90s and modernize it for a whole generation, while still pleasing diehard fans.
Eternal was able to build upon this idea and create a more challenging and unique experience.
Sure, Doom 2016 was a little too easy in some parts and the multiplayer was uninspired. Yeah, Eternal's story was complicated and the learning curve was too steep, but that's just something the developers can improve on next time.
For now, let's just enjoy jumping back into the fray and raining hell on the armies of Hell.