E3 2018: Every Conference Ranked Worst To Best

Who came out on top?

By Jack Pooley /

Insomniac

E3's annual parade of conferences is over for another year, and it's safe to say that 2018's series of shows were a little on the soft side as the current generation of gaming begins to wind down.

Advertisement

Expectations were high regardless - as they always are - yet sadly not a single of the Big Three really delivered the home-run show fans were hoping for.

Much like last year's E3, the more low-key nature of the reveals and announcements paled in comparison to previous E3s of this generation, presumably as the likes of Microsoft and Sony start holding back content to be revealed once the PS5 and new Xbox consoles have actually been announced.

Advertisement

Ultimately, most of the E3 surprises this year were negative omissions of expected titles rather than megaton shockers, and while next year's E3 should be a little more exciting - fingers crossed - 2018's was generally a safer and less interesting effort than most were desiring...

8. Square Enix

Square Enix

Square Enix's half-hour livestream can only scarcely be called a conference, and their showing here was so utterly piecemeal you have to wonder why they really bothered.

Advertisement

The widely-expected Avengers Project no-showed, we heard nothing more about Final Fantasy VII Remake, got a weird, ambiguous teaser for new action game The Quiet Man, and saw a technically sloppy, badly-edited trailer for Kingdom Hearts III.

Aside from introducing PlatinumGames' new IP Babylon's Fall and smartly going the pre-recorded route after 2015's laughable live show, this was extremely disappointing and a far cry from what most fans were expecting.

Advertisement

Ultimately, this felt like an arbitrary show lazily cobbled together to appease investors rather than one to actually get fans excited about upcoming titles.

Rating: 3/10

Advertisement

7. EA

EA

For the most part this was your typical EA conference: it had a ton of corporate speak aimed at investors and placed an excessive, exhausting emphasis on sports.

Advertisement

We also had to suffer through possibly the most underwhelming formal announcement of a Star Wars game in the history of the medium and the depressing reveal that Command & Conquer is now a mobile game franchise.

Battlefield V's presence was meanwhile surprisingly scant, EA once again struggled to convince that Anthem is anything more than another generic open-world squad-based shooter, and we have to dock them an extra point for teasing Skate fans with that Session reveal.

Advertisement

However, Unravel Two was a wonderful surprise and the best shadow-drop of E3 - the game's awesome too, by the way - while EA's contrition regarding lootboxes seemed at least half-way genuine.

Were it not for the reveals of Unravel Two and new indie Sea of Solitude, though, this would've been a pretty soulless conference. Maybe one of these years EA will surprise us with a vibrant show, but sadly not this time.

Advertisement

Rating: 4.5/10

6. PC Gaming Show

Shedworks

The PC Gaming Show is often mocked as "the boring E3 show", what with its more technical focus on chipsets and the intricacies of PC gaming.

Advertisement

However, the show kept tech talk impressively brief this year, focusing instead on an absolute smattering of games. There was something for just about every type of PC gamer here, even if the show's near-two-hour length also meant that long stretches of the show probably offered up nothing for you.

There was perhaps a Battle Royale game or two too many, but some truly intriguing titles got their moment in the spotlight - especially Maneater, Sable (pictured above) and Ooblets - and host Sean Plott aka Day9 continues to be a charming host, with an uncanny ability for offsetting some of his awkward guests.

Advertisement

Again, though, it was far too long for what it was, and honestly, was anyone talking about it the next day?

Rating: 5.5/10

Advertisement

5. Bethesda

Bethesda

We're going to be a little controversial here and actually grade Bethesda's show lower than most seem to have, because as immediately compelling as it was to see Starfield and The Elder Scrolls VI formally announced, those logo reveals ultimately didn't amount to much.

Advertisement

The main issue with Bethesda's show was the horrible pacing: it was almost 15 minutes before we saw a scrap of gameplay, and the Andrew W.K. musical number was wasted on a dead crowd who (hilariously) didn't care.

There was far too much of a focus on card and mobile games, a ton of cringey chatter and the disappointing lack of gameplay for Doom Eternal.

Advertisement

However, Rage 2 was able to pretty much steal the show as a result, new offerings for Prey and Wolfenstein look neat, and we got a convincing deep dive into Fallout 76. Plus, as brief as its reveal was, it was certainly satisfying to have Starfield finally confirmed after all these years.

Overall, it was a frustrating showing from Bethesda: this was often a legitimately poor conference, yet was ultimately propped up by some great moments and the indefatigable charm of director Todd Howard.

Advertisement

Rating: 5.5/10

4. Ubisoft

Ubisoft

This was a totally typical Ubisoft conference as expected: kind of embarrassing in places (though less so than in recent years) with a big focus on extremely familiar AAA franchises.

Advertisement

Disappointingly there weren't any big new game reveals from the likes of Splinter Cell, Prince of Persia or Watch Dogs 3, and the over-abundance of cinematic trailers quickly became exhausting. Plus, unless you're really into Assassin's Creed, the Odyssey extended look was a bit of a flat way to end the show.

Still, the Trials Rising announcement was awesome, Beyond Good and Evil 2 continues to be by far Ubisoft's most intriguing upcoming project, and getting back into bed with Nintendo for Mario + Rabbids Donkey Kong DLC and a Star Fox-themed version of Starlink: Battle for Atlas sure isn't bad.

Advertisement

And whether it was for you or not, their extensive, continued support for Rainbow Six Siege and For Honor should definitely be lauded. Neither among Ubi's best or worst-ever E3 shows, this was basically fine.

Rating: 6/10

Advertisement

3. Nintendo

Nintendo

Much like Bethesda's show, Nintendo's Direct livestream was a real mix of highs and lows. Super Smash Bros. Ultimate looks absolutely fantastic and the Direct did a fantastic job selling it, but the demo also ran far too long, making it abundantly clear that Nintendo just didn't have much else to show fans.

Advertisement

The biggest sticking point is Metroid Prime 4's absence, as well as the lack of fun, surprising announcements (with leaks mostly taking the wind out of the show's sails ahead of time).

Fortnite getting shadow-dropped was great and it's always nice to hear about a new Fire Emblem, but ultimately the show was propped up almost single-handedly by Smash, even if Nintendo also made it outstay its welcome.

Advertisement

Rating: 6/10

2. Sony

Insomniac

Sony's show was another weird one. The gameplay reveals of the core games were excellent - and it was certainly smart to announce their focus on just a few games ahead of time - but the wildly unnecessary "intermission" as the live crowd moved to a new location was an awful idea that should never be repeated.

Advertisement

The main disappointment here was the lack of high-profile games that had no-showed all the previous conferences up this point. Sony had to shoulder a lot of hope that they'd "save" E3, and they basically didn't, even if almost everything they showed off nevertheless looked pretty great (save for Remedy's middling, over-familiar sci-fi actioner Control).

In isolation, gameplay reveals for The Last of Us Part II, Ghost of Tsushima and Death Stranding looked especially fantastic, while Resident Evil 2 Remake finally got its belated reveal, and Nioh 2's even on the way, so that's nice.

Advertisement

This wasn't a show to remember like Sony's stunning conferences from 2015 and 2016, though, and clearly a product of them preparing to wrap this generation up and not wanting to announce PS5 titles yet.

Rating: 6.5/10

Advertisement

1. Microsoft

Microsoft

And finally, Microsoft scarcely won E3 solely by way of serving up the most consistent, best-paced and least disappointing conference, even if it was hardly a fantastic showing from them either.

Advertisement

The opening Halo: Infinite reveal fell a little flat through its lack of follow-up information, while Gears 5's announcement was fine but not particularly interesting.

The biggest disappointment here was that Microsoft didn't sell Game Pass or the Xbox Brand as a whole hard enough. That said, the focus was on games, games, games, with over 50 titles being featured throughout their snappy show.

Advertisement

MS got the honour of debuting Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, Devil May Cry 5, Cyberpunk 2077 and the new Battletoads, while Forza Horizon 4 looks rad, and acquiring four new studios (while creating a fifth) shows a firm commitment to the future of the brand.

Plus, we even got a vague mention of the next Xbox console, which was neat. It wasn't a great show that decisively won E3 this year, but it was nevertheless the best performance in a pretty mild year.

Advertisement

Rating: 7/10

How would you rate this year's E3 conferences? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement