Fallout 4: 8 Huge Problems Nobody Wants To Admit

More like Fallout 3.5.

By Scott Tailford /

It's safe to say the vast majority of gamers are cautiously optimistic about Fallout 4. It comes from a seasoned developer who've tested the waters multiple times with all sorts of experimental game designs and mechanics, its world has an established canon that's endlessly rewarding - and the very idea of a spruced-up post-apocalyptic setting is a context ripe for exploration and perilous combat scenarios. However, following the initial buzz of "Holy *^&£ it's actually happening", many forum-posters (myself included) have been voicing concerns about how the game is rolling out, with the general oppositional consensus being "Shut up dude, it's Fallout!" Now, that's all well and good, and regardless of anything I'm about to shine a light on, November 10th will indeed release what'll be the most feature-complete Fallout yet; one with perfected control schemes, intricately detailed levels and a character progression only Bethesda can do like no other. That said though, I'm sure I'm not alone in addressing that niggling sensation that something's amiss with just how 'off' many aspects of its production seem. So, in the spirit of dissuading deflated launch day hype before it's too late, let's address them right now and temper expectations a little.

8. The Whole 'It's Fallout 3 Perfected' Angle Is A Problem

From the opening few shots of the debut trailer, through to the gameplay impressions critics are reporting from Gamescom 2015, there's something decidedly 'un-sequel'-looking about Fallout 4, in that it almost looks like a visual overhaul of part three. That's not necessarily a bad thing depending on what you go to a Fallout game for (thousands of us still journey through Bethesda's 2008 wasteland just for kicks), but as we saw such a huge leap forward in terms of features from Fallout 3 to New Vegas, 4 appears to be sprucing up the colour palette, and not much else. You can very much tell Bethesda have doubled down on answering every criticism of Fallout 3, from far more impressive animation to ironing out bugs and glitches, to even removing the level cap and letting you continue to explore the world after the credits, remedying where F3 initially went so wrong. All of these things go a huge way into making an incredible experience that plays how you always wanted the older games to in the first place, but I'm struggling to find aspects that really make F4 stand out on its own. Which brings me to...

7. Where Are The New Features?

Go on, what's Fallout 4's defining feature? What can you absolutely not wait to get your hands on and experience? Chances are you're envisioning doing more of the same gameplay features as before, and although Fallout fans are a hard bunch to please when it comes to iteration, Bethesda have put in the likes of crafting and more world detail as direct responses to criticism, leaving the only notable 'all-new' feature as base-building. The idea of building your base just isn't that appealing when the core appeal of your game is exploration and moving from place to place. It begs the question of why would you want to repeatedly come back to an HQ-style setup when you can rest up on the go and keep moving? This core idea was patched into Skyrim through the Homestead DLC, something that left the option up to those who want to take their level of role-playing immersion to the next level, but for the standard Fallout player who's rarely hanging out in one spot unless they're taking up quests, it's a strange thing to showcase as a unique selling point.

6. It's Too Gun-Happy For Fallout Fans, Not Enough For Casuals

Bethesda obviously have a hugely profitable franchise in their midst, and even though for every comment stating Fallout's 3 and New Vegas are still the best RPGs of all time, you'll get another fan of the older games stating how they "just aren't Fallout". Maybe they are, maybe not - I go with the notion that whatever a creator's mark of approval gets stamped on, means it's worthy of the name (that's what's got me through being a Metallica fan, anyway). That said, the extremely gun-filled gameplay demo at E3 that ended on a jet-boosting mech-fight rubbed plenty up the wrong way, whilst on the flip-side any prospective consumers drawn in by this stuff would be roundly put off by the crafting, stat-management and base-building aspects everywhere else. Fallout 4 is in danger of appealing to everybody and nobody at the same time, and whilst fans need to be more accommodating of modern game design aspects that make the experience more immediately fun and engaging, that split approach can really scupper any sense of both identity and playability.

5. We Still Can't Trust Bethesda

Following Fallout 3 and Skyrim (the latter having some positively nightmarish graphical hitches when the web-winged dragons started contorting or getting up in your face), it's impossible to trust Bethesda can deliver a product that's as polished as say, Batman: Arkham Knight (save for the PC version) or GTA V, being they've never come close in the past Things bode well as they've assumedly held off announcing Fallout 4 was coming until everything was completely polished to a mirror sheen, but time will tell if any aspect of the game's world or production has been scaled back to allow for a higher degree of fidelity across the board. Many fans of the studio's games tend to reconcile themselves to accepting the bugs for the sake of a world and experience no one else can deliver, but in a climate where quite literally every single majorly-release game in the last year has needed multiple patches or was straight-up broken on launch - it really doesn't give you hope Fallout 4 (of all things) can break the trend.

4. Time Shouldn't Move In V.A.T.S

As I've mentioned, Bethesda really are taking note of every last possible criticism of Fallout 3, but one I'm personally really disappointed they've changed is the aspect of V.A.T.S stopping time. Beforehand, you could treat this as an XCOM-style 'pause and collect your thoughts' button, allowing you to take stock of your surroundings, plan which items or weapons you were going to use, weigh up percentage-chances of connecting with the distance of enemies, and mostly just prevent the game devolving into an overly frantic mess. Now V.A.T.S doesn't stop time, it only slows it down (something you'll hopefully be able to upgrade to the point where it freezes again), meaning you really don't get the chance to do any of the aforementioned things. Many critics mentioned this older mode allowed players to just 'game the system', popping in to constantly ensure better contact with weapons, but I don't think it proved V.A.T.S' time-dilating strategic elements were inherently bad. The entire point of V.A.T.S is to get away from the up close n' personal nature of gunfighting, and if the problem was that it was too easily accessible, then remedy that with a more strict cooldown timer, rather than let you pop into it more frequently but cripple its utility in the field.

3. Fallout 4 Is Only Bethesda's Second Fallout Game

Seems strange to read, doesn't it? Strange, but true. Bethesda actually acquired the rights from Black Isle Studios following that company's dissolution, converting the in-progress 'Van Buren' codename into what would then become their own Fallout 3. Following that we got the now-legendary instalment, but it was also one that sparked the divide in the fanbase that exists to this day. After 3's release Bethesda went on to make Skyrim, before letting Obsidian take the reigns on New Vegas; a semi-sequel that many lovers of the original two games preferred, thanks to its more varied colour palette, robust features and better sense of immersion. It's only now, where seven years later they're returning once again to such a divisive franchise, that we're seeing what the proper 'next step' for the main thread of Fallout games is. In many ways that either reinforces or dissipates the fear against why it's all looking so similar, point being; Bethesda are still getting used to a series that's barely associated with them, and that's either cause to play it safe, or to continue perfecting their original vision until it's the defined take on the mythology.

2. An Increased Focus On Gun Combat Will Lower Class Variation

Considering the game's out on November 10th, now would be the perfect time to step away from the gunfire and gasoline-soaked set-pieces of helicopter-explosions, as anyone who played Fallout by focussing on the stealthier aspects of their character is all but being ignored. You can understand the need to showcase the most crowd-pleasing and instantly memorable parts of your game at a debut conference like E3, but when Gamescom's showing was a behind-the-scenes gathering of press officials who could've had a far more in-depth breakdown of everything the game has to offer... they ended up being shown more grenade-tossing, turret-detonating action spectacles instead. V.A.T.S./Vault-Tec is definitely the way I'll be playing, but once you've had one playthrough where you're blasting the living daylights out of everything, you have to imagine there'll be cause for replayability on a purely mechanical level, rather than playing a firearms-focussed build with modded silenced weapons, just to 'force' the game into letting you try something else. Skyrim pulled this off perfectly, the first few moments of gameplay in either a mage or melee class being hugely contrasting. So far it looks like Fallout 4 is a dedicated first-person shooter when it comes to how you play it - which is a style that's overshadowing the variation hinted at in previous instalments.

1. The Perfect 'Fallout Experience' Is Already Out There

As I mentioned earlier, Fallout fans either fall into two camps: One, the scorned former lovers of Black Isle's work from the first two games, who forever state F3 was 'a bad Fallout game' as they enjoyed New Vegas thanks to having returning members of BI on-staff. And two, people accepting of the newer direction as 'their' Fallout, but who after seeing Fallout 4's almost candy-coated graphical approach, are willing Bethesda to put something more apocalyptically-tinged into its presentation all the same. May I thereby point the defendant in the direction of Exhibit A, Metro: Last Light, and B, Wasteland 2? The former is developer 4A Games tale of a humanity rebuilding following a nuclear fallout, whereby many have fled underground to survive. Playing as Russian ranger Artyom in a weighty first-person mould, you get to explore the various facets of life, culture, religion and more as people rebuild themselves and raise a new generation based on the remnants of what was recoverable after the blast. There's nothing as introspective and well executed in terms of a scenario you can walk through as many of Last Light's underground areas, and combat-wise things like having to clean your visor, doggedly watch your ammo count and genuinely struggle to stay on the surface all contribute to one hell of a 'Fallout-style experience' that feels progressive, weighty and memorable. Then there's Wasteland 2, co-developed by inXile Entertainment and Obsidian (the latter comprised of staff that worked on the original Fallout titles). Essentially the lost Fallout game they never got to make, it is hands-down the perfect continuation of those games' project directions left off.
The isometric camera creates a sense of being and exploration that many fans have mentioned just doesn't come across in first-person, and when the combat is turn-based, you can spend hours speccing characters in thousands of ways and the interlinked upgrade paths and gameplay systems take hours to perfect; it's the 'pen n' paper'-style RPG that Fallout will never be again. Maybe it's time for all those so vehemently opposed to 'old' or 'new' Fallout, to just admit there are better experiences out there from developers with far less to lose, and let Fallout 4 be something of a middle-child that caters to both in smaller ways. Is that the real huge problem? Let us know in the comments below.