With rumors and sadly fake trailers circling the web about an upcoming sequel to Bethesda's new age take on PC gaming's best RPG series ever, it's hard not to speculate what might or might not make the cut in the final edition of the fabled Fallout 4. Though no company has made any official claims that a third installment to the Bethesda Fallout line is or will be in the works, Bethesda was quite clear in 2008 when they told TVG that they intend to make several Fallouts. Now, with Fallout: New Vegas losing its steam, and Skyrim still generating new DLC, but beginning to slow down, Bethesda turns its attention to other projects. Their website currently only lists Prey 2 and Dishonored as their current titles in the works, but as fans of the company know, Bethesda doesn't abandon successful properties. They let them sit for a few years, and then announce to the world that they have been quietly working on a new installment, presumably while flying around in a magic sleigh pulled by flying reindeer. That's how I envision Bethesda, by the way. So, if an eventual sequel to the now world famous series does get made (whether it be by Bethesda or a company which purchases license to produce the game), what massive improvements would we, the audience, need from it? How can a great game be made better? What mistakes could be fixed? Why am I typing questions to myself? Well, ladies and gentlemen, you'll find the answers to all these questions (except one) if you read on.........
9. Increased Customization
I know that's a pretty broad request to make, but don't worry, I've got plenty of ink and paper with which to flesh out the details. Some people might say that Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas already had a decent amount of customizable options, what with all the beards and perks. Grant it, the recent additions to the Fallout series have had so e level of customization, but with a game as expansive as the Fallout series the character's options must be as daunting as the options the rest of the world presents. If the character feels limited, then the limitless game universe feels like it has artificial restrictions in it. Enough complaining on my part. How about some examples of how it could be improved. A) Stats One of the only true complaints I've had with the new Bethesda made Fallouts is the stat system. Every character I made felt streamlined into one of two roles. A lot of that had to do with the companion system limiting players to a simgle buddy (not including the dog) and the lack of chances to talk your way out of trouble. But an expanded stat system would give players more options, such as specializing in a certain weapon, lying/bullying/offering sex instead of just a speech skill, or using poisons to tip their melee weapons. B) Clothing There is absolutely no doubt that the clothing options in Fallout 3 (F3) and Fallout: New Vegas (FNV) looked awesome. The raider clothes made of old tires and other junk not only pleased the eye, but offered tangible products of a post apocalyptic fight for survival. But when I learned I couldn't fashion my own makeshift armor from refuse lying around in the derelict landscape, I was heart broken. I wanted to nail a tire to my shoulder myself, damnit. I wanted to wear combat boots, pink panties, and a bunny mask. But alas, I could only wear that amazing outfit in my room while playing. There are obviously rendering/clipping, memory, and programming time issues to take into account. However, ideally in Fallout 4 the player would be able to build makeshift armor pieces one at a time. That means they could fashion gauntlets, shoulder pads, a chest piece, a helmet, boots, and pants that were all to their liking and combine them into whatever pattern they felt fit their fashion needs. That said, I would hope that Bethesda would at least include a few pre made craftable armor sets for us to enjoy searching for. D) Race Plain and simple. I want to be a friggin super mutant. I've been waiting for he opportunity for years. Do it, Bethesda. Do it, right now. Need a few extra years to develop the skins for armor for a mutant? I don't care. Do it. Need to charge me 5% more on top of the price so you can afford to render 50 selectable ghoul faces? I don't care. Do it. C-7) Weapons One of my favorite parts of Fallout 2 and F:NV was the ability to add pieces to your weapons. The hunting rifle could be equipped with a better scope, you had the option of obtaining an extended clip for the 9mm, etc. With the modded weapons available, my rifle was no longer just a rifle; it was Betty. And Betty didn't take any crap from anyone. Period. Unfortunately, the system was limited to a few specific modifications for a few specific weapons. That's not to say the system was bad, it just felt a bit hollow. Adding a few dozen more mods would be the obvious answer to the problem, but why stop there? If Bethesda were to add an increased number of craftable mods, or even better, allow the player to customize their weapons extensively, then Betty and I could really get down and dirty. And then....then I would be truly happy.
8. Perk Downsides
Something that stood out in Fallout: Tactics was the ample availability of perks. There were hundreds. But the great thing about the, was that many of the best perks had a significant downside. For instance, you could pick up a character with the "glowing one" perk, who would heal when exposed to radiation, but would constantly irradiate your teammates. The presence of these downsides gave the game a distinct feeling of give and take that perfectly matched the post apocalyptic world's need for sacrifice in order to stay alive. Perhaps more importantly it helped to create distinct and specialized characters. If a member of your squad had the "glowing one" perk, you could then turn that character into a stealth/sniper. Sure, he could never stand near his teammates in a frontal assault, but he could easily sneak into an unguarded irradiated area and provide supporting fire while constantly receiving a health bonus to protect him, if he started taking fire. The new Fallout series lacks these kind of perks, for the most part. But there's no real reason to leave them out of the mix. Not everyone would want to specialize in one thing, but for those of us who might like to feel a little more realistic, the option would be very much appreciated.
7. More Hardcore Mode Options
The Addition of a "Hardcore Mode" which required the player to eat, sleep, and drink throughout the game was perhaps Bethesda's greatest contribution to the Fallout series. You know, other than suing the original developer, Interplay, and rescinding Interplay's rights to make an MMO. But that's neither here nor there. What I'm getting at is that Fallout: New Vegas was the first game to feel like the player was out to survive, instead of upend the entire wasteland without any effort. There were times when having hardcore mode active went totally unnoticed. And, there were other times when I found myself scraping through every trash can and abandoned box I saw because I had zero water left in my inventory. While those hardcore options gave the game a more involved feel, they were still a bit weak for the tastes of many gamers. In theory, the game could be expanded to allow for several hardcore options, letting players pick and choose the exact style of game they wanted to play. Maybe they found sleeping in game to be just monotonous, but got a kick out of needing to see a doctor to fix a limb. Well, why not let them set up a game that accommodates their specific wants. Further, why stop at the same system from F:NV? There are literally hundreds of ways to make the hardcore option more realistic, many of which could greatly increase the game experience. Long term poisons/venom, a less accurate map, need for batteries to power certain helpful devices, and disease are just a few options that Fallout could offer the player as a means of increasing their challenge. Of course, the ultimate challenge was the one that the original two Fallout games had, a mission timer. Though it might seem like an artificial restriction in a vast and unexplored world, the timer from the first Fallout had me on the edge of my seat. I won't drop any spoilers for people who haven't played it, but eventually you realize that unless you stop farting around the Mojave Desert and actually do what you set out to do in the first place, a lot of people are going to die. That's not a mechanic that everyone would want, since many people thrive on he exploratory aspect of the game. However, writing in space for the option, that's just good marketing on the part of Bethesda.
6. A Better Soundtrack
Remember how awesome it was the first time Three Dog popped up on your Pipboy radio and started howling out golden oldies? There was a certain rush of excitement that followed the first radio announcement detailing your exploits in the wasteland. You knew you were part of something bigger, something that would interact with you. Remember how excited you were the thousandth time you heard that radio announcement, right after you had heard the same song the the billionth time? No? Neither do I. Weird. Bethesda claimed early on that Fallout: New Vegas would offer players about 100 hours of gameplay. So, why then did they only include about 15 minutes of radio? Was this not a lesson we learned early on in the sandbox genre? After being showered with similar complaints, Rockstar Games made massive efforts to beef up the radio in GTA: Vice City. The result? Not only did the complaints cease, but the soundtrack itself generated revenue in the form of a station by station collection of CDs that is still available for purchase. However, after receiving similar complaints about Fallout 3, nothing at all was done. It is certainly harder to develop such a variety of radio stations, DJs and songs in the Fallout universe, since the wasteland is, by nature, supposed to be largely devoid of modern technological conveniences. However, if they found a way to include a 24/7 violin only radio station run by an old woman who apparently never sleeps, they can find a way to give the next Mr. New Vegas more than 10 records to play.
5. Weather
Nothing complicated and nothing doing. Nothing would set the mood better than a little acid rain and nuclear ash falling from the sky. The Fallout worlds were often accused of being a bit bland. Well duh, they take place in a burnt out, nuked desert. But one way to spice up life a bit would be to add a bit of dynamics to the weather situation. That might not work in modern day deserts, but who's to know how weather would be different after a nuclear war?
4. Interactable "Bad Guy" Factions
I'm tired of always having to play the hero. Even when there are options presented that allow me to act like an evil bastard, they never really benefit me. What's more entertaining that defending a village from raiders? Being a raider and tearing the village to shreds. That's what. Why? Because I have dark and violent urges that only find themselves purged through the acting out of my perverse fantasies in videogames. Also, because it's just a stupid video game, and the whole point is to do stuff you would never even consider doing in the real world. Raiders, slavers, The Enclave, The Supermutants, and many more. That's who I want to hang out with at parties, as I sip bourbon from a car muffler and lounge in a Lay-z-Boy I snagged from some other dude's house. Just think of the amazing side quests you could get working for criminals. No more rescuing 12 legged cats from trees. No, no. You'd be PUTTING cats in trees, like a total anarchist. Fallout has always capitalized on the option of being able to be the bad guy, but the player has never really been able to do that on a large scale (excluding the choice to join The Legion, but really, that wasn't the most involved choice, since there total benefits package was "join The Legion, maybe don't die immediately"). Sure, you can just plain murder people, but that isn't quite as fun as joining a group of bounty hunters that hunts down military officers and sells them to the Legion. Tell me you wouldn't want to do that at least once. If you told me, I don't believe you. Everyone wants to be the bad guy, at least for a minute. And so, Fallout 4 should most definitely give us the option of siding with the bad guys more often.
3. Bigger Towns
Simply put, New Vegas felt tiny. Everything in both the new Fallout games felt tiny. There were towns of 8 people, and bustling cities of 20. Since Elder Scrolls 3, Bethesda has spent tons of money and time on perfecting the look and feel of towns, and the end result has been some amazing cities, especially those in Morrowind. However, their cities have always felt a bit lack luster in terms of population. Grant it, Fallout is in the wasteland, and there aren't supposed to be thriving metropolises of millions of folks living in skyscrapers and dining in wine and cheese. Save that crap for George A. Romero movies. But, when the only single sizable settlement is New Vegas, it makes the entire game feel too sparse. In Fallout 1 it was OK to be sparse, because humans were just starting to crawl back out of their caves and vault to put things back together. New Vegas, on the other hand is set in a time where they have hydro-electric power, paper money, and war. Surely there must be more than one city with a large population. There are sure to be smaller settlements across the wasteland, which consist of a family or two trying to make it on their own. And, there are certain to be issues the prevent programmers from making cities of thousands. But, at least a few cities with a population upwards of 50 would make Fallout 4 worth playing for days. The amount of internal exploration that could be done in such an urban microcosm would be enthralling. The list of side quests that could be programmed into a town of that size is too big to even address, but one thing is for sure, doing the missions in a place that felt that alive and full of diversity would give players real reason to keep playing after the main quest line finished.
2. Increased Karma Importance
Measuring moral decisions on a +/- scale can't possibly be an easy thing to do. I mean, there are literally hundreds of different standards by which to assign values of good and bad, and very few of them are as simple as "drowning people good, saving nuns bad". When companies like Interplay, Bioware, Bethesda, or others set out to build systems of moral measurement, based on a numbers, such as the Fallout Karma system, I imagine it's as daunting a task as anyone has ever attempted in a videogame. And to be fair, it works pretty well for the most part. But in the newer games, especially New Vegas, there was a simplicity to the Karma system that clearly strove for moral ambiguity, but landed somewhere between apathetic and unimaginative in that murky "good enough for government work" section of philosophy. OK, it made sense that blasting a random passerby in the face with a shotgun just so I could help myself to his iguana on a stick is bad. There was little to gain and the cost was high (buckshot isn't cheap). But, not everything fits into such a clear cut category. For instance, shortcut that the developers took in New Vegas was that NCR troops all had good Karma, and Legion troops all had Bad Karma. Kill an NCR trooper, you get evil points. Kill a Legion trooper, you get good points. Yet the game presented the choice of aligning yourself with one of the two as a moral choice available to the player. How can it be up to the player if the game is already telling you one is evil and one is good? The dichotomous system led to such a simple choice that the Karma system kind of seemed pointless, unless you count the radio announcements as worthy goal, which is understandable since you have to hear them every five freaking minutes. Next time around, Bethesda would do well to take the focus off "kill based Karma" and put it on specific actions. No one is either good or bad in the real world, and the NPCs shouldn't be either. Most people make some kind decisions and some really cruel choices as well. One of the ways the original games dealt with this was by introducing stigmas, mostly negative ones. If you were mostly a good guy, but from time to time went around digging up graves for extra cash, word would spread and people would treat you accordingly. They would say, "There goes that Johnson boy. It sure is nice of him to take care of his grandmother so often. Maybe he's hoping she'll be buried with her valuables." Or, if you needed quick cash, you could join the slavers guild. Of course, that meant getting a tattoo on your head that drew some pretty serious positive/negative reactions from different factions of NPCs. You could even become a famous porn star (how famous depended on your stamina and charisma traits), which would get you huge charisma boosts with seedy folks. I could go on at great length, but I'll save you the mental imagery of me being a pixelated porn star and just get to the point. The Karma choices in Fallout 3 and F:NV just didn't seem all that important, because the world didn't give all that much of a crap about it. Sure, some of the bigger choices stood out a bit, but even those seemed to have a lack of staying power. The best example is the most obvious: I blew Megaton sky high the first time I played Fallout 3. Screw those people. Yet within minutes it seemed like everyone had forgotten about it. Sure there is other stuff happening, around the wasteland but you would think that word would spread about the guy who rigged an atomic bomb to blow, and people wouldn't be all that happy when they ran into him. And I don't just mean the occasional token Ranger/bounty hunter patrol. That is just a cop out. So let's have it, Fallout. Make my choices stick with me, so that the next time I play through, I have to actually consider the consequences of my actions.
1. Ditch the PG-13 BS
There's been a lot of chatter about this one on the internet since Fallout 3 came out, but sit down and relax, because I intend to settle this argument once and for all. See, Gamer A says, "Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas aren't true to the genre, because the player can't kill children." Gamer B says, "Dude, that is seriously messed up. You should not be allowed to harm children even in a virtual environment." Developers say, "Look, it's not a big deal. There's no need to actually kill a child." And a senator that has never seen a game says, "Hibbity Jibbity, games make you eat people." All of them are right. That's the sad truth. Even the senator has a small nugget of truth, unlike the quotes I used. How then can such an argument be settled? Well, it can't. It can't because we lack the shared definitions with which to find a greater truth. I say videogames are art, and art should never be censored. You say they're entertainment, and entertainment should be censored. I present studies disproving the implied effect of viewing violence, you present studies proving it. Nothing gets solved; mostly because we've both forgotten what we're talking about. So what's my point? Are cheerleaders being sexualized a controversial thing? Yes, but they are in Madden games, because they're in the NFL. Is the coldblooded murder of a foreign national a bad thing? Yes, but you can do that all you want in MW3, because that's what's tactical response teams do.These things are bad, but they are necessary to capture the spirit of the game that is being developed. Without them, the game would work, just not as well. Making a game about the lawless wasteland that demands people follow your presupposed moral code is like making a basketball game in which players are not allowed to shoot from mid-court. Yes, the decision probably only affects the 10% of players who choose to shoot the moment they touch the ball. But those who do want to shoot from mid court find themselves enraged that you have imposed such an arbitrary restriction on them. Only in Fallout it's much worse, because the player is supposed to be interacting with a world devoid of laws and standards. The freedom to do as you wish goes with post apocalyptic gaming in the same way that the freedom to do exactly what you're told goes with FPS gaming. Look, I don't want to massacre a kid in every town I visit. And, there are plenty of other mature options that were taken out of the new Fallout games, such as the ability to be a prostitute, join up with organized crime, round up slaves for money, and lots lots more. The short of it is, the game isn't complete without total freedom. And the new additions to the series don't have the same level of freedom that the originals did, because Bethesda understands that gaming is becoming a younger and younger hobby. Fine, we get that. You gotta make a buck, and an M rating is not the way to reach a wide audience since many companies won't even stock M games. All I'm asking is: would it kill you to push the envelope a little, or at least release adult rated DLC that would let us play the game we want to play, not the game we're being forced to play?