My animosity towards the player ratings often put forward by the overlords at EA has moved me to greater lengths than simply criticise them in a short article; if EA are interested I have a 3 hour powerpoint with 876 slides and 18 musical numbers telling them how they do this the completely wrong way. But for now, as we wait for the release of this year's addition to the behemoth footballing game franchise on Friday, we will focus our attention only on the demo and the small amount of teams which EA Sports have so far presented us with, and the player ratings errors involved there. While the gameplay is once more impeccable; their approach to player ratings borders on the lazy and they have missed vital steps in a positive direction by not paying more attention to the specifics and labelling players on reputation... Or sometimes just seeming to make things up off of the top of their heads. So, here we go with the 6 ratings EA Sports got wrong in the FIFA 13 demo...
Vincent Kompany
Demo Rating: 85 Really? 85? Kompany consistently makes the defenders he plays with look like short, middle aged men more likely to break a hip and start crying than defend half as well as he does. So giving a rather middle of the road rating to the worlds best defender is quite ludicrous. Though we dont have evidence to support it, but one can assume that Vidic (who has been injured for a season) and Pique (whos as likely to out-muscle a player as I am to outmuscle a mountain bear) are both rated higher than the best defender in the best defence in the best league in the world (as Sky Sports tells us). Obviously Citys current form doesnt represent this fact very well, but hes as much a victim as managerial tinkering as Joe Hart, the best English goal keeper who has kept less clean sheets than Ben Foster, and therefore his rating should be quite higher than it is.
Advertisement
Wojciech Szczsny
Demo Rating: 79 This must be predicated on Arsenals recent history of having goal keepers more inclined to throw the ball in to their own net than try and stop it going in. However this isnt the case anymore; anyone who watched Arsenal regularly last season learned that Szczesny is in a new league of Arsenal goal keeper. Forceful, confident and incredibly athletic he is one of the best young goal keepers in the world today and is going to be one of the stars of the future... So why on earth is his rating the same as it was at the beginning of Fifa 12? A 21 year old goal keeper who hadnt played a full season in goal is rated the same as a 22 year old who had spent a season calming an Arsenal defence who looked on the verge of collapse? Arsenals relatively poor clean sheet record in comparison to the bigger clubs didnt change the fact he was a stable rock in Arsenals injury filled defence and his rating should reflect his important role.
Robin Van Persie
Demo Rating: 88 Ok, its difficult to argue that Van Persies 88 rating is low and he will likely be the second or third best player in the Premier League on Fifa 13. However based on last years performance where he almost single-handedly carried Arsenal to Champions League qualification whilst scoring more goals than any other player in the league and winning player of the year; surely he should be the highest rated player? Not only does he score goals more naturally than any other player in the league, potentially even the world, but he is a solid captain, a great player of the ball and creates goals as well as scores them. Yet you can bet that Rooney will have the highest Premier League rating; and after Rooneys moderately embarrassing start to the campaign which saw him dropped and then injured, is such a decision even merited? Rooney has had a reputation for being the worlds best since he was 18, yet that shouldnt overshadow the fact that Van Persie is one of the best players in the world and should be referred to as such in the comparisons to the Premier League.
Alexandre Pato
Demo Rating: 83 Alexandre Pato made an incredible debut for AC Milan and his first couple of seasons easily made him look like one of the worlds greatest up and coming prospects. However the fact hes incredibly injury prone and isnt renowned for his match winning contributions (of late) surely merits a lower rating for a player who is still pure raw potential over world quality? 83 seems like an awfully high rating for someone of Pato's background, reflecting his potential a lot more than his actual on-pitch impact. More consistent players will surely be given a lower rating than him and his 2 point drop from last season is a step in the right direction, however his high rating still boggles considering he has struggled to maintain fitness and improve on his early promise.
Thomas Vermaelen
Demo Rating: 82 Thomas Vermaelen has to deal with the unfortunate fact that he looks like a Bond villain; but that shouldnt hamper the fact that he is the difference between Arsenals defence looking mid-table and looking like Champions League worthy players. Hes powerful, technically brilliant and a great defensive organiser who really makes a difference to Arsenal and is one of the top defenders in the league; and this should surely merit a higher rating than 82? Why yes, this is good, he is streets better than the other defenders Arsenal have on their books and their brilliant defensive start to the season should merit an upgrade for an underrated player.
Yaya Toure
Demo Rating: 85 He is Manchester Citys best and most influential player, yet is rated lower than several of the others just in the Manchester City team; how do they get away with that? Although, lets be fair, Man Citys default setting puts him in Defensive Midfield, maybe Fifa 13 is so realistic that if you play as Man City and push him forward for the last 20 minutes he turns in to a 92 rated player, runs the show, scores a goal and receives tonnes of plaudits and people saying Mancini should play him further forward. However I doubt this is the case, and his game changing ability and constant influence in the Man City teams seems to be underappreciated as he is rated lower than many other players who he excels past. What do you think FIFA 13 fans? Did EA Sports get the ratings above right? Or do you agree that they should have been different. Share your thoughts below.