FIFA 13 vs PES 2013: 9 Reasons FIFA Will Win The War

WhatCulture list the reasons why EA Sports will once more reign supreme with FIFA 13.

By Simon Gallagher /

Advertisement
Last week, our own Michael Atkinson provided his own insight into this year's round of the football feud to end them all, confirming that he thinks Pro Evo 2013 will emerge victorious this year as a better game than EA Sport's FIFA 13. Like him, I've played both demos, and though the PES team have made some major strides this season, they are still playing catch-up and the developed features come at a cost and I can't look beyond EA Sport's latest addition to the genre. For the first time in a long while though, the battle for supremacy this year has been a lot closer than some fans might have expected, and this decision was far from as easy as it has been in the past few years. Last year both games had their problems, with PES attracting a lot of criticism and FIFA 12 attracting specific criticism relating to the new defensive system, and FIFA 12 ultimately emerged as the champion once more. That seemed to prompt Konami into making more wholesale changes, rebuilding their game's engine from the foundations with the bias on gameplay and the development of balance between the old arcade sensibilities of ISS and the modern fascination with realistic sim-like play. And PES 2013 is a triumph of a game in comparison with the last few games of the series - Konami have really thought about their fans, and what it takes to keep a player engaged on the pitch, though there have been some compromises elsewhere unfortunately. And that's where FIFA 13 has the room to beat this years PES - taking advantage of the areas that Konami can't compete in to once again capture the crown of the best football video game of the year. It's those areas we're going to focus on here, exploring every major aspect of FIFA 13 to confirm exactly why EA Sports' release will be better than PES 2013 for both fans and critics alike. And it has nothing to do with how many copies will be sold. Click next to reveal the nine reasons football gaming fans can expect FIFA 13 to be the victor once again this year...

1. The Gameplay

FIFA 13's gameplay experience is exceptional. EA Sports have clearly spent a lot of time under the bonnet of the game, developing new features with gameplay in mind, as well as balancing the realism of the game with an entertainment factor that could match PES 2013's toned-down arcade-like feel that is a major step forward from the over-boosted pace of PES 2012. And their work has paid off in this year's game. My own comparison of the two demos summed up the gameplay as follows:
The new features, brought in with an obvious eye on the game€™s overall authentic feel, work wonderfully to add that realism as well as making the game feel fun again. Both the defensive AI and attacking AI have been given a revamp after some of the problems of last year, and attacking play in particular feels a lot less one-dimensional than it has at times in the past. Thanks to the increased intelligence of team-mates, there are always a number of options available to the attacking player, and if the player should decide to take it on themself, the change in the dribbling system, and control system mean that trying to take a man on is not the furstrating experience it was in FIFA 12, when the containment system meant evasive one-twos were a lot more successful (though less entertaining).
At the final summation, EA Sports have created a gameplay experience that equally balances both realism and entertainment: this is not only the most authentic football gaming experience ever released, it is also one of the most purely entertaining, and though PES 2013 is also the most entertaining that franchise has been for some time, FIFA 13 edges it here. The slickness, and the bias towards scoring goals - which I will come to explore - both lend themselves to the overall gameplay feel, and it is no exaggeration to say this is the best on-pitch experience any football game has ever offered.

2. The Realism

For most of the past few years, the PES team have been attempting to make ground up on FIFA, with their misguided previous attempts focusing predominantly on EA Sports' eye for realism, to the cost of the gameplay experience of the game. In short, the franchise abandoned its roots and lost its way somewhat: but that has changed this year with a healthier balance between realistic play and entertainment. But it is still FIFA 13 which captures the essence of playing football the best: the new control system adds autheticity, and the balance between attacking play and defensive ability is a lot better than it was last year, when players could use contain to repel the attacks of even the best players, encouraging an all-conquering one-two passing game that got very frustrating. Added to that, the likenesses and the slickness of celebration animations, and FIFA 13 looks and feels like the most realistic football game that has ever been released.

3. The Impact

One thing that EA Sports have done well throughout their entire stable of sports games is channel the ceremony of sport, celebrating the spectacle of the game through presentation, and adding to the effect with a tub-thumping soundtrack to get players focused and excited for the upcoming matches ahead. FIFA 13 has continued that trend, thanks in part to the excellent new Match Day set-up that makes every match feel like an FA Cup final, with the sort of pomp and circumstance that you might expect from the biggest sporting events in the world. But on an even more simple level, FIFA 13 packs the perfect amount of impact when it comes to scoring a goal, something that it plainly missing from PES 2013. As Michael said in his own article about PES:
FIFA feels like it has a weight to it: goals feel like they hit the back of the net and the feeling that gives is greater than scoring in Pro Evo, so much so that I imagine Arsene Wenger prefers Pro Evo. After all, why would you ruin a good move with a goal when the result is so understated? All joking aside, that is actually a major flaw: the entire point of the sport is the one thing that Pro Evo fails to deliver on. It might even be the lack of commentary on the demo that manages to dilute the reaction as the goal goes in, but I doubt it. It could also be a result of the ball physics I€™d praised earlier and the weightlessness that provides, but there€™s certainly something not quite right.
I can't help but agree. PES 2013 really feels like it rewards attractive football and a passing game, but FIFA 13 feels more like it's geared towards the art of goal-scoring, even despite the rebuilt control and dribbling systems. It is a more direct game, and the reward is enough to make it the better of the two games in that regard.

4. The Visuals

Again, both FIFA 13 and PES 2013 have enjoyed their annual visual revamps, with player likenesses improving in both cases, and indeed both games look better than they ever have. But it's FIFA 13 which emerges as the better of the two by some distance, thanks to EA Sports' strong foundation and their attention to detail in the finer points of the aesthetics. PES 2013 still has a tendency to look less realistic when compared side by sides with FIFA 13, and when it comes to animations the gap opens up even more as PES players lack that necessary life-likeness that seems to come a lot easier to EA Sports. In the animations, PES players have no spark to their eyes, and their mouths hang open with an oddly cold, lifeless effect, which is an unfortunate sign that Konami's focus was elsewhere (and I have to admit to the overall benefit of the game). The only slight reservation is the lighting, which is a little over contrasted in the interest of realism, but which comes at a cost. But it's by no means a fatal flaw, and overall, FIFA 13 looks incredible again, right down to the ball. Crowd animations are still limited, but they look better than PES, and in the vital areas of the game, its hard to fault the game in relation to the current generation of consoles.

5. The Presentation

One thing guaranteed by the EA Sports label is slick presentation, and FIFA 13 is no different. In fact, this is probably the area in which FIFA 13 outstrips PES 2013 the most, thanks to Konami's apparent realisation that spending money trying to compete on the frills of the game would be less beneficial to the game than developing the on-pitch experience. EA Sports have brought their usual flair to the table, with slick, though still overly convoluted menu pages (a symptom of all sports games these days), an exceptional soundtrack suited to the demographic and the atmosphere of the sport and an exceptional new Match Day presentation that amps up the slick feel even more. FIFA 13 also features the best commentary of any sports game yet released, with fluid banter between the co-commentators and a more natural and authentic feel, rather than the stunted examples of former years. Obviously there are only so many phrases the game can hold, but it will take a long time to get sick of them this time out.

6. The Licences

One criticism that always follows PES around is the lack of licensing, and once more EA Sports have made their rivals look a little less professional in comparison, and this year is no different. The full collection of licences for FIFA 13 means the inclusion of an embarrassingly rich collection of competitions to add gameplay depth and diversity when you get sick of playing simple online matches or trying to win the Premier League. It might seem a little odd to suggest something that has no real effect on the gameplay as a reason the game will be better than PES 2013, but the licences add to the overall slickness of the game, and show EA Sports' commitment to building the complete experience both on and off the pitch.

7. Skill Games

EA Sports' decision to bring in a whole new system for learning skills is a major boost for this year's game. The Skill Games mode is an ingenious way to bring an entertainment factor into what amounts to simple tutorials, with very specific opportunities to develop the necessary skills to really master the game. FIFA 13 is a game set up for the player to really immerse themselves in learning how to play, adding in a steeper learning curve but balancing that with entertainment and rewarding players who stick with the learning process through to the end. The skill games themselves feel professionally designed as well, designed to hone skills as well as develop them from the ground-level up, so players can learn simple things like dribbling, and develop their shooting and passing accuracy. Stick with it and EA Sports are effectively giving you an Idiot's Guide to beating the game, and to developing your skills before heading out into the big bad world of online play. And most importantly of all, the game does it all without compromising the engagement factor, bringing in a points system to encourage repeated play against particular Skill Games and never letting the player get bored despite the functional nature of the mode. http://youtu.be/VgpRgRj3nlY

8. Ultimate Team

FIFA Ultimate Team feels like a game entirely of its own, channelling the huge appeal of fantasy football and Football Manager to allow players to build and trade their own teams of stars. It's a hugely addictive addition to the main game, also channeling that wonderful child-like joy of buying and unwrapping Panini sticker packs, which makes it a huge money-driver for the developers without feeling too much like an obligatory addition. This year, EA Sports have rebuilt the system with new players in mind as well as introducing some new features to bring even more depth to the game, and Ultimate Team is a lot better for the developments. It might have already suffered an exploit, but Ultimate Team will still be a resounding success - and indeed the fan reaction to the conduct of those players naughty enough to take advantage of the exploit to flood the market with inaccessible star players and boost their own finances hugely proves exactly how highly regarded the sub-game is. And those players, who are now banned for life, will no doubt be extremely frustrated that EA Sports came down on them so hard. In both cases, the fact that so many players already had access to the game proves how successful Ultimate Team is - as EA Sports made the UT web app available for returning players with a selection of rewards to thank them for returning. A smart marketing move, and a very clever way to retain custom when the biggest rival on the market is making such big strides back to their own success. http://youtu.be/UtT_geeYKAs

9. Longevity

Like the excellent, and equally addictive Football Manager franchise, FIFA encourages the player to log in a LOT of hours not only to become the best player you can possibly be and reign supreme in the online leagues, but also so the player can develop a sense of legacy. The career mode and the Ultimate Team mode encourage the player to build their own dynasty, taking over a real life team and stamping their own authority and identity on to it with a new set of players and new tactics. In comparison, PES 2013 feels like a more immediate and thus more disposable experience, with an exceptional on-pitch experience and very good gameplay being slightly let down by the lack of depth in other modes. FIFA 13 is designed to encourage the player to stick around as long as possible, and as close to the next annual addition to the franchise - which is the biggest mark of success of this sort of frequently updated property - and based on what we've seen so far, it will succeed in that endeavour. That isn't to say that PES 2013 will be found gathering dust on gamer shelves in the near future, it's just less likely, considering the game's comparative lack of depth and diversity that it will be as frequently played as FIFA 13 when the autumn release window comes around next year. So, FIFA fans, are you excited for next week's release of the game? Share your thoughts below. You can follow all of our FIFA 13 coverage by heading over to our dedicated FIFA 13 hub-page. FIFA 13 is released on 28th October.