Maybe the one thing which overshadows the release of a new FIFA game is the release of a new set of player ratings, systematically ranking the best (and worst) players on the planet by the numbers. Each and every year with the release of a new instalment, the most exciting thing for we FIFA nerds is to place the brand-spanking new disc in the drive and go straight to the team selection menu to see what rating the egg-heads at EA Sport have given to all the top players, long before we ever even sit down to actually play the game. Inevitably there will be fractious fans in their droves moaning that their favourite players have been sold short or complaining that the EA Montreal team have once again overestimated the talents of a highly touted player. Though everyone is fallible and they have certainly made their fair share of dubious ratings in every entry into the franchise, for the most part the ratings are spot on; aptly reflecting the player in questions achievements in the preceding season. With every national league now winding down it is now possible to carry out a fair assessment on what rating each player should be given in FIFA 15. Clearly the World Cup in Brazil still gives the best players the potential to alter their rating but their performances in the national leagues must be considered the most important. Were What Culture given control of the globes premier football sim, here are the players we would downgrade in FIFA 15:
10. Clint Dempsey (Seattle Sounders) 81
Once upon a time Clint Dempsey was certainly worthy of an 81-rating but, sadly for the 31-year-old, those days are long gone. As a pioneer of the sport in the United States Dempsey has every right to return to his homeland and enjoy the game he helped popularise but his decision to return to the MLS this March finished any chance Dempsey had of deserving to retain an 80+ rating. Playing in a vastly less competitive league means that even if Dempsey runs the show State-side it would be hard to justify him being an 81. In the first half of this season Dempsey returned to Fulham a club he spent six long seasons with between 2006-2012 but was unable to help The Lilywhites avoid relegation, playing only seven games and failing to score. Once upon a time Dempsey would have offered the kind of offence from midfield which wouldve helped Fulham stay in the top-flight but no more.
9. Stevan Joveti (Manchester City) 84
A series of calf and hamstring injuries has led to Jovetis career at Manchester City starting with more of a whimper than a bang. Since the Montenegrin internationals big-money move to the Barclays PL, Joveti even when he has played has been a ghost of his former self during his Fiorentina days. During his first season Joveti has followed the dubious tradition set by other highly priced City forwards of seeming to be world-beaters elsewhere before underperforming at the Etihad, joining the likes of Robhino, Adebayor and Balotelli. In FIFA 14 Joveti is not only a great goal scoring threat but also has the capacity to create chances for others. We have seen no sign of this during the 2013/14 season and though it may seem unfair to downgrade a player who has been plighted by injury, the ratings can only be made on the evidence in front of you and 84 is irrefutably too high.
8. Radamel Falcao (AS Monaco) 90
Unfortunately Falcaos first season at AS Monaco was cut in half last January as he suffered a severe knee injury which may even rule the Columbian superstar out of the World Cup. Not wanting to add to Falcaos sorrows but the 28-year-old isnt deserving of his 90-rating. For exactly the same reasoning we gave regarding Stevan Joveti, Falcaos rating should be downgraded in FIFA 15 its unjustifiable to give a player 90 who has barely been on the field. Yes the flashes of greatness weve seen from Falcao certainly been better than those seen from Joveti but a rating of 90 makes El Tigre one of the games greats. Even while Falcao was running the show at Atlético Madrid a rating of 90 was arguably highly generous, particularly considering his lack of Champions League success.
7. Erik Lamela (Tottenham Hotspur) 81
Advertisement
The sale of Gareth Bale and the subsequent buying frenzy it initiated at White Hart Lane was supposed to mark the beginning of Spurs time as real title contenders. However, a turbulent management situation combined with the void left by Bale who saved Spurs hide on many occasions has led to a disappointing season in north London. A player who typifies the 2013/14 season of Tottenham Hotspur is Erik Lamela. Lamela, on whom Spurs set a new transfer fee record of £30m, held so much promise having seemed to be a potent talent in Serie A. In his last season at Roma, Lamela racked up 15-goals in 35-appearances compared to his one goal all season at Spurs. The Argentines 82-finishing and 81-long shots are starting to look a little generous now, no?
6. Roberto Soldado (Tottenham Hotspur) 84
The second of Spurs underwhelming signings, at least Erik Lamela has periods of injury to excuse him from his lack of impact. Roberto Soldado has become the butt of many a joke for his ability to spurn even the finest of goal scoring chances. Atlético Madrid are rumoured to be interested in relieving Spurs of their poisoned chalice meaning they can at least recoup some of their financial loses. A move back to sunny Spain might be just what the doctor ordered for Soldado to rediscover his golden-touch. During his time at Valencia Soldado was the King Midas of Spain, scoring 30-goals in 46-appearances at Spurs he has managed to bag a feeble six league goals in 28-outings. His inability to score this season means his rating of 84 needs downgrading and his 88-finishing certainly needs readdressing. In many ways it has been like Spurs have bagged themselves their very own Fernando Torres.
5. Nemanja Vidi (Manchester United) 87
Nemanja Vidic is a player who has come to represent all that is currently wrong with Manchester United. Once a brick-wall at the back which allowed United to wreak havoc at the opposing end without fear of the counter, Vidi is unrecognisable from the player he once was and is certainly no longer deserving of being rated as the best CB in the Premier League. Being ranked over the likes of Vincent Kompany, John Terry and Per Mertesacker is an astonishing feat for Vidi given how lackadaisical United have looked at the back all season long. The announcement that the Serb would be leaving Old Trafford in the summer was met with fear and despondency from many United fans however, these mourners are certainly wearing their rose-tinted glasses and are ignoring how uninspiring their lost talisman has looked all season.
4. Fernando Torres (Chelsea) 82
Since his record breaking move to Chelsea back in 2011 for a reported £50-million, Torres rating has gradually been chipped away at like the slow erosion of a sea-cliff. Many make the fair argument that the Spaniards rating should have entered the realm of the sub-80s two years ago. El Niños time at Chelsea has been defined by his clumsy finishing, hesitancy and self-frustration and the performances of the modern Fernando Torres in no way warrant his 82-rating. Continuing to value a forward who has scored just four times in 27-league-appearances as being one of the better players in the game is one of the biggest head scratching decisions made by EA. If a players past achievements count for so much, consistency means that men like David Beckham, Thierry Henry and Ronaldinho should still have an 88+ rating.
3. Ashley Cole (Chelsea) 85
His 85-rating makes Ashley Cole the best left back in FIFA 14. Is he the best left back in the world? Ashley Cole isnt even the best left back at Chelsea (thanks for that one John Lennon) as César Azpilicueta has shown himself to be far more effective in the position for most of the season. Ashley has enjoyed a long and successful career at the top clubs in the Premiership but he no longer has the pace or athleticism to be an 85-rated defender. If Cole were still deserving of an 85 he wouldnt be in a dog-fight with Luke Shaw and Leighton Baines for who boards the plane in the summer indeed, many believe Baines (rated 83) should be treated as Englands first choice left back.
2. Ashley Young (Manchester United) 82
For the past few instalments Ashley Young has been one of the most consistently overrated players in the FIFA franchise. The 28-year-old who showed so much promise during his time at Aston Villa has generally been underwhelming during his three seasons at Old Trafford. There seems to be no logically explanation other than the FIFA developers just adoring Ashley Young the time has come for the winger to be rated below 80. Young is no longer the prodigy who used to tear it up at Aston Villa. Instead of being known for his pace and skill-moves Ashley Young is generally just mocked for being a speciality diver, capable of tricking a penalty from even the stingiest of referees. Young was entirely incapable of breathing life into the tepid Manchester United squad during his fleeting appearances this season as an 82-player should be able to.
1. Lionel Messi (Barcelona) 94
Without doubt the most controversial player to have found himself featured on this list, Messi finds himself in the #1 spot not because he is the player most in need of a downgrade but rather because it is such a shock to see the Argentine finding himself in this position. For so many years now Messi has been the franchises poster boy, consistently being rated as being the best active player in the world. This years performance however which is, after all, what FIFA ratings should be based on has seen Messi find himself hidden in the shadow of his long-time rival Cristiano Ronaldo (rated 92). We wouldnt for one minute suggest that Messi should be downgraded any more than a point-or-two but it should definitely be reflected that he has had an uncharacteristically quiet season and that Ronaldo is currently the top-dog. This being said, a strong World Cup performance leading his team to the Semis or further could be all it takes to revive Messi football is a truly unpredictable enterprise.