FIFA 16: 12 Most Overrated Players

Some of world football's biggest names need to be toppled.

By Michael Potts /

Every year there's always a trough of players with ridiculous ratings that seemed like great ideas at the time. One-hit wonders seem to be in abundant supply at the minute, causing EA all kinds of problems when it comes to judging whether a player is genuinely world class or whether he's just on a great run of form. Manchester United has been a breeding ground for overrated talent in recent years with the likes of Angel Di Maria coming and going in the blink of an eye. Several Red Devil players (ex and current) have made the list, while a plethora of Premier League stars and a 90-rated attacker also need to be knocked off their high perches. As always, it was obviously tough to estimate how each player would fare this season, but there are still plenty of players who could be on the receiving end of a downgrade in the near future...

12. Phil Jones - 79

Phil Jones is an enigma. Nobody really knows what to do with him, and the longer versatile England man goes without settling on one position, the harder it will become for him to ever live up to his once massive potential. The 23-year-old Manchester United defender's £16.5 million transfer from Blackburn seems like an age ago, and while he is still young, there are far brighter prospects flourishing. He was bundled into the same category as Chris Smalling, though the ex-Fulham man has leapt ahead of Jones. Still, the defender has managed a near-80 rating on FIFA 16, with a string of highly impressive defensive and physical stats without really proving he has a lot to offer other than hilarious meme faces.

11. Mikel Arteta - 81

Mikel Arteta was more than worthy of an 80+ rating, but the Arsenal man has been frozen out of proceedings at the Emirates, yet he still manages to cling onto his impressive 81, despite age being firmly against him. The 33-year-old Spaniard is yet to start a Premier League game this season, and has played just 109 minutes in the top flight so far. And in those few minutes, he barely influenced games as proven by WhoScored's lowly 6.58 average performance rating. Arteta was once a gem, but he's no longer deserving of an 81 rating, or a place in Arsenal's team.

10. Leighton Baines - 83

Just a couple of seasons ago, Leighton Baines was hot property. Everton were flying, and that was in large part down to their lethal left back. The England man's set-piece delivery and execution was second-to-none and he weaved his way into the national team contention. However, injuries halted the late-blooming 30-year-old's progress and he's not featured at all this season. His comeback will be a welcome relief for Everton, but putting him as high as 83 on FIFA 16 is very high considering that puts him just behind David Alaba and Jordi Alba, on the same level as Real Madrid's Marcelo. He's good, he's just not that good.

9. Radamel Falcao - 83

How do you solve a problem like Falcao? The Colombian was a terrific talent in mainland Europe, tormenting defenders and bursting the net on a regular basis for Porto, Atletico Madrid, and PSG, but while he conquered Portugal, Spain and France, the striker simply hasn't been able to handle England. There's no complex explanation for why Falcao has transformed into a Premier League farce, he simply hasn't looked like the hitman we'd heard all about. He was given a significant drop from his FIFA 15 rating, but after 18 appearances in all competitions for club and country, he's bagged just one goal. That's not 83-rated material. Could another downgrade be on the cards?

8. Robin Van Persie - 84

Falcao's former United teammate Robin Van Persie isn't having a fun time in Turkey. Videos have emerged showing the star apparently disgruntled with life away from the bright lights of the Premier League. He's bagged 4 goals in 8 league games for Fenerbache in the Turkish League, but there's not a lot going right for him at the moment. The 32-year-old is on the decline, and his first team football is limited, despite a decent goal record, and it would be no surprise to see him drop again down to around 82. Nothing dramatic, just another couple of notches shaved off for a more accurate card. Saying that, Barcelona have been strongly linked with a move for the Dutchman as backup for their already mind-boggling strikeforce. It would be RVP's last chance to hit the heights.

7. John Terry - 85

John Terry had a somewhat resurgent season during 2014/15, though now it looks as though it may have been his dying (career) breath as opposed to a second wind. The Chelsea legend has failed to live up to his own high standards this season in an all-round horror-show campaign for the Blues so far. The 34-year-old has made 9 appearances in all competitions, but they were blighted by a red card and own goal in the opening stages of the season. He's slowly creeping back into some form, but when it comes to FIFA, you'd expect an 85-rated defender to be at the top of his game at all times. He's level with Vincent Kompany, Gerard Pique, and Diego Godin, three defenders at their peaks, whereas many suspect Terry is on a natural decline.

6. Wayne Rooney - 86

Wayne Rooney is the epitome of 'overrated'. The recently-crowned top England goalscorer of all time has led a fantastic career, with some incredible moments, but Rooney peaked way back. The United icon has always been rated immensely highly on FIFA games, and now he's starting to slide, but 86 is still too high. The 30-year-old recently suffered a 12-game league goal drought, and while quality players can still dip in and out of form, Rooney looks like a shadow of the exciting player he once was. England will always be thankful for his goals (even if the majority were against the behemoths of San Marino, Andorra, and Moldova), but he truly was world-class at one point, but there's no way Rooney should find himself equal with current superstars such as Thomas Mueller, Alexis Sanchez, and more.

5. Bastian Schweinsteiger - 86

You could comfortably throw Bastian Schweinsteiger into the same category as Rooney right now. The dominant German midfielder has seen far better days, and really hasn't made the impact at Manchester United he was expected to make. He's still a good player, but I don't think he's proven himself as a world class footballer based on this season's performances. The 31-year-old is still a classy midfielder but on FIFA 16 he's currently level with Kevin De Bruyne, Paul Pogba, and Arturo Vidal, three immense talents making headlines across the continent. Schweinsteiger is just two marks away from being the best central midfield player in the world, yet he doesn't start every week in Manchester United's team. That doesn't make sense. A drop closer to 83 is needed.

4. Diego Costa - 86

Diego Costa is the ultimate Premier League pantomime villain. If he's playing against you, you're going to despise him. If he's playing in your team, you'll love him. But now that the goals have dried up, he's beginning to look more and more like a petulant child as opposed to a world-beating striker. Everything he touched last season seemed to fly into the back of the net. I'll even admit that I love his 'clever' style of play, winding up opponents to breaking point. He's playing one big mental game, and the likes of Arsenal's Gabriel quite simply lost the battle when he flicked out at the Spanish striker. He's pure entertainment, pure rage on a football field, but he's bagged just 3 goals in 13 games this season for Chelsea. Was the 86 rating premature?

3. Franck Ribery - 87

Franck RIbery is a wizard. In his prime, the Frenchman could cast a spell over the ball and torture full backs at will. He could probably do similar now, but injuries have ravaged the latter part of his career, leaving his future in peril. The winger will have lost some pace, and if he does come back, will he be the same Franck Ribery? He's yet to feature this season, and only made 15 appearances last season. While he's a technical genius, I feel like 87 ratings should be reserved for current, sure-fire incredible footballers. Nobody knows if/when he's coming back, so should he be taken down to around the 85 mark? He's 32 years old and won't have a great deal left in the tank... Surely?

2. Cesc Fabregas - 87

Cesc Fabregas has endured one of the most disappointing runs of form in recent Premier League history. The Spanish midfielder was breathtaking in the first half of his debut season for Chelsea, and his partnership with Costa provided a goldmine of goals for the team on their way to winning the league. But 2015 has been a major let-down for the man who should be Jose Mourinho's key player in the Chelsea midfield. He's recorded just one assist and is yet to score in nine Premier League games this campaign, and there's certainly no coincidence that Costa is struggling up front with his main ammunition man failing to deliver. If Fabregas kicks into gear, Chelsea's season could roar into gear, until then, their season looks bleak.

1. Arjen Robben - 90

Arjen Robben falls into the same category as Bayern Munich teammate Franck Ribery. He's a magician on the ball, but his impact is decreasing, so is it time he was plucked out of the immensely exclusive 90 club? There are just four players with a 90+ rating: Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Luis Suarez, and Robben. Does he really deserve to be in there ahead of some other phenomenal stars? He's 31 and injuries are beginning to take their toll, meaning the Dutch master has only featured in 3 league games this season, scoring once. Surely Sergio Aguero or Neymar are more deserving of a 90+ spot? Neymar in particular has sizzled this season with 8 goals and 4 assists in 7 league games. There should be no room for sentiment in FIFA, and while Robben was unquestionably worthy of 90 in recent years, his time at the top is gradually coming to a graceful end.