FIFA 16: 15 Criminally Underrated Players

When the best player in the Premier League is a 73, you know it's time to upgrade.

By Michael Potts /

Every year EA look into their crystal ball to seek out the top players, and every year, they receive a barrage of: "WHAT?!" "76?!" "I'M BUYING PES" with gamers descending into full rant mode as their favourite footballing superstars are given a slightly lower number next to their name than expected. It's a thankless task for EA, with one-season wonders complicating their process of assigning stats. Harry Kane bagged a remarkable 32 goals for club and country last season, yet he was still only handed a 78-overall rating on FIFA, a decision that has been fully justified by his second-season wobble. Then there are the players who weren't expected to achieve a great deal, before exploding onto the scene in 2015/16. This has all led to some bizarre ratings when you look at them right now, but who are the most underrated players on FIFA 16?

15. Gylfi Sigurðsson - 78

Gylfi Sigurdsson may not be in the greatest run of form just yet, but the Icelandic midfielder has been a proven talent for long enough now to deserve an 80-overall rating. The 26-year-old's red-hot form during his first spell at Swansea led to a switch to Spurs, though he returned to South Wales at the beginning of last season in an attempt to pick up where he left off. He returned with 7 goals and 11 assists in the league, and while he hasn't started quite as well this time around, he's still a quality player worthy of higher.

14. Antoine Griezmann - 83

To call an 83-rated player 'underrated' clearly shows that the man in question must be sensational. Antoine Griezmann is. The Atletico Madrid striker is the latest in a long line of Rojiblanco goal machines. The French 24-year-old is an emerging presence on the world stage after slamming home 25 goals in 50 games last season across all club competitions. He's an outstanding talent who is being touted to move onto even bigger things if he keeps on impressing. However, at 83, he's joint with the disappointing Falcao, and that's simply not right. Boost Griezmann.

13. Alexandre Pato - 79

Alexandre Pato may be a slightly bizarre inclusion to the list, after all, mentioning his name is like entering a time warp back to 2009 when he was named Serie A Young Player of the Year and everyone believed he was the second coming of Pele. However, his form and fitness dipped, and a once ridiculous talent turned into a ridiculous waste of potential. But now, Pato's on the road to redemption with Corinthians after notching 22 goals and 7 assists so far in the Brazilian season. He's been in remarkable form and has been linked yet again with a big move to Manchester United. He's still just 26, and his talent surely nudges his rating up to 80 at least?

12. Alex Song - 79

When Alex Song originally signed for West Ham, mid-table fans across the country let out enormous sighs. How could they have wrestled a Barcelona midfielder away from the Nou Camp at an age where he should still be in his prime? The Cameroonian midfielder enforcer wasn't getting first team football in Spain, so a season-long loan to the Hammers was pushed through. He enjoyed a remarkable season back in the Premier League, dominating the midfield as West Ham climbed the table. Unfortunately, he's yet to feature this season due to injury, but talent-wise, his 79-overall is very poor considering Mikel Arteta, Jack Wilshere, and Moussa Dembele are rated at 81, 81, and 80 respectively, despite not featuring often.

11. Juan Mata - 84

Many would argue that Juan Mata is rated just about perfectly, but given his importance to Manchester United and the impact he's made this season, I'd happily see him bumped up another point or two. Yes, that's incredibly high, but I'd happily argue that Mata is incredibly talented. The 27-year-old still has plenty of years left in the tank, and Jose Mourinho will surely still be wondering why Chelsea ever wanted to sell him, especially to their league rivals. The Spanish maestro scored 9 goals and assisted 4 in 33 league games last year, though 6 appearances were from the bench. Mata was ludicrously benched for spells, despite being one of the most talented players in the division.

10. Yohan Cabaye - 79

The rise of Crystal Palace is a remarkable one. They're currently demonstrating the perfect model of a mid-table football club and how they can step up another gear. Palace finished 10th last season but the signing of Yohan Cabaye suggests they're going to top their own excellent achievement. The French midfielder wasn't being given game time at PSG, but his talent on display at Newcastle proved there was a more than capable footballer in there. He is the heartbeat of a Palace team soaring in 6th, and while he may not provide as many stunning highlights, his all-round game is worthy of a boost.

9. Mauro Icardi - 79

The fall of Italian football is so widely-documented you don't need me to tell you it's not exactly what it used to be. Still, Inter are starting a steady climb back to the top, and one of the main men leading the charge is Mauro Icardi. The 22-year-old Argentine striker bagged 22 goals and 6 assists in 36 games last season, and Inter will be hoping for similar figures this year if they are to maintain their excellent start to the season. Icardi is immensely talented, and still so young. Surely such an impressive return deserves higher than a 79-overall rating? Especially considering he found the net more times than Carlos Tevez (86), Gonzalo Higuain (84) and Jeremy Menez (81).

8. Frank Lampard - 79

Can somebody explain to me why other legends can move to the MLS with their stats in tact, while arguably the only one who could still ply his trade at the highest level saw his stats plunge to 79? Frank Lampard enjoyed a marvellous final season at Chelsea before a switch to Man City (via NYCFC) and in his Premier League bow, he still managed to pop up with crucial goals. The 37-year-old saw his stats drastically dip, while Andrea Pirlo (84), Steven Gerrard (84) and Didier Drogba (81) all managed to cling onto high ratings. Lampard hasn't enjoyed the greatest time in the MLS just yet, but it's still unfair to see him drop while everyone else is comfortably into the 80s.

7. Chris Smalling - 79

It's taken some time, but Chris Smalling is finally beginning to quieten his doubters with a string of excellent defensive performances for Manchester United. The criticism aimed in his direction was well-justified, but he's progressing very well at the moment. He's an established 25-year-old centre back now, and no longer a youth product out of his depth. He'll want to sustain his upward curve if he wants to become a truly world class defender by the time he peaks, but for now, he's deserving of a FIFA boost considering his current rating only puts him level with Dejan Lovren, Joleon Lescott and Younes Kaboul.

6. Dimitri Payet - 81

Dimitri Payet has been one of the stars of the Premier League season, and while 81 is high, you have to wonder whether he'd be raised another notch or two if he played for one of the top sides. He's certainly talented enough for almost any team in the Premier League. The French wizard has been a major factor in West Ham's rise from being a 'good' side to a 'great' side, with 5 goals and 3 assists in 9 games from midfield. If he keeps up that pace, he'll statistically end the season as one of the top players in the entire league. He's been raised on EA Matchday up to around 84, and while that may be steep as a permanent rating, Payet's certainly worthy of an 82/83.

5. Douglas Costa - 81

Douglas Costa shouldn't have been as low as 81 to begin with, and now he's proving EA wrong with every magical touch of the ball. He's recorded 5 assists and a goal in the Bundesliga already this season, proving he's more than capable of filling the boots of Arjen Robben and Franck Ribery who have been missing through injury lately. The Brazilian won't simply fall back to the bench when the time comes for one of Bayern's old guard to return, but that's a great problem for Pep Guardiola to have. Costa is coming along at the perfect time for Bayern and is well-worthy of a boost.

4. Sergio Aguero - 87

Sergio Aguero is having a typically 'Sergio Aguero' season for Manchester City. 11 games, 8 goals, 1 assist, and a lengthy injury, including a ridiculous 5-goal haul against Newcastle. He's relatively low-profile for such an immense talent, and maybe that has something to do with why he's not lauded in the same category as the infamous Luis Suarez. The Argentine superstar has 84 goals in 128 league games for City, a mind-boggling total for a striker in a league as tough as the English top flight. If you threw him back into La Liga, or more specifically into the Barca forward trio instead of Suarez, he'd burn the league to the ground. For me, Aguero is a talent who deserves a place in the 90 club. That's not something I say lightly, but he really is that good. Let's just hope the injuries calm down soon so we can see a constant stream of class from him.

3. Hector Bellerin - 74

Hector Bellerin is a well-timed graduate from the Arsenal academy (after almost a decade progressing through Barcelona's youth system) and he's firmly cementing his place as a key cog in Arsene Wenger's starting XI. You'll have seen videos of Douglas Costa ripping the very footballing soul from the 20-year-old with a piece of explosive skill, but you can combat that with Bellerin's lung-busting run for Arsenal's second goal. He is pace personified, and could develop into one of the finest full-backs in world football if his meteoric rise continues. Of course, it was tough for EA to predict Bellerin's success, but an upgrade from 74 is sorely required.

2. Jamie Vardy - 71

Jamie Vardy, Top Premier League Goalscorer. It doesn't make any sense, yet here we are, and fair play to the man who's career path reads: Stocksbridge Park Steels (07/10), Halifax Town (10/11), Fleetwood Town (11/12) and Leicester City (12-Present). He's a late-bloomer at 28, but everything Vardy touches at the minute seems to turn into a goal. He's got 9 goals in 9 games so far in the league, a tally that simply can't be argued with. Yes, he will probably suffer a blip at some point in the season (surely...) but regardless, 71 is simple too low for the man who's scored more than the entire squads of Liverpool, Stoke, West Brom, Watford, Aston Villa and Sunderland.

1. Riyad Mahrez - 73

What else is there to say about Riyad Mahrez? The Leicester man is quite simply a revelation in the Foxes' side. The 24-year-old creative midfielder was picked up for just £400,000 from Le Havre in 2014, and he's making an absolute mockery of the fee with 5 goals and 4 assists in 7 Premier League games so far this season. The Algerian is still young, and will only improve, whether that be at the Midlands club or somewhere higher. Like Vardy, he will endure tough times this season, but so far this season, I'd go as far as saying he's been the best player in the Premier League so far, and all of that from a man rated at just 73 on FIFA. He will be upgraded, there's no doubt about it. The question is: How high?