FIFA 17: 8 Things EA Still Can't Get Right

After all these years, they still haven't managed to fix these obvious issues.

By Sean Michael Hackett /

FIFA 17 is out and fans have wasted no time getting stuck into the latest entry of the famous football simulator. The new story mode, ‘The Journey’, has proved popular with the majority of fans, suggesting story-based modes have a future in FIFA games, and Ultimate Team is still as addictive as ever.

Advertisement

With improvements in defending, goalkeeper reactions and Career Mode, including global brand exposure as a way of earning income, FIFA 17 has been praised by critics and looks to have pipped Pro Evolution Soccer to the title of ‘Best Football Simulator’ once again.

However, despite its improvements, FIFA 17 still has the same old problems it’s had in every previous game.

Here are the basic issues that EA still hasn’t got round to fixing this year...

8. Crowds

With even more licensed and perfectly-replicated stadiums available in FIFA 17, you would think that EA may have finally addressed the issues with the poor crowd designs that have plagued the series for years.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, they haven’t. The fans still look terrible, they still react unrealistically to the events on the field, and the strangely negative reactions to slide challenges that marred last year’s Pro Evolution Soccer seem to have crept in as well (it’s nowhere near as bad as PES 2016, but the boos and jeers that occur when someone even attempts a sliding tackle are still noticeable).

With console power getting bigger and better each generation, and with upgraded consoles on their way, there’s no excuse for EA to neglect the crowds. There are games on the PS2 that made more of an effort with crowds than FIFA do.

World Championship Rugby, released in 2004, showed short cutscenes of fans celebrating, waving to the camera or holding their heads in their hands following tries and conversions. It was primitive, but at least it made an effort to engage with the crowd and make the game really feel like it was being played in an actual stadium.

7. Set Pieces

Set-pieces are a divisive issue when it comes to FIFA. Every year, at least one out of free kicks, penalties and corners get changed and causes fans to either celebrate or rage. FIFA 17 has decided to update all three, meaning this year’s set-pieces are now completely different to previous games, with off-the-ball control at corners and adjustable run-ups for penalties.

Advertisement

Depending on who you speak to, these changes are either the improvements fans have been waiting for all these years, or a massive slap in the face of players who had finally perfected the mechanics. Every time they change the free kicks or penalties (does moving your player back two feet really make that much of a difference?), it’s just another unnecessary game mechanic we need to learn.

This list is full of things that really do need updating, so why do EA feel like they need to mess around with set-pieces every year? The actual sport of football hasn’t changed set-pieces this much over the last 150 plus years! It comes across as EA being lazy by making radical and obvious changes to the set-pieces just to make it clear that this year’s FIFA is different from last years.

6. Fixture Congestion

Fixture congestion has become more of an issue in real-life football over the past few years, with managers like Arsene Wenger criticising the amount of games teams have to play and the lack of a winter break in the English game. This is an issue fans of FIFA know all too well, as players have been stuck with horrific fixture scheduling in their careers modes for years, with FIFA 17 being no exception.

Advertisement

Once again, players are facing two, even three games in one week. It may not seem that big a deal, but if you are playing as a smaller club with a limited squad, having to play too many games back-to-back (most often a league game then cup tie a day or two later) usually means you’re almost guaranteed to lose one of them due to player fatigue, which can ruin a season objective and can ultimately impact your entire career.

If real-life football associations can manage to get their fixture schedules right, surely EA can figure out how to do it as well?

5. Computer AI

Regardless of what difficulty you’re playing on, making the computer AI as realistic yet user-friendly as possible is always a challenge. Make the players too poor and amateur-ish will ruin the realism of the whole game and make you feel like you're playing against kids. Make the players too responsive and realistic and you’ll have to be an actual professional footballer to get anywhere in the game. In general, the AI in FIFA 17 is pretty responsive and controls the players like an actual player would. However, there are still a few little things that EA haven’t fixed.

Advertisement

On your own team, players will still make poor runs or just get in your way when you’re storming into the box. On the opposition, players will still manually run in circles to control the ball rather than use skill moves, and will still do those annoying short free kicks and goal kicks when the natural instinct would be to hit it long. Obviously not every team just hoofs the ball upfield, but it seems the computer always wants to take it short, even when you’ve got a man closing in on the receiving player.

It doesn't impact on the overall experience that much, but it's obvious enough to make you wonder why EA haven't just fixed it already.

4. Player Demands In Career Mode

As the years have gone by, FIFA has tried to make the game as similar to real-life as possible, including the transfer market. Gone are the days you could just bring Nedved to Blackburn because you had the money. Just like in real life, the top players will only come to your team if you match their level. And just like in real life, if a player starts playing well for a small team, it’s inevitable that they will get snapped up by a top club. However, applying this to FIFA’s Career Mode is still something EA are struggling with.

Advertisement

As always, gamers are getting stuck with average players demanding transfers because they’ve gotten ‘too big for the club’, only to see them end up at a team lower than them in the league. Other fans have shared stories of Neymar demanding almost €1 million a week to stay at Barcelona.

It’s great that EA have tried to incorporate this type of challenge into the game so you can’t just breeze through with an unstoppable dream team, but these issues have been happening for years without being sorted.

3. Goalkeeper Kits

The kit selection screen has been part of the FIFA games, and all football games in general, for decades. It’s simple; pick what colour strips you want the teams to play in. That’s it. However, one thing EA still hasn’t added to this feature is the option to pick your goalkeepers kit. It may not seem like much of an issue, but getting your keeper confused for an opposition player during a goalmouth scrabble is so frustrating; especially because of something as basic as clashing colours. It doesn’t have to be an option on the selection screen; EA can just use the same algorithm they use to make sure the referee is in a different colour shirt.

Advertisement

Also, the goalkeeper kits of the lower league teams are still poorly replicated, most of the time being a bland, one-shade colour with no brand logos and just the team’s badge pasted on. If EA has the licenses for the outfield kits, surely they can make sure the goalie’s kits are accurate as well? They can replicate stadiums, boots and even hairstyles, so why is it so hard to have the correct goalie kit?

2. Tranfer Market

Making the transfer market seem believable and realistic in FIFA’s Career Mode has always been a difficult task. We all know Lionel Messi would never leave Barcelona for the sunny shores of Plymouth Argyle, and that is easy enough to program into the game, but it appears replicating the unpredictable (but also really predictable) nature of the modern-day transfer market is still too much for EA, as the same old issues have cropped up in FIFA 17.

Advertisement

Many players have taken to forums to describe how, in their games, Man United have monopolised the world’s best strikers, with everyone from Greizemann, Suarez and Icardi being signed by the club in a single transfer window, alongside keeping their existing strike force intact. Fans have also noticed that the same old transfers keep occurring, with David Alaba constantly getting signed by Juventus; a transfer that has seemingly happened in every Career Mode in every FIFA game for the past few years.

Most fans aren’t likely to care what the other teams are doing during their Career Mode, but when you’re winning the Champions League year after year, yet are struggling to sign even average players, it can get frustrating seeing the ‘big’ teams spending hundreds of millions of pounds just to create the world’s most expensive subs bench.

1. Commentary

Commentary has always been an issue with FIFA fans. Every year the commentary improves, with more player names and teams added and more natural, realistic discussion between Clive Tyldesley and Alan Smith. But there are still so many things wrong with the commentary that still haven’t been addressed.

Advertisement

Picture this; Bayern Munich are 6-0 up with minutes left, against a team who haven’t managed a single shot on target all game. A poor slide challenge gets a Bayern player sent off, and all of a sudden Alan Smith’s saying ‘it’s a backs to the wall job now’ and how Bayern will struggle to hold out for the rest of the match. Surely EA are capable of recording just a few more variant lines of dialogue for red cards for situations like this?

Also, the same old issues with commentary are still prevalent in FIFA 17, such as the clearly default viewpoints of certain teams in Career Mode (you’ve taken a League 1 club to the Premier League and have won the title several years in a row, but Alan still thinks you’re in for a relegation battle at the start of every new season), and the bizarre way the commentators stop announcing the score if it gets too high, even if it’s still fairly believable. It’s almost an impossible task to create dynamic, relevant and unique commentary for every game, but there’s so much more EA can do to improve this key feature.

Agree with these? Think there are other problems with FIFA that EA haven't bothered to fix? Let us know in the comments below.

Advertisement