FIFA 18 Top 100: 7 Biggest Surprises

Bale's big drop spells disaster for Brits in this year's game...

By Jamie Kennedy /

EA Sports

EA's Top 100 players dropped over the past week, and it should come as no surprise that Real Madrid's Cristiano Ronaldo was top of the list. Muscling out others like Lionel Messi and Neymar in the Top 10, CR7 was always going to be FIFA 18's main man. He's on the cover, he was in the ads, and he's the reigning Ballon d'Or.

Advertisement

One of Ronaldo's most esteemed teammates didn't make the cut in the top places. No, we're not talking about Karim Benzema. He wasn't in it either, but it's one of the Spanish club's other main frontmen who is a more notable omission. EA didn't show much love to Brits in general, and that extended to the lack of Premier League players in the top 10.

Thank God for those other 90 spots then.

Advertisement

The Top 100 was bursting with surprises overall. One of the best young strikers in world football was posted missing, superstars suffered due to advancing age, and even one seriously injury prone defender made the cut...

7. Boateng's Fall From Grace (8th to 33rd)

EA Sports

To quote EA, Boateng was "your top ranked defender" in FIFA 17. Boasting 79 pace, 90 defending and a huge 85 for physical stats, the German was a back line monster. Either other defenders in world football have improved or EA feel Boateng has dipped, because the Bayern Munich man has slipped from 8th to 33rd in time for FIFA 18.

Advertisement

That's a fall of 25 places, and even Jérôme's stats have taken a hit to reflect this. His pace is now 75, defending now 88 and his physical's 84. There are drops all over the place, and that must come as a disappointment to the CB who was previously regarded the best on the planet by EA. Now, he's even behind team mates like Mats Hummels.

His defensive stats still mean Boateng is one of the best, but he's no longer out on his own as FIFA's top defender. Keep that in mind when trying to buy him in Career Mode too; theoretically, Boateng should be a little cheaper now he's a year older and his stats have dropped.

Advertisement

6. 30 Premier League Players Included (But Only 1 In Top 10)

EA Sports

Listen to geezers like Gary Lineker on Match Of The Day each week and you'd be led to believe that the Premier League is where the world's best ply their trade. EA disagree, because only one man from the division cracked the Top 10 this year. Whether you agree the Prem is over-rated next to Europe's other top leagues or not, that's a surprise.

Advertisement

Chelsea wizard Eden Hazard was the man to do it, coming in at number 8 on the list. Elsewhere, 29 other Premier League stars joined him in the Top 100, but the closest to Hazard was Man Utd stopper David de Gea (11th). After the Spaniard, Arsenal's Alexis Sánchez came in at 14th, closely followed by Man City's Kevin De Bruyne at 15th.

The lowest ranked Premier League star in the Top 100? Man City's new wide man Bernardo Silva just squeaked onto the list in position 100. Others are sprinkled throughout, but only Hazard can boast being ranked alongside names like Lewandowski, Messi, and Ronaldo.

Advertisement

5. David de Gea's Exclusion From The Top 10

EA Sports

It's a surprise that the stunning reflexes of David de Gea didn't land him a spot in the Top 10. Look at some others, like Gonzalo Higuain or Toni Kroos, and it becomes even more perplexing. Did EA Sports simply decide they only wanted one goalkeeper in that 10, with Bayern keeper Manuel Neuer getting the nod?

Advertisement

That's what it looks like, because there's no good reason for de Gea's exclusion from the elite list. He's probably a more essential player than guys like Higuain or Kroos, and could even be considered more important to his team's success than Neuer is to his; a quick look at the points saved by the Spaniard at Old Trafford due to brilliant saves feeds that argument.

Younger and with better reflexes than his German peer, de Gea is the keeper of choice in FIFA 18 despite his lower ranking. Last year, he was 10th on the list, and after another sterling season between the sticks at Old Trafford it's a slight shock to see him drop a place this year.

Advertisement

4. Vincent Kompany Sneaking In (84)

EA Sports

EA said themselves that the Top 100 was drawn together via in-depth analysis of player "performances from the past year of football". It's totally baffling then that often-injured Man City defender Vincent Kompany is even on the list at all. He only played 15 matches in league and cup last season for City.

Advertisement

Usually seen watching from the stands these days, the Belgian is a great CB when he's fit, but those occasions are becoming increasingly rare with each passing season. Seeing him stroll onto the list in the 84th position ahead of last season's superstars like Dele Alli (93rd on the list) and Liverpool's Senegalese sensation Sadio Mané (98th) is hard to stomach.

EA obviously rate Kompany and haven't taken his injuries into account. That's weird, because they quite clearly took the injury woes of Zlatan Ibrahimović to heart this year. The Swede dropped from 7th in FIFA 17 to 30th this season, and that must be due to his own fitness problems.

Advertisement

3. The Drop In Stats For Some Top Stars

EA Sports

According to FIFA, Lionel Messi isn't quite as good at dribbling with the ball as he was last year. Why else would the Barcelona legend go from a 96 stat to 95? That seems to be change for the sake of it, and Messi isn't alone either. EA's tampering has extended to others like Cristiano Ronaldo and even PSG's new star man Neymar.

Advertisement

Bizarrely, the Brazilian's pace has also taken a one point dip (95 to 94), with the same fall for his passing (79 to 78). As for Ronaldo, even being FIFA 18's poster boy couldn't save him from suffering hits to his overall stats in the game. It's strange to see FIFA's top trio become slightly worse players in some areas.

Ronaldo's pace has gone from 92 to 90 and his dribbling from 91 to 90. There are small improvements to other stats that compensate for these changes, but they still come across as strange considering the glittering achievements and goal-scoring records all three had in season 2016-17.

Advertisement

2. Gareth Bale's Drop (6th to 17th)

EA Sports

After hauling Wales to the semi final stage of EURO 2016, the right wing skills of Gareth Bale were rewarded with a place as the 6th best player overall in FIFA 17. In EA's opinion, last season wasn't quite so sparkling, and that's why Bale looks on enviously at Real Madrid team mates like Toni Kroos, Sergio Ramos, and Cristiano Ronaldo this year.

Advertisement

Now ranked 17th for this year's game, Bale is surprisingly below others like Alexis Sánchez and even falls just short of another Madrid chum. Bernabéu playmaker Luka Modrić is in 12th position, a full five slots ahead of his Welsh colleague. For someone expected to be bothering the top spots this year, that has to be disappointing.

Perhaps a return to the Premier League would reinvigorate the Welshman's career. Saying that, he's hardly doing badly by winning trophies galore with Madrid, but he isn't quite as celebrated as his natural talents suggest he should be.

Advertisement

Are you watching, Man Utd?

1. No Mbappé In The Top 100

EA Sports

Kylian Mbappé Lottin was a hidden gem in FIFA 17, and the kind of player 'showing great potential' you could pick up for a song with the right timing. Over a few seasons, the Frenchmen would develop into one of the game's best strikers, and that talent was visible in the real-life game too. Mbappé netted 26 goals as Monaco won the French league and reached the Champions League semis last season.

Advertisement

Being touted by some of the world's top clubs (and eventually joining stars like Neymar at PSG) still isn't enough to convince EA that the teenager is one of the Top 100 players in the world. That has to change in time for FIFA 19, surely, because the ex-Monaco man is set to take over the game and become football's top striker.

At the very least, you'd expect to see him lurking towards the back end of the Top 100, but Mbappé isn't to be found. Maybe this will change should he start the season in blistering form for PSG - EA can't ignore the sought-after 18 year old for long.

Advertisement

-

What other surprises were lurking in the FIFA 18 Top 100? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!

Advertisement