FIFA 19 Demo Review: 3 Ups & 3 Downs

If hearing that Champions League anthem doesn't hit you right in the feels, nothing will...

By Jamie Kennedy /

EA Sports

As predicted before it happened by all and sundry, FIFA 19's demo dropped on Thursday afternoon, a fortnight or so before the full game releases on 28 September. Good news: it's a winner for the most part, and it's a blast to play as teams like Real Madrid in the Santiago Bernabéu or city rivals Atlético in their cavernous Wanda Metropolitano.

Advertisement

10 teams are available in all, and the demo allows you to get to grips with some new gameplay mechanics in a one-off Champions League group stage match. Elsewhere, there are some standard pre-match training drills, a teaser for The Journey: Champions (which is set to be Alex Hunter's swan song) and the usual EA 'BUY IT NOW' buttons splashed all over the place.

It is a demo, after all.

Advertisement

So, the big question on everyone's lips will be about those sweeping changes EA promised to the action on the pitch. Are they all there? In a word, yes, although it's worth noting that some other hyped tweaks don't exactly do what they say on the tin without some imagination from the player...

Downs...

3. Irritating 'New Features' Reminders

EA Sports

It's totally cool that EA would want to blast players in the face with some unskippable text-heavy menu screens the first time they boot up FIFA 19's demo. What's not nice is having to sit through those same old sliders every single time the demo loads. There's only so many times one can see Neymar's smiley little face without starting to resent it.

Advertisement

Worse, those screens pop up again and again when you come out of matches. That means a lot of frantic X button hammering (or A if you're on Xbox One and not PS4) to get rid of them. This kind of constant advertising, even in a demo, is a bit excessive.

It's not as though the info contained within requires scrutiny; this is basic stuff, and only serves to outline what can be expected from the full game. EA should have limited such hyperbolic annoyance to a one-off, or had the sense to make it appear from the top of the demo instead of throughout.

Advertisement

2. The Journey 3 Teaser Doesn't Reveal Much

EA Sports

In the teaser for The Journey's third chapter, don't expect to be seeing an awful lot of what the branching storyline has to offer. Here, you'll see Alex Hunter watch a Champions League draw, waffle away with some pals and agents, play a quick training drill with his new Real Madrid teammates, play 30 mins against Man Utd in Europe then answer one media question.

Advertisement

That's literally it, and if it sounds like a lot then apologies, because it isn't.

OK, so this is a demo (blah blah blah), but EA did a naff job of revealing why those who have followed Hunter's tale should be excited. There's no hint at the role Danny Williams or Alex's step-sister Kim will play in the narrative either, and newbies will be left wondering what all the fuss is about.

Advertisement

This teaser makes The Journey look like Be A Pro with some cut scenes added in, when it can be so much more than that. No talk of customisation, no focus on the three-pronged story and zero time to get to grips before it's done.

1. Tactics System Doesn't Seem As In-Depth As Advertised

EA Sports

Unless there's more to it in the full game, then EA's big talk about a refined, in-depth and exhaustive tactical overhaul has boiled down to nonsense.

Advertisement

Sure, keen managers can set up unique playing styles for individuals in the team and tag them to specific strategies like 'All-Out-Attack' or 'Defensive', but there's no sign of the discussed ability to hatch clever plans such as wing backs staying back after 70 mins. You'll still be controlling things the same way as ever.

In other words, Footy Manager this ain't. Maybe we were all expecting too much and should reserve judgement until the full release?

Advertisement

In the demo, FIFA's tactical suite is much the same as it's been over the past few years, just with some new terminology. As for set piece strategies, they're largely the same, and it's definitely still possible to 'Park The Bus'.

Changing the wording doesn't count, EA. You had to do more here than tweak. PES 2019 still has the advantage here, and that's disappointing after all the rumour, hype and tantalising potential for on-the-couch tacticians.

Advertisement

Ups...

3. Atmosphere Is Booming

EA Sports

Onto the good stuff.

Advertisement

First things first, FIFA 19's presentation absolutely blows Konami's workmanlike PES 2019 effort out of the water. Honestly, it's stunning stuff, and the first time you fire up that Champions League group game (regardless of the chosen teams) is a breath-taking moment.

It's not only that official UEFA anthem blaring as the teams pretend the whole world isn't watching them line up, it's the sheer majesty of the booming chants from the crowd and some neat little touches that make the occasion come to life. For example, seeing fans revel in the Champions League excitement by taking selfies before and during the match is somehow awesome.

Advertisement

This writer's first trial run was a 'home' game (at the Wanda Metropolitano) for Juventus against Man Utd. Immediately, the difference in styles between those supporting Ronaldo's new mob and outnumbered English fans watching their beloved Red Devils was startling.

2. New Commentary

EA Sports

As good as Martin Tyler and Alan Smith have been on commentary duty forever in FIFA, their banter was beginning to grow a bit stale. That was more true of European nights in last year's game; that Champions Cup drivel was awkward in a license-driven product like EA's monster is.

Advertisement

Derek Rae and Lee Dixon are a refreshing change of pace, and their excitable voices will give any FIFA veteran's ears a rest from Tyler's "...and it's live" catchphrase or Smith's witticisms about life at Arsenal in the 1980s when they're playing on the continent.

Quite sincerely, this is the best FIFA's commentary has sounded since 15 was released.

Advertisement

Of course, it remains to be seen how long it'll be before Rae and Dixon start repeating themselves. That's the downfall of any sports title these days, audio wise. Nonetheless, it's genuinely great to have some new narrators, and both men exchange natural banter without trying too hard.

1. Some Hyped Gameplay Changes Make A Difference

EA Sports

If tactics appear a letdown, then other changes promised by EA pick up the slack.

Advertisement

One of the first things you're bound to notice when playing is how much weightier each player feels. This is particularly handy when contesting a loose ball in the middle of the park. EA weren't lying about those 50/50 crunch tackles, and the ball spins naturally away from both players with a titillating realness.

Similarly, slide tackles no longer feel like laser-guided missiles that'll result in picture-perfect steals or tedious bookings from whistle-happy refs every time. This helps the long-established 'play on' feature shine for the first time ever, but it's also a balancing act. Try to dive in too many times and defending teammates behind your man will now become flustered, often darting out of possession to cover your mistake.

Advertisement

That leaves space behind, space that can be punished by quick over-the-top through balls and EA's 'Timed Finishing' mechanic. Surprisingly, it actually works, and it can end in net-bursting glory or the world's best looking like Sunday League losers.

Overall, FIFA 19's gameplay seems solid, less scripted than before and comparable to the silky slickness of PES.

Advertisement

What did you think of the new FIFA 19 demo? Were you basking in Champions League atmosphere or slightly underwhelmed? Let us know down in the comments section below!