Final Fantasy 7 Remake Review - 6 Ups & 5 Downs

Square have delivered, and there's so much to break down.

By Scott Tailford /

Square Enix

Rating: ★★★★☆

Advertisement

Was there any way for Square Enix to completely nail the Final Fantasy VII remake? We're talking about something that was instrumental to millions of us caring about not only the game, but the medium of gaming overall. Multiple generations of players will remember taking down the red scorpion boss, hanging out at Cosmo Canyon or piloting the Highwind airship towards a climactic battle (or three).

Point being: This is easily Square Enix's greatest triumph, and the first Final Fantasy that made its way to the West left an indelible mark - one the company themselves have tried to revisit and improve upon multiple times.

Advertisement

With promising remake videos being labelled "tech demos", 10th year anniversary celebrations giving us CG movie sequels and handheld prequels to boot, Final Fantasy VII is practically its own cottage industry within Square Enix.

For them to go back to the drawing board so directly - literally calling this a "remake" and updating everything from the score to the script - it became one of the most highly anticipated titles of all time.

Advertisement

In the end though, can FF7R live up to the hype?

- Ups -

6. One Of The Best Looking Games Of All Time

Square

Let's start with the positives. FF7R is literally one of the finest looking titles available on modern hardware - a jaw-droppingly stunning achievement in regards to the craft of games, and something that anyone who's seen FF7: Advent Children will be totally blown away by.

Advertisement

Clothing detail including stitching, billowing skirts and hyper-detailed buckles, weapon marks, scuffs and material surfaces. Even Cloud's hair illuminates differently depending on whether you're standing amongst a pile of rubble, or against the backdrop of a setting sun.

I'll get to combat mechanics in a sec, but that too is a sight to behold. Every clash of steel or powder keg spell results in a shower of particle effects - the developers confident enough in their work to let you pause the action and watch every frame drip out in ultra slow-motion.

Advertisement

In many ways, FF7 Remake is a celebration of Final Fantasy VII, and it's a total visual feast in the best way possible.

5. Combat Is Phenomenal (When It Works)

Square Enix

That small bracketed caveat will be expanded on in the negative portion of this article, as for the most part, this is the best combat system Square Enix have ever devised.

Advertisement

Literally, you have all the lessons learned from Final Fantasy 12 and 15, rolled into something that totally works. FF 12 in terms of party management, pausing the action to jump between characters and assign spells, special abilities etc., and FF XV's real-time combat, except this time you're punching attacks in with timed presses, rather than holds.

The result is a blast, especially paired with the visuals I mentioned earlier.

Advertisement

Over time you'll need to constantly switch between the whole party, queuing up attacks and maximising everything they have on offer as a unit. You can always focus on one character and go all-out, but this is a perfect hybrid of 1997's turn-based original, and a new-age "action RPG" feel, the likes of which only Ni No Kuni 2 has ever really got right.

A pioneering battle system for everyone else to take influence from? That sounds like Final Fantasy VII to me.

Advertisement

4. The New Levelling System

Square Enix

In most other RPGs, you level up and every stat increases. Strength, speed, magic attack and defence - it's something we've taken for granted.

Advertisement

In FF7R, that's totally upended. Now when you do so, you're awarded Skill Points (SP), that can be fed into each weapon's "cores". These come with a handful of abilities like "+200 HP", "Healing spells increase effect when on 20% or less HP", "Limit Breaks increase faster", "ATB increases faster" etc.

It lets you specialise each new weapon how you like, whilst also - brilliantly - meaning you can continually increase the starter weapons across the whole game. By the end switched back to Cloud's Buster Sword - now one of the best weapons in the game - and that just felt ace.

Advertisement

Lastly, each weapon comes with a signature attack you can learn if you pull it off multiple times. Once done the character will learn the ability, and it transfers over to every other weapon.

Combined with the core system, you're more than encouraged to try every character's full weapon set, benefitting from abilities and playstyles across the entire runtime.

Advertisement

All-round, it's the best new change in the game, and something I hope Square and other devs run with going forward.

3. Realising Midgar In An Interactive, Geographically Mapped Space

Square Enix

It may seem like a tiny detail to newcomers, but being able to actually pan the camera around and "breathe in" a fully realised, fully rendered city of Midgar, is a massive positive. It's an engaging and memorable locale even for newcomers, and later in the game you'll unlock a series of fast travel points that get you around everything Square have designed in one giant playspace.

Advertisement

Separated by corridors, these "hubs" are replete with everything from optional challenge to a combat arena, secret item vendors, music tracks to collect and many other things to take in.

Being able to run from Aerith's church allll the way down to Wall Market is a fan-pleasing inclusion many will be glad to see, and it lays out just how many new assets Square Enix built for this remake.

Advertisement

2. Fan Service, And One GENIUS Thing You Won't See Coming

Square Enix

I'm staying away from spoilers completely, but one of the many reasons I think this works better as a celebration of Final Fantasy VII - or FF7 ephemera - is some of the fan service.

Advertisement

There are things here that feel as though Square Enix literally combed through forums across the last 20 years, and deliberately picked out what fans cited as "No way... there's no way they'll ever do that."

I won't spoil what these are, but from boss battles to teasing future plot points, referencing character beats or the wider FF7 fandom, if you've been on this ride for the past couple of decades, they're more than aware of how to pay that off.

Advertisement

Atop this - and it's the biggest spoiler in the game so I'll keep it vague - there's a new inclusion to the narrative, that directly addresses both the existence of the FF7 Remake, and where they go from here.

Not going any further than that for now, but the final hours are something I absolutely adored, and will be dissected for years to come.

Advertisement

1. When It's Allowed To Be Final Fantasy VII, There's Nothing Better

Square Enix

The biggest positive by far is honing in on the start and end of the experience.

Advertisement

My completion time was 30 hours, and that was doing the vast majority of the side missions too. There's a big ol' bloat in the middle where it doesn't feel like anything other than padding is being thrown your way, but the opening and closing arcs are immaculate.

When the combat is popping off, you're switching between everyone as they trade banter and special attacks, the music is soaring and everything looks iconic and gorgeous - THAT is the Final Fantasy VII Remake.

Advertisement

Bafflingly, one of the best examples of this comes towards the VERY end - literally 20+ hours in - and that's an insane marker for "when it gets really good".

FF7R is a triumph in all of the areas I've mentioned, but there are some negatives too.

Advertisement

- Downs -

5. Pacing & Padding

Square Enix

The one thing that will stick out massively to newcomers and returning fans, is an insane amount of padding that bulks out each chapter.

Advertisement

I'm talking old-school, "this door is locked, go find three switches!", "this character fell off a walkway so here's half an hour of corridor-crawling to get back", "Time to slowly walk sideways through various crevices"-levels of padding.

It's very clear Square were in a bit of a tight spot, even in conceptualising how to "do" Final Fantasy 7 for a modern audience, on modern tech.

Advertisement

We're talking about a game that's 40-60 hours long, and Midgar is barely a fifth of that. Chopping everything around so that Midgar is now a 30 hour experience means plot beats get elongated, "game-ified" open spaces are injected everywhere to prolong getting to the next story moment, and it gets in the way at every turn.

Replayability is aided by a merciful chapter select after you've finished, but first time through - especially as the core plot drive is SO good - you'll be begging for all these drawn out sections and animations to stop.

Advertisement

4. WAY Too Many Story Changes For The Worse

Square-Enix

Final Fantasy VII is one of the best games of all time for many reasons - most of them being thematics, loveable characters, great builds and payoffs, and an intricate world where plot twists land with weight and sometimes horror.

Advertisement

FF7 Remake is very much not trying to replicate that sensation, which feels like a mistake. I've mentioned the "celebratory feel", but this applies to a general tonality of blockbuster cinema or the recent spate of Disney remakes.

It's like all the plot points of the full game were scattered onto a table, then remixed and gathered in different groups. Yes, every major story beat of Final Fantasy VII (the original) is here, but by compacting everything into its opening section and stretching that out, we have a TON of notable changes for the worse.

Advertisement

Main villain Sephiroth for example, is completely different. He loses ALL of his most iconic scenes - the ones that set the tone for his character and impact on the gang - and is given a "is he real/is he not" cutaway over and over until the climax.

Cloud's cross-dressing scene - while still having its heart in the right place - doesn't come together with the same agency on behalf of Aerith, and ditches the angle of a retired male dress maker choosing to come back for one more project.

Advertisement

These are just two things that stand out, but in the coming weeks and years when people have time to compare everything, it's staggering how much was changed for the worse.

MANY plot reveals and moments from post-Midgar are inserted as a way to try and tell a "fuller" story, but they have a knock-on effect of not making sense, as characters can't fully follow up until much later in the overall narrative.

Advertisement

3. Writing & Dialogue Can Be Pretty Terrible

Square Enix

Another negative that stems from hyper-extending character writing from the opening of a game into a full three-act structure: Almost everyone is written badly, or comes across as nowhere near as nuanced as the original script.

Advertisement

Yes, that original is cited as being a mess thanks to a one-man translation team, but it clearly worked for millions of us, and there were only a handful of things to change if someone was going to re-approach.

Instead, we have a completely new script that attempts to blend the tonalities of newer Square Enix releases - the Kingdom Hearts of the world, plus the FF7 Advent Children movie AND Crisis Core - resulting in an "anime-adjacent" sensibility.

Advertisement

This could've totally worked, but Cloud is underwritten to a fault. For 20 hours you're stuck with him answering characters in one word grunts, or not answering at all. It's clearly to serve where his character goes in the full story, but even in the original game, he was more chatty overall.

Square Enix

Aerith, Tifa AND Jessie are reduced to glorified waifus for the majority, pining and thirsting over Cloud in a very "fangirl"-esque way, to the detriment of their characters overall.

Advertisement

Essentially, you'll either be able to go with this more "on the nose" depiction of each characters' core tenets - and it does get better towards the back third - but for me, it's a negative.

I'll also say, that in a couple of spots that should be incredibly emotional, Cloud's delivery and the way the audio is edited together, was straight-up unintentionally hilarious.

Advertisement

2. Combat Does Have Some Fatal Flaws

Square

A quick negative on the combat, is it's far too easy to just get stun-locked into oblivion.

Advertisement

Enemies can interrupt your animations - be it a healing spell or even item use - and it can come from off screen, sometimes making it feel like the game just wanted you to die.

You can largely mitigate this with forward planning, positioning and layering on stun attacks yourself, but coupled with a camera that REALLY loses its mind indoors, there are spots where the whole thing falls apart.

Advertisement

Know that I do consider combat in FF7R to be one of the highlights, but it can go south at a moment's notice.

1. The Original Is Still Better

Square Enix

Over time, Square Enix have referred to this project as a number of different things.

Advertisement

First it was a "full remake", then it was going to be released episodically, then they were still calling it "the Final Fantasy VII Remake", but the rest of the story is coming at some point in the future. THEN during many interviews and a press event I attended, it was referred to as the "Final Fantasy VII re-imagination project".

Clearly, this has been a mammoth task to bring together, and the final game is something that ticks many boxes of the original with aplomb. However, production schedules or other whims have resulted in great characters, plot beats, overall pacing and memorability being sacrificed to try and force an opening section to be a full game.

Advertisement

It's noticeable, I imagine even to newcomers, and for all the reasons I'm mentioning, I'd still recommend the original as your overall introduction to this mythos.

Final Fantasy VII Remake is still an outstanding game in many respects, but fundamentally, it does not replace its stellar 1997 release.

Advertisement