Final Fantasy - Which Game is The Best?

We rank 22 Final Fantasy games to answer the ultimate question of which one is the best in the series...

By Damon /

SPOILERS in this list, so you might just want to check the numbering. We'll be covering a lot of entries in the series here, so let's start off (again, fair warning to all, there will be SPOILERS):

Advertisement

22. Final Fantasy XIV

If there ever was a train-wreck in the Final Fantasy series, it was FFXIV. Released way too early, it was a buggy mess with plenty of technical issues. Created as an MMORPG to succeed FFXI, FFXIV failed massively to deliver. I still remember when this game was first announced at E3 some years ago, everyone was ecstatic to see another new Final Fantasy game, until the word Online came up on the trailer and everyone realised it was going to be an MMORPG. I personally wished that Square Enix used a different moniker/title for the MMO's, something as simple as Final Fantasy Online, and start a new numbered series from there or something. Alas, it is what it is now. It should be noted that since that disastrous start, FFXIV has been undergoing improvements under a new team direction and will be getting a second release as version 2.0 sometime in the future. Whilst it would be unfair to condemn any future version of the game simply because of the initial release, for now, FFXIV deservedly reserves the last spot in this list. Click "next" below to read the next entry...

21. Final Fantasy VII: Dirge Of Cerberus

One of the many spin-offs that came out after Square Enix suddenly decided to cash in on the FFVII name, Dirge of Cerberus is a big disappointment. Unlike most games on this list, DoC isn't an RPG, but an action third-person shooter with RPG elements. It still makes this list due to the FFVII relation. DoC wasn't that good as an action game anyway, but its most glaring fault was trying to portray its setting as being more important than that of FFVII (we all know better). A major mistake any sequel can make is to downplay the original. DoC attempts that but still fails at execution. This wasn't a fun return to Midgar and its surroundings. Hopefully Square Enix learnt from this experience. For the most part, all direct sequels that have been made to FF games are worse than its predecessor. This being the worst of them all. They should really start putting more effort into direct sequels.

20. Final Fantasy IV: The After Years

The sequel to FFIV came during a time when RPGs had changed and evolved massively. As such, a trip down memory lane will only please the die-hard fans of FFIV. Unashamedly, TAY practically re-told the story of FFIV, only this time through the eyes of Ceodore. It was also very short and featured the annoying aspect of DLC side-stories and side-quests, at a steep price, to get the most out of the game. In the end, it was a short game for the pure FFIV fan.

19. Final Fantasy II

To be fair, most of the earlier titles in the Final Fantasy series can't quite live up to today's standards. Simpler plots, graphics and gameplay make it harder to compete, but they do deserve a spot in history. At number 19 we have Final Fantasy II, the first 'sequel' in the series, that wasn't a direct continuation of the first Final Fantasy, but told its own story with its own lore, background and characters. FFII did a few things differently to FFI. For starters, it had a stronger, more driven story. It was an interesting if lengthy romp with a good degree of drama and emotion. The major downside with FFII is with the leveling system, known as a proficiency system where you level-up the attributes you use the most. While that sounds good, and has been done well in other games, in FFII there are drawbacks. To increase your life bar, your characters need to get hit a lot. Seriously. Which means you need to constantly be taking damage to reach good levels or, as many found out, you could just whack your own characters during an easy battle to level up quick and easy. The weird balance issues with the leveling system is one of the main reasons you'll find FFII near the bottom of many Final Fantasy ranking lists. A quick note that the first appearances of Cid and Chocobos were in this game.

18. Final Fantasy

Ah, the original. The game that brought Squaresoft out from the brink of bankruptcy. As fans know and some others like to point out as irony, the first Final Fantasy was meant to be 'final'. A last ditch effort to make it in the gaming world. It worked, and the rest as they say, is history. FFI provided a solid RPG experience coupled with a simple story. It got its foundations right and gamers ate it up. It's hard to compare such an old game to today's standard, it would certainly be tough to recommend nowadays, but it deserves its place in history. 25 years ago - 1987 - was when it was released. And many fans are grateful not only to this original game, but to the fans who ate it up at the time, as the FF series grew, diversified and created many more memorable games.

17. Final Fantasy IV

This will probably be the first contentious entry in this list. I will freely admit, I did not like FFIV. It is still one of the few FF games that I have never bothered to complete. A lot of that is to do with the story, but the straight forward leveling system is part of that too. The best way I can describe my thoughts about FFIV's story is that it focuses way too much on plot-twists as its form of plot development. These plot-twists also seem to serve no other reason than to extend gameplay time, so that the player has more to do. Many instances crop up to showcase this like: Were you told there were only 4 crystals? You'd be a fool for believing that, as there are another 4 crystals hidden away. Someone sacrificed themselves for the party? You'd be a fool for falling for that, as numerous people return from the 'dead', drastically diminishing the effect of any 'death scene'. Think the enemy is evil? Think again, he's only being mind-controlled. The list goes on and on. It doesn't help that the protagonist, Cecil, is the epitome of a knight in shining armor. Always righteous and dutiful. And dull. The best way I can compare it is to imagine playing Tales of Vesperia (if you've ever played it, good game that one) as Flynn instead of Yuri. Too bad the 'Yuri' of FFIV, Kain, doesn't reach great heights. The game is also very linear. Not that linearity is a bad thing, but when so many people criticise newer FF games for their linearity and cite older entries as purely better for being non-linear, well, FFIV is very linear too, both in terms of story and gameplay. Leveling up is a straight forward accumulation of experience points. You don't even know what abilities will unlock as you level up, so you do it blindly. That's a lot worse than newer entries. FFIV did however introduce gamers to the Active Time Battle gauge that charged up to indicate when a character's turn was approaching. The ATB gauge has been used in almost every FF game since then, providing a better flow for combat as players had to now strategise on the go. I can wholly understand how FFIV gained such high praise back in the day. Its story was more complex and its characters more varied than previous entries. Over time though, it has easily been overshadowed.

16. Final Fantasy VIII

Perhaps another contentious entry in this list. Again, I will freely admit, I did not like FFVIII. At least, in terms of story. I didn't wholly mind the leveling up system with magic drawing and whatnot, although I do recognise the flaws of that mechanic. Since I didn't go in abusing the system however, I still had some fun with FFVIII's gameplay. Having said that, FFVIII is one of the other games in the series I never bothered finishing. And that's to do with the story. I guess it should speak volumes that I kinda liked the gameplay yet couldn't bring myself to continue. The story is just overall badly told. I'm not sure if it's to do with translation/localisation issues, as the core story is more than bearable. Squall himself isn't too bad as a protagonist, but the other characters and numerous plot points of the game leave you with a bad taste in your mouth. I still remember half the party moping around thinking Squall (and so the player too) left them with a mission because he didn't like them or something. The over reliance on Squall as some sort of special 'Hero' by practically everyone around him annoyed me to no end. And then there's the 'Orphanage Scene', possibly one of the worst storytelling moments in gaming ever. I can't even bring myself to write about it. Aside from those few moments, a good chunk of the game is enjoyable. Learning the background of certain characters is interesting too. Ultimately though, the bad moments outshine the good in the overall scheme of things. That is why FFVIII ranks here.

15. Final Fantasy III

FFIII owes most of its praise due to the job system, which it introduced first. FFIII allowed players to switch character jobs at any given time, providing plenty of freedom to mix and match jobs as you saw fit. FFIII suffered from the same issues the older games had, namely a simple story and graphics, but the gameplay shone through. Later remakes provided names to the characters with background information to boot, enhancing the experience slightly. A good game overall, and sometimes, a simple story is better than a bad one.

14. Final Fantasy XI

FFXI was the first MMO in the Final Fantasy series. It is a huge game, with quite a few expansions and a new expansion has even been announced recently. There are a number of quests in the game, some with pretty decent stories to guide you forward too. Overall however, being an MMO is highly polarising. If you can't stomach the amount of hours and effort needed to be put into the game, you won't enjoy it. The game requires a lot of grinding to boot, which I don't particularly find fun in the other games anyway, let alone here. Still, it does have its attractions, and at the time, it was a decent experience. With World of Warcraft now the king of MMORPGs, it's hard to see people opting for it FFXI now.

13. Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings

The sequel to FFXII focused on Vaan and Penelo and a few other familiar faces as they encounter a new threat in Ivalice. Interestingly enough, Revenant Wings isn't an RPG, but features gameplay more akin to a real-time strategy (RTS) game. A more simplistic RTS at that, meaning no resource gathering as such. Sequels are hard to rank because interest in the game will depend a lot on whether you liked the first game, and it's not that different here. The storytelling in itself is decent, and gameplay is fun if you're into the RTS-like feel. Gameplay could be a bit tough if you weren't fully accustomed to the Nintendo DS controls though, something that doesn't effect many of the other games on this list, but needs to be stated in this case. That said, it is still simplistic in nature, and an 'all out attack' mentality can still get the job done; and done well.