Five Years Later: 10 Things You Learn Replaying Fallout 4

Fallout 4 recently turned five! From crafting to The Commonwealth, how does it hold up?

By Alfie Seymour /

It's safe to say the Fallout franchise isn't in the best of places right now.

Advertisement

Fallout 76 was a disaster. It took one of the best ideas for a game - an online Fallout world for you to explore with friends - and buried it under buggy gameplay, a weak excuse for a campaign and a lifeless world. And that's without even mentioning the various controversies Bethesda managed to drag themselves into over things such as misleading collector's editions and premium online passes.

However, with all of the hysteria that came with Fallout 76, it's easy to forget how excited people had been for Fallout 4 just a few years earlier.

Taking the bold move (for the time) of announcing their next big release just months before its release, Todd Howard stood on the E3 2015 stage and proceeded to blow the expectations of everyone away as he unveiled Bethesda's first game since Skyrim hit the scene in 2011.

Upon launch, the game was widely praised by critics and sold extremely well. However, it was met with mixed reviews from fans of the series. While it may have been partially due to the immense level of hype Bethesda managed to create, it seems worth going back to Fallout 4 now and examining its successes and shortcomings to see whether the criticism levelled at it were justified.

10. The Visuals Hold Up Better Than Many Think

While it's no Red Dead Redemption 2 in the graphics department, Fallout 4 still holds up better than many give it credit for.

Advertisement

When the world isn't bugging out and textures aren't popping in, Fallout 4's world is excellent to look at. Part of the reason games such as Fallout 3 haven't aged as well compared to other games from the 360/PS3 generation is that their moody colour palette makes them appear dull by modern comparisons.

However Fallout 4 has a much brighter aesthetic compared to its predecessor, and the game looks all the better for it. When the sun is shining down on The Commonwealth, you can't help but gaze around and take the glory of the world in.

Yes, some of the textures look a little bit murky when compared to other games this generation. Yes, it is a tad concerning that Bethesda plan to use the same Creation Engine from Fallout 4 for both Starfield and The Elder Scrolls VI. However at its best, Fallout 4 is still a solid looking game that doesn't get the praise for its graphics that it perhaps should.

9. The Perk System Was Heavily Underrated

One of the key aspects of any RPG is the progression system. Without a good sense that your character's skills are improving with time, it is difficult to feel as though you're truly developing them into your character.

Advertisement

Fallout 4's progression system represented a major departure from the previous games in the series. Whereas previous entries had you investing points in certain skills to improve your stats over time, Fallout 4 seems to take inspiration from games like Bioshock and its tonic system, as instead players invest in a perk each time they level up which adds a certain buff to their character.

While this may seem like dumbing down to some, the system allows for a great deal of variety. Each section in the S.P.E.C.I.A.L system has nearly a dozen perks to choose from and each perk has multiples levels to it allowing for a huge amount of player choice in how they upgrade their character. It allows players to only pick the specific benefits of an attribute they want rather than investing lots of points just to get one specific upgrade along with five they don't want.

Overall, while some perks did feel like little more than stat buffs, lots of them did have tangible benefits in-game that could be felt from the moment you bought them, which helped bring a strong feeling of progression to the game, something that wasn't talked about enough when it came out.

8. The Crafting System Is Amazing

One thing a lot of games which involve collecting lots of junk from around the world struggle with is making everything you pick up useful. What's the point of picking up all of this stuff if you aren't ever going to use it for anything? That's what makes Bethesda's crafting system in Fallout 4 so brilliant.

Advertisement

Every item in the world you pick up contains components, and these are essential for helping you construct upgrades for your guns and power armour that you journey through The Commonwealth with. Bethesda give you a huge amount of customisation and upgrade options for your guns, which means that you can take even the most basic rifle and turn it into a super-mutant destroying monster with enough tender love and care.

The catch is that while some components such as screws come along with every pipe-pistol you pick up from the raider you just dismembered, there are some which are much rarer. This can lead to desperate searches for very specific objects which contain the component you need, adding another layer of depth to the game's exploration.

This leaves the player with agonising decisions as to whether they want to sell off their expensive new item for caps at the risk that they may not have a necessary component when they need it down the line. It's a very engaging system, which provides both new reasons for exploration and endless customisation of your character's playstyle.

7. The Base System Feels Pointless

Guns weren't the only thing you could craft in Fallout 4. You could also use it to help build settlements for the people of the Commonwealth to reside in, complete with defences and shops run by settlers.

Advertisement

While this makes sense within the context of a Fallout game, and it would be a shame to see the option disappear entirely from future games, it feels as though Bethesda weren't quite able to capture the essence of what makes titles like Minecraft so enjoyable to build in.

Put simply, the bases you build serve virtually no purpose in the wider game. While they serve as good places to store your collection of power armour sets or to get large amounts of purified water, the bases have no impact on the story or the world whatsoever, meaning that all the effort that goes into building them feels wasted.

Add in the fact that the complex menus make learning how the system works and choosing what to build a chore and you have a recipe for an underwhelming feature.

The bases may have been somewhat pointless in Fallout 4, however that shouldn't discourage Bethesda from building on the system further. It just needs fleshing out to be more consequential and intuitive to use.

6. The Side-characters Are A Mixed Bag

Fallout is a franchise that lends itself well to having a wacky cast of characters (all that radiation must take a toll on people), and fortunately Bethesda delivered that in Fallout 4. However, while many of these characters are interesting when you first meet them, many of them simply fade into the background, which is a shame, because Bethesda had some truly awesome ideas with some of them.

Advertisement

Take Nick Valentine, Diamond City's resident private detective. He is a synth that escaped The Institute and is now living in a world where he is feared by many. Despite this, he remains committed to helping those who need it. A character like this has the potential to be a massive point of interest throughout the story, especially given the debate put forward about the integration of AI into society, yet he disappears from the story after only a couple of missions.

The best way to get the most out of the side characters on a play-through is to commit to keeping one with you at all times, as it allows you to build a relationship with them based on what you do, and can ask on their opinions on the events of the game as it unfolds.

However, it's a shame that Bethesda couldn't find a more natural way to flesh some of these characters out. Still, this can to an extent be passed off as a limitation of the genre rather than Bethesda themselves.

5. The Dialogue System Didn't Work

Bethesda's decision to opt for a fully voiced protagonist, as opposed to the silent one featured in previous games, was met with mixed reactions. Some felt that losing the ability to put their own voice on the character would limit their connection to the character while others felt it was a necessary step forward for modern games. However, one thing that can be agreed on is that the dialogue system failed to please either group.

Advertisement

Rather than the text answers given in previous games, Bethesda 'streamlined' the way you interact with characters by attributing certain kinds of responses to certain buttons. However, these options essentially boiled down to little more than 'yes', 'no', 'question' and 'sarcastic'.

The problem was that it was impossible to entirely understand what the ramifications of your answer would be as you didn't really know what your character would say once you pressed the button. Furthermore, it removed much of the nuance that comes in your answers as your options for answering every question are the same, meaning that few conversations stand out as memorable for what your protagonist says.

While a voiced protagonist may be something that many can get behind, it feels as though Bethesda will need to rethink how they approach player dialogue when Fallout 5 inevitably comes out.

4. The Open World Is Still One Of The Deepest From The Last Generation

Few game developers, aside from CD Projekt Red and Rockstar, can boast to creating open worlds quite as detailed and lore-heavy as Bethesda. Every room has a story and trawling through computers for diary entries and audio logs can be a fascinating experience given how much has happened in the world of Fallout.

Advertisement

The Commonwealth, based in Boston, is stuffed to the brim with towns and enemy bases to discover. Key locations such as Fenway Park have been recreated in haunting detail, highlighting the destruction caused by the nuclear apocalypse.

Furthermore, the world has a wide selection of location types, ranging from built-up areas like Diamond City, rural settlements where the residents are forced to scourge whatever they can to survive, to radiation infested hell-holes where the only life is ghouls and Radscorpians.

There's nothing quite like being on your way to complete a mission only to a stumble upon a vault, which you obviously have to look inside, before wishing you hadn't upon discovering the kind of horrifying experiments committed by Vault-tec inside. It's moments like this which make the open-world feel alive and show that Bethesda is still one of the best when it comes to building them.

3. The Story Is Generally Excellent...

The Fallout games have always been known for their stories. In fact, one of the main reasons Fallout 76 failed was because its story was virtually non-existent, but thankfully Fallout 4 didn't fall down the same hole.

Advertisement

Fallout 4's campaign opens with our first extensive look at what life was like in America before the bombs dropped in 2077. From here the player and their family are forced into Vault 111 where their newborn son is stolen and their spouse murdered. Thus The Sole Survivor sets out looking to avenge them both.

Fallout 4's story poses some interesting questions to players, especially those surrounding artificial intelligence and where it fits into society in the future. Players can opt to join a variety of factions which appeal to all sides of the moral spectrum, however none of them are perfect and players are forced to learn the true consequences of many of the factions' aims as the story progresses.

Furthermore, Fallout 4's story contains some of the more bizarre missions of the series, such as going on a tour through the memories of a deadly assassin. These missions add variety and prevent the game from ever getting too repetitive.

So yes, Fallout 4's story is generally very good. Unfortunately...

2. ... But The Ending Is Terrible

Having spent hours exploring The Commonwealth and getting to know the ins and outs of all four factions, it's a huge shame to see Fallout 4's main story go out on such a whimper.

Advertisement

Following the reveal that your son Shaun is now the leader of the Institute, the very organisation you've been told for the entire game represents nothing but pure evil, the player is left with the admittedly fascinating choice of whether they want to join in with the questionable practices of The Institute for the sake of their family or leave that behind for what they see as the morally correct choice. Unfortunately, no matter what choice you make the ending underwhelms.

Fallout's gameplay doesn't exactly lend itself to cinematic events, which means that the big final battle is decidedly lacking in bombastic action. Furthermore, while all of the factions provide different experiences in terms of how the final missions play out, only the ending where you side with the Institute has any significant impact on how the world appears after the credits roll, with your character becoming its leader and most of the characters in The Commonwealth hating you for it.

The other endings all have little to no impact on the game world after the story ends as even though they see the Institute wiped out, none of them assume power in The Commonwealth, meaning that the world feels directionless following the ending.

Furthermore, it is insulting that all three of the non-Institute endings end with essentially the same ending, as it makes every choice you made to side with these factions across the dozens of hours it takes to complete the story feel worthless.

1. It Didn't Quite Live Up To The Hype

Regardless of whether you think Fallout 4 is a great, terrible, or even just ok game, there is no denying that Bethesda didn't quite manage to meet the lofty expectations they set for fans.

Advertisement

With Fallout 4, Bethesda clearly wanted to appeal to those outside the traditional RPG genre that had helped bring the series so much success in the past. While this isn't necessarily a bad idea - the world of Fallout has significant mainstream appeal - Bethesda approach meant they created a game that covered many genres but failed to excel in any of them.

The traditional role-playing elements are heavily undermined by the stilted dialogue system that failed to give the player enough meaningful input on the world, while the average shooting mechanics and lack of intense shootouts meant it failed to appeal to more casual shooter fans. Furthermore, the attempts to give those into survival games something resulted in a base-building sideshow that while complex, provided little value outside of eye-candy.

It's a shame, as Fallout 4 shows Bethesda at its very best, with the atmospheric and story-rich open world along with the excellent crafting system standing out as the game's highlights. Ultimately, its shortcomings mean that while Fallout 4 should be remembered as a great game, it falls short of what gamers were expecting from Bethesda's latest offering in the series.

Advertisement