Football Manager 2015: 10 Essential Fan Demands It Must Include

If we're going to be addicted, let it be on our own terms.

By Edward Owen /

sports interactiveIt's getting to that time again. Every domestic competition has been sewn up, the players of quality have once again revealed themselves and a small army of managers have been given their marching orders. As is always the way, the footballing landscape has changed irrevocably. Everyone's either recovering, celebrating or doing something in between. But for Football Manager addicts, these are the drought months. While most are so far into their best game now that real-world continuity ceases to matter, there's still a select few who might wish to start again. But now, they're greeted with data they know to be factually wrong, and even worse, time has moved on far too much for their game to remain realistic. Sure, they could download a patch updating the player roster, but you'll still be forced to start in 2013. Some might take this with a pinch of salt, but FM's converts are a notoriously obsessive bunch. To them, the prospect of Juan Mata playing for Manchester United before the turn of the year is anathema, and seeing the Red Devils top the league as a result seems like sheer mockery, especially when compared to their real-life performances last season. So rather than focus on parallel universes where David Moyes leads victory parades, the discerning FM fan will look to what the future holds, the new innovations Sports Interactive will bring to the party, and what persisting bugbears they will fix. You might frown at that previous clause, but it's warranted €“ glorious as SI's opus is, it isn't perfect. Indeed, the game's near-perfection shines its small flaws in harsher light, like the one violin that's off in a beautiful orchestral piece. So with this in mind, it becomes a necessity to point out where improvements could be made before FM Day 2015. Read on, and if you agree or disagree, feel free to comment below, adopting the 'aggressive' tone of voice.

10. The German National Team

Adam Davy/EMPICS SportLet's start with a big one €“ the German national team, and their continually baffling absence from the shores of FM. Since times immemorial, the Nationalmannschaft seem to only exist as a bunch of anonymous, grey-texted dopplegangers. We don't get to see Mesut Ozil, Thomas Mueller or Mario Gotze stick on the famous white shirt and go Teutonic on the situation, and that's a shame. The reason they don't exist on the game is simple €“ Sports Interactive, and by extension SEGA, can't thrash out a proper agreement with the national federation. So until then, we've got to make do with these made-up names. While it's not a gigantic, game-gutting absence, for an FM completist (that is to say everyone who plays FM) the absence of the European powerhouse can be a bit galling. After all, if you want to indulge in a little England-Germany rivalry, witnessing Daniel Sturridge jink past some nobody called Thorsten Fritz is something of a missed opportunity. And that's to say nothing of your German club players, who keep being questioned on why they're not being called up to a team that physically can't call them up. Baffling.

9. The Japan And The J-League

Shuji Kajiyama/AP/Press Association ImagesStaying with abandoned countries now, and it might escape your notice that the Japanese don't exist in FM's world either. While the Samurai Blue don't have as storied a footballing history as their German counterparts, the loss of the Asian powerhouse is still keenly felt to those who love their world football. After all, you don't rid the world of an Asian powerhouse and the team of footballing hipsters everywhere without somebody noticing. However, unlike the Germans, it appears the Japanese have been extricated from the game at both root and stem. While you can still play in the German Bundesliga, the J-League and all its constituent clubs appear to have vanished into the ether. Again, for the more cosmopolitan football fan, this smarts a bit €“ the Japanese League is a huge success story, one of the strongest domestic competitions outside football's European and South American heartlands. It teems with young talent, high-profile players (Diego Forlan plies his trade over there now) and amazing supporters. To be denied the chance to acquaint ourselves with its virtual equivalent is a sad injustice, and one that must be remedied.

8. Better Board AI

Peter Byrne/PA Wire/Press Association ImagesFor all FM's style, panache and sheer meticulous detail when it comes to world-building, there is sadly one place where it occasionally lets itself down €“ the AI. While everyone would gladly prostrate themselves to Miles Jacobson and his team of programming warlocks for crafting this wonderful world, when you're swearing at your board for making head-thunkingly awful decisions over and over again, such gratitude falls into the background very, very quickly. There's no other way of saying it €“ compared to other areas of the game, the AI at board level is stripped down, and incapable of grasping nuance. Oftentimes, you'll find yourself in a packed league where there might only be six points between second and tenth, meaning you can plummet up and down the league like a yo-yo on crack. This would be all well and good, but whereas dropping down a few places in a tight league would be treated with a pinch of salt in real life, the virtual board take it as an opportunity to light the beacons and beckon you to the dreaded performance interview. What was once a blip or a set-back becomes something altogether more crippling, and you're left shaking your fist as they hand you your P45 and change the locks to your office. Basically, what the AI needs is just a better reading of context, and looking beyond the baseline numbers. On paper, being predicted fifth and languishing in eleventh looks bad. But if the difference between those places is only six points, then there's no need to make the manager clear their desk and send their virtual empire crashing down around their ears.

7. Ability To Tap Up Free Transfers To The Press

Sports InteractiveFree transfers are like manna from heaven to the discerning football manager. Signing someone up without having to dip into the transfer war-chest or gutting the wage budget to find funds is a giddy thrill, especially when you find someone truly special. With Keisuke Honda taking the laurels as this season's biggest prize, delving into the morass of free agents can be a tricky prospect, but a thrilling, rewarding one if it pays off. But the problem with the free agent market is that everyone else is involved too. Again, you don't have to use any of your transfer war chest to acquire an uncontracted player, and no matter what financial state your club's in, that's always awesome. So when you find a diamond in the rough (the rough here being the over-35s, failed prospects and an odd influx of Ghanaians formerly of the Bundesliga) you can bet your bottom dollar that at least ten clubs are interested, and will fall over each other to offer contracts if you dare discuss terms. It's like a Mexican standoff, but with paperwork and financial responsibility. So naturally, when faced with this dog-eat-dog situation you want all the possible advantages you can get. But short of bugging the other teams' negotiations (and no, you can't do that), there's very little that can happen. You just name your price, and hope the chips fall your way.

6. A Better Morale System

Sports InteractiveIn the changing rooms and managerial offices of the FM universe, many managers fail to inspire their charges. Though it's a fact of life that not every manager is blessed with the gift of Churchillian oratory, this curse seems to apply to many more virtual managers than real life ones. But why is this? Basically, it's because the morale system €“ and all its influencing factors €“ is still an absolute lottery. It's the equivalent of fumbling for objects in the dark €“ there's no rhyme or reason to how your players might react to your wording and tone of voice beyond your assistant occasionally mentioning it before a private conversation. This makes for a motivational crapshoot, where you don't quite know if you're acting out the equivalent of Any Given Sunday, or flipping off your players while insulting their grandparents. It might seem inconsequential in nature, but when you need a result in a cup final, accidentally letting off a verbal stink-bomb can be the difference between victory and defeat. It probably wouldn't be that hard to sort out €“ just give the manger information regarding a player's body language and mood before you talk to them, and they can judge for themselves what wording and tone to take.

5. Personalised Player Animations

Adam Davy/EMPICS SportAdmittedly, this is a minor quibble. But still, the devil is in the details, and let it never be said that FM is nothing short of forensic in every other aspect of capturing a player's likeness. So with this in mind, why not go the extra yard and capture some of their physical likeness too? Ever since the 3D Match Engine's introduction, it's had its critics. That's fair enough €“ you can't please all of the people all of the time, and most of the time you shouldn't even try. But even with its vociferous opposition, there's still plenty out there who welcomed the chance to see our squad in more detail than before. The eagle-eye 2D dots approach will always have its plus points, but seeing an added dimension hammers the realism nail further home. But still, there's something missing. Nobody's really distinct enough, and it's very clear that past a certain point all the players are automatons. There's a very clear sense of going through the motions, and hard as you try, you find it hard to think of these figures as real, personality-driven players. Yes, we know it's a game, but damn it all to hell if we're not allowed to dream. There's clearly only so much they can do here €“ the key to FM's success is simplicity and the fact it can be played on most PCs, so obviously FIFA-style graphics are out the question. Yet it wouldn't be demanding the moon to ask for a larger repertoire of player animations. When they score, let them have a personalised celebration instead of simply running about. It would lift many users' hearts to see a virtual Danny Sturridge do his pop-and-lock dance, or Tim Cahill beat the living daylights out of the corner flag. Better yet, If it's a last minute cup-final goal, why not have the player run into the crowd? If you've got an aggressive player, why shouldn't he attempt to pump up the fans. The possibilities are endless €“ all it would require is a half-decent animator, and it would do a world of good.

4. More Distinct Managers

Media Image LtdIf you're a marathon FM player (and all the best people are), you know that nothing ever stands still in your footballing parallel universe. Jobs change hands, folk get transferred, and if you leave it long enough, Cristiano Ronaldo becomes the manager of Scunthorpe. There's no problem here €“ bearing in mind 12 managers received their marching orders in the Premier League last season, it proves FM is nothing if not realistic. Yet there comes a time in every FM player's life when he looks up and finds everything has changed, and worse yet, he didn't even realise it. Barring a choice few, just about every job in the division has changed hands, and you're all sorts of baffled to find that not only is Thomas Schaaf managing Manchester City, he's been at it for four years. The reason for this obliviousness? It's quite simple €“ managers simply aren't distinctive enough in their personalities to warrant being remembered. Perhaps we can put this down to the limited, binary set of responses a manager can give regarding another manager. After all, if everyone's singing off the same hymn sheet, any sort of difference quickly falls by the wayside. Quite frankly, this is a crying shame €“ the gilet-wearing, perma-furious Tim Sherwood isn't the urbane, shrewish Arsene Wenger, so they shouldn't be alike on the game. To have these nuances batted down for ease of use simply smacks of missed opportunity.

3. More Forgiving Interviews In An Online Game

Sports InteractiveWe live in the internet age, and to FM's credit, it's managed to keep up. Failed experiment with FM Live notwithstanding, it's now easier than ever to crank up a game with absent friends, whether they be in the next room or another country. Clearly, this is a brilliant thing €“ while having everyone play off the same laptop is a retro, archaic thrill, opening up the world's greatest glorified spreadsheet to easier multiplayer games is awesome. However, it's exactly the same as the single-player game, and therein lies the rub. Being sacked is like an FM rite of passage €“ you never forget your first time, and it's embarrassing to boot. Whether you've disrupted your team's harmonies by signing in a boatload of Lithuanians, absent-mindedly let your Director of Football sell your star players for peanuts or simply been unable to find your side's best formation, everyone comes a cropper eventually. So, sure as you'll receive your marching orders playing alone, you'll also be unceremoniously booted in multiplayer too. While this leads to about two hours of banter over how the hell your friend's formerly promotion-chasing side could only pick up one point from 21, this soon dies out when you realise that he's unable to find a new post for months. More often than not, this leads to your game playing host to a complete passenger, as he waits out for a job that isn't Stenhousemuir or in the Belgian Third Division. Needless to say, it's frustrating, and many a promising game has been ruined simply because your friend's being booted from interviews at every turn. It's even more frustrating if you're playing in the lower divisions, where it's likely you could never pick up another position again. Granted a request to dumb the game down might sound like anathema to some. But still, it's a warranted complaint. If they just made the interview process and job pick-up rate a smidge easier for multiplayer, it certainly would save a lot of treasured campaigns going down the swanny because your sacked friend threw his toys out the pram.

2. More Licenses

Martin Rickett/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesWhen hipster-types or your creepy burlap sack-wearing neighbour tell us we're slaves to brands, they're actually right on the money. Everyone loves official stuff, adorned with the correct logos and sanctioned by whoever and whatever. You don't have to be ashamed of it €“ it's just a mark of quality, and we all want the best deal. This probably applies double in gaming, and especially sports games. While many would probably deny it now, back in the days when FIFA was demonstrably inferior to Pro Evolution Soccer the reason many still flocked to EA's juggernaut was because they had all the licenses. While PES had some, it didn't matter €“ Manchester United fans simply weren't interested in controlling Man Red, with their misspelt player names and Sunday League kit. They were willing to tolerate slightly worse gameplay for a bucketload more realism, and this kept the franchise going despite tepid reviews. FM should look at this and take lessons. While it's true that the game doesn't have a true rival in the way that PES was to FIFA pre-PS3/Xbox 360, this should breed complacency. Many players would gladly fall over themselves for proper licenses and kits for the Premier League and international sides and competitions, and while you can download fan-made equivalents, nothing beats the official product. Yes, the licenses are a small concern. However, it would go a long way if the developers could finally secure them.

1. Better Press Conferences

Owen Humphreys/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesCould it be anything else? For years now, FM players have had to suffer with the same banal set of quips to a slew of repetitious questions. Hell, most veteran campaigners can't even be bothered with this aspect of the game anymore, instead choosing to send the assistant in and damn the consequences. Familiarity breeds contempt, and we've been putting up with this since the days of FM 2007. While there have been innovations to help spice up the rigmarole of meeting the press, it's been nothing but putting lipstick on a particularly unattractive pig. Yet ore so than most, this is an area in drastic need of an overhaul to bring back the cynics. but each year the same old system is dragged out with little more than a new question added. It's not enough. Though the solution for what they would create to replace this archaic, boredom-inducing system remains up for debate (having you co-host conferences with the captain, chairman or new signing might be a good idea), one thing is clear €“ they need to do something. The adversarial relationships between clubs, managers and the press is one of the most interesting parts of modern football, and it has yet to be properly captured by Sports Interactive.