Football Manager 2018: 10 Essential Fan Demands It Must Include

FM 2017 was close to perfect - here's how to make it even better.

By Andy H Murray /

Football Manager 2017 brought a number of new features to the table, but for the most part, fans got exactly what they expected from the game. It was another year of minor tweaks and adjustments over complete innovation, and while additions like the social feed helped FM 2017 stand-out from 2016, the gameplay was largely unchanged.

Advertisement

This is what fans have come to anticipate from Sports Interactive, but that's okay. You don't mess with a winning formula, and FM's unparalleled depth, longevity, and social life-destroying addictiveness can't be topped. SI don't need to reinvent the wheel to produce a great game every year, and they're never going to tear Football Manager apart and start anew.

That being said, there are a number of gameplay innovations that SI could bring to the table in order to drive the series forward. The annual data updates and match engine tweaks are appreciated, but let's be honest: new versions of FM are always a lot more satisfying when they amount to more than a glorified patch.

Football Manager 2018 hasn't even been announced yet, but it's never too early to speculate on what the new game might bring. Here are 10 things FM fans would love to see included in this year's version...

10. Optional Brexit

Sports Interactive have always prided themselves on extreme realism, but for most players, adding Brexit to Football Manager 2017 was a step too far. Including the UK’s forthcoming departure from the EU made managing in England an infinitely trickier task, particularly when it came to signing new players, and the worst part? It was unavoidable.

Advertisement

Brexit wasn’t implemented into FM Touch, but it was present and correct in the standard game. The warning messages seem innocuous at first, but after 2 or 3 seasons, the game forcibly removes the UK from the EU.

From that point onwards, work permit issues become a major stumbling block for almost anyone you want to acquire, making it borderline impossible to sign young talent from the remaining EU nations.

Some fans might appreciate the added realism, but for many, Brexit made managing in England a real chore. In 2018, Sports Interactive should seriously consider giving player the option to remove it from the game.

A simple toggle box on the options screen should suffice, and it’d no doubt save many players the stress of working through a feature they never asked for in the first place.

9. Match Engine Improvements

SI Games are often criticised for the lack of innovation between different versions of Football Manager, but they always tweak the match engine. It hasn’t seen a complete rebuild in several years, however, and for all the positive tweaks made to FM 2017’s engine, it was still rife with massively frustrating problems.

Advertisement

Anyone who has played the game for longer than five minutes can attest to the goalkeepers’ erratic behaviour. FM’s goalies routinely flub seemingly easy saves, leading to many an undeserved loss, and their outfield counterparts are often just as dumb.

Things have improved through SI’s latest patches, but some issues remain, and whether this is a scripting issue or one related to the way that the action is rendered, it must be fixed next year.

Furthermore, the engine could use a few aesthetic tweaks. It’d be great to see real-life stadiums recreated in-game, not the generic stock arenas that FM throws together. Similarly, small touches like better celebrations and fluid, realistic animations would greatly improve the average FM matchday. It’s not bad at the moment and the engine will never be perfect, but SI have some tweaking to do.

8. Greater Manager Customisation

Adding customisable manager avatars was a smart choice that helped make Football Manager feel like a more complete gaming experience. The implementation hasn’t been perfect, however, and while the feature has succeeded in giving FM an extra layer of customisation, its features are thin, flimsy, and unsatisfying.

Advertisement

Users are presented with just a handful of different options for clothing, hair style, facial hair, etc. The customisation tree is so limited that almost every character produced using the system comes out looking the same, regardless of your choices. These features just aren't at a satisfactory level yet, and the majority of these characters emerge looking bug-eyed and distinctly non-human.

FM has never been about graphics, but if they’re going to include this feature in the game, they might as well perfect it. Aesthetics aside, players are also given the opportunity to customise their manager’s mental attributes at the start screen, but these have little noticeable impact on how the game plays. Increasing their importance would be another significant step towards making Football Manager feel like a more personal experience.

7. Comprehensive Licensing

Sports Interactive have always been incredibly resourceful when it comes to licensing. The game’s realistic database is a huge part of its appeal, and most of the world’s major clubs and competitions are present in their true form. Some blind spots remain, however, and while it’s unlikely SI will ever purchase a fell set of licenses, it remains a minor complaint every year.

Advertisement

To be fair, they usually do a better job of covering for unlicensed teams than Konami do with PES. There’s no East Dorsetshire or West Midlands Village here: instead, we get Schalke labelled as Gelsenkirchen (the club’s home city), Borussia Monchengladbach as BMG, and a host of Brazilian and Portuguese clubs labelled with similar three-letter initials.

These problems can be neutered by downloading a small third-party patch, but it’s an inconvenience that many fans just can’t be bothered with. These fake club names remove your immersion, and reduce the game’s realism. The same goes for substitute league games and generic club logos, and while EA Sports’ ownership of such licenses makes things difficult, it’d be great to see them included in FM someday.

6. Enhanced Youth Academies

Developing youth players in Football Manager has always been a relatively straightforward experience. You invest money in building the best possible facilities and acquiring a crack coaching team, set the routine, and leave them to it. It’s a largely automated process that only really requires intervention when it comes to choosing what to do with a player’s contract, and one that could use a revamp.

Advertisement

Seeing exciting young talents develop into world-beaters is one of FM’s great pleasures, and it’d make sense for SI to make this a more hands-on experience. Clubs like Barcelona have cultivated a tremendous identity with their La Masia youth academy, particularly when it comes to building and maintaining a club-wide footballing philosophy. This allows them to develop swathes of players that seamlessly fit into the first team’s tactical system every year, but there’s little scope to do that in FM.

Players should have the opportunity to take a larger role in nurturing young talent, and guiding their coaching team’s hand. A tiered age group system would also help make this a more comprehensive and realistic facet of the game, allowing managers to mould youngsters in their own image from an earlier age, and not whatever predetermined set of stats the game has in mind.

5. Varied New Roles

While Football Manager gives you complete flexibility when it comes to where you start your career, there’s only one choice as far as your specific role goes. You’re either a full-time first-team manager, or you’re unemployed - that’s it. There’s no scope for anything else, and while this has been the game’s backbone for years, it’s not entirely realistic.

Advertisement

A huge number of real world football managers start their careers elsewhere on the backroom staff, and slowly work their way up. On that note, it’d be great to see SI offer players the opportunity to manager club’s youth and reserve teams as a “foot in the door” for their managerial career. This would obviously remove transfers and contract decisions, but it’d be a fun challenge nonetheless.

Similarly, FM still lacks the opportunity to join a club as a caretaker or temporary manager, and earn the chance of a longer stint through strong performances. It’s very surprising that SI haven’t implemented this feature yet, given its prominence in the modern game, and doing so would give Football Manager 18 yet another level of realism.

4. More, More, More

Football Manager’s database is almost incomprehensibly vast. There are more available leagues and clubs than anyone could ever hope to play as, and most players won’t even scratch the surface. The game features literally hundreds of thousands of personnel every single year, and provided your computer has enough processing power, you’ll rarely be short of potential signings, challenges, and teams to play as.

Advertisement

That being said, FM gamers are always crying out for more, and the default database still has room for expansion. Sure, you can add new personnel and competitions to the game by downloading data packs, but this can be a minor hassle, and it’s not an option if you’re an FM Touch player. It’d be awesome to see SI expand Football Manager's scope not only by adding some of the missing leagues, but by thinking outside the box for some exciting new additions.

Why not add a handful of classic databases, or even introduce women’s football to the game? EA Sports have already toyed with this concept in FIFA, and given the women’s game’s growing prominence around the world (particularly in America), it makes perfect sense.

3. Chairman Mode

Football Manager is obviously the most comprehensive management experience to be offered in a football game. Nothing else has ever come close, and while a handful of competitors keep limping through a meagre existence, failure is an inevitability. Developers can’t compete with SI’s extensive network and decades of hard work, and all other management games feel shallow by comparison.

Advertisement

That being said, there has only ever been one way to play the game, and that’s as the head coach. It's called Football Manager after all, but regardless, Chairmen and Directors of Football continue playing an increased role in the modern game. Whether it’s meddling Mike Ashley at Newcastle or Real Madrid’s infamous president Florentino Perez, these figures are just as influential within the club, and playing their role would be a welcome additional.

It would see FM become much more of a business simulator, rather than a sports game. Players would be granted greater control over budgets, marketing, and facility improvements. They’d also have the opportunity to hire and fire managers, of course, placing the player several levels above the usual hotseat, and completely changing FM’s power dynamic.

2. Organic Manager Rivalries

Football Manager generally does it a good job when it comes to club rivalries. If you manage Manchester United to a horrendous 5-0 panning at Man City’s hands, you’re probably going to get slaughtered for it, just like you would in real-life. Such stories comprise the backbone of football’s narrative, but the sport is about much more than inter-club relationships, and feuds between individual personalities are almost just as compelling.

Advertisement

From Arsene Wenger vs. Jose Mourinho to Alan Pardew vs. anyone with a common sense of decency, touchline tensions are often just as compelling as the game itself. This is something that FM has never truly implemented, however, and it’d make for a welcome addition in 2018.

All you really need to do to make another manager dislike you is say some mean things about them in a press conference. They might return the favour, but that’s the extent of their impact, and such interactions rarely result in anything other than a morale change.

It’d be far more fitting to see managers react by raising their game, increasing their team’s aggression, or talking themselves into a touchline ban while facing a hated opponent.

1. A Better Social Feed

Football Manager’s social feed was one of last year’s big new features, but it wasn’t well fleshed out. Used to break news, spread rumours, and provide a greater in-game platform for fan opinions, it sounded cool at first, but soon became a pointless addition. After a few hours’ play, the social feed feels incredibly generic, and rarely reflects the gameworld.

Advertisement

Your star striker can finish the game with a hat-trick, Man of the Match award, and a 9.8 rating, but there’ll still be boatloads of negativity on the social feed. It doesn’t make any sense, and while it usually takes SI at least 2 or 3 games to master new features like this, 2017’s first attempt was a big disappointment.

If the feature isn’t improved on in 2018, it’s going to become redundant. There was no real reason to click on the social feed after playing FM 2017 for a while, and it provided little engagement. SI must find a way to make it better reflect the games’ goings-on, and if they can do this, it’ll not only become a valuable tool for keeping up with the latest news, but also gauge fan opinion and make adjustments accordingly.

Plus, how good would it be to see more Tweets from the players themselves, particularly those prone to Joey Barton-esque outbursts?

Advertisement