Forza Horizon 4 Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs

Time to dust off your Xbox One.

By Jack Pooley /

Playground Games

The long-awaited Forza Horizon 4 is out now, and Playground Games has once again delivered a one-of-a-kind racer that effortlessly blows its meagre competition out of the water.

Advertisement

It's certainly not perfect - though what game is? - yet as a gorgeously designed, insanely addictive racer like rarely seen, it truly is a high-point for the genre this generation, if not beyond.

Furthermore, with the game being part of Microsoft's brilliant Xbox Game Pass initiative, you don't even need to shell out full whack to play it: for a few cursory bucks you can start cruising around the game's inexplicably beautiful rendition of the United Kingdom.

Advertisement

Though October is a ridiculously crowded month for AAA games of all kinds, you absolutely shouldn't sleep on this genre and generation-defining effort that gives the Xbox One a much-needed console exclusive barn-stormer.

Before we start foaming over its many brilliant features, though, here are some minor gripes to consider...

Advertisement

Downs...

3. The Long-Winded Interface & Loading Screens

Playground Games

Like a lot of content-rich games, you can practically feel Forza Horizon 4 straining to keep its (mostly) well-oiled machine chugging along, resulting in the overall user interface and organisation feeling a bit clumsy.

Advertisement

Though the menus themselves look slick enough, manoeuvring around them can feel a tad sluggish, and it seems designed more for aesthetics than efficiency or simple ease-of-use. Considering you'll be spending a lot of the time in the game's menus, that's somewhat disappointing.

Worse is the sometimes infuriating loading screens, which can last close to 30 seconds for a race on the original Xbox One, to say nothing of how long-winded it can be getting a match going online.

Advertisement

There are also a frustrating abundance of glossy, unskippable splash screens transitioning between gameplay segments, which is clearly a not-so-subtle attempt to mask yet more loading screens.

The overall experience is absolutely worth the sometimes lumbering framework, but given the mind-melting scope of the game, it certainly would've benefited from favouring function over fashion.

Advertisement

2. The Story Mode & Human Interactions Aren't Great

Playground Games

Like the previous Forza Horizon games, there's a distinctly human grounding to all the vehicular mayhem, despite it being completely unnecessary.

Advertisement

Though your voice-over assistant is charming enough, the voice acting during the game's cinematic sequences range from mediocre to laughably bad, and the human character models look embarrassingly low-res compared to the jaw-dropping fidelity of the cars themselves.

It probably would've been smart to just do away with people altogether, honestly, but Horizon 4 ultimately goes the other way. Its tangential Story Mode, for instance, flings players into a series of chapter-based scenarios where human interaction is all-too-frequent.

Advertisement

Though the opening stuntman events are fun to a point, the hackneyed dialogue gets old fast, and the missions themselves end up feeling quite repetitive. It's this aspect of the game that feels the most workmanlike and unnecessary: the world doesn't need to be populated with any robotic, stiffly animated-and-voiced people for it to feel alive.

1. It Doesn't Really Innovate The Franchise

Playground Games

This might sound like an unfair criticism to some, but coming away from a few days dug into Forza Horizon 4, there is a distinct feeling of ordinariness, that as brilliant as it so often is, it just doesn't really do enough to innovate.

Advertisement

This is a sublime racer, no question, but if you were hoping that Horizon 4 would build substantially on the well-regimented formula, it's more a steady refinement that plays things relatively safe.

Some will argue that this is not only fine but even preferable, though honestly, it would've been nice to see Playground push the boat out with some bolder design decisions. Instead, this mostly feels like a slicker, glossier version of the previous game with a different setting, though there are certainly worse things to be called out for.

Advertisement

So, these criticisms accepted, there is a ton of fun to have with this game, and if you own an Xbox One or gaming PC, you absolutely owe it to yourself to play it. Here's what Forza Horizon 4 gets right...

Ups...

6. So. Much. Content.

Playground Games

Even in its worst moments, this game is nothing if not ludicrously addictive and jam-packed with content to the point that it actually feels overwhelming at times.

Advertisement

There is always something new popping up, be it a regular exhibition event, story mode chapter, speed trap, stunt, sign, scripted showcase event (even a Halo-themed one!), timed challenge or hidden barn, not to forget 450 vehicles to customise and a gigantic online multiplayer suite. Phew.

Nobody on Earth can justifiably complain that this game is lacking in content out of the box, and players will easily be able to pour dozens of hours into it without exhausting everything it has to offer.

Advertisement

Though it's a shame the interface isn't a little slicker, the variety of the content available ensures there's always something different to give a whirl.

It certainly takes a surprising amount of time to acclimate to the sheer dizzying array of content on offer, but in a world where so many AAA games shamelessly carve content out of the core experience, this really feels like a bargain (especially if you're playing it on Xbox Game Pass).

Advertisement

5. The Eye-Wateringly Beautiful Graphics

Playground Games

It scarcely needs to be said to anyone with a functioning pair of eyeballs, but yes, Forza Horizon 4 is one of the best looking games ever made, racer or otherwise. Even when played in mere, lowly 1080p, this thing is an absolute technical masterclass, with uncannily photo-realistic vehicular textures and lighting effects.

Advertisement

Sure, it's not an entirely consistent visual showcase - the aforementioned human character models are horrible and the underside of most vehicles are a single flat texture - but where it really counts, the game is an absolute aesthetic belter.

Especially stunning is the Edinburgh-set portion of the game, and if you've ever visited the Scottish city, it's hard not to be left agape at how lovingly it's been recreated here.

Advertisement

Though the U.K. isn't the first setting that comes to mind for a racing game, Playground has done a wonderfully job exploiting its natural beauty for every drop it's worth.

4. It Might Be The Best Multiplayer Racer Ever

Playground Games

This might sound like hyperbole, but seriously, when it comes to pure online multiplayer mayhem, Forza Horizon 4 may well be the greatest game of its kind.

Advertisement

Much like Burnout Paradise, Horizon 4 understands that multiplayer racers work best when players have as much freedom and versatility as possible. To that end, there is SO much to do here, from simple online races to more eccentric modes such as Infected and Capture the Flag, and also free roam with up to 72 players.

Creating a shared world this large and ambitious could so easily have backfired, but if you can forgive some of the overly lengthy matchmaking times and overt abundance of loading screens, this is a masterful multiplayer suite that instantly becomes compulsively addictive.

Advertisement

3. Seasons Are An Awesome Addition

Playground Games

Though Horizon 4 doesn't innovate all that much as mentioned, one wonderful addition is the new inclusion of changing seasons, allowing players to experience the U.K. in summer, autumn, winter and spring.

Advertisement

This adds an unexpected level of diversity to the game not only visually but also difficulty-wise: in the winter cars are far more challenging to handle, and when the spring comes, you'll still need to be mindful of those dew-soaked roads.

Impressively, the cosmetic changes aren't just shallow surface flourishes: for instance, lakes will freeze over in the winter, and sections of the game will open up that can't be reached in other seasons.

Advertisement

Once you've made your way through the surprisingly lengthy introductory year, the seasons become fixed and will rotate on a weekly basis, ensuring that no matter when you sit down to play the game, there's something different just around the corner.

It's not exactly a complex gimmick, but it is one that works splendidly well without overtly trying to railroad the player into a specific mode of play.

Advertisement

2. It's Still A Total Blast When Played Offline

Playground Games

While there's been an increasing incidence in recent years of online, shared world racers forcing players to play the game while connected to the Internet - looking at you, Need for Speed - this is among a dying breed that can be played entirely offline (bar the multiplayer suite, of course).

Advertisement

If you're fed up of being shunted to death by online human racers or are inexplicably without Internet for some reason, Forza Horizon 4 still boasts a fully playable offline experience. Real humans will be substituted out for the series' familiar Drivatars, and the bulk of the racing modes will open up to you just as they would if you were playing online.

Sure, there are precious few players who will decide to play the game this way, but in an age where many publishers are seeking out as many ways as possible to control players, it's worth noting that the Forza franchise appears to be rejecting that notion.

Advertisement

And more to the point, while many offline-only versions of shared world games end up feeling dead and empty, here the game still feels vibrant and "alive" whether you're connected or not.

1. It's The Best Xbox One Exclusive In Years

Microsoft

If the Xbox One is your primary console of choice, then it's no doubt been a fantastic investment, but if you use it as a secondary console to your PS4 for the sake of exclusives - as many seem to - it's been a pretty grim couple of years with precious few acclaimed AAA exclusives to choose from.

Advertisement

What a relief it is, then, that Forza Horizon 4 comes along and delivers the most content-rich, high-value, technically accomplished console exclusive in literally years.

If your Xbox One has been collecting dust while you've been busily ploughing through the PS4's recent avalanche of quality exclusive titles, this is a wonderful reminder that Forza is the Xbox One's most enviable franchise.

Advertisement

Considering the PS4 doesn't exactly have many - if any - truly masterful racing games, Forza Horizon 4 is as great a reason as any to turn your Xbox back on.

And again, with it being available on Game Pass, you haven't really got much of an excuse not to.

Advertisement

Have you been playing Forza Horizon 4? What do you think so far? Shout it out in the comments!